Bears Grades: After one good half, a 2nd-half disappearing offense in loss to Giants

Bears Grades: After one good half, a 2nd-half disappearing offense in loss to Giants

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. – The Bears would be near the top of the standings were the NFL a 30-minute league, ending games at that point instead of needing to win a second half,

But for the second straight week the Bears failed to score in a second half, one this time that ended with a Jay Cutler interception that seemed somehow a statement of its own, complete with a foot-slip and a pass that was an easier catch for an opposing defensive back than for the intended receiver.

Contributing to the problem in the situation was a group meltdown: sack allowed on first down and an illegal-shift penalty on second, creating a second-and-29 after a first-and-10 at the New York 30.

“I tried to put it over the top to [Marquess Wilson], give him the chance there,” Cutler said. “Whatever, long yards there to pick up.”

The offense started the game with three straight scoring possessions, the first time all season for this. Those would also be the only scoring possessions of the game for the Bears.

Quarterback: D-

Jay Cutler was moderately strong in the first half when the run game was working and holding up the rush. He faltered increasingly in the second half as the rush got closer and he was on too many occasions slow to get the ball out of his hands and into receivers’ based on faster reads.

His defining moment was again a turnover, the fourth time in his five starts this season in which he has thrown at least one interception. This one was effectively game-ending, an underthrown ball toward Marquess Wilson that was intercepted inside the New York 25 on what had a chance to be a game-winning drive.

“I went to step and my foot just kind of bounced a little bit,” Cutler said. “Kind of got wider [stance] than I wanted to. Hips didn’t work. I couldn’t get through the throw and it came out flat.”

Cutler was under more pressure in the second half but also seemed rattled and breaking down when forced into faster decisions.

What was most disturbing about Cutler’s performance was that he was 11-for-14 in the first half with a solid run game. In the second half, with the Giants adjusting to take away the run, Cutler was a poor 6-for-16 even against a defense clearly fine with making him throw to win.

[MORE BEARS-GIANTS COVERAGE: Bears defense grades]

Running back: C+

The game plan was clearly structured to run through the backs rather than Jay Cutler’s arm. Jordan Howard was outstanding early, with 72 yards in the first half, on 12 carries. The rookie finished with 77 yards on 17 carries (4.5 ypc.).

Howard committed a glaring drop in the fourth quarter on a screen pass intended to get the offense out of a deep hole. He failed to hold onto a low throw on the following snap, although the play would not have gone for any real yardage. Howard caught just one of eight passes thrown to him.

Jeremy Langford worked in place of Howard and was effective as a receiver, catching three passes in the first half. Langford was shut out in the second half and finished with just eight yards on his six carries.

Receivers: C

Missing Alshon Jeffery because of a suspension, tight end Zach Miller produced on a 29-yard touchdown catch in the first quarter and followed that with a grab for 34 yards to put the offense again in scoring position a possession later. Miller finished the first half with catches on all three of his targets, for 61 yards. But Miller hobbled off the field with a foot injury late in the half.

Run blocking by receivers was abysmal and badly hurt the run game with a couple of blown assignments resulting in sizeable losses.

Cam Meredith caught four passes for 49 yards but was flagged for an illegal shift on the next-to-last Bears snap, adding five yards to what the Bears needed to sustain their final drive. Cutler was intercepted on the next play.

Marquess Wilson celebrated his first game back from PUP list with a 35-yard reception in the fourth quarter to get the offense into New York territory. He was targeted on the final play, the interception, but had little chance to make the catch or break up the ball.

“It’s kind of hard to come back when you’re turned upfield, and you see it at the last minute,” Wilson said. ”[Cutler] gave me a shot and I have to come up and make that play.”

Offensive line: C-

Very difficult to evaluate because of injuries but the NFL does not grade on a curve. The Bears were generally effective up front in the first half, not at all so in the second.

Despite (or maybe because of) missing right guard Kyle Long and right tackle Bobby Massie, coaches put the offense in the hands of the line with a run-based plan that was successful early. The injury problem worsened when Josh Sitton had to be helped off the field in the second quarter with an ankle injury. Sitton and center Cody Whitehair were strong in the run game getting to the second level.

Mike Adams at right tackle was badly overmatched in pass protection, unable to stand up to power rushes and contributing to a pair of sacks of Jay Cutler. Adams was bull-rushed by Jason Pierre-Paul for a strip sack of Cutler.

“It wasn’t anything special,” said Pierre-Paul. “I just beat him. I rushed the edge and that was basically it. It wasn’t anything special.”

Coaching: D

Coordinator Dowell Loggains might have been dubbed predictable after putting football in the hands of running backs on six of the first seven first-down plays but the reality was that the Bears effectively said they were running the ball and defied the Giants to stop them, which they couldn’t. The result was a game plan that did not run entirely through Jay Cutler’s arm, and the Bears led 16-9 after the first half with a 17-14 run-pass balance.

The problem came in the second half when the Giants took away the run game, yet the Bears were unable to devise any sort of passing adjustment to exploit the situation. Despite being in a one-score game, Loggains called just eight run plays in the second half vs. 20 pass plays, and too many of the latter appeared to be deep drops behind an offensive line missing three starters.

Coordinator Vic Fangio eschewed any unorthodox scheming to handle Giants wideout Odell Beckham Jr., and the Bears were effective at controlling the Giants’ primary downfield threat despite getting little pressure on Eli Manning. The Giants had one completion of 48 yards, but no others longer than 20 yards, and the run defense allowed just 3.5 yards per New York rush.

Special teams had individual breakdowns but more problems of execution than scheming.

From Bears’ win over Seahawks, 4 takeaways not named “Khalil” or “Mitch”


From Bears’ win over Seahawks, 4 takeaways not named “Khalil” or “Mitch”

The Bears reaching .500 is in itself news, since the last time it happened (2014) was two Bears head coaches and three Brandon Marshall uniforms ago, and only three current position players (Kyles Fuller and Long, Sherrick McManis) were on the roster back then.

But beyond getting coach Matt Nagy his first win as an NFL head coach, the win over Seattle occasioned a handful of takeaways beyond all of the ones headed up by Khalil Mack and Mitch Trubisky:

Defense in a rush, even at less than full strength

The Bears lead the NFL with 10 sacks (which is on pace to fall just short of the NFL team record of 72 for a season, set in 1984 by the Bears, for those who delight in frivolous early-season stat’ing). The production is especially noteworthy because the sacks are spread among eight different players.

Even more significantly, the sacks haven’t just come from eight different players; they’ve come from eight different POSITIONS, including every position in the front seven in the Bears base 3-4: both outside-linebacker spots (Mack, Aaron Lynch) and both insides (Trevathan and Roquan Smith); both defensive-end slots (Akiem Hicks and Roy Robertson-Harris); and nose tackle (Eddie Goldman).

The rush has contributed to one of the NFL’s worst pass-picking secondaries effectively sealing the Seattle game with one interception (Prince Amukamara) and having the Green Bay game within its grasp on another (Kyle Fuller).

What makes the sack production even more impressive is that none of the stops have come from Leonard Floyd, still playing with one hand encased on a padded cast and whose playing time was cut back from 77 percent of the snaps in Green Bay to 59 percent against Seattle. Floyd has zero quarterback hits in his 85 total snaps but delivered 3 tackles, a pass defense’d and a fumble recovery against the Seahawks despite his limited hand, which is a factor.

“Oh, for sure,” defensive coordinator Vic Fangio said last week. “I mean there’s no way around it. Like trying to type on your computers there with one hand. You’ve got your head in the sand if you don’t think that affects a guy’s play.”

Kevin White’s absence is surprising.

White did not generate the wow factor of rookie Javon Wims in preseason but he revealed an eye-opening ability in the open field with the football in his hands, the kind of yards-after-catch that West Coast offenses treasure. Not insignificantly, with the added reps with the No. 1 offense while Allen Robinson was held out for knee rehab, then working with Robinson in a variety of packages, White had developed a positive relationship with Mitch Trubisky; the two worked out together in California, and quarterbacks have a warm spot for 6-3 receivers with downfield speed.

But White played just two snaps against Seattle, down from 12 at Green Bay, and he has yet to be thrown a pass after consistently earning plaudits from coaches through the off- and preseason.

“I think that’s just how the game goes,” Nagy said. “Sometimes depending on whether it’s a slight injury to a wide receiver, a guy’s out of breath or tired, but there’s nothing either good or bad from that. It’s just the way it kind of played out.”

How White’s NFL future plays out is becoming increasingly problematic, and less and less likely to be in Chicago. Allen Robinson is signed for three years, Taylor Gabriel for four, and Anthony Miller’s rookie contract is for four. White went into this off- and preseason with a clean slate in the form of a new coaching staff. That slate still has 14 games remaining, but White doesn’t play special teams, and the only other players with fewer than 21 game snaps Monday were major special-teams contributors: Josh Bellamy, 2 snaps on offense, 18 on ‘teams; Ben Braunecker, 1 on offense, 19 on ‘teams; and Daniel Brown, 1 and 14.


The Bears can talk about finishing but their two opponents have combined for five fourth-quarter touchdowns, leading to the loss of a 20-point bulge and the game in Green Bay, and turning a 14-point lead over Seattle into a one-TD game. Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson have posted a combined passer rating of 98.4, up from an 89.9 for 2017. The Bears held the Seahawks to just 2-for-10 on third downs for three quarters, then had Seattle convert all three in the fourth quarter.

Neither the Packers nor Seahawks scored in their first quarters, but of the 41 teams scored against the Bears, 35 of them have been tallied in the fourth quarter.

Probably a jinx here, but special teams have been special

Pat O’Donnell’s job wasn’t all that secure after last season, the fourth in his four NFL seasons with a punting net less than 40 yards. The Bears re-signed him but just to a one-year contract and brought in rookie Ryan Winslow for preseason competition. O’Donnell rose to the challenge with a net of 41.7 yards on 12 punts, five yards longer than Winslow on his seven.

O’Donnell has kept his game on: nine punts with a 41.8-yard average net, and four of the kicks inside the 20. His work has combined to allow the Packers and Seahawks to return just two of eight punts, the inverse of the Bears, who’ve had Tarik Cohen return six of the eight caught.

The NFL has been awash in missed placekicks this year – 15 last weekend – and the Bears have had constant and serious kicker issues in the past few seasons, ever since cutting Robbie Gould, come to think of it. Conor Barth after Gould, then Cairo Santos and Mike Nugent and Cairo Santos brought in last year after Barth missed five of his 23 field-goal attempts.

Cody Parkey has made all five of his PAT’s and his four field-goal tries, although none longer than 33 yards. The results have made the Bears one of only 10 teams to be 100 percent in both field goals and extra points through two games.

Bears film breakdown: Matt Nagy's playcalling shines in critical second-half scoring drive against Seattle


Bears film breakdown: Matt Nagy's playcalling shines in critical second-half scoring drive against Seattle

One of the more important questions the Bears had to answer Monday night was how Matt Nagy would call plays if given another second-half lead. Nagy answered that question well against the Seattle Seahawks, specifically with how he dialed up a well-executed 11-play, 66-yard scoring drive midway through the second half of the Bears' 24-17 win on Monday Night Football. 

The Bears never gained more than nine yards on a single play until the final one of the drive, which went for 10. But the Mitch Trubisky-led offense also never faced a third down, with this group staying on schedule while out-scheming and out-executing the Seahawks. There's an argument to be made it was the Bears' best offensive drive of the young season: The other two touchdown drives of 2018 came on the first drive of each game when plays were scripted.

Nagy had to make an adjustment with the Seahawks frequently dropping eight men into the box and selling out to stop Jordan Howard. He did so on this drive, and it got the Bears into the end zone. Here's the blow-by-blow of how:

First play: First and 10, ball on Bears' 34

Tight ends Dion Sims and Trey Burton are lined up to the near sideline, and Trubisky quickly fires a screen to Taylor Gabriel. It’s the first time the Bears give this look in Monday’s game after Nagy admitted he over-used some screens against the Packers. Gabriel does a nice job after the catch to gain six yards, starting the drive on schedule. 

Second play: Second and four, ball on Bears' 40

In 11 personnel (one tight end, one running back), Howard runs a stretch to the right, away from the middle of the field the Seahawks had so successfully clogged all night. Kyle Long delivers a punishing pancake block, and Gabriel holds his own as a run blocker, too, to net Howard a gain of five and a first down. 

Third play: First and 10, ball on Bears' 45

This is the only ineffective play of the drive, and it underscores how the Seahawks' defense had been playing the Bears' offense. On the far sideline, safety Earl Thomas picks up tight end Trey Burton (red arrow), which would've left Allen Robinson (blue arrow) in one-on-one coverage with no safety help over the top because Bradley McDougald (yellow circle/arrow) is in the box. Trubisky sells the pass fake, but McDougald stays committed to the run. The Bears' offensive line does its job but can't block the extra defender, and McDougald makes a tackle for a one-yard gain. 

Fourth play: Second and nine, ball on Bears' 46

McDougald (green circle) blitzes from the edge on a play fake to Howard. Burton (blue arrow) is open for an easy completion at the line of scrimmage, while linebacker Austin Calitro (yellow arrow) backs up as the ball is being thrown, possibly to carry wide receiver Anthony Miller over the middle. He doesn't make the tackle on the play, which goes for nine yards and a first down. 

Fifth play: First and 10, ball on Seahawks' 45

This is the only time the Bears ran the ball into the interior of the Seahawks' defense on this drive. After attacking the edges and getting in rhythm with some quick passing plays, the Bears' offensive line (as well as Sims and Burton) get their best interior run blocking push of the night, with most of Howard's blockers one or two yards upfield before he crosses the line of scrimmage. Howard gains six on the gorund here. 

Sixth play: Second and four, ball on Seahawks' 39

Gabriel lines up in the backfield to Trubisky's right, and the pair run a zone read. Trubisky makes the correct read on the play, and but Robinson couldn't hold his block as the play stretched toward the sideline. Gabriel does well to get four yards on it. 

Seventh play: First and 10, ball on Seahawks' 35

Credit Sims with a good job in pass protection, as he routes Frank Clark upfield just enough for Trubisky to escape the Seahawks' edge rusher and get into open field. Trubisky is keeping his eyes downfield (blue arrow) while moving to his right, and he doesn't see a throw he likes so he takes off and runs for four yards. That Trubisky kept his eyes downfield was generally a good thing, though had he put his head down and took off sooner he probably could've got more than the four yards he did. That's a lot easier to say from the comfort of a couch, though. 

Eighth play: Second and six, ball on Seahawks' 31

Another play fake to Howard draws linebacker Barkevious Mingo (green arrow) toward the backfield, and Trubisky has no problem throwing a quick swing pass to Josh Bellamy (blue circle) for a gain of six and a first down. 

Ninth play: First and 10, ball on Seahawks' 25

A well-designed and well-executed jet sweep with some misdirection to Gabriel (red arrow) draws linebacker Mychal Kendricks (green arrow) the wrong way. Left tackle Charles Leno gets to block Calitro in space (blue circle), to highlight a good matchup for the Bears. This play is well-blocked, but it's again safety Earl Thomas who's the only reason why it didn't go for more, as he diagnoses the play and makes a tackle on Gabriel for a gain of eight to end the third quarter. 

Tenth play: Second and two, ball on Seahawks' 17

The Bears go back to Howard, who goes off the left end for a gain of seven. While only three of Howard's 14 runs came on this drive, over half his yards (18/35) were gained on it. 

11th play: First and goal, ball on Seahawks' 10

Miller runs an excellent route, beating cornerback Akeem King with a perfectly-set-up move. Trubisky, rolling to his left, fires a perfect pass to Miller. Touchdown. 

Final takeaways

A number of players deserve credit for making this drive work, from the obvious (Trubisky, for taking what was there) and Gabriel (for slipping through or past tackles for a few extra yards) to the less obvious (Sims, in particular, had a strong series as both a pass and run blocker). But Nagy stood out, too, for calling the right plays to kick-start an offense that punted on its previous two second-half possessions.