Bears Grades: Defense lets momentum, Bucs QB Jameis Winston slip away in loss

Bears Grades: Defense lets momentum, Bucs QB Jameis Winston slip away in loss

TAMPA – A game in which an opponent scores 36 points should have reflected a defensive disaster but the Bears were not one, save for a small handful of cataclysmic plays. Two, actually, the missed sack by rookie Leonard Floyd and Willie Young on the third play of the second half, and a coverage slip-up one play later for a 43-yard touchdown. Both occurred when the Bears had game momentum within their reach.

“We come back out [in the second half] and they go right down and score on us,” said coach John Fox.

The Bears limited the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to 2.6 per rushing attempt, with no carry longer than 10 yards. They sacked quarterback Jameis Winston four times, and the Bears held Tampa Bay to just 164 yards in the first half.

But breakdowns were inevitable with the offense running just nine plays for a total of five yards in the third quarter and sustaining none of its final 12 possessions (out of 13) longer than 2:52 and turning the football over to the Buccaneers on five different occasions. By game’s end seven different Bucs had pass receptions of 10 yards or longer.

“I’ve got go and watch the film and see what happened defense-wise,” said linebacker Pernell McPhee, although he didn’t need to see any replays to raise the bar for how the defense prepares in practices.

“You’ve just got to get pissed off and study film more,” McPhee said. “We gotta take out there on the practice field and dominate practice. When we go against the scout team, they shouldn’t complete a pass or gain a yard. That’s got to be the focus.”

Defensive line: C-

The defensive line was generally stout and got some pocket push on Winston while shutting down Tampa Bay’s run game. Eddie Goldman marked his return from an ankle injury with a sack of Winston in the third quarter. Goldman was reported to have an ankle issue after the game but “it felt pretty good, and it felt real good just to be back out there,” said Goldman, who finished with four tackles, one for loss.

Goldman was active for the first time since the Philadelphia game but Will Sutton remained the starter and was credited with four tackles. With Mitch Unrein down with a back injury, rookie Jonathan Bullard got his first NFL start but contributed just one tackle.

Defensive end Akiem Hicks was strong against the run, with three tackles, one for loss.

[SHOP: Gear up Bears fans!]

Linebacker: C

Floyd batted down a pass and got a hit on Winston that won’t show up in the stats because the play was nullified by a Tampa Bay penalty. That was in the first quarter; Floyd then sacked Winston in the second when Young got excellent outside pressure to flush Winston into Floyd.

But those were overshadowed by Floyd and Young failing to get a scrambling Winston down on the third play of the second half, allowing Winston to get free enough to throw a desperation pass that swung the tide of the game irrevocably in favor of Tampa Bay. “[Winston] just made a good move, got me off balance,” said Floyd, whose 1.5 sacks give him 4.5 in the last three games. “Then he kept repeating, I kept after him but he just stepped up and let it ride” for a 39-yard completion that was a decisive momentum-turner for the game.

“We just gotta get him on the ground, that’s all,” Young added.

Secondary: D

The pass rush was too inconsistent to help the secondary lock down on Tampa Bay receivers, who had too many open catches and too many significant gains on breakdowns.

Adrian Amos was beaten cleanly across the middle by tight end Cameron Brate for Tampa Bay’s second-quarter touchdown. Tracy Porter lost track of wideout Mike Evans on a broken play that resulted in a 39-yard completion on a desperation heave by Winston. One play later Cre’Von LeBlanc let wide receiver Freddie Martino break behind him for what was a clinching 43-yard TD in the third quarter.

If there was any irony to the situation it was that Evans, Tampa Bay’s leading receiver and TD producer, managed no scores and and 27 total yards on his other three receptions. And Martino’s was his only catch of the game.

“It was a route from the other side and I just recognized it late,” said LeBlanc, who had three tackles for the game.

Harold Jones-Quartey gathered in a pass off the hands of wideout Cecil Shorts for a first-quarter interception inside the Tampa Bay 25. The takeaway produced nothing as Jay Cutler lost the football on a strip-sack at the Tampa Bay 4.

Special teams: D

Connor Barth gave the entire team a much-neede boost with a 54-yard field goal late in the first quarter after Tampa Bay’s defensive touchdown. Pat O’Donnell had another effective game, averaging 42.6 yards net on five punts, two down inside the 20.

Deonte Thompson made a dubious decision to run back a kickoff late in the second quarter, fielding the ball in the end zone while some blockers appeared to assume Thompson would take the touchback.

Eddie Royal returned punts but fielded one inside the Chicago 5 and was nearly taken down in the end zone before leaving the offense at the 2. That series resulted in a strip-sack on which the football went out of the back of he end zone for a safety.

Bears receive Sports Illustrated's top offseason grade in NFC North

Bears receive Sports Illustrated's top offseason grade in NFC North

The Chicago Bears are less than one month from the start of training camp, but the praise for general manager Ryan Pace's offseason continues to pour in.

Pace and the Bears received an A for their offseason -- the best grade in the NFC North -- from Sports Illustrated. A big part of the perfect score was the overhaul at wide receiver.

Chicago had one of the weakest receiving groups in the NFL last season—the team ranked dead last in passing yards per game (175.7)—so that position was clearly an area of focus this offseason for general manager Ryan Pace. The additions of Allen Robinson from Jacksonville, Taylor Gabriel from Atlanta and Anthony Miller via the draft will boost a stagnant group, assuming Robinson returns fully healthy from last September’s ACL tear. If 2015 first-round pick Kevin White can stay healthy for a full season for the first time in his ill-fated career, it’s an added bonus.

Much is expected from the revamped group of pass-catchers even though none of them have an overwhelming history of production. Robinson had a dominant season in 2015 (1,400 yards, 14 touchdowns), but his last two seasons involved mediocre production in 2016 and a torn ACL in Week 1 last year. Gabriel's never topped more than 621 yards in a season and tight end Trey Burton has been a backup his whole career. Miller has yet to play a snap in the NFL and White, now entering his fourth season, is still looking for his first touchdown catch.

Mitch Trubisky has a lot of work to do once training camp kicks off. Not only must he master coach Matt Nagy's offense, but he must do so while building chemistry with all of his new receivers. Growing pains will happen, but the upside and expectations for the Bears in 2018 are higher than they've been in many years, and it's all because of a great offseason had by the front office.

Bears shut out (again) in NFL Network players’ poll naming Top 100 players of 2018


Bears shut out (again) in NFL Network players’ poll naming Top 100 players of 2018

No NFL season is without its snubs – Pro Bowl omissions, (insert job)-of-the-year head-scratchers, endless “rankings” of units and individuals based on some sort of logic or arcane analyses that challenge credulity.

But the Bears have received a group snub for the second straight year, something that, even discounting personality factors, can be considered a cause for concern, and escalating concern at that.

No Bear is among the Top 100 NFL players as voted on by those NFL players, in the results of the annual poll by NFL Network/ The final 10-1 selections air Monday night on NFL Network, but any suspense involves only whether Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers is the players’ choice for the No. 1 player in their game, or how the Bears can possibly match up with the L.A. Rams this season and beyond with three in the top 38 and all young (Aaron Donald, Todd Gurley, Jared Goff).

This year’s blanking follows a shutout in last year’s poll, which represented returns from more than 900 players. This year the number was more than 1,100, making the rankings more than simply the opinion of an individual or even small group.

Making them more disquieting from a Bears perspective is the fact that this marks a de facto third consecutive year that the Bears approach a season without a player whose peers rate him among the top 5 percent in the game. Because the 2016 survey (coming out of the 2015 season) listed running back Matt Forte (No. 90) as the lone Bear, and he was on his way to the New York Jets by the time his number was called.

Rankings based on opinions can skew strangely. Akiem Hicks’ absence from the top 100 is more puzzling than his finishing out of the Pro Bowl money. Same with Eddie Goldman, maybe even Leonard Floyd, to name a few.

But they aren’t there yet. And whether the Bears are bottom-third in pass protection, Nick Kwiatkoski is top-five inside linebacker, or who has a high rating in Madden ’19 can all be classed as cred-lite.

Not so easily dismissed when the evaluation is the aggregate take of nearly two-thirds of the league.

More to the concerning side, some correlation may be drawn between that index of star power and team performance, either cause or effect, or both. The last time the Bears had more than Forte representing them in the Top 100 was 2014, meaning coming off the 2013 season. That Top-100 included Brandon Marshall, Alshon Jeffery, Tim Jennings and Forte – from the last Bears team (8-8) to win more than six games in a season.

Enough fingers were pointed at Marc Trestman and then John Fox for what happened on the field. But the New York Giants (2) and Houston Texans (4) had fewer wins than the Bears last season but still were represented on the players’ honor roll.

“I need to point the finger at myself as well,” GM Ryan Pace said in the wake of firing Fox. “Our record is a reflection on me as well. But I feel good about where we’re at right now. I feel much better about where we’re at right now than at this time last year and that starts with the quarterback position. We have a 23-year-old quarterback that we feel very good about that we need to build around. We need to build upon that core and fortunately we have the resources to do that.”

One of Pace’s mandates has been to bring Bears talent to a level competitive with at least the NFC North. The more than 1,100 players canvassed don’t think it’s happening: The Bears are one of only four teams (plus Indianapolis, Tampa Bay and the Jets) not represented in the top 100, while Detroit (2), Green Bay (7) and Minnesota (5) have multiple selections. Even the 0-16 Cleveland Browns boast a pair – wide receiver Jarvis Landry, running back Carlos Hyde) by virtue of their offseason moves.

Getting down to Bears cases

The Bears may be convinced that Mitch Trubisky is a franchise quarterback, but his 12 starts apparently didn’t show enough for his peers to vote him into elite status. Deshaun Watson (No. 50, six starts) and Jimmy Garoppolo (No. 90, five starts) fared better in the balloting.

Trubisky goes into 2018 as the fourth-best quarterback in a four-quarterback NFC North. Player voting pretty much confirms that, leaving him off a list that includes Kirk Cousins in Minnesota (No. 94), Matthew Stafford in Detroit (No. 31) and Rodgers (top 10). And Trubisky knows he’s got some catching up to do.

“I just feel like I know what to expect more on a day-to-day basis,” he said during minicamp. “What I need to do, how I can make my teammates' job easier — and just continue to set goals. Weekly goals, short-term goals, continue to meet those goals, keep raising the bar and get better each and every single day.”

Jeffery and Marshall are Bears no longer, but Allen Robinson is, which Pace has wagered heavily will be a very good thing. Robinson’s peers in the past have agreed: Robinson was pegged at No. 31 in 2016, coming in off his 80-1,400-14 season of 2015. He came back to produce 73-883-6 in 2016 but finished off the list, perhaps not entirely surprising after his Jaguars went 3-13 in 2016. The Bears are gambling that Robinson will return to his elite form from last year’s torn ACL; the rest of the NFL has effectively said “prove it.”

Jordan Howard’s fit in the offense of Matt Nagy/Mark Helfrich has been and will be debated until he proves himself conclusively as a receiver. And Howard and Tarik Cohen may be popular among rankers of backfields.

But not yet with their peers. Neither made the players’ list, while New Orleans placed Alvin Kamara No. 20 and Mark Ingram 43rd among the top six running backs, which include Kansas City’s Kareem Hunt.

Floyd, Goldman and Hicks? Too many Pro Bowl selections ahead of them, at least at this point.