Instant Replay: Reds 7, Phillies 4

Instant Replay: Reds 7, Phillies 4


CINCINNATI -- One Phillies debut went pretty well Thursday afternoon.

Another did not.

Daniel Nava clubbed a pair of homers to help build an early three-run lead, but Clay Buchholz could not protect that lead and the Phillies ended up with a 7-4 loss to the Cincinnati Reds in the season-opening series finale Thursday afternoon.

Nava and Buchholz, former teammates with the Boston Red Sox, were both in their first game for the Phillies.

Buchholz left the game after five innings with the score tied, 4-4.

The Reds pulled away with a pair of home runs against reliever Adam Morgan.

After winning on opening day, the Phillies lost two in a row to the Reds. Jerad Eickhoff delivered a quality start in one of them but got no run support. The Phils could not hold a three-run lead in the other.

Starting pitching report
Buchholz pitched five innings and allowed nine base runners -- seven hits and two walks. He gave up four runs. Three of those runs came in the fourth inning when the Reds' first four batters reached base on three singles and a walk.

Cincinnati right-hander Rookie Davis gave up five hits, including both of Nava's homers, and four runs over three innings in his major-league debut, but his mates got him off the hook.

Bullpen report
Morgan took the loss. He gave up a tie-breaking, solo homer to Michael Lorenzen with two outs in the sixth and a two-run homer to Adam Duvall in the seventh.

Cincinnati's bullpen worked six scoreless innings.

At the plate
Nava hit the second pitch he saw in the first inning for a solo homer. He then clubbed a two-run shot in the third to put the Phillies up 3-1. They build the lead to 4-1 in that inning after Odubel Herrera doubled and eventually scored on a wild pitch.

The Phils did not score a run after the third inning. They got the first two men on base in the fifth and sixth innings, all via walks, and did nothing with the threats. Both ultimately ended on double-play balls. One was short-circuited by a base-running mistake by Andrew Knapp, who made his first big-league start.

Phillies hitters struck out 12 times. They struck out 13 times on Wednesday.

Lorenzen had a huge hand in the Reds' two wins in the series. The relief pitcher got three big outs with men on base in the eighth inning of the Reds' 2-0 win on Wednesday night. In this game, he was used as a pinch-hitter in the sixth inning. He smoked a 3-1 pitch over the center-field wall against Morgan to give the Reds the lead. Lorenzen has a history as a hitter. He was an outfielder/pitcher at Cal State Fullerton.

Zack Cozart drove in the Reds' first two runs.

Lineup stuff
Knapp (catcher) and Brock Stassi (first base) made their first big-league starts.

Up next
The Phillies play their home opener Friday afternoon against the Washington Nationals. Vince Velasquez will oppose Max Scherzer in a battle of hard-throwing right-handers.

Scherzer won the NL Cy Young award last season. He is 7-1 with a 2.14 ERA in 11 career starts against the Phillies and 4-0 with a 1.95 ERA in five starts at Citizens Bank Park.

Phillies' ramped-up rebuild demands starting-pitching upgrade

Phillies' ramped-up rebuild demands starting-pitching upgrade

Let the record show that on a snowy Friday afternoon 10 days before Christmas 2017, the Phillies ramped up their rebuild.


What other conclusion can be drawn after the club went out and signed Carlos Santana, one of the best offensive players on the free-agent market? With the signing, confirmed by multiple baseball sources, general manager Matt Klentak has attached a new level of importance to the 2018 season.

Just a couple of days ago at the winter meetings in Orlando, Klentak spoke of how 2018 was going to be a time to "find out" more about the team's young core of players. Who would continue to take a step forward? Who would fall by the wayside?

But now that Santana is here, 2018 doesn't feel like it's just a find-out season. It feels like a season in which the Phillies can continue to find out about players — separate the studs from the duds — and also start nibbling around that second National League wild-card spot.

Sure, a lot has to go right for that to happen.

And one of the things that has to go right is Klentak has to land a starting pitcher to slot in around Aaron Nola and the rest of the staff, which has the look of a bunch of No. 4 and No. 5 starters — until someone steps forward.

Santana's deal is for three years and $60 million, according to sources. Three years is a nice get — i.e., it's not cripplingly long — for a 32-year-old (in April) who hits for power, produces runs and does what Klentak likes best: controls the strike zone. (You could say that Klentak added two players who control the strike zone to his lineup Friday as the trade of Freddy Galvis to San Diego for strike-throwing pitching prospect Enyel De Los Santos cleared the way for J.P. Crawford to be the regular shortstop.)

The Phillies need to do everything within reason to make sure that the first of Santana's three seasons with the club isn't about simply inching the rebuild forward. The Nationals are the class of the NL East, but the rest of the division ranges from ordinary to awful. The Phils, with an improved offense and bullpen (Pat Neshek and Tommy Hunter), can play with the Braves and Mets and clean up on the Marlins, the jewelry store that became a pawnshop, in agent Scott Boras' words.

It's just up to Klentak to get more starting pitching, and he's on the case. He admitted that at the winter meetings. He is particularly fond of young starters with years of control remaining on their contracts. Gerrit Cole, Chris Archer and Michael Fulmer fit this description. It takes talent to get pitchers like that. The Phillies have enough depth of prospects to get one of these guys and their reserves of expendable talent just grew with the Santana signing.

Santana, a switch-hitter who has averaged 25 homers, 85 RBIs and a .810 OPS in eight seasons, is going to be the team's primary first baseman. Rhys Hoskins is going to be the primary leftfielder. That means the Phillies suddenly have a young outfielder that they could deal. Maybe they try to capitalize on Nick Williams' strong half-season in the majors and package him for an arm. Or maybe it's Odubel Herrera or Aaron Altherr.

However it plays out, you can be sure that Klentak will be creative. You can rule nothing out with this guy. The other day, we poo-pooed the Phillies signing Jake Arrieta, who is looking for a long-term deal approaching $200 million. But if Arrieta lingers out there until February and is looking for a two-year landing spot, hey, maybe.

We wouldn't even put it past Klentak to entertain the idea of using Santana at third base a little bit — he did play 26 games there in 2014 — and trading Maikel Franco. The Giants were sniffing around, gathering intel on Franco at the winter meetings. There has to be a reason for that. Also at the meetings, an official from a rival club said the Phillies weren't as aggressive as he expected in trying to move Cesar Hernandez. Could it be that Hernandez would get some time at third if Franco were to be moved? Hernandez is still a trade chip, but he doesn't need to be cashed in until July and by that time Scott Kingery should be here.

There are a lot of ways this thing can go. And with the signing of Carlos Santana — which won't become official until he passes a physical next week — the Phillies have guaranteed that the remainder of this offseason will be a busy one.

It has to be.

The stakes have changed for 2018. The rebuild is still in place, but it has been ramped up. Matt Klentak has improved the bullpen and the offense. Now he has to attack that starting pitching and he has the trade weapons to do it.

Source: Phillies agree to $60 million deal with Carlos Santana

Source: Phillies agree to $60 million deal with Carlos Santana

The Phillies' busy Friday continued with a pricey free-agent signing.

The Phils have agreed to a three-year, $60 million deal with former Cleveland Indian Carlos Santana, a source confirmed to NBC Sports Philadelphia's Jim Salisbury.

It is by far the most expensive contract the Phillies have given out under the Matt Klentak-Andy MacPhail regime.

They had the money. When the offseason began, the only player the Phillies had signed to a multi-million dollar deal was Odubel Herrera.

Santana, 31, has always been a high-walk power hitter. From 2011 through 2017, he walked between 88 and 113 times each season, all while maintaining relatively low strikeout totals for a man with such power and plate selection.

In 2016, Santana set a career high with 34 home runs. Last season, he hit .259/.363/.455 with 37 doubles, 23 homers and 79 RBIs.

This addition provides the Phillies with much-needed pop to protect Rhys Hoskins and also gives the Phils added versatility. Santana is a switch-hitter who came up as a catcher, but he hasn't caught since 2014. The last three seasons, he has played primarily first base. In his eight seasons, Santana has also started 26 games at third base and seven in right field.

The move likely means Hoskins will play left field, and it could facilitate another Phillies trade of an outfielder such as Nick Williams, Aaron Altherr or Odubel Herrera.