Bears stave off Newton, Panthers


Bears stave off Newton, Panthers

Sunday, Oct. 2, 2011Posted: 3:15 p.m. Updated: 9:15 p.m.

By John Mullin Bears Insider Follow @CSNMoonMullin
Box score Photo gallery
15 on 6: Run game provides great victory
READ: Hester, Forte receive highest mark
Gameday Blog: 'Devin Hester, you're ridiculous!'
Cutler: Still trying to find out identity
Lovie: Teams may stop kicking to Hester
Moon: On the Bears victory over Carolina
Miller: Shows his praise for Newton

So much for Ron Riveras storybook return to Soldier Field.

Pounding on the ground as they havent done all season, the Bears (2-2) withstood another outstanding show by rookie quarterback Cam Newton to put down the Carolina Panthers 34-29 for as close to a must-win as any fourth game of a Bears season can be.

We wanted to be 4-0, said quarterback Jay Cutler, who had one of the lightest passing workloads of his career with 17 passing attempts. We feel like we gave our two Ls away but were happy where were at. Theres a lot of football left to play.

The win halted a two-game slide that suddenly placed the Bears season in some peril, given a road game against the surging Detroit Lions (4-0) next Monday night. The Lions won in Dallas with a comeback against the over-hyped Cowboys and Tony Romo Sunday and the Bears could not afford to fall any further behind the Lions and Green Bay Packers at the end of the first quarter of the 2011 season.

A defeat would have put the Bears in serious jeopardy with the season just one-fourth over. They lost four games all last season in the NFC; a defeat vs. Carolina would have been the third this season and created potential problems with wild-card scenarios unless the Bears managed a reversal, which Sundays win may have been.

The Bears went to the ground early and for most of the game, including 13 of their first 14 plays. Behind an offensive line forced to shuffle personnel, the Bears sprung tailback Matt Forte for repeated big gains and punched in from the 3-yard line with less than two minutes remaining on a Marion Barber burst over left guard. The resulting 34-23 advantage and security they have not felt since the opening week of the season.

The defense provided points with a 20-yard return of an interception by nickel back D.J. Moore. That was supplemented by Devin Hesters history making punt return in the second quarter.

A key to the rushing effectiveness Sunday Forte finished with 205 rushing yards on 25 carries, making him just the third back in franchise history to run for 200 yards in a game was adjustments made virtually every series to answer scheming done by the Carolina front seven.

Coach Mike Tice and coach Mike Martz came up with a great run plan, said guard Chris Williams. They knew what they wanted to do coming in. Every time they countered us, we came right back with something.


It was not a dominating win in all areas, although each of the Bears three phases scored at least once. The Panthers and Newton blew through the Bears for 438 yards in three quarters and trailed just 24-23.

Carolina added a field goal in the fourth quarter and a late touchdown on a pass from Newton to former Bear Greg Olsen with four seconds remaining. The Bears overcame that with the Barber touchdown run with 1:23 remaining after Robbie Gould converted from 24 yards.

Carolina finished with 543 total yards to the Bears 317.

I dont really care because we won, said linebacker Brian Urlacher. Ill be pissed off when we watch the film but right now, we won, so its not a big deal to me.
Early explosions
With scores from all three phases, the Bears got out to a 24-10 lead in the second quarter. Forte scored on a 17-yard run. Moore went 20-yards to score after intercepting a deflected Newton pass. Hester made NFL history with his 69-yard return of a second-quarter punt for a touchdown, the 11th of his career and most by any player in league annals.

The Forte touchdown was also the first Bears rushing TD of this season.

You get lucky if you can win with two phases, or one phase, said coach Lovie Smith. The best way to almost guarantee a win is if all three phases are working. For us, looking at our history, thats normally been the case, especially when we have at least two.

Newton kept the Panthers at least in the discussion with a pair of short touchdown carries in the first half, the second a 2-yard carry that was followed by an Olindo Mare field goal to bring Carolina back to 24-20 at halftime.

But the Bears were not stopping the Carolina offense, which was trampling the Bears defense. The Panthers totaled 299 yards in just the first half; worse, it came on 100 rushing yards and 199 on Newton passing, meaning the Bears were not stopping much of anything.

The Panthers scored on four of six first-half possessions, one ending in an interception and only one in a punt.
Pound it early

As they had not done in any game this season, the Bears brought the hammer. Every play in the opening drive, for a field goal, was a running play, including a highlight trip around the right side by Forte for 45 yards. Barber marked his first appearance as a Bear by giving Forte the next two downs to rest and picking up 12 yards on the two carries.

Cutler even got into the spirit of things with a third-down carry from an empty backfield. He didnt score but the pattern was being established.

We knew as an offense that we can run the ball, Forte said. We just had to establish that first and continue to do that throughout the game.

Moore continued his mastery of the deflected pass, picking off a ball intended for wideout Legedu Naanee but tipped by linebacker Lance Briggs. Moore reacted out of his zone coverage on the short left to gather in the ball and pick his way through Panthers for a 20-yard touchdown, the second by the defense in four games after Urlachers TD return of a fumble in week one.

The Panthers immediately took advantage of a blown coverage by free safety Brandon Meriweather, who failed to provide deep support behind Tim Jennings after Jennings handed off Steve Smith on a deep route. The 53-yard completion was turned into a touchdown when Newton bootlegged around the right side to score from two yards out.

The Bears opened their game with eight consecutive runs, the last a quarterback draw by Cutler from an empty backfield, to go from their 20 to the Carolina 3, from where Gould converted his seventh straight field goal of the year, from 20 yards for a 3-3 mark midway through the first quarter.

Bad D start

For the second week in a row, the initial problem for the Bears was not their offense, but their defense. The Green Bay Packers started their win over the Bears with an 80-yard touchdown drive after the opening kickoff; the Panthers went 65 yards in 10 plays to set up a 29-yard field goal from Mare.

The drive might have netted a touchdown but for two penalties on former Bear Olsen, who started the Panthers possession with a false start and then was flagged for holding inside the Chicago 10 to push Carolina back out of TD range.

John "Moon" Mullin is's Bears Insider and appears regularly on Bears Postgame Live and Chicago Tribune Live. Follow Moon on Twitter for up-to-the-minute Bears information.

Plenty of possibilities loom ahead of Bears' draft pick

Plenty of possibilities loom ahead of Bears' draft pick

As the Bears begin to fill out their draft board in earnest, they’ll do so by evaluating the players they like and the players they think will be available when they pick eighth in April. And what players check both those boxes and go into their draft “clouds,” as Ryan Pace calls them, will depend largely on how many quarterbacks are taken ahead of the Bears’ pick. 

With about a month until the draft, it seems clear two teams will take a quarterback with a top-seven pick: the Cleveland Browns and New York Jets. The Browns own the Nos. 1 and 4 picks; the Jets traded up from No. 6 to No. 3, and teams rarely invest that kind of draft capital to not draft a quarterback. 

That leaves a few hinge points in how many quarterbacks are picked by the time the Bears are on the clock:

New York Giants (No. 2 overall)

The Giants still have an aging Eli Manning but could move to use the second pick to draft his long-term replacement. Or, alternatively, they could use this deep class of top-end quarterbacks as an avenue to trade down, add some picks and build out a young core that way. Either of these scenarios would be good news for the Bears, as we’ve seen Penn State running back Saquon Barkley, N.C. State defensive end Bradley Chubb and Notre Dame guard Quenton Nelson connected to the Giants at No. 2 as well, if they were to stay there. The Buffalo Bills could be motivated to trade up to No. 2 to make sure they get the guy they want with quarterbacks almost assuredly going off the board at Nos. 1 and 3. 

Cleveland Browns (No. 4 overall)

If the Browns get their quarterback with the first pick — Sam Darnold? — they could be sitting in an ideal spot at No. 4. If the Giants draft a quarterback, Cleveland could play hardball and tell teams they’re fine keeping the fourth pick and drafting Barkley with it. That could create a bidding war between the Buffalo Bills (No. 12) and Denver Broncos (No. 5) to trade up and draft the last of the four clear-cut top quarterbacks in this class. In this scenario, Cleveland adds a bunch of picks to an already-sizable stash and accelerates their growth through the draft. 

If the Giants were to trade out of the No. 2 pick, let’s say to the Bills, it may lessen Cleveland’s desire to trade down from No. 4 unless a team in need of a quarterback like the Arizona Cardinals (No. 15) or Miami Dolphins (No. 11) starts lurking around. But as we saw last year with the Bears trading up one spot to draft Mitch Trubisky, teams don’t want to leave things to chance if they have conviction on the quarterback they want. So that brings us to the…

Denver Broncos (No. 5 overall)

The Broncos signed Case Keenum to a two-year deal and still have 2016 first-round pick Paxton Lynch on their roster, though he hasn’t shown much in only five games as a pro. Does Denver absolutely, positively have to draft a quarterback? No. They’re probably in the same boat as the Giants in that regard. But what if they really like Josh Allen and/or Baker Mayfield, both of whom their coaching staff worked with at the Senior Bowl, and one of them is still on the board when the Browns’ pick comes up at No. 4? Or what if Josh Rosen has been their guy all along? 

In that case, John Elway may make an aggressive move to guarantee he gets the quarterback he wants, and not risk losing that guy if a team were to cut the line by trading with the Browns. 

The other scenario is less positive for the Bears: Maybe the Broncos only have one or two quarterbacks out of this group they want, and they either can’t find a trade partner to move out of No. 5 or don’t want to. If three quarterbacks are drafted in the first seven picks, the Bears may not have the opportunity to draft one of Nelson, Chubb or Alabama defensive back Minkah Fitzpatrick. That’s not necessarily a bad thing — Virginia Tech’s Tremaine Edmunds, for example, is a super-talented prospect — but we seem to be moving toward a consensus that Nelson, Fitzpatrick, Chubb and Barkley are the four best non-quarterback prospects in this draft. And in all likelihood, the Bears will only be able to draft one of them four quarterbacks are taken before they pick. 

The wild card here is Nelson, given his position (guard) is rarely seen as worthy of being a top-10 pick. But those who saw him up close in college believe he’s a future perennial Pro Bowler, possibly beginning as soon as his rookie year. The Bears’ fit is obvious, with Harry Hiestand coming to coach the offensive line from Notre Dame and the team — as of right now — still having a fairly clear need for another interior offensive lineman. Perhaps Nelson falls to the Bears even if there are only three quarterbacks off the board before they pick, but having four go off the board would make things a little less stressful at Halas Hall in late April. 

Indianapolis Colts (No. 6 overall) and Tampa Bay Buccaneers (No. 7 overall)

The Colts already traded down once, and likely did so with the confidence that Chubb would still be on the board at No. 6 to help their limp pass rush. Fitzpatrick seems to be a good fit with Tampa Bay, though a player of his caliber would be a good fit anywhere. Either of these teams still could be persuaded to trade down, especially if the Giants and/or Broncos pass on a quarterback.

Chicago Bears (No. 8 overall)

If four quarterbacks are off the board by the time the Bears pick, that’s ideal for Pace. If three are, he still could get someone from his No. 8 pick “cloud” and be content staying there. If only two are — and this doesn’t appear to be a likely scenario — that means the Bills haven’t found a trade partner and may want to leapfrog the Dolphins at No. 11 to get their guy. More likely, if the Bears are able to trade down from No. 8, it would be because a team like Arizona wants to make sure the quarterback they want isn’t snagged by an opportunistic team ahead of them. 

But Pace's draft history has seen him trade up far more frequently than trade down. If someone who's in his draft cloud is available when the Bears go on the clock, chances are he'll pick that guy and not trade down. 

Plenty can and will change between now and when the draft begins on April 26. But for right now, the landscape ahead of the Bears suggests only positive things setting up for their first-round pick. 

SportsTalk Live Podcast: Will Cam Meredith return to the Bears?


SportsTalk Live Podcast: Will Cam Meredith return to the Bears?

Hub Arkush (Pro Football Weekly/670 The Score), Mark Grote (670 The Score) and Mark Carman (WGN Radio) join Luke Stuckmeyer on the panel. Quenton Nelson works out at Notre Dame’s pro day. If he’s still on the board at 8, should the Bears take him? Plus the panel talks about the Cubs outfield heading into 2018 and if it’s time to shut down both Jonathan Toews and Lauri Markkanen.