David Carr

Why David Carr doesn't rank Joe Montana among top 10 QBs of Super Bowl era

montanausa.jpg
USATSI

Why David Carr doesn't rank Joe Montana among top 10 QBs of Super Bowl era

For most people, the debate over the greatest quarterback of all time comes down to two names: Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

David Carr, it appears, is not most people.

The 2002 No. 1 overall draft pick, who now is an analyst for NFL Network, surely made some jaws drop Friday when he said Montana was not (!) a top-10 quarterback in the Super Bowl era.

Yes, you read that correctly. 

So, why does Carr believe the quarterback who was a perfect 4-0 in Super Bowls and universally is regarded as one of the best to ever spin it isn't a top-10 signal-caller? Well, things just set up too perfectly for Montana.

Um ... all right.

[RELATED: 49ers Mailbag: Should Bosa, Samuel contracts be concern?]

So, just because Montana's talent was such a perfect fit with legendary coach Bill Walsh, that means the 49ers legend's accomplishments automatically are discounted?

Just an unspeakably brutal take.

David Carr defends Derek's costly turnover on downs in Raiders' loss

David Carr defends Derek's costly turnover on downs in Raiders' loss

Former NFL quarterback David Carr came to the defense of younger brother -- and Oakland Raiders QB -- Derek on Sunday, after the younger Carr's incompletion caused a costly turnover on downs in the Raiders' 20-6 loss to the Los Angeles Chargers. 

Trailing by two touchdowns with just over four minutes in the fourth quarter, Carr's Raiders faced a critical fourth down. After the snap, Carr faced immediate pressure, and he threw the ball into the ground in front of not-so-open running back Jalen Richard.

A fan tagged Derek's older brother in that clip on Twitter, and the former No. 1 overall draft pick defended his brother's decision-making. 

The pass landed a couple yards in front of Richard, who appeared to stumble on his way out of the backfield. Derek Carr told reporters in his postgame press conference that the play was designed for Richard. 

"[With] the look they gave us, Jalen's the guy," Carr said. "We've seen it on film work against them a whole bunch of times. We just didn't get it."

Sunday wasn't the first time this season that one of the Carrs publicly defended their brother. When The Athletic reported Derek Carr had lost the confidence of some of his teammates, Darren Carr disputed questions surrounding Derek's toughness.

With the loss, the Raiders fell to 1-8. It's their worst record after nine games in franchise history.

Carr gifts Eagles a Christmas win, late interception leads to GW field goal

raiders-postgame-2.jpg
AP

Carr gifts Eagles a Christmas win, late interception leads to GW field goal

BOX SCORE

PHILADELPHIA – The Raiders had nothing to play for Monday night. They were formally eliminated from playoff contention Sunday afternoon, leaving just two games to wrap an incredibly disappointing season.

Effort never waned against the Eagles, though the Raiders played like a team that doesn’t belong in the postseason.

Offense is to blame for the season going so far south, and was the problem yet again on Christmas night. That unit was awful, and the passing game in particular was ugly as ever against the Eagles.

Defense kept the Raiders in it with one stop after another.

The offensive gave this one away, and was responsible for a 19-10 loss at Lincoln Financial Field.

Quarterback Derek Carr’s second interception was a back breaker, giving the Eagles possession near midfield with less than a minute to go. Philadelphia worked into field goal range and Jake Elliott converted from 48 yards out with 22 seconds left.

There was no late-game magic in that unit, which could move an inch with the game on the line. The offense turned it over four times in the second half, including the final play with the Eagles returning a fumble for a touchdown.

The Raiders ran well against the NFL’s best rushing defense, with 137 yards on 33 carries. Marshawn Lynch paced that effort, with 94 yards and was the team’s steadiest offensive presence.

The passing game, however, was completely out of sync. Protection was suspect. Receivers weren’t getting much separation.

Quarterback Derek Carr couldn’t find a rhythm, wasn’t terribly accurate and made some poor decisions one of his worst games this season. He completed 15-of-29 passes for 147 yards, a touchdown and two interceptions. He also lost a fumble at the end.

Most of his yards came from one pass.

Amari Cooper scored the Raiders’ first touchdown on a 63-yard reception from Carr. Cooper ran a slant and go route, and Eagles cornerback Jalen Mills bit hard on the first half on a double move.

Cooper was wide open for a relatively easy touchdown.

The Raiders struggled to sustain drives, as they have all season, but found themselves in the driver’s season down the stretch.

Defense maintained firm control over an Eagles offensive far more explosive with Carson Wentz under center. He’s out with a torn ACL, leaving backup Nick Foles to captain the ship. Raiders fans will remember him for seven touchdown passes at Oakland Coliseum in 2013, but he was far less effective this time around.

Offensive play was truly offensive in the third quarter, with three turnovers in four plays. Carr threw an interception. Jay Ajayi lost a fumble to plays later and then Marshawn Lynch coughed it up on the next play.

The Eagles only got a field goal from that exchange well into Raiders territory, securing a 10-10 tie heading into the fourth quarter.

The Eagles broke it late, but it wasn’t the defense’s fault. This “L” falls on the offense.