Bears Camping Out 2016: WRs need to prove durability as well as abilities

Bears Camping Out 2016: WRs need to prove durability as well as abilities

The accomplishments of the offense under then-coordinator Adam Gase and quarterback Jay Cutler become all the more impressive when placed in the context of available resources.

At no time, from the beginning of training camp on, did the offense have its projected top three receivers available, and barely did the offense have even two of the three simultaneously.  Wideouts Alshon Jeffery and Eddie Royal, who played in a combined 63 of 64 total games the preceding two seasons, missed 14 combined entire games in 2015 and portions of several others because of myriad injuries.

And Kevin White, the No. 7 pick of the draft and slated to start opposite Jeffery, was lost to a stress fracture until late in the season when the decision was made, with the Bears sitting at 5-8 after demoralizing losses to San Francisco and Washington, to hold him out for the entire season.

Jeffery was a virtual non-participant in training camp and preseason because of a calf strain, foreshadowing a succession of lower-body injuries that made a long-term contract impractical at his price and use of the franchise tag a logical compromise. Jeffery’s anticipated playing this season for the guaranteed $14.6 million tag amount became official on Friday afternoon when the deadline for a deal passed.

Jeffery finished with 54 receptions, good enough to lead the Bears. But his 807 yards, a decline from his 1,421 of 2013 and 1,133 of 2014, was still more than any two other Bears combined. Royal was signed to be principally the No. 3, but with White unavailable, was pressed into starting all nine of the games he played and finished with 37 catches but only one for a touchdown.

The Bears got production from Marquess Wilson (28 catches), Marc Mariani (22), Josh Bellamy (19) and Cameron Meredith (11), all combining for 14 starts. But the group netted just three total touchdowns. Mariani emerged as a viable third-receiver option, with first downs recorded on 19 of his 22 catches and 11-for-11 on third-down targets.

Offseason adjustments

The exit of Gase to Miami, replaced by promoting Dowell Loggains from QB coach to coordinator, will stand as one of the single biggest adjustments within the entire on-field operations. The Bears also allowed receivers coach Mike Groh to leave for a post as passing-game coordinator and receivers coach with the Los Angeles Rams. In his place the organization hired Tulane receivers coach Curtis Johnson, who worked as a member of the New Orleans Saints staff during the Super Bowl season of 2009 and while Bears GM Ryan Pace was in personnel there.

White began making a major impression in closed practices once he was cleared for work late in the season. His developing a relationship with Cutler has been an emphasis this offseason. The two watched the Super Bowl together and traveled to Tennessee for some work together. “That’s been going good,” White said. “He’s a great leader. A great guy. So we’re trying to get on the same page.”

To the Bears dissatisfaction, Jeffery opted out of working with the team in Chicago other than for mandatory sessions, instead working out in south Florida on his own program. “I was just working on some soft tissues issues,” Jeffery said. “I was working out with my trainer and some other people I was seeing down there.”

The Bears used a seventh-round draft pick on Daniel Braverman out of Western Michigan, where he caught 108 passes for 1,367 yards and 13 touchdowns. Undrafted free agent Kieren Duncan secured a spot at least on the roster going into training camp.

Wilson was lost for an undetermined amount of time, expected to include the first six weeks of the regular season, when he fractured his foot during a minicamp practice.

But the focus is less on the depth chart than what the top of the chart – Jeffery and White – generates in their first time working together.

“They’re still learning,” Cutler said. “Al has got a little catching up to do with some of the stuff that we’re putting in, and then Kevin, taking a year off, it’s hard for anybody to not play football for a year. He played at West Virginia where our offense is a little bit different. So he’s kind of got a year and a half of just straight catching up with what he has to do in a short amount of time.”


WR  Alshon Jeffery

WR  Kevin White

WR  Eddie Royal

The Mix

Josh Bellamy

Daniel Braverman

Kieren Duncan

Derek Keaton

Marc Mariani

Cameron Meredith

Darrin Peterson

Deonte Thompson

3 questions camp will begin to answer…

…What exactly does $14.6 million buy the Bears?

Jeffery’s mindset and dedication have been subjects of conjecture, particularly after he missed seven games last season in what was a contract year. The franchise tag makes him one of the highest-paid receivers for 2016, but he was not an integral part of the offseason program and is a health concern until he isn’t.

And there is the matter of a new offensive coordinator, new receivers coach and a new wideout on the opposite side. “I mean, there were a few tweaks here and there,” Jeffery said, “but pretty much most of the stuff is still the same.”

…How far behind will Kevin White be after missing his entire rookie season beyond a handful of practices?

White’s attitude and work ethic are exemplary, but he had a handful of drops in offseason sessions, and does not have the NFL-experience base that his teammates have as the offense undergoes a change of coordinator. His to-learn list is extensive:

“Learning different types of coverages,” White began. “What the corners and safeties jobs are to stop a certain kind of concept we may run. Learning different types of techniques as far as press release, versus off and zone. That sort of stuff.”

…Is there quality and durability after Jeffery and White?

Not that either of those two have established records of durability, but Royal turns 30 and is coming off missing games at three different points last season. Wilson already is down until further notice. The Bears need to get through camp healthy and with starter-grade quality evident in more than their top two receivers.

2017 Bears position grades: Offensive Line

2017 Bears position grades: Offensive Line

2017 grade: C+

Level of need: Medium

Decisions to be made on: Josh Sitton (contract), Eric Kush (contract), Hroniss Grasu (contract), Bobby Massie (contract), Tom Compton (free agent), Bradley Sowell (free agent)

Possible free agent targets: Andrew Norwell, D.J. Fluker, Justin Pugh, Josh Kline, Jonathan Cooper

How the Bears’ offensive line will shape up in 2018 begins with a decision on which the Bears are already on the clock. The team has until March 9 to pick up Josh Sitton’s 2018 option -- or, to put it another way, they have until March 9 to determine if Sitton was/is/will be good enough to justify keeping him and not netting about $8 million in cap savings, per Spotrac. 

For what it’s worth, Bleacher Report ranked Sitton as the league’s sixth-best guard in 2017. If the Bears’ grades of Sitton match those outside ones, then the team probably won’t cut him -- not destabilizing Mitchell Trubisky’s offensive line would be well worth the money in that case. While Sitton turns 32 in June, cutting him would put a lot of pressure on Kyle Long, who hasn’t been fully healthy since 2016. The Bears are hopeful that Long will be back to full strength after multiple offseason surgeries, but releasing Sitton and then signing/drafting his replacement would be a gamble on Long’s health. 

Sitton’s status is the first part of the Bears’ 2018 offensive line equation. There’s also a decision to be made on Bobby Massie, who Bleacher Report ranked as the NFL’s 14th-best right tackle last year but could be cut for about $5.5 million in cap savings, according to Spotrac. It wouldn’t be surprising if the Bears cut or kept both Sitton and Massie for now, then drafted an offensive lineman in the first round (like Notre Dame guard Quenton Nelson or Texas tackle Connor Williams) and released one of them. Or they could keep both through the end of the 2018 season. All those options would make sense on some level.

What wouldn’t seem to make sense is the Bears cutting Sitton or Massie and replacing them with a free agent. This year’s offensive line free agent class, without adding any potential cap casualties to it, isn’t particularly strong. By Bleacher Report’s rankings, the best free agent right tackle is Houston’s Breno Giancomi, who’s 27th in that list -- 13 spots behind Massie. At left tackle, New England’s Nate Solder (No. 22) isn’t rated as highly as Charles Leno (No. 20), who we'll talk about in a bit here. 

The only potential upgrade available via free agency would be Carolina Panthers guard Andrew Norwell (No. 2 in B/R’s rankings), who’s 26 and is in line for a big payday this spring -- but that would seemingly be counter-intuitive to releasing Sitton and then potentially paying more money to a different guard, even if he’s younger and has more long-term upside. The Bears could opt for a cheaper guard in free agency who could have some potential working with respected O-line coach Harry Hiestand -- the Giants’ D.J. Fluker (57th in B/R’s rankings) or Justin Pugh (42nd) fit that mold, as would the Titans’ Josh Kline (37th) or Cowboys’ Jonathan Cooper (38th). Or the Bears could keep Sitton and still sign one of those guys as insurance in case Long and/or Eric Kush, who tore his ACL last training camp, isn’t ready to start the season. 

Tom Compton and Bradley Sowell proved to be serviceable backups last year and could be an option to return, even with a new coaching staff in place. The health of Kush, who was missed as a reliable backup in 2017, will be important in figuring out what the Bears' O-line depth looks like. Hroniss Grasu struggled when he was on the field and missed time due to a hand injury, and despite playing for offensive coordinator Mark Helfrich at Oregon could be on the chopping block before/during training camp. 

We’ll finish here with some thoughts on Leno and Cody Whitehair. Could the Bears upgrade at left tackle and displace Leno to the right side of the offensive line? Possibly, especially if Hiestand believes he can make that move work. But it’d be odd if the Bears shifted Leno off left tackle and then signed someone who’s older and, depending on the evaluator, not even as good as him. 

This is all probably a moot point, since the Bears’ internal evaluation of Leno is what matters here. Leno is 26 and the Bears believe he hasn’t reached his ceiling yet, so more than likely, he’s sticking where he is. At the very least, he’ll enter 2018 with a starting job on the Bears’ offensive line. 

One other offseason objective for Hiestand and the new coaching staff: Keeping Whitehair at the same position. Whitehair’s versatility felt like it worked against him at times last year, with the former regime opting to shift him between guard and center quite a bit from the start of training camp through the early part of the season. That instability seemed to affect Whitehair’s play, as he went through a bizarre patch of snapping issues after moving back to center and struggled to be as consistent as he was in 2016. But Whitehair finished 2017 strong, and keeping him at center for the entirety of 2018 could get him back on track to make his first Pro Bowl. 

2017 Bears position grades: Wide receivers

2017 Bears position grades: Wide receivers

2017 grade: D-

Level of need: High

Decisions to be made on: Markus Wheaton (contract), Dontrelle Inman (free agent), Kendall Wright (free agent), Josh Bellamy (free agent), Kevin White (fifth-year option)

Possible free agent targets: All of them? (But more specifically Jarvis Landry, Mike Wallace, Paul Richardson, Marqise Lee, Ryan Grant, Eric Decker, Albert Wilson, Donte Moncrief, Jaron Brown, Taylor Garbriel, Terrelle Pryor, John Brown, Allen Robinson)

The Bears cannot go into 2018 with a wide receiver core as weak as the one with which Mitchell Trubisky had to work in 2017. That doesn’t necessarily mean they have to go out and sign Jarvis Landry for huge money and then draft, say, Alabama’s Calvin Ridley, but adding multiple reliable wide receivers is a massive need for the offseason. A blend of free agents and draft picks seems like the most likely route.

Before we look at this year’s free agent class, a word on Cameron Meredith, who said this on locker cleanout day Jan. 1: “Training camp for sure I’ll be back. Right now it’s staying on pace so that I can do that. Yes, full recovery.”

The Bears shouldn’t count on Meredith to improve off his 66-catch, 888-yard 2016 season by virtue of him coming back from a torn ACL suffered last August. But it’s also not like any production from Meredith will be a bonus; if he’s even close to the player he was two years ago, he’ll be a significant part of the Bears’ offense.

So if the Bears are counting on Meredith to play in 2018, do they absolutely need to go out and splurge for the best receiver on the market in Jarvis Landry? Not necessarily. Landry reportedly wants Davante Adams money (four years, $58 million, with $32 million guaranteed) and might get more than that if a bidding war develops on the open market.

Would Landry be worth it? He followed consecutive 1,100-yard seasons in 2015 and 2016 with a league-leading 112 receptions in 2017, and won’t turn 26 until next November, so yeah, he very well could be. The Bears should have enough cap space to chase Landry, too.

But for a few reasons, Ryan Pace has either never landed nor pursued the priciest free agents in his three cycles as general manager. He splashed $38.75 million for Pernell McPhee in 2015; that was the 10th-largest free agent contract signed that year and has the 13th-highest amount of guaranteed money, per Spotrac. Danny Trevathan got $28 million in 2016 (22nd among free agents), and Mike Glennon’s ill-fated $45 million contract ranked 11th last year (with significantly less guaranteed money).

The other part of Pace’s free agency strategy hasn’t been under his control: The Bears just haven’t been an enticing destination lately. Cornerback A.J. Bouye -- 2017’s highest-paid free agent -- turned down more money from the Bears to sign with the Jacksonville Jaguars, for example.

The Bears hope that’s changing, with a promising franchise quarterback, a young and affable head coach and a major renovation to Halas Hall. For all the losing, and for all the gripes outside Lake Forest about John Fox, the Bears did have a good culture in their locker room. Selling the future of this franchise should be a lot easier in 2018 than it was in 2017.

Will that all add up to the Bears signing Landry to a huge contract? Not necessarily. The Bears could make a strong pitch and sizable offer, but he could be lured by another team that’s had more recent success (like the Oakland Raiders). Or Pace could continue to look for bargains in free agency, which hasn’t particularly worked out for him in the past, but then take a receiver with the Bears’ first-round pick.

But perhaps Pace will see his long-term vision coming together, and will see a big-ticket free agent like Landry being the guy who puts the Bears over the hump from winning to losing. He could be the franchise’s Jon Lester, or if you’re a hopeful White Sox fan, Manny Machado.

But here’s a counter to the argument for signing Landry: Kansas City’s offense last year didn’t have a big-time outside target. Tyreek Hill’s versatility and explosive playmaking ability made him the Chiefs’ best wide receiver, but he was able to line up at almost any position on the field. Albert Wilson (who’s a free agent) had the second-most targets of among Chiefs receivers with 62; tight end Travis Kelce was targeted a team-high 122 times.

The Bears don’t have a Hill or a Kelce on their roster. Tarik Cohen and Adam Shaheen could be the “light” versions of both, which may necessitate a need for better “traditional” wide receivers. That doesn’t necessarily mean Landry, to be fair.

Mike Wallace is 31 but showed he still has something in the tank, missing only one game the last two years while racking up 1,765 yards and eight touchdowns for the Baltimore Ravens. Paul Richardson had a breakout 2017 with the Seattle Seahawks, catching 44 passes for 703 yards with six touchdowns as an effective deep threat. Marqise Lee had 119 catches for 1,553 yards in the vertically-challenged Jaguars offense the last two years. Ryan Grant has never missed a game in his four-year career and is coming off a career best 45-catch, 573-yard season with Washington. The aforementioned Wilson caught 42 passes for 554 yards with the Chiefs last year, both career highs.

Perhaps no free agent receivers have as much to prove than Terrelle Pryor and Donte Moncrief. Pryor, like Alshon Jeffery, found the free agent market weak in 2017 and took a one-year prove-it deal, but instead turning it into an extension and Super Bowl ring, he bombed with only 20 catches for 240 yards with Washington. It’d be a risk, but if he can get the stink of 2017 off him and flash the talent that got him 77 receptions and over 1,000 yards with the Cleveland Browns in 2016, he’d be worth it.

Moncrief is another interesting name out there. He was targeted over 100 times in 2015 and caught 64 passes for 733 yards and six touchdowns as the big-bodied complement to T.Y. Hilton in Indianapolis, but struggled to stay healthy the last two years, only playing 21 games and totaling 56 receptions for 698 yards.

One other guy to highlight: Allen Robinson. The Jaguars probably won’t let him get away, but even if they do, would the Bears really want to sign him and then have three wide receivers coming off season-ending injuries (Meredith and Kevin White being the other two; Robinson tore his ACL in Week 1 last year). The Rams’ Sammy Watkins is also an impending free agent, but it’d be a huge surprise if Los Angeles let him hit the open market, so he’s not worth considering for the Bears right now.

We’ll see what direction Pace takes next month with free agency. But expect the Bears to return no more than one receiver from their Week 2 lineup -- Kendall Wright (59 receptions, 614 yards) is probably the only guy who could be back, if the two parties want to re-unite. Wright, as it stands for my grade, was the only guy keeping this unit from an “F,” as in a total failure.

Markus Wheaton, who became only one of nine players since 1992 to be targeted at least 15 times and catch fewer than 20 percent of those targets (he caught two passes), is likely to be cut. It’s unlikely Josh Bellamy or Dontrelle Inman will be re-signed (slight chance for Inman, but he disappeared in December). And the Bears probably will decline Kevin White’s fifth-year option, making 2018 a prove-it year for the former first-round pick.