Bears Grades: Players, not coaches, at fault of core problems in loss


Bears Grades: Players, not coaches, at fault of core problems in loss

Coaches will be hit with blame for poor starts (which the Bears have done nearly all season) and sloppy play (everywhere on Sunday). The core problems of the Bears’ 38-17 loss to the Minnesota Vikings, however, belongs squarely at the feet of players on offense and defense in particular whose failed execution doomed the organization to another year eliminated from the playoffs.

“It’s about individual plays when it’s one on one,” said linebacker Pernell McPhee, “making plays when it’s time to make plays.”

[MORE BEARS GRADES: Quarterback ¦ Offensive Line ¦ Linebackers]

As has been the case through much of this season, players were frequently in positions to make plays and just did not. Plays on offense were blocked and then undone by an individual breakdown or penalty. Defensively, receivers and backs rarely were running wide open (a common sign of schematic breakdowns) but Bears defensive players were consistently slow to react, a step behind breaking on balls and in coverage, with the result that they were constantly chasing Vikings and rarely catching them.

The case of wide receiver Stefon Diggs running by two Bears defenders on the way to getting open on his way to his 33-yard TD reception in the third quarter was a case study. Diggs ran by a linebacker and defensive back to make an uncontested catch and then pick his way through the rest of the defense for the score.

“We did not execute, since one of their leading receivers went unnoticed across the whole field,” said coach John Fox, adding pointedly, “It is not by design.”

The special-teams unit under coordinator Jeff Rodgers was the exception, blocking precisely to spring Deonte Thompson for a 49-yard return on the opening kickoff, executing and recovering an onside kick to start the second half and covering three of Pat O’Donnell’s four punts inside the Minnesota 20.

[SHOP BEARS: Get your Bears gear right here]

The idea of an onside kick, recovered by Sherrick McManis, to start the second half was the sort of bold stroke both worth taking strategically and as a chance to ignite the offense after an abysmal 96 yards in the first half. But the gambit was wasted when the offense gave up the ball on a strip-sack and the Vikings turned the takeaway into seven points.

But the near-constant inability of the Bears to start a game with fire and execution either offensively or defensively has become a chronic condition, which obviously traces to poor jobs by players, but reached the point Sunday of being systemic. It is simply what the Bears do.

“We have not lost three in a row all season long,” Fox said. “It does a little to thwart your confidence. But we are all professionals. We will get this out of our system and get ready for Tampa Bay.”

Moon's Grade: B

Pro Football Focus: Bears rank near bottom-third of NFL in pass protection

Pro Football Focus: Bears rank near bottom-third of NFL in pass protection

If the Chicago Bears want to make a real run at the playoffs in 2018, the offensive line will have to do its part by keeping QB Mitch Trubisky upright. The offense is expected to be more pass-heavy under coach Matt Nagy and will depend on Trubisky having time in the pocket to go through his progressions and find the open target.

New offensive line coach Harry Hiestand should help that cause. He's universally praised as one of the best offensive line coaches in the sport and will be charged with getting a better effort from a unit that ended last season ranked in the bottom-third of pass protection, according to Pro Football Focus.


2017 pass-blocking efficiency: 77.9

Best individual PBE: Josh Sitton, 97.4

Because of several crippling injuries, nine different players saw at least 100 pass-block snaps for the Bears in 2017. They gave up 152 pressures on 536 passing plays. The top performance came from left tackle Charles Leno Jr., who enjoyed the best season of his career and allowed just 24 pressures all season. Heading into the 2018 campaign, rookie guard James Daniels is penciled in to fill the shoes of the recently departed pass-blocking star Josh Sitton. Daniels performed well in pass protection during his final college season, allowing just 10 pressures on 371 pass-blocking snaps at Iowa.

The Bears will be without last season's top pass-protector, Josh Sitton, who was let go by GM Ryan Pace this offseason and signed with the Dolphins. 

Pass protection was once all about the play of the offensive tackles, but with the NFL's interior defensive linemen evolving into disruptive forces up the middle, guard play will be nearly as important. A healthy Kyle Long is critical. Chicago can't afford growing pains from James Daniels, either. Cody Whitehair returns to full-time center duties, a role he excelled at during his rookie season. 

Charles Leno should provide reliable play at left tackle. Bobby Massie remains a wildcard, but with little depth behind him, the Bears can do nothing more than hope his bad reps are limited in 2018.

With Hiestand in the fold and a healthy Long ready to compete at a high level again, the Bears' offensive line should be much improved this season.

Predicting the value of Roquan Smith's rookie contract with Bears

Predicting the value of Roquan Smith's rookie contract with Bears

Chicago Bears first-round pick Roquan Smith remains unsigned, a situation that prior to the rookie wage scale would've been cause for concern. With contracts now based on slotting, or where a first-round pick is selected, there's little reason or room for agents to haggle over terms. A holdout isn't expected.

There have been some exceptions to this general principle, however. Joey Bosa, who was selected with the third pick by the Chargers in 2016, held out until August 29 over offset language and his signing bonus. So, while a holdout for Smith is unlikely, it's not impossible.

Assuming he agrees to a contract on time, here's what the terms of his deal should look like, according to CBS Sports:

2018 Cap Number: $3,349,485
Signing Bonus: $11,517,940
Four-year value: $18,477,168

If the numbers are correct, Smith will have the 17th-highest cap hit for the Bears in 2018, according to Spotrac. By comparison, Danny Trevathan has a $7.15 million cap hit this season.

Drafting well is critical for long-term success. If a general manager misses on first-round picks, the cap consequences mount over time. Consider Kevin White, the seventh-overall pick in 2015. He has zero touchdowns in his pro career but has a $5.27 million cap hit this year. Leonard Floyd, the team's first-rounder in 2016, has a $4.30 million cap hit and Mitch Trubisky, last year's second pick overall, is $6.59 million. Pace's four first-round picks, when counting Smith's expected deal, are four of the top-17 paid players on the payroll even though none of them have the production to back it up.

Smith, however, is as close to a bust-free prospect as the Bears have drafted in Pace's tenure. He was considered one of the best pure football players in the entire 2018 draft class and will start immediately alongside Trevathan as a rookie, assuming he's under contract in time to contribute in Week 1.