If you log the moves Paul Holmgren made during the eight years he spent as general manager of the Flyers, the good outweighs the bad in terms of sheer number of moves.
Unfortunately, the bad outweighs the good in terms of player impact and the salary cap and roster.
As a general rule, the Flyers, historically, have been too generous and too lenient with their players to sometimes make hard, rational decisions.
Example: Giving Kimmo Timonen a $6 million, one-year extension when the club was under salary cap duress and it was clear Timonen no longer warranted that kind of money.
Flyers chairman Ed Snider always took care of his players in the present and in the future with jobs and help once they retired. It’s why so many players -- even those cast aside -- rave about playing in Philadelphia.
It’s like being a city employee with outstanding benefits long after retirement. Everyone was treated like family, regardless of whether they deserved such recognition.
So when judging Holmgren’s eight years at the helm, you have to consider the culture under which he operated whereby every player was treated as family.
Holmgren’s moves in 2006-07 to get the Flyers back to respectability with the signings of Timonen, Scott Hartnell and Braydon Coburn were significant in laying a foundation of stability that righted the franchise.
Yet in subsequent years, he overspent in money and/or years in trades and free agency that still left gaping holes in the lineup.
Coming out of the lockout, the Flyers were ill-prepared to compete on defense and it showed when they failed to make the playoffs last spring.
The signing of goalie Ilya Bryzgalov represented overreaction by the organization -- and that includes Snider. The Flyers were fortunate to get out from under his nine-year, $51 million gargantuan contract only because of a lockout.
Yet the signing of Vinny Lecavalier last summer was just as bad -- five years at $22.5 million for a center who never had a guaranteed spot in the lineup.
The Flyers needed a scoring winger, yet signed Lecavalier hoping he would unseat Brayden Schenn. When that didn’t happen, they hoped he could convert to wing. Failed experiment.
That wasn’t Lecavalier’s fault. It was the organization’s fault.
Hextall’s biggest challenge moving forward is what to do with Lecavalier for the next four years unless he trades Schenn. Lecavalier’s contract is near impossible to move at his age (34).
Holmgren was blunt in assessing his own performance as GM.
“We didn’t win,” he said. “At the end of the day, that is all it’s about. ... Unfulfilled. Fulfilling personally, but in terms of what we’re supposed to do, we didn’t win.”
Here's a closer look at some of the key moves Holmgren made during his tenure:
Holmgren’s best trades
Feb. 24, 2007: Alexei Zhitnik to Atlanta for Braydon Coburn
June 18, 2007: First-round pick ('07) to Nashville for rights to Scott Hartnell and Kimmo Timonen
Nov. 7, 2008: Steve Downie, Steve Eminger and fourth-round pick ('09) to Tampa Bay for Matt Carle
June 26, 2009: Joffrey Lupul, Luca Sbisa, two first-round picks ('09, '10) and second-round pick ('10) to Anaheim for Chris Pronger and Ryan Dingle
July 1, 2010: Second-round pick ('12) to Tampa Bay for Andrej Meszaros
Feb. 16, 2012: Second-round ('12) and third-round ('13) pick to Dallas for Nick Grossmann
April 3, 2013: Michael Leighton and third-round pick ('15) to Columbus for Steve Mason
June 12, 2013: Shayne Harper and fourth-round pick ('14) to the Islanders for Mark Streit
March 4, 2014: Third-round ('14) and second-round picks ('15) to the Islanders for Andrew MacDonald
Jury still out
June 23, 2011: Rob Bordson and Mike Richards to L.A. for Wayne Simmonds and Brayden Schenn
June 23, 2011: Jeff Carter to Columbus for Jakub Voracek and first-round pick (Sean Couturier); thirrd-round pick (Nick Cousins)
Holmgren’s worst trades
June 7, 2011: Matt Clackson to Phoenix for rights to Ilya Bryzgalov
June 23, 2012: James van Riemsdyk to Toronto for Luke Schenn
Oct. 31, 2013: Max Talbot to Colorado for Steve Downie
Best free-agent signing
July 1, 2007: Danny Briere
Worst free-agent signings
June 23, 2011: Ilya Bryzgalov
July 2, 2013: Vinny Lecavalier