Red Sox

Red Sox doing right thing by not dealing prospects for Edwin Diaz

cp-mariners-edwin-diaz-112818x.jpg
File photo

Red Sox doing right thing by not dealing prospects for Edwin Diaz

BOSTON — Acquiring Edwin Diaz in a hypothetical trade would have been a mistake for the Red Sox. Not because he’s anything less than excellent, but because the Sox can’t put all their prospect eggs in one basket, not for a reliever who’s at peak market value — again.

Diaz is reportedly about to be packaged with Robinson Cano in a blockbuster deal with the Mets.

The Sox have already been down the road of trading for premium relievers with years of control, and they’ve been burnt for it. Carson Smith and Tyler Thornburg both haven’t panned out.

Rightly, people can say that the Smith deal -- coincidentally, also with Seattle -- didn’t see the Sox lose any talent they feel regret about. But that’s missing the point. The talent the Sox gave up was talent they theoretically could have used in another way, in another deal.

Going after Diaz would be the opposite of bargain hunting for a team that at some point, if it cares about sustainability, needs to prioritize bargains. The team both depleted its pipeline and has done little to refill it under Dave Dombrowski.

MORE RED SOX

No one's complaining because they're the reigning champs. Nonetheless, this winter is about the future, and Diaz probably will never command a higher trade value. 

Relievers are volatile year to year, too. They can be pushed aside a bit for starters in the postseason, as the Red Sox showed us themselves in 2018.

Plus, there’s a number of strong relievers available via free agency. The Sox definitely need to add to their ‘pen, or at least maintain the status quo, with Joe Kelly and Craig Kimbrel free agents.

As a general rule of thumb, a team giving up prospects should be less desirable for fans than a team giving up dollars.

We know precisely how teams can acquire young talent, the different avenues. It’s regulated: Clubs get draft picks, some money in the international market. And then from there, you can trade. 

We know what’s in a prospect pool. There are top-10 and top-30 lists readily available. 

MORE RED SOX

We have no clue, however, about how much money teams actually make, can afford or reasonably should be able to afford. We just just accept that a team will probably stop spending in a certain range.

Let the Red Sox pay for relievers this winter, just in dollars. They're easier to get back than prospects.

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.

NBC SPORTS BOSTON SCHEDULE


 

How did World Series champions who missed the subsequent postseason respond the year after?

How did World Series champions who missed the subsequent postseason respond the year after?

With a loss to the Rays and an Indians win over the Phillies, the Red Sox were officially eliminated from playoff contention in a season following their World Series championship. 

Boston has won 4 titles in the last 15 years, a mark no other team has matched in the same time frame. But the last two times the Red Sox have won it all, they failed to make it past September the following season. 

After winning the World Series in 2013 with a magical bearded run following the Boston Marathon bombings, the Red Sox finished with a 71-91 record, which was good for last place in the AL East. They followed up 2004's championship with a first-round sweep to the eventual champion White Sox and then fell to the Rays in Game 7 of the ALCS in 2008. 

Fortunately for the Red Sox, it's become pretty common for a World Series hangover to last an entire season after the fact. Boston is now the 10th team since 2000 to miss the postseason after hoisting that World Series trophy. 

Of course, we know what those teams did after they won it all, but what happened the year after they failed to get back? How many bounced back vs completely faded away?

2004 ANGELS

The Angels followed up their first championship in franchise history with a letdown year in 2003. They finished 77-85 and finished third in their division. However, they returned to form in 2004 and took back the AL West crown. The addition of Vladimir Guerrero certainly helped. The 29-year-old superstar won the AL MVP in his first season with the Angels, hitting .337 with 39 home runs and 126 RBI. The Angels would eventually get swept in the ALDS by the eventual champion Red Sox.

2005 MARLINS

The Marlins shocked the world by beating the Yankees in the 2003 Fall Classic, but finished third in the NL East the season after. Things didn't get much better for them in 2005 either. Sure, they had a better record, but they once again fell to third place and would eventually trade Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis to Detroit and send ace Josh Beckett to the Red Sox. This is probably the path the Red Sox want to avoid. The Marlins have been one of baseball's worst over the last 10 years. 

2007 WHITE SOX

After winning the World Series in 2005, Chicago went 90-72 the following season. A strong showing, but the AL Central was a powerhouse that year. The Tigers and Twins made the postseason over them. The year following, the White Sox went 72-90 and haven't been a real threat in the American League since. 

2008 CARDINALS

St. Louis won its first championship since 1967 in 2006, but missed the playoffs the next two seasons after. Cardinals fans wouldn't be disappointed for long though, as they won another title in 2011 in an epic series with the Rangers. 

2012 GIANTS

Ah, the Giants. Kings of winning a World Series, missing the playoffs and then bouncing back to win another. The Giants missed the postseason after winning it all in 2010, but then came back the following year to beat the Tigers in the World Series. Few will forget Sergio Romo striking out Triple Crown winner Miguel Cabrera to close out the series for San Francisco. 

2014 GIANTS

Look who it is! It's the Giants yet again! The 2014 run was how Madison Bumgarner became one of the best big-game pitchers of all time. He carried the Giants staff on an incredible workload to lift the Giants to their third championship in five years. They're the only team close to the Red Sox' level of success since the turn of the century. 

2015 RED SOX

The Red Sox were terrible in 2014, and while they weren't as bad in 2015, they still finished last in the AL East and below .500. Fortunately they would win the next three straight division titles to go with a World Series in 2018, but sometimes the reload takes a bit longer than you'd want from a team that was able to reach the pinnacle of their profession. Age most certainly played a factor for Boston here. 

2016 GIANTS

Everyone assumed the Giants would bounce back for the fourth time and win another World Series after missing the playoffs in an odd-numbered year. Alas, it wasn't meant to be, and the Giants would miss the playoffs for the second straight season. They have not been back to the postseason since. 

2017 ROYALS

The Royals took down the Mets in 2015 to finally get their World Series championship after falling to the Giants in 2014. The next two season would not be kind to the Royals, where they missed the playoffs both seasons with a record around .500. Kansas City is now one of the worst teams in baseball, but at least they got one. 

2020 RED SOX?

The Red Sox have a lot of questions to answer regarding their roster with Dave Dombrowski officially out as President of Baseball Operations. J.D. Martinez can opt-out of his current deal for a pay raise, and Mookie Betts' extension weighs over the franchise's head too. After a season like 2019, Boston needs to upgrade their pitching staff, but they might not be able to if they want to commit resources to their best players. Boston could be in trouble moving forward. 

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.

Highlights of the Red Sox' 5-4, 11-inning loss to the Rays

Highlights of the Red Sox' 5-4, 11-inning loss to the Rays

FINAL SCORE:  Rays 5, Red Sox 4 (11)

IN BRIEF: Willy Adames' RBI single in the 11th inning gave the wild-card contending Tampa Bay Rays a 5-4 victory over the visiting Red Sox, who blew their 28th save of the season. The defending champion Sox had officially been eliminated from playoff contention before the loss by a Cleveland Indians' victory earlier Friday. BOX SCORE

RED SOX RECORD: 80-73

HIGHLIGHTS

7th inning:
Holt doubles to left, Moreland hits a two-run homer off Morton on an 0-and-2 pitch (2-0, BOS).

(D. Hernandez replaces Porcello on the mound) d'Arnaud singled to center, moves to second when Aguilar, pinch-hitting for Kiermaier, walks, Heredia pinch-runs for Aguilar. Brosseau, pinch-hitting for A. García, walks to load the bases (Walden replaces D. Hernandez on the mound), Lowe, pinch-hitting for Duffy, grounds into a fielder's choice, scoring d'Arnaud (2-1, BOS).

Adames hits a ground-rule double to right, scoring Heredia (tied, 2-2).

(Taylor replaces Walden on the mound) Taylor throws a wild pitch, scoring Lowe (3-2, TB).

8th inning:
(Cashner replaces Taylor on the mound) Meadows walks, Choi doubles to right, scoring Meadows (4-2, TB).

9th inning:
(Pagán replaces Anderson on the mound) G. Hernández triples to right, Moreland hits a two-run homer to left off Pagán on 1-2 pitch (tied, 4-4).

11th inning:
(Kelley replaces Poyner on the mound) Brosseau walks, Davis pinch-runs for Brosseau, moves to second when Robertson walks, Adames singles to left, scoring Davis (5-4, TB). 

UP NEXT:
@Rays, Saturday, 6:10 p.m., NESN
@Rays, Sunday, 1:10 p.m., NESN
@Rangers, Tuesday, 8:05 p.m., NESN
@Rangers, Wednesday, 8:05 p.m., NESN
@Rangers, Thursday, 2:05 p.m., NESN

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Celtics easily on your device.