Mike Giardi

Eagles and Pats DBs agree: Tough to avoid hits like one that concussed Gronk

Eagles and Pats DBs agree: Tough to avoid hits like one that concussed Gronk

BLOOMINGTON, Minn. -- When Jacksonville safety Barry Church delivered that massive shot to Rob Gronkowski, the one that knocked the Patriots’ all-world tight end out of the game, the rage amongst Pats fans was real.

Opinions on Church’s fate ranged from immediate ejection, to suspension, to my personal favorite - the Jags safety not being allowed to play again until Gronk was finally cleared to return to a game - any game.


Given modern day technology, we had amateurs breaking down the point of impact like they actually knew there was intent to injure. Given the emotion of the moment, and the sight of a woozy Gronk heading off to the locker room,  never to return to the AFC Championship Game, it was somewhat understandable. Somewhat. 

There’s no arguing the hit was against the current NFL rules, and Church got what the rule book said he should: a 15-yard penalty. Later, the NFL tacked on a fine of nearly $25,000. 

“25K for making a football play?” asked Eagles safety Corey Graham. “That’s tough.”

Another Eagles safety, Malcolm Jenkins, didn’t want to make light of concussions -- or any injury for that matter -- but did note that, “We’re put in positions all the time in secondary where we gotta protect ourselves, our pockets and the other team. That makes no sense. I think we should start fining quarterbacks for putting guys in situations like that, personally.” He was joking about the last part, sort of.

Devin McCourty has roamed the secondary for eight seasons. As he points out, the Pats “don’t draw a lot of those penalties,” thanks to an emphasis on fundamentals and tackling techniques, but admits that what happened to Church will eventually happen to any defensive back that’s in the game long enough.

“We’ve all had those type of plays,” he said.

Teammate Duron Harmon concurs.

“That’s one of the tricky things about playing in this game,” said the fifth-year pro. “You can’t take it away from what the refs are doing. They’re calling it right. It is illegal using the crown of your head. But it was one of those plays that was bang-bang. He definitely didn’t intend to do it.”


“That’s been the debate going around all year, right,” asked Graham. “Defensive backs . . . they put us in a tough situations. Honestly, i don’t know what was so bad about that hit. Obviously, you don’t want to see him get hurt. You never want to see anybody get hurt, but you got two options, you hit him high or you hit him down low. I don’t think Gronk wants a guy going in on his ankles, flipping him and messing up his legs and his knees and stuff like that.”

“I didn’t think what [Church] did was wrong,” said another Eagles safety, Rodney McLeod.

“It was unfortunate,” added Jenkins, one of the most well-respected veterans in the league and someone who will probably find himself up against Gronk quite a bit on Sunday. While he appreciates the league’s desire to make football safer, Jenkins notes that “you can’t take the violence out of it,” and that hit was “one of those things . . . in a game, especially a playoff game, where you’re trying to separate a ball from a receiver, some of those things are hard to avoid.”

As Graham said, do you think Gronk or any other receiver wants their knees targeted? We know that’s something that Gronk has been very animated about in the past, and a multitude of players have said they too would prefer a head shot than a torn ACL. The latter, they reason, can cost you a season and as we’ve seen many times, maybe your job. Though the long-term ramifications of concussions are murkier and certainly scarier, few NFL players lose sleep over the big picture, and even the smartest ones, like Jenkins, have hidden brain injuries in the past.

“I got a concussion and nobody really knew,” Graham admitted Wednesday about an unspecified game. “I chose to keep it to myself, which in hindsight probably wasn’t a great idea.”

Jenkins says the league is doing a better job of watching out for it’s players even though it’s not without its flaws, as we’ve seen.

“It protects players from themselves,” he said. “We’re all competitors and especially at this stage, the Super Bowl, wanting to be able to go out and compete. We’ve worked so hard to get to this point, it’d be hard for any player to keep himself out of this game. So I think that’s what the protocol is in place for.”

A protocol, by the way, that Gronk remained through Wednesday’s full padded practice here in Minnesota. The Pats tight end is already on record as saying he’ll play Sunday, and the consensus is the team, which can wait to get him ‘officially’ cleared, is confident about his availability as well. You can also bet that won’t have trepidation about sending him down the seam again. After all, the object is to win the game. Which brings us back to the Church hit again, and notion that defenders can find a strike zone to hit the receiver even as he’s moving.

“The strike zone changes that fast,” said McCourty, snapping his fingers. “You can go in there and have it timed up perfectly but if the pass is low and the guy bends down, now you’re at his head.”

“Unless you get there when he’s still extended and he can’t get his head down, what do you do?” said Graham. “To me, I just don’t think about it much. Just go out there and play football and hope you don’t get caught in a bad situation.”


We’ll leave the final word to Jenkins, who may just find himself in the same dilemma Church was in less than two weeks ago.

“I think people assume that we’re better athletes than we really are,” Jenkins answered when I asked about the idea of zeroing in on one area in a second, or less. “The speed of the game makes it really really really tough to adjust like that on the fly so often times as you approach a receiver you make up in your mind kind of where that target is and you strike. Often times, you see receivers that duck. They catch the ball and all of a sudden they change their body position and the defenders already picked their strike zone which, when he went to go hit, was probably legal and now all of a sudden the offensive guy changes his body position and you’re in a compromising position.

“Or, like you said, you see guys go like and they’re going to call it a dirty hit. I don’t think people really understand what it feels like as a defender, especially as a DB, to run full speed into guys 240 pounds (or in Gronk’s case 265 or so) and hit him right in his center of gravity. That makes it dangerous to the defender.”

So you must make that decision. Me? Or him? I don’t know anyone who plays this game that would answer the former . . . 


Harmon on Patriots success: 'Nobody can take this from us, we earned it'

Harmon on Patriots success: 'Nobody can take this from us, we earned it'

BLOOMINGTON, Minnesota -- Barry Sanders. Dick Butkus. Steve Largent. Eric Dickerson. Gale Sayers. John Randall. LaDainian Tomlinson. Dan Dierdorf. Derrick Thomas. Lee Roy Selmon. Earl Campell. Deacon Jones. 

What do all those Hall of Famers have in common?

None ever played on the game’s biggest stage, the Super Bowl. That’s unreal when you think about the greatness of those careers, and in some cases, how long those careers lasted. The number of touchdowns and yards and tackles and sacks and forced fumbles from that group is mind-numbing. But how many of those stats do you think they’d trade just to have gotten one ring? Hell, one crack at one ring? 

MORE PATRIOTS - Butler: 'I want to go out like Kobe'

Contrast that with someone like Duron Harmon. He’s about to finish his 5th season with the Patriots. This is his third Super Bowl appearance. His other two years in New England resulted in trips to the AFC Championship game.

“It’s great living,” smiled the affable Harmon. “You see guys who play in this league for 10 plus years who never sniff the playoffs, let alone get to the Super Bowl so I know I’m definitely in a great spot.”

Like everyone on the roster during this stretch, Harmon has benefited from the Bill Belichick/Tom Brady combo platter. One’s the greatest coach of all-time. The other is the greatest quarterback of all-time. And if you won’t give them that (what’s wrong with you?), you’ll at least admit they’re very much in the conversation. 

But here’s where things get a little twisted. While those two outshine even a Super Moon, they’re not the only reason why the Pats are here seemingly every single year. And though Harmon doesn’t want to outright say that, his tone is pretty clear.

“I’m blessed, but at the end of the day we work for this,” he said. “Nobody can take this from us. We earned it.  We put the work in day in and day out, year in and year out. We all do a great job of deciphering from year to year to never let the previous year determine how we play the next year. That has allowed us to continue to always have a goal a mind and never backtrack or think about the past.”

Why is that important? Harmon emphasizes, “because the past really does nothing for you when you’re playing a football game.”

MORE FROM NBCSPORTSBOSTON.COM - Mannix: C's high on Monroe's list

Spoken like a player who knows what’s what, and one who’s just about ready for kickoff.

“It’s the Super Bowl,” he said. “If you can’t be focused for the Super Bowl, you shouldn’t be playing this game…Everybody is definitely ready. You can tell it.”

There’s plenty of players on the Patriots who know what that feels like. Harmon’s one of the lucky ones. It’s all that he knows. 


Will Eagles' RPO attack give them a TKO over Patriots?

Will Eagles' RPO attack give them a TKO over Patriots?

MINNEAPOLIS -- It was late in the first quarter of the NFC Championship Game, score tied at 7-7. Eagles quarterback Nick Foles was lined up in shotgun, with LeGarrette Blount offset to his right. At the snap, Foles kept his eyes up, reading safety Harrison Smith, who had moved up to assume the role of weak side linebacker. Smith was waiting on Foles to either hand it off to Blount or pull the ball out of his belly and attack the right side of the defense.

He guessed wrong on both counts. Instead, Foles zipped a tidy six-yard completion to Alshon Jeffrey, throwing the ball into the area Smith should have been defending. The Eagles offensive line also sold the ruse, zone blocking to the opposite side of the throw and getting the linebackers to flow that way as well.

Welcome to the world of RPOs -- run-pass option. 


Once considered a college offense, it’s become all the rage in the NFL. Super Bowl Sunday will be the third straight game the Patriots will face an offense and a signal caller that lean on the run-pass option as an important piece of their game planning and play calling. 

“They think (you need a) young, athletic college quarterback (to run RPO plays),” said Eagles offensive coordinator Frank Reich. “That’s not what the RPO game is all about. It’s centered on accurate throwing, good decision-making and good execution. When we use it, Nick has shown a great aptitude of doing that very well.”

The Eagles haven’t scaled back their use of RPOs since the gifted Carson Wentz was lost for the season with a torn ACL and PCL. Actually they’ve leaned on it more since Foles has taken over, using it first as a means to get their backup into the flow of the game. According to Pro Football Focus Foles is 15-of-16 on such plays, averaging over seven yards a throw. Wentz, who was in the conversation for league MVP prior to getting hurt, was 23-of-35 on such plays but averaged just 5.9 yards on those passes.

“Everyone wants to hate on Nick Foles, but he’s done a great job,” said Patriots linebacker Kyle Van Noy. 

Van Noy is one of those Pats defenders who will find himself caught betwixt and between when forced to defend the RPO. I asked him about the challenge and he was as nonchalant as possible. 

“You just want to read your keys and play football,” he said. “Not try to overthink. Guys that are playing run play run, guys that are playing pass play the pass.”

Sounds simple, but it’s not. The Pats had their hands full with the Titans in the divisional round before Marcus Mariota strained his quad. That essentially wiped out a portion of Tennessee’s playbook, the portion that was working. A week later, in the AFC Championship Game, Blake Bortles played the game of his life for three quarters, relying heavily on being able to exploit Van Noy and company with RPOs. 

“At the end of the day you’ve got guys who are assigned to certain things," said Van Noy. "You’ve just got to do your job.”

And if you don’t do your job?

“You’ll hear about it.”


Trey Flowers didn’t have to hear from any coaches after a play early in the second quarter against Jacksonville. Faced with a 1st-and-15, the Jags had Leonard Fournette offset to the left of Bortles, who was operating out of the gun. The offensive line did a tremendous job selling run action to the right side, aided by a quick belly fake to Fournette. But Bortles quickly wheeled and hit Corey Grant, who had lined up in the left slot. Van Noy overreacted but Flowers blamed himself. He hesitated for just a second. That was all it took. The Jags blocked it up well on the outside but if anyone had a chance to submerge the 15-yard gain, the third-year pro from Arkansas thought it was him and him alone.

“I could have made that play," he said. "I should have made that play.” 

Looking over the film, it’s hard to agree with Flowers. His idea of hesitation was a split second. It also appears Flowers read his keys and -- wait for it -- did his job.

The Patriots buttoned it up in the final stretch, but a further review of the tape shows that the Jaguars had no plays left in their RPO reservoir. They had run through every wrinkle, every formational variance they had in offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett’s playbook. And just like that, the dreams of a Super Bowl withered and died at Gillette Stadium.

“Hey, they had a hell of a plan and they executed it well,” said Duron Harmon. “They didn’t get to that point without being a great team. But I think our guys just handled their responsibilities better and we recognized what was happening a little quicker than we did, say, in the first or second quarter.”

The Eagles' RPO package will post an even bigger threat to the Patriots than the Jags. They’re better at all levels, with a more diverse and explosive group of weapons. Don’t believe me? I’ll turn it over to Bill Belichick.

“They do a good job of creating conflicts for the defense and that’s difficult, too,” Belichick said of the Eagles. “When a guy gets a key and two different plays look like the same play . . . if he's right on one, he's wrong on the other. A lot of those plays are read by the quarterback, so actually both plays are in play and then the quarterback makes a decision on what to do as he reads the defense. So you can’t be right defensively is the philosophy there. There's a lot of that; yeah. They do a real good job of attacking every inch of the field.”

Another example of what Belichick is talking about happened later in that NFC title game. The Eagles came out in a similar set to the one highlighted at the beginning of this piece, only this time Jeffrey tightened up his split -- a minus split in football-ese. That forced the Vikings corner to back off, fearful that if he pressed Jeffrey, there was too much room to defend from where Jeffrey was lined up all the way to the sideline.  It essentially created a two-way go. The space that corner surrendered once again provided Foles with a window to fake the handoff and hit his wideout for another positive play, this time for eight yards. 

“We have a method and a madness for why we do what we do,” said Foles. “It starts with execution, specifically in that aspect of the game, It’s knowing who you’re reading, what we’re trying to accomplish and as a QB you have to make good decisions on the fly.”

Unless you’re inside the head of Foles or his coaching staff,  it’s usually hard to decipher the read that triggers the decision to throw instead of hand it off on each individual play. What’s not hard to understand is why the Eagles are doing it they way they do.


“The key to any great offense is you want to keep teams off balance,” said Foles. “You want to show them looks that (appear) similar but you can do anything out of it. Anyone who’s ever played football will tell you that. Think about it: If you’re seeing the same thing but you don’t know what’s coming, it’s very hard to play. So you just have to wait and see what’s going on.”

By then, it can be too late. Just as Foles has to make good decisions on the fly, so too does a defense that doesn’t actually know what was called in the huddle or audibled to at the line of scrimmage. That means defenders have to make even better decisions and do it in a shorter period of time.

“I mean, look, everything we have to defend in this league is a challenge," safety Devin McCourty told me. "But sure, [the Eagles] really force you to read and react as quickly as possible."

And that holds true not just for the front seven but but for the guys who usually act as the last line of defense: The secondary.

“When you have that run-pass option, pass players that sometimes turn into run players because a guy is blocking him, a receiver or a tight end,” said McCourty. “You can’t free up and just go to the ball because you still have to cover your guy because he’s not blocking. He’s running a route. So for you, it’s a pass play. For the six or seven guys in the box it might be a total run look, so you might not gain any help underneath because they’re playing the run. Individually, matchup-wise if we're in man-to-man or it’s a zone and a guy is in our zone we've got to be sound and be able to play what we're getting. It’s a run-pass option so it could be a run, but if you’re getting a pass play in coverage then you need to play the pass. When the pass comes up you’re ready to play and the guys up front that play the run have to play the run.”

Doug Pederson had never called his own plays until he took over as the Eagles head coach. He’s a West Coast-offense disciple, having learned under Mike Holmgren. He was introduced to the RPO game while serving as offensive coordinator in Kansas City under Andy Reid, who felt it was the best way to utilize then-QB Alex Smith’s skill set. It was something San Francisco had done well with Smith before handing the keys to Colin Kaepernick.

Part of what fascinated Pederson about that style of offense was how it often tested the opposing team’s discipline or, even more finite, that one player who is being read.

If it’s the linebacker and he sells out to stop the run, a smart quarterback knows to fake and hit the receiver running to that vacated area on what’s usually a simple slant. But if that ‘backer is thinking pass first and peels back into coverage, usually the quarterback is taught to quickly turn his attention to the edge player, be it a defensive end, outside linebacker or even a safety or slot corner. If they crash down, it’s on the QB to keep the ball himself. Bortles did that with some success against both Buffalo and Pittsburgh in previous playoff rounds. To the Pats' credit, they handled that end of it two Sundays ago.

At the end of the day you’ve got guys who are assigned to certain things. You’ve just got to do your job. 

-- Kyle Van Noy

Foles hasn’t had to show off whatever athleticism he possesses on that front, either. It’s not that he’s gone undefended in those instances. It’s just that the more desired options have been available to him. 

Carolina Pro Bowl linebacker Thomas Davis has seen just about everything in his decade-long career. Speaking at the end of the season, he made it clear that the RPO game isn’t going away any time soon because -- quite frankly -- it’s too damn hard to defend.

"It's pretty much a play where you can't be right as a linebacker," Davis said. "Because if you guess and you play downhill to play the run, they're going to throw the ball right where you were. If you drop back and you play the pass, then they're going to hand the ball off. So the quarterback is basically reading the linebackers and safeties in that situation and it's a situation where a lot of the time you can't be right.”

But as has been illustrated here, it’s not just the linebacker who’s getting put into the blender. Go back to Flowers, who grew quite animated when I asked how much of a challenge it is to not go with the flow of the play, especially if that flow has ripped off five, six and seven yards a pop.

“You say to yourself, 'Stay, stay, stay,' " he said. “It challenges you instinctively because they’ll fake you here and throw over there. They’ve got a lot of things going on the other way and that means you definitely have to go against your instincts.”

How hard is that?

“Very hard. But that’s what we need to do if we’re going to be successful Sunday.”