10 takeaways: Jarrett Stidham may have locked up Patriots backup QB job vs Panthers

10 takeaways: Jarrett Stidham may have locked up Patriots backup QB job vs Panthers

FOXBORO – Jarrett Stidham may have officially made Brian Hoyer obsolete.

For the third game in a row the rookie fourth-rounder showed enough arm, accuracy and pocket presence to envision him being the sole backup to Tom Brady in 2019.

Stidham went 6 for 9 for 52 yards on two second-quarter drives then came back and went 3-for-3 on the first drive of the second half for another 19 yards. Beyond the stats, Stidham showed a willingness to stay in the pocket and take a hit waiting for targets to uncover. Twice, he hit Jakobi Meyers with late deliveries. A third-and-12 completion for 13 yards to a diving Meyers was the best throw he had closely followed by a crosser that Meyers snatched from over the head of a Panthers DB.

Stidham played all but the first three drives of the game and finished 15 for 19 for 134 yards.

But Stidham’s night wasn’t without some adventure. That opening drive of the second half ended with a lost fumble when left guard Hjalte Froholdt got turnstiled and Stidham was forced to run for his life. The ball popped loose when Stidham was snagged from behind.

Stidham also took a false start when he hedged on a shotgun snap, turning a third-and-6 into a third-and-11. He had a couple of balls forced into tight coverage as well that could have been picked but fell incomplete.

On the Patriots only other drive of the third, Stidham had a terrific completion on the sidelines to Meyers good for a first down and was the beneficiary of a generous defensive pass interference call to put the ball inside the 10 but shameful pass protection – especially by Froholdt – turned the Patriots backfield into a Panthers team meeting. Stidham was ultimately sacked five times.

Still, Stidham – who came into the game 28 for 43 for 372 with two touchdown passes – probably pushed the valued veteran Hoyer a little closer to the cut line. The arm strength, mobility and upside all argue in his favor. Even this team didn’t have too many other competitive positions where players who make the team will contribute, Hoyer might be safe. But going two deep behind a player who hasn’t missed a game due to injury since 2008 would be overkill.


While Meyers continued to have incredible chemistry with Stidham – he caught seven passes from Stidham in less than two quarters – he didn’t have the same kismet during Tom Brady’s time on the field. Brady’s first throw to Meyers was a deep ball down the seam and Meyers got walled off by the defensive back and bailed on the route. He also had a drop on a throw over the middle and was called for a holding penalty (admittedly, a sketchy call).

Meyers, who got the start, came into the game with 12 receptions for 151 yards and two touchdowns and he added another seven catches for 74 yards. He leads the NFL in preseason yards with 325 on 19 catches.  

He’s also gotten one earful from Brady. Asked if the sideline lecture after the long incompletion was intimidating, Meyers said, “I wouldn’t say intimidating. But I was like man, this is … I’m really being yelled at by Tom Brady.”


Stephen Gostkowski missed a field goal for the second week in a row, this one from 43 yards. Replay showed that holder Jake Bailey had the laces pointed at Gostkowski so the flight of the ball wasn’t ideal. He hooked it wide left. Gostkowski later made a 23-yarder. Bailey will be holding down the holder duties this season, the first time since 2013 that someone other than Ryan Allen has been the regular holder for Gostkowski.


If the Patriots want to keep Julian Edelman out of harm’s way on punt returns this season, Gunner Olszewski so far looks like the front-runner to take over that job. Olszewski had four punt returns for 63 yards including a 28-yarder when he burst from the pack after reversing field. Olzewski, a converted corner from Bemidji State, left the game after a 15-yard catch when he got squished by two Panthers. He’s a very slight gentleman and needs some seasoning at wide receiver, obviously. If he were merely a receiver option, chances are he’d be headed for the practice squad – same with second-year wideout Braxton Berrios. But Edelman could be too vital to the Patriots offense in 2019 to risk putting him back there except on plus-50 punts and critical returns.


The Patriots opened the game defensively with these players on or near the line of scrimmage: Chase Winovich, Michael Bennett, Lawrence Guy, Kyle Van Noy, Donta Hightower, Jamie Collins and Devin McCourty. On the back end were Stephon Gilmore, Jason McCourty, Duron Harmon and Terrence Brooks. That’s a lot of talent and a lot of experience for an opposing quarterback to have to process and it wasn’t long before the Patriots had driven Cam Newton from the game with an ankle sprain. The Patriots allowed two first downs in the opening half (the Panthers were 0 for 5 on third down) and gave up 29 total yards (15 passing, 14 rushing).

“We talked about getting off to a good start against a team that was very high-powered on offense,” said Devin McCourty. “You talk about Cam Newton, [Christian] McCaffery, [Curtis] Samuels – all of those guys – [Greg] Olsen. They're very tough to stop once they get going, so I thought we did a good job of first stopping the run, and then getting a few good rushes in there to mix it up. We've got a lot of players out there that have played good football, either here or other places, so it felt good for all of us to get out there and start to put it together.”


Officials in the preseason are known to get a little flag-happy. The idea is to throw now so that players rein it in when the season starts. But the throwing seemed a little excessive on a number of plays. The 29-yard pass interference against Patriots tight end Ryan Izzo that was called on Carolina in the second half was iffy. Even if Izzo had spun around, the ball from Jarrett Stidham wasn’t real close. The chop block in the first half whistled on Shaq Mason and Marcus Cannon was also bogus. Cannon was executing a chop block but Mason wasn’t engaged with the defender, he was pushing off the hands of the defender as the defender tried to engage with him. There was also a questionable hold called on Meyers when it actually appeared he was getting rag-dolled. There were 17 penalties in the game, nine on the Patriots. Last week, there were 22 with 12 on New England.

At least there was a high bar on replay review. The Panthers tried twice to get officials to drop pass interference flags on the field against the Patriots. Neither time did it work. And that’s good because if the league was looking for clear and obvious contact that has a material effect on a receiver, neither Jason McCourty’s sideline coverage in the first half nor J.C. Jackson’s end zone coverage in the fourth quarter qualified.  


Rookie guard Hjalte Froholdt was a liability in the second half Thursday against the Panthers. It was his missed block that caused Stidham to scramble and ultimately fumble and he was also involved in other pressure leading to sacks. Froholdt, who went to Arkansas, looked slow-footed and not real agile. Maybe it’s just a phase and something he’ll eliminate as he gains experience. Or maybe he’s chronically slow-footed. We will keep an eye-peeled during the preseason finale next week against the Giants.

NFL Rumors: Dolphins trade Minkah Fitzpatrick to the Steelers

NFL Rumors: Dolphins trade Minkah Fitzpatrick to the Steelers

The Miami Dolphins have reportedly traded Minkah Fitzpatrick to the Pittsburgh Steelers, ending any chance the Patriots had to secure their division rival's young star. 

The Steelers will send their 2020 first round pick to the Dolphins for Fitzpatrick, giving Miami three first round picks and six total selections in the first three rounds of the upcoming draft.

Fitzpatrick, a versatile safety with experience playing both safety spots along with slot and outside corner, will help a Steelers secondary that was completely obliterated by the Patriots in Week 1. Ben Roethlisberger is out for the rest of the season, so it will be up to Mason Rudolph to lead the Steeler offense after their defense gets a major upgrade. 

This also takes a potential trade off the table for the Patriots. Our own Phil Perry outlined why it would have made a ton of sense for the Patriots to try and pry Fitzpatrick away from Miami, but it appears the Dolphins will deal their first round selection from 2018 to one of New England's rivals. 

Jalen Ramsey requested a trade from the Jaguars on Monday, so if the Patriots are willing to give up a first round pick for some help in the secondary, there's still an elite option out there. However, New England's corner group has been exceptional during the first two weeks of 2019. 

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.

New York Jets quarterback Trevor Siemian injured on Monday Night Football

New York Jets quarterback Trevor Siemian injured on Monday Night Football

The New York Jets are playing the New England Patriots in Week 3 of the 2019 NFL season. And ahead of that game, it looks like they could be down their top two quarterbacks.

The Jets were already without their starting quarterback Sam Darnold as the second-year passer battles mono. But against the Cleveland Browns on Monday Night Football, they may have lost their backup quarterback too.

In the second quarter of the game, Trevor Siemian was hurt after taking a hit from Myles Garrett. On the play, Siemian bent over backward awkwardly and appeared to injure his ankle in the process. While he was able to hobble off the field, he went to the locker room almost immediately. He was a woeful 3 of 6 for just 3 passing yards while being sacked twice before the injury knocked him out. 

If Siemian can't play in Week 3 against the Patriots, they will be still be licking their chops as they look at the resume of his backup. Siemian was replaced by third-string quarterback Luke Falk who has been on three different teams (Tennessee Titans, Miami Dolphins, Jets) since being a sixth-round pick in the 2018 NFL Draft. He hadn't played an NFL snap before entering Monday night's game.

While the Patriots were likely looking forward to facing Siemian, they'll hardly complain if given a chance to face Falk in what could be his first NFL start. Their defense has been stellar to start the season, so they shouldn't have much of a problem containing a Falk-led Jets attack.

Perhaps they'll be able to build on their historic start to the season as they look to start the season 3-0 with two divisional victories.

Phil Perry's Report Card: Pats D gets straight A's in win>>>

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.