Jamie Collins

Do Patriots have another trick up their sleeve?


Do Patriots have another trick up their sleeve?

The NFL trade deadline is nearly upon us, and the question is: Will Malcolm Butler get the Jamie Collins treatment?  Could he be gone next week?

TOM E. CURRAN: It's easy to scoff at this possibility but don't forget how stunning it was last Halloween when the Patriots traded Collins, who player after player would describe as the team's best defender. Collins had a reduced role in his final game with the Patriots and had been remarkable in just one game -- the Week 3 win over Houston -- but nobody thought the last grains of sand were coming out of his Patriots hourglass. His situation does mirror Butler's -- both guys essentially in the last years of their contracts and approaching free agency with a desire (deservedly) to make a boatload of dough. But while Collins was becoming actively non-compliant, Butler hasn't been. He's had his down days but he never fails to compete. He hasn't -- in my limited view -- burdened his teammates with his business and he's not poop-stirring with the media. Additionally, he's their best corner. Still. How does the team get better in 2017 by trading him? He's going nowhere until March and then... he gone.

OTHER TRADE QUESTIONSWill Patriots trade Jimmy Garoppolo? | Will Pats trade for linebacker with Hightower out? | Will Larry Fitzgerald pipe dream become a reality?

MIKE GIARDI: Au contraire mon frère.  Butler has been a pain in the ass at times, and his private persona has been a lot different than his public one. But the combo platter of Gilmore's injury and poor play, coupled with Eric Rowe's groin, makes this a long shot at best. Whereas before all that, I'd say it would have definitely been on the table. Now Butler seems to be getting his on-field mojo back and that only adds to a difficult equation. Curious to see what he looks like when Gilmore returns. Suspect the Pats feel the same and would like that to happen this weekend. 

PHIL PERRY: We've said it since Stephon Gilmore put pen to paper on his new contract this offseason: Malcolm Butler is an obvious trade candidate, and it wouldn't surprise me if the Patriots dealt him before Halloween. It may not make them better in 2017, Tom, but we know that's not necessarily a pre-requisite for a trade in Bill Belichick's mind. Did the Patriots get better when Chandler Jones was dealt? What did the Patriots linebacker group look like when Jamie Collins was sent off? Addition by subtraction in those instances, you say? Maybe, but Mike is saying there are things bubbling under the surface with Butler where maybe the same logic could apply. And don't forget, Logan Mankins was dependable and as beloved as anyone in the Patriots locker room before he was moved. The Patriots eventually ended up more than fine after all of those moves (in fact they won the Super Bowls immediately following all three), but it couldn't be argued that they were better in the immediate aftermath. If Gilmore is healthy (he returned to practice on Wednesday), if Eric Rowe is expected to return for the stretch run (he's been doing light running as he rehabs, but his groin issue continues to linger and may have to be managed all season), and if Johnson Bademosi is all of a sudden a legitimate option, then I think there's a possibility Belichick tries to get something for Butler before losing him this offseason. They've done it before.

It's official: Patriots nab third-round compensatory pick in Collins trade


It's official: Patriots nab third-round compensatory pick in Collins trade

The Patriots received a conditional fourth-round pick in 2018 from the Browns in return for Jamie Collins. That's how the trade was described on the league's transaction wire. 

The "condition" of that fourth-rounder? Well, if the Browns received a third-round compensatory pick in 2017, the Patriots would nab that pick instead. 

On Friday, the NFL announced that the Browns had in fact been awarded a third-round compensatory pick, which meant that almost three full weeks after Super Bowl LI, everything was still coming up Patriots.

In actuality, the odds were pretty good all along that the Patriots would get what they got

Cleveland lost Pro Bowl center Alex Mack in free agency last offseason when he opted to sign with the Falcons. Because compensatory picks are based on free agents lost and free agents acquired, and because the Browns did not sign any similarly-impactful free agents, there was a good chance Mack's departure would render a third-round comp pick that would be shipped to New England.

Had Mack suffered a significant injury that forced his play to drop off or limited his time on the field, a third-rounder may have been out of the question, but he played well (named a Pro Bowler and a Second Team All-Pro) and stayed healthy -- lucky for the Patriots -- missing just 17 total snaps in the regular season. 

The Browns comp pick that will be sent to New England is No. 103 overall. The Patriots were also awarded a fifth-round comp pick, No. 185 overall. That was a result of the league weighing the departures of Akiem Hicks and Tavon Wilson against the arrival of Shea McClellin.

The Patriots now have nine selections in this year's draft: One first-rounder; one second-rounder; two third-rounders; one fourth-rounder*; two fifth-rounders; two seventh-rounders.

The third-round compensatory pick acquired by the Patriots carries additional value this year in that it is the first year in which compensatory picks can be traded. A near top-100 overall selection may allow the Patriots to move up the draft board or build assets in the middle rounds should they be inclined to deal. And we know they oftentimes are. 

* The Patriots forfeited their highest fourth-round selection in this year's draft as part of their Deflategate punishment. They acquired a fourth-round pick from the Seahawks last year. Because that would have been the higher of their two selections, that's the one they'll lose. They will make their own fourth-round pick at No. 137 overall.

Patriots To-Do List: To tag, or not to tag Hightower?

Patriots To-Do List: To tag, or not to tag Hightower?

What to do about High?

The most pressing personnel question facing the Patriots in this offseason surrounds a 26-year-old team captain and second-team All-Pro who, since 2009, has played on two BCS National Championship teams at Alabama and two Super Bowl champions with New England.


And Dont'a Hightower not only made the play that set up the play to win Super Bowl 49, he made the play that turned a smoldering comeback into an inferno in Super Bowl 51.

What’s not to like? In terms of impactful front-seven players, he may be team’s most vital. You could see it in the NFL Films "Sound FX" episode when he was the defense’s main conscience and communicator. He’s a run-stopper (witness the stuff of Devonte Freeman to start the second half in SB51) and a pass-rusher (his strip sack of Matt Ryan in the third quarter). He’s a little underrated in coverage, his savvy and decisiveness making up for the fact he’s transporting 265 pounds around in open space against quicker players.

Earlier this season, Hightower told me in the award-winning "Quick Slants the Podcast" segment “Hey! Wassyournumbah?!” that he was encouraged as a rookie to switch from 45 to 54 because of the linebacker legacy that number held thanks to Tedy Bruschi.

Hightower was a first-round selection in 2012 and, with the team $63 million under the salary cap and having already offloaded Chandler Jones and Jamie Collins, the money is there to sew him up long-term.

The highest-paid linebackers in the NFL are outside linebackers such as Von Miller and Justin Houston. Former Patriot Jamie Collins just entered that realm as well with a four-year, $50M deal from the Browns. The highest-paid inside linebackers are Luke Kuechly, Bobby Wagner and Navorro Bowman. Hightower is an inside linebacker though he lines up on the edge as well in some sets. 

A deal that would average out at $12M per year and net him $35M to $40M in guaranteed money should be the goal for Hightower’s agent Pat Dye.

And that’s where the call gets tough for the Patriots. In the past three seasons, Hightower’s played 12, 12, and 13 regular-season games. He’s had knee and shoulder injuries and he plays a position in which there is no preserving oneself. Careers are short and violent.

To compare, Kuechly has missed nine games the past two seasons and his concussion issues at the end of this season were alarming. Wagner just played a full 16-game season this year for the first time since his rookie year. Bowman, a durable, three-time All-Pro, was limited to four games this season. And the Patriots have Hightower’s friend and predecessor Jerod Mayo as a cautionary tale as well.

Mayo agreed to a five-year extension at the tail end of his All-Pro 2010 season. Then knee and chest injuries robbed Mayo of 23 games over the next four seasons.

When Hightower’s healthy, he’s regularly on the field more than 90 percent of the defensive snaps. He played every snap against Houston in the Divisional Playoff Game. With his shoulder a little balky, he played just 52 percent of the snaps in the AFC Championship.

In the past three seasons, he’s played 67.9, 54.3 and 76.6 of the Patriots total defensive snaps.

The easiest answer – and one that it took me some time to realize – would probably be to use the franchise tag on Hightower. The cost will be about $15M for the season and, while that will prevent Hightower from realizing the windfall of a big signing bonus and the on-paper security of a long-term deal, he will have made $22M between 2016 and 2017. He’ll also be headed back toward unrestricted free agency next year as a 27-year-old with, fingers crossed, some years left to play.

Don't anticipate Hightower doing handsprings about that. He’s taken the leadership mantle the Patriots desired him to take and he’s done the things on-field one would expect an elite player to do. Will there be a “quo pro” to his “quid” or will the Patriots lock him down in the golden chains of the tag?

The tag window opened up Wednesday, so the team can make that play now if it wants to. 

I wouldn't expect Hightower to rail outwardly if he were to be tagged, but I think he'd expect a diligent effort to get something done between now and July 15 (the deadline for lifting the tag because an extension is reached), so the tag could be lifted before 2017 starts.