Levine: Don’t deflate the science


Levine: Don’t deflate the science

Neil deGrasse Tyson, the famed astrophysicist, TV host, Internet super hero and spirit animal, once said: “The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it.”

And guess what? He’s right. Science is truth. It’s not absolute truth, but given evidence, science is our most pure and unbiased judge.

Unfortunately, science is also exhausting. It’s confusing. It’s often boring. For most of us, the mere mention of “science” is a portal back to those long days stuck in an uncomfortable desk, in an overheated classroom, doodling in our notebooks while the teacher goes on with the Borophyll, praying that some classmate would lighten the mood with a stupid joke, or a fake fart noise, or anything to break up the monotony.

In our adult lives, we’re not required to sit through science class anymore, so when we encounter anything that drums up those old bored, desperate feelings, our brain taps out and shuts down until we can hit it with something more immediately gratifying. Something to break up the monotony — the real world fake fart noise. Or, in the case of DeflateGate, the fact that the Patriots are claiming that Jim McNally called himself The Deflator in reference to his weight loss.

In the hours after the Pats released their nearly 20,0000-word Wells report rebuttal, The Deflator line was the only thing that made an impact. It was the easiest, most tabloid-friendly, and admittedly, stupidest joke in the entire report. Whether or not it’s true, it looks ridiculous, and it can’t be proven either way. So, that became the rallying cry for those people too lazy to read the whole report and looking for another excuse not to read the whole report. They latched on to that Deflator line and ran with it, and with the way the Internet works, that headline blew everything else out of the water.

Under that “everything else” umbrella lies the most important thing of all: The science.

If you read the Pats’ report, which included a breakdown from Nobel Prize winning chemist Roderick MacKinnon, or this recent article, by Drew Fustin, who has a Ph.D is Physics from the University of Chicago and wrote his dissertation on air pressure, then you understand the truth about this whole mess. You’re aware of the science. Basically, that the conclusions drawn in the Wells report were incorrect. That, even though we don’t have all the evidence, the evidence we have supports the Patriots claim that there was no deflation at all. That the changes in the Patriots’ football, even as compared to the changes in the Colts footballs, were entirely consistent with the Ideal Gas Law. In other words, that Jim McNally didn’t deflate the balls in that bathroom.

And sure, one can claim that MacKinnon has a business relationship (however loose it might be) with the Kraft Group, and one can claim that Drew Fustin, despite his ph.D in Physics, is a Patriots fan. But unlike with the garbled mess that was presented in the Wells report, can one question the science behind MacKinnon and Fustin’s conclusions? Did they manipulate facts? Make unjust assumptions?

If not, then their bias doesn’t matter. If not, then barely anything matters. In that case, whether or not you believe in it, the science is true.

And after all that, if your response is still: “BUT THE PATS SAID THE DELFATOR WAS TALKING ABOUT WEIGHT LOSS. OH MY GOD. WHAT A JOKE. WHAT AN INSULT. THIS JUST KEEPS GETTING WORSE!” — then here’s one more quote from the great NdGT to wrap this column in a nice little scientific bow:

“One of the biggest problems with the world today is that we have large groups of people who will accept whatever they hear on the grapevine, just because it suits their worldview — not because it is actually true or because they have evidence to support it. The really striking thing is that it would not take much effort to establish validity in most of these cases...but people prefer reassurance to research.”

Follow me on Twitter: @rich_levine





Patriots' biggest advantage vs. Chiefs in AFC Championship Game? They have everybody this time

Patriots' biggest advantage vs. Chiefs in AFC Championship Game? They have everybody this time

FOXBORO – The biggest difference between these playoff Patriots and any other this decade? Good health.

Every year since 2012, the Patriots have had at least one major player land on injured reserve during the season and be lost for the playoffs.

IR aside, the Patriots can realistically look at 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2015 as seasons that ended with losses almost completely because they took the field for their final game with key players missing or playing at severely reduced levels.

This year? Fresh as a daisy.

The only veteran Patriot the team put on IR this season was cornerback Eric Rowe. He was capably replaced by both Jason McCourty and J.C. Jackson.

The other important guys who landed on IR were newcomers - running back Jeremy Hill, rookie offensive lineman Isaiah Wynn and rookie linebacker Ja’Whaun Bentley. They were poised to make contributions but their regular-season level with the team wasn’t established.

“I think we’ve stayed away from some of the bigger injuries, which we’re very fortunate to do,” said Tom Brady. “And you’re right, I mean, you know my belief on injuries. I think a lot of them are [preventable]. I try to take as much responsibility and accountability for my injuries as possible so that I can be out there. Sometimes you have bad luck in football. It’s obviously a contact sport. You can take a bad hit and that’s your season. Our team’s been very fortunate in that sense this year to not really take those things. The guys have done a great job staying healthy and trying to go week to week.”

It takes seeing the names to really appreciate the toll injuries exacted on previous teams.

Here are some of the key guys from previous years who were off the active roster when the playoffs came (a nod to my guy Zack Cox at NESN who tweeted the full list here):

2017: Julian Edelman, Donta Hightower, Marcus Cannon, Jonathan Jones, Malcolm Mitchell, Nate Ebner, Martellus Bennett.
2016: Rob Gronkowski, Sebastian Vollmer.
2015: LeGarrette Blount, Dion Lewis, Jerod Mayo, Nate Solder, Ryan Wendell.
2014: Aaron Dobson, Jerod Mayo, Stevan Ridley.
2013: Gronkowski, Tommy Kelly, Jerod Mayo, Sebastian Vollmer
2012: Nobody of consequence
2011: Dan Koppen, Andre Carter, Mike Wright.

Aside from IR, the 2012 season was meat when Gronk broke his arm against Houston in the Divisional Playoff and couldn’t play in the AFC Championship against the Ravens.

The 2011 Super Bowl against the Giants was also hosed by a Gronk injury – that one suffered in the AFC Championship against the Ravens. It left him a shell of himself in the Super Bowl. When Aqib Talib got obliterated in the 2013 AFC Championship by Wes Welker, the Patriots were pretty much cooked.

I’m not recalling all these injuries to play the woulda-coulda-shoulda game. It’s all hypothetical anyway.

The greater point is that, as they enter this AFC Championship Game, everybody’s tip-top. It’s astounding. Nothing wrong with Hightower or Gronk. Edelman is tip-top. Both tackles are good-to-go as is the interior offensive linemen. The secondary’s been healthy for weeks.

That can all change within one series, but if you ask what’s a greater advantage, home field or good health? I’d say good health.

“Obviously, you need your best players out there, and the guys that you expect to deliver, you need them playing well,” said Brady. “The only way to play well is to be healthy. If you have a bad whatever and you can’t do your job – if you’re a runner, run, or if you’re a thrower, throw, or if you’re a blocker, block – I mean, it’s hard to do on one arm or one leg. But, if you can feel good and you can feel like you’re trending always toward feeling your best for Sunday, I think that gives you a lot of confidence. Even some of the games we lost this year, I think you come out of those games and you think, ‘Wow, OK. A positive, we didn’t lose anybody.’ I think we’re at this point this year, and we’ve been pretty healthy to this point.”

As recognizable as Brady is as a diet/nutrition/pliability/training devotee, he didn’t resort to the TB12 Method because the Patriots were lagging behind.

As this story from Phil Perry in February 2015 demonstrated, Bill Belichick is as evangelical as anyone about the vital role nutrition plays 

And sleep (here’s Phil from February 2017 on the Patriots use of flotation tanks for kickass sleep).
And in 2016, Belichick went wayyyyy in-depth discussing the efforts the team expended after the 2015 season ended with practically half the team out or on the injury report for the last game.  

Predictably, Belichick didn’t want to get into a mess of salutes for his medical and training staff two days before the game. Probably feels like bad karma.

But he did allow that, given the focus the team has given to keeping their human resources available, the relative health could be a result of that.

“But,” he added. “I think in the end, it’s a combination of a lot of things. Training is like anything – it helps to have a good plan, it helps to follow the plan, and the players have worked extremely hard. There’s no pill we can take to get in condition or get stronger or get faster or anything. You’ve got to go out there and you’ve got to work at it, and you do that day after day, week after week, month after month, in some cases, year after year, and that’s how you improve, just like anything else.

“So, the players have worked really hard as a total team with a lot of consistency,” he reminded. “I think the work that, as you mentioned, the other people behind in those areas have done has been good, but it’s a combination of a lot of people working together and doing a good job. But, I think you can’t take anything away from the players. In the end, players work to get in condition. Certainly, they need a good plan, good structure – I’m not saying that – but if they don’t work hard at it, then you could have the best plan in the world, and probably aren’t going to have great results.” 

Those results have been so good they may have more to do with Sunday’s result than any other factor we whip out.

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.

Here's where to watch or stream New England Patriots vs. Kansas City Chiefs, AFC Championship Game

NBC Sports Boston illustration

Here's where to watch or stream New England Patriots vs. Kansas City Chiefs, AFC Championship Game

The New England Patriots play the Chiefs in Kansas City for the AFC Championship and a trip to Super Bowl 53 at 6:40 p.m. on Sunday, January 20. Here's NBC Sports Boston's coverage throughout the day, along with a list of where else you can catch the game. . . 

  • 4 p.m.: Opening Drive
    • with Jade McCarthy and Albert Breer in Burlington, and Tom E. Curran and Phil Perry in Kansas City
    • TV: NBC Sports Boston. STREAMING:
  • 5 p.m.: McDonald's Pregame Live
    • with Michael Holley, Troy Brown, Jerod Mayo and Rob Ninkovich at Toby Keith's in Patriot Place at Foxboro, Tom E. Curran and Phil Perry in Kansas City, and DJ Bean in Burlington
    • TV: NBC Sports Boston. STREAMING:
  • 6:40 p.m.: New England Patriots at Kansas City Chiefs
    • TV: CBS. STREAMING: Game PassRADIO: 98.5 The Sports Hub
    • Live Stream: "Watch Now with fuboTV - Try free trial"
  • Halftime Live
    • with Michael Holley, Troy Brown and Ron Ninkovich at Toby Keith's in Patriots Place at Foxboro
    • TV: NBC Sports Boston. STREAMING:
  • At game's end: Twin River Casino and Hotel Postgame Live
    • with Michael Holley, Troy Brown, Rob Ninkovich and Albert Breer at Toby Keith's in Patriots Place at Foxboro, Tom E. Curran and Phil Perry in Kansas City, and DJ Bean in Burlington
    • TV: NBC Sports Boston. STREAMING:


Tom E. Curran's Hard Truths on the game, presented by Plymouth Rock Assurance:

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.