Ray Lewis

Brian Urlacher, the Bears' accidental middle linebacker: 'They did the right thing'

Brian Urlacher, the Bears' accidental middle linebacker: 'They did the right thing'

Call him perhaps the Bears’ all-time Accidental Draft Hit. Indeed, Brian Urlacher landed in Chicago as much by chance as by Bears' choice. That Urlacher this weekend is a Hall of Fame finalist sets the stage for an exclamation point to the reality that it was the fortuitous choice/chance for both.

Going into the 2000 draft, the Bears held the No. 9 pick of the first round, and they had a cluster of players they’d determined to be worth that level of pick. Urlacher was among those.

When the Philadelphia Eagles selected defensive tackle Corey Simon at No. 6, the Bears still had three of their targets on the board: Virginia running back Thomas Jones, Michigan State wide receiver Plaxico Burress and Urlacher. The Bears were good with any of the three, so decided that they would stay at No. 9, assured of getting one of the group.

The Arizona Cardinals at No. 7 chose Jones. Inside the Pittsburgh Steelers’ draft room, a furious debate ensued; coach Bill Cowher wanted Urlacher but was overruled and the Steelers selected Burress. The Bears then made Urlacher their call.

Mark Hatley, then vice president in charge of personnel, once confided to this reporter that serious Bears thought was given to playing Urlacher at safety. Hatley and the Dick Jauron coaching staff reasoned that Urlacher’s mix of size, speed, instincts and skills had the potential of producing a safety unlike any ever seen in the NFL.

After all, he had been an All-American at New Mexico playing safety, so maybe yes, maybe no.

“I’m not sure how I’d have been as a safety in the NFL, to tell the truth,” Urlacher said, laughing. “I would’ve gotten better and could’ve played safety, but I don’t think I would’ve had the impact back there that I did at middle linebacker. I was closer to the ball and could make more plays up there.

“They did the right thing, for sure.”

Elite criteria

Longtime Hall of Fame selector and McCann Memorial Award winner Ira Miller once shared with me one of his criteria for selection into the NFL’s ultimate Ring of Honor: “If you were to write the history of professional football,” Ira said, “would you have to include this guy by name?”

Not every inductee reaches that Ira criterion, but any history of the NFL arguably should include Urlacher, a 2018 finalist up for selection to the game’s Hall of Fame on Saturday in advance of Super Bowl LII. That game is being played in Minneapolis on the same date — Feb. 4 — 11 years after Urlacher made his lone Super Bowl appearance, in the Bears’ 29-17 loss to the Indianapolis Colts.

The attention to his candidacy has necessarily put more of a spotlight on the situation than Urlacher would like. In this writer’s experience covering his full career, Urlacher was a great conversationalist one-on-one, but got progressively less comfortable the more cameras and microphones arrived in front of him.

“(Hall of Fame talk) has been going on for some time now, and I think people think I think about it more than I do, because it’s really not on my mind all that much,” Urlacher said. “I honestly don’t think about that stuff, just take it as it comes. Me worrying about it isn’t going to change anything.

“I’ve heard from a lot of guys, a lot of guys who’ve been here and some were disappointed. Kevin Mawae (New York Jets center, 2018 finalist and former Bears assistant offensive line coach) gave me the best advice: ‘Just enjoy the process.’

“If it doesn’t happen, I’ll be OK.”

Talent transcending scheme

Mawae told Talk of Fame Radio’s Clark Judge that Urlacher was a more difficult matchup for him than fellow finalist Ray Lewis of the Baltimore Ravens. The reason runs counter to perceptions/misperceptions that Urlacher was a speed linebacker and Lewis the more physical presence.

“Kevin told me, ‘You always gave me a hard time, because you would hit me,’” Urlacher said. “That’s probably the opposite of what people think. I tried to run into those (offensive) guys.”

Urlacher’s statistical achievements, Pro Bowl selections and such stand on their own. He was named defensive rookie of the year in 2000, defensive player of the year in 2005, and to the NFL’s All-Decade team for the 2000s, along with Derrick Brooks and Ray Lewis, the former already in the Hall of Fame and the latter now a selectee with Urlacher.

But to put him in a broader context: Urlacher was defensive rookie of the year in one scheme, defensive player of the year in a dramatically different one and an All-Decade selection for his combined body of work.

“You don’t get the chance very often to coach and be around a player and person like Brian Urlacher,” said Lovie Smith, Bears and Urlacher’s coach from 2004 to 2012, both winding up their Chicago careers that same final season. “He absolutely knew what every player on the defense was supposed to do, on every play.”

Certain players are products of or significantly aided by schemes that maximize their talents and opportunities. Urlacher transcended scheme.

Consider: Operating in the 4-3 scheme of Dick Jauron and Greg Blache, behind a prototypical two-gap front four that included massive tackles Keith Traylor and Ted Washington and 290-pound defensive ends Phillip Daniels and Bryan Robinson, Urlacher was freed to run while the two-gappers engaged offensive linemen. In 2001 he finished with 148 tackles (based on coaches’ film review), six sacks and three interceptions.

In 2002, Washington was out all but two games and the other defensive-line starters missed five games. Urlacher’s year: 214 tackles, 4.5 sacks and seven passes broken up.

Jump to 2005 and the Lovie Smith scheme that lived on fast one-gap linemen tasked with getting through gaps, not engaging blockers. Ends Alex Brown and Adewale Ogunleye were sub-260 pounds, and tackle Tommie Harris was barely 290 most of the year. Urlacher’s year: 171 tackles, six sacks, five passes broken up.

“That is one thing that shows you how great Brian was,” Smith said. “He put up outstanding numbers in every area — tackles, sacks, pass coverage.”

Brown told ChicagoBears.com, "There are players that can run sideline to sideline and there have been, but not like he did it. You couldn't create a better middle linebacker on a computer to fit in a cover-two scheme.

"He's fast enough. He's smart enough. He's big enough that it made the quarterbacks have to throw over him but fit the ball in just before the safety got there and it was just too hard to do. Most of the time they'd under-throw it and he'd pick it off because he was an athlete. He can jump. He can run. He did everything. He stopped the run. He could run down a fast running back. He could run down a receiver."

Rough start, then ...

Coaches mistakenly positioned Urlacher at strong-side linebacker initially, a job he was given on draft day but lost to Rosevelt Colvin early that preseason. “They just plugged Brian in and I was really upset,” Colvin said in an appearance this week on WSCR-AM. “They put him on the line at ‘SAM’ (strong-side linebacker) and he was just getting pushed around.”

Colvin outplayed Urlacher, the Bears bumped Urlacher inside to middle linebacker and into history, so “If Brian does not call me and give me a ticket to Canton,” Colvin joked, “I’m going to be highly upset.”

Urlacher eventually stepped in at middle linebacker when Barry Minter went down injured in a Wally Pipp moment. Urlacher immediately went on a run of five straight games with at least one sack, with two in the fifth of those games, against the Minnesota Vikings and Daunte Culpepper.

In a 2001 matchup with Michael Vick and the Atlanta Falcons, Urlacher delivered eight tackles, one for a loss, a sack, forced fumble, interception and returned a Vick fumble 90 yards for a touchdown (Vick didn’t run him down). Later that season Urlacher earned special-teams player of the week honors when he caught a 27-yard pass for the winning touchdown against the Washington Redskins.

As with any Hall of Fame inductee, individual highlights are too many to chronicle entirely. But the Bears’ legendary 24-23 Monday Night Football comeback win against the Cardinals, in which Urlacher was credited with 19 tackles, three quarterback hits, two passes deflected and a forced fumble that was returned for a touchdown. "We watched the film,” recalled teammate Devin Hester, “and everybody was saying that he just turned into the Incredible Hulk the last four minutes of the game, just killing people and running over and tackling whoever had the ball.”

It was perhaps the signature moment in a signature career marked by many such moments.

"You knew when you were playing the Chicago Bears that you had to be ready because he was not only going to be ready, he was going to have that defense ready and they were coming at you,” former Los Angeles Rams and Steelers running back Jerome Bettis, himself a member of the Hall of Fame, told ChicagoBears.com.

"The best thing that stood out about him as a player was his leadership ability. That's what you want from your middle linebacker. You want him to be a dominant player, but you want him to be a leader on the field and that's what he was."

Ray Lewis vs. Brian Urlacher: Who has the edge for the Pro Football Hall of Fame

Ray Lewis vs. Brian Urlacher: Who has the edge for the Pro Football Hall of Fame

As things go for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, it’s rare for two players who played the same position to be inducted into Canton in the same year. Running backs Ladanian Tomlinson and Terrell Davis bucked that trend a year ago, while two pairs of quarterbacks (Troy Aikman and Warren Moon, and Dan Marino and Steve Young) did in the mid-2000s. 

But only once have a pair of linebackers been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in the same year: 1990, when Jack Lambert and Ted Hendricks were enshrined (it's also not like there have been a lot of years with two elite linebackers up for election). 

Could that spell bad news for Brian Urlacher (or Ray Lewis) on Saturday?

Urlacher and Lewis are both in their first year of Hall of Fame eligibility, and are joined as 2018 finalists by running back Edgerrin James, wide receivers Randy Moss, Isaac Bruce and Terrell Owens, center Kevin Mawae, guards Steve Hutchinson and Alan Faneca, tackles Tony Boselli and Joe Jacoby, cornerbacks Ty Law and Everson Walls and safeties Brian Dawkins and John Lynch. 

Is that class deep enough to potentially pit Urlacher against Lewis in one of the Hall of Fame selection committee’s cut-downs (from 15 to 10 and 10 to five)? For the sake of this argument, let’s say it is, and compare the careers of the Bears’ and Ravens’ longtime, franchise-altering linebackers:

  Lewis Urlacher
Years 1996-2012 2000-2012
Games 228 182
Tackles* 2,050 1,353
Sacks 41.5 41.5
Interceptions 31 22
Forced fumbles 19 12
Playoff games 21 7
Playoff tackles 211 55
Playoff sacks 2 2
Playoff INTs 2 2
Playoff FFs 6 0
Conference titles 2 1
Super Bowl titles 2 0
Pro Bowls 13 8
1st-team All-Pro years 7 4

*A quick note on tackles: The NFL only began officially tracking tackle totals in 2001, so these are unofficial combined (which included assisted) career totals via ESPN.com. Beyond the odd nature of this country’s most popular sports league somehow not tracking its most basic defensive statistic until after the turn of the millennium, it may make both Urlacher and Lewis’ tackle numbers not 100 percent accurate. Either way, both players were productive on a per-game basis after 2001: Urlacher averaged 7.4 tackles per game, while Lewis averaged 8.8 tackles per game in the same time period. 

Anyways, back to the main point: The statistical comparison above doesn’t favor Urlacher if it were to come down to him or Lewis making the Hall of Fame. Yes, they're equal on sacks, but on a per-game basis, Lewis tops Urlacher in every other category in both the regular season and playoffs. 

But one of this year’s fellow finalists — Mawae, who played for the Seattle Seahawks, New York Jets and Tennessee Titans from 1994-2009 — offered this reasoning why he’d choose Urlacher over Lewis in a head-to-head battle for a Hall of Fame spot:

"I’ve got to view it in the lens of how I played against guys … not as if I was in the coach … I’ve got to do it in how I played against them,” Mawae said, via Talk of Fame Sports Network’s Clark Judge. “To me, Ray was all over the place — an athletic guy, but he was not a downhill hitter. He’s not taking on offensive linemen. He was a jump-around guy.

“Brian Urlacher, sideline to sideline … could do it all … just like Ray. But he was more of a physical player in the box against offensive linemen, and that’s just the way I view it. Half-one dozen, half the other. Both of them are going to get in. You know what I’m saying?”

Both Lewis and Urlacher will be enshrined in Canton. Whether they go in together or a year apart is the first question — and then if Lewis will get in before Urlacher seems to be the second question. We’ll find out Saturday. 

Brian Urlacher named semifinalist for Hall of Fame


Brian Urlacher named semifinalist for Hall of Fame

In his first year as an eligible candidate, Brian Urlacher was named as one of the 27 semifinalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame.  

The announcement doesn't come as much of a surprise considering the brilliant career the legendary Bears linebacker had. In 13 seasons with Da Bears, Urlacher proved how valuable he was against both the run and pass, tallying 22 interceptions, 41.5 sacks and 1,040 tackles.

In other words, yeah, he's a worthy first-ballot inductee. 

As the captain of those tremendous Bears defenses in the 2000s, Urlacher made the Pro Bowl eight times, All-Pro teams five times and was honored as Defensive Player of the Year in 2005. And despite falling just short of capturing the team's first Super Bowl since 1985, the Bears were usually competitive even with consistent offensive woes and a revolving door for quarterbacks. 

There are a few more hurdles to clear before No. 54 dons a Hall of Fame jacket, though. The list of 27 gets cut to 15 before voters make their final decisions as to who ultimately gets the call to Canton, Ohio, and there are several other deserving players. Ray Lewis, Randy Moss, Ronde Barber and Terrell Owens are just some of the other headliners in the Class of 2018: 

The Bears will soon have their first Hall of Famer since Richard Dent, who received the nod in 2011. The only question now is whether the voters make Urlacher wait a year.