Jake Arrieta vs. Madison Bumgarner goes completely off script before a Giant comeback

Jake Arrieta vs. Madison Bumgarner goes completely off script before a Giant comeback

SAN FRANCISCO – Jake Arrieta vs. Madison Bumgarner went completely off script before the San Francisco Giants wrote another classic ending as the playoff team that will not die.

“This is October baseball,” Arrieta said after a crazy 6-5 loss that took 13 innings, the Cubs wasting a golden opportunity to finish off the Giants and end this National League Division Series with a three-game sweep. “We know games are going to be very closely contested. These guys are no slouches. With their pedigree in the playoffs, we know we have our work cut out for us.”

With one swing, Arrieta had seemingly shattered the aura of invincibility around Bumgarner on Monday night, temporarily exposing the Giants as a team without any magic tricks left. It silenced a crowd that had been whipped into an orange-towel-waving frenzy. The Cubs turned AT&T Park’s visiting dugout into a mosh pit, celebrating as if they had just clinched.

Uh, wasn’t this still only the second inning? A team that designed a Party Room into the clubhouse as part of the $600 million Wrigleyville development reacted spontaneously and deliriously when Arrieta lined a 90-mph fastball into the left-field seats for a jaw-dropping three-run homer.

Bumgarner – who had willed the Giants through 23 scoreless innings in his last three postseason elimination games – leaned over on the mound with his hands on his knees and dropped his head. Anthony Rizzo gave Eric Hinske a bear hug in the dugout, lifting up the big assistant hitting coach as the Cubs jumped around in the dugout. Arrieta screamed as he reached home plate.

If Arrieta felt slighted by all the pregame attention paid to Bumgarner, all the questions about his fitness for October, he hid it pretty well on his stone face. Especially for someone with guts, a huge ego, an endorsement deal with an underwear company, a cover spot on ESPN The Magazine’s Body Issue and a Boras Corp. attitude to play everything out until free agency and a potential nine-figure megadeal next winter.

[SHOP: Gear up, Cubs fans!

This would automatically be remembered as The Arrieta Game, if Jake hadn’t already thrown two no-hitters in a Cubs uniform and a complete-game shutout against the Pittsburgh Pirates in last year’s wild-card game. And if the rest of the night hadn’t involved so many different twists and turns, the Cubs five outs away from winning Game 3 before a Giant comeback.

Arrieta is an alpha male who wanted to be in the Home Run Derby this summer as soon as he heard about Bumgarner’s interest in the All-Star event. Arrieta takes his hitting seriously, homering twice and putting up a .720 OPS during the regular season. But relying so heavily on the pitchers for offense isn’t sustainable – Kyle Hendricks and Travis Wood drove in three of the five runs during a Game 2 victory at Wrigley Field.

A grinding mentality forced Bumgarner to throw 51 pitches through two innings. Giants reliever George Kontos actually warmed up in the second inning and never got in a game that lasted five hours and four minutes. The Cubs knocked out Bumgarner after five innings, but allowed the Giants to hang around and win their 10th consecutive postseason elimination game.

Arrieta still outdueled Bumgarner – giving up two runs across six innings and finishing with five strikeouts against one walk – and that’s not an insignificant takeaway for a Cubs rotation that will need to survive three playoffs rounds in a year set up as World Series or bust.

“We were that close,” Arrieta said. “But at the same time, we know the task isn’t going to be an easy one. These guys aren’t going to roll over and just let us clinch a series in their ballpark. We’re going to have to come out tomorrow and be ready to go again.”

Around midnight in the Bay Area, a reporter mentioned that it’s today already.

“It’s tough to not get up for games like this,” Arrieta said. “The emotions are just going to continue to run throughout the playoffs. And that’s kind of what you live on.”

The Cubs are ahead of the game in MLB's brand new world

The Cubs are ahead of the game in MLB's brand new world


Joe Maddon couldn't contain his glee as he was told there is actual scientific evidence that proves the Launch Angle Revolution has not had any impact on the uptick in homers over the last couple seasons.

The reason MLB players were hitting the ball into the bleachers more than ever before in 2017 was because of the way baseballs are made now, reducing the wind resistence and causing balls to carry more.

But all these players changing their swing path to get more lift on the ball? Not a thing for the group as a whole (h/t

But in analyzing Statcast™ data from the measurement tool's 2015 inception through 2017, the committee found no evidence that batter behavior, en masse, has been a contributing factor toward the homer surge. In fact, exit velocities decreased slightly from 2016 to 2017, spray angles from the time studied were stable and a small increase in launch angles was attributable primarily to, as the study refers to them, "players with lesser home run talents."

Basically, the long-ball surge was global, affecting players from all spectrums of homer-hitting ability and irrespective of their approach.

"Going into this, I thought that was going to be the magic bullet, the smoking gun," Nathan said. "But it wasn't."

Hence the "BINGO!" cry from Maddon, who has been very vocal in the fight against the Launch Angle Revolution this season.

The end result is the study will eventually lead to baseballs being returned to normal levels and a more uniform way of storing the balls moving forward. Thus, homers figure to eventually return to normal levels, too, and everybody who was caught up in the Launch Angle Revolution may be left behind.

It's the changing landscape of baseball and we've already seen the after-effects this year: April was the first month in MLB history where there were more strikeouts than basehits.

Why? Because strikeouts are a natural byproduct of the Launch Angle Revolution as players are swinging up on the ball more and sacrificing contact for power and lift.

That, coupled with an increase in velocity and higher usage of relievers, has led to more strikeouts.

It makes perfect sense — it's tougher for a player to try to catch up to 98+ mph at the top of the strike zone with an uppercut swing.

"It's one of those things that sounds good, but it doesn't help you," Maddon said of launch angle. "There's certain things that people really want to promote and talk about, but it doesn't matter. When a hitter's in the box, when you're trying to stare down 96 or a slider on the edge, the last thing you're thinking about is launch angle.

"Now when it comes to practice, you could not necessarily work on angles — your body works a certain way. Like I've said before, there's guys that might've been oppressively bad or they just had groundballs by rolling over the ball all the time So of course you may want to alter that to get that smothering kind of a swing out of him.

"But if you're trying to catch up to velocity, if you're trying to lay back and I could keep going on and on. It sounds good."

The idea of hitting the ball hard in the air has been around for decades in baseball, pretty much ever since Babe Ruth on some level. It just wasn't able to be quantified or accessed by the public as easily until Statcast came around and made it all mainstream.

The Cubs, however, have been anti-launch-angle to a degree this season. They let go of hitting coach John Mallee (who liked players to hit the ball in the air and pull it) and replaced him with Chili Davis (who teaches the full-field, line-drive approach).

The effects haven't yet yielded results in terms of consistently plating runs or having a better performance in the situational hitting column, but the contact rate is, in fact, up.

Here is the list of Cubs hitters who currently boast a career best mark in strikeout rate:

Kris Bryant
Javy Baez
Willson Contreras
Addison Russell
Jason Heyward
Kyle Schwarber

Even Ben Zobrist is very close to his career mark and Anthony Rizzo is right at his career line.

Some of that jump in contact rate can be attributed to natural development and maturation of young hitters, but the Cubs are buying into the new way of doing things and it's paying off.

It's also probably the way the game is going to shift, with an emphasis on contact going to become more important the less balls are flying out of the yard.

The Cubs have seen firsthand how to beat the best pitching in the postseason and they know that cutting down on strikeouts and "moving the baseball" (as Maddon likes to put it) can help manufacture runs in low-scoring, tight affairs in October.

Now science is supporting those theories and Major League Baseball teams will have to adjust. 

The Cubs, however, are at least a step ahead of the game.

It's a long game — the offensive strides will take time to fully take effect even for the Cubs, who are at least a full offseason and two months ahead of the curve in terms of bucking the Launch Angle Revolution.

Maddon concedes that launch angle is a cool stat to see on the video board after homers, but other than that, he doesn't see much of a use for it, pointing to Kyle Schwarber's laser-line-drive homers having the same effect as Kris Bryant's moonshots.

However, Maddon does believe there's a place for launch angle and exit velocity in the game, though mostly for front offices trying to acquire players (think "Moneyball").

"As a teaching tool, you either come equipped with or without," Maddon said. "It's like you buy a new car, you either got this or you don't. Sometimes you can add some things occasionally, but for the most part, this is what you are.

"I like inside the ball, top half of the ball, inner half of the ball, stay long throughout the ball, utilize the whole field. I still think that's the tried and true approach and I'm not stuck in the mud on this by any means.

"The harder pitchers throw the baseball, the more laying back is going to be less effective."

Theo Epstein brushes aside rumors: 'There's essentially zero trade talks involving the Cubs'

Theo Epstein brushes aside rumors: 'There's essentially zero trade talks involving the Cubs'

No, the Cubs are not currently talking to the Baltimore Orioles about bringing Manny Machado to the North Side of Chicago.

So says Theo Epstein, the Cubs president of baseball operations who met with the media at Wrigley Field ahead of Friday's series opener with the San Francisco Giants.

Epstein vehemently shot down the notion of trade talks and specified the major diffence between trade rumors and trade talks, while refusing to comment on Machado in particular.

"I'm not addressing any specific rumor or any player with another team," Epstein said. "I would never talk about that in a million years. The simple way to put it is there's been a lot of trade rumors involving the Cubs and there's essentially zero trade talks involving the Cubs.

"There's a real disparity between the noise and the reality and unfortunately, sometimes that puts a player or two that we have in a real tough circumstance. And that's my job to clarify there's nothing going on right now.

"We have more than enough ability to win the division, win the World Series and we really need to focus on our roster and getting the most out of our ability and finding some consistency. Constant focus outside the organization doesn't do us any good, especially when it's not based in reality right now."

The Cubs have presented a united front publicly in support of Addison Russell, whose name has been the one bandied about most as a potential leading piece in any move for Machado.

After all, the Cubs have won a World Series and never finished worse than an NLCS berth with Russell as their shortstop and he's only 24 with positive signs of progression offensively.

Trading away 3.5 years of control of Russell for 3-4 months of Machado is the type of bold, go-for-it move the Cubs did in 2016 when their championship drought was well over 100 years.

Now, the championship drought is only one season old and the window of contention is expected to remain open until through at least the 2021 season.

Epstein likes to point out that every season is sacred, but at what cost? The Cubs front office is still very much focused on the future beyond 2018.

"Everybody's talking about making trades in May — the first part of the season is trying to figure out who you are," Epstein said. "What are the strengths of the club? What are the weaknesses of the club? What's the character of the club? What position is the club gonna be in as we get deeper in the season? What's our short-term outlook? What's our long-term outlook? What's the chemistry in the clubhouse?

"All those things. It's a process to get there and figure it out. If you rush to those kinds of judgments, you can oftentimes make things worse. I think it's important to figure out exactly who you are and give guys a chance to play and find their level and see how all the pieces fit together before you make your adjustments."

So there's no chance we could see the Cubs once again jump the market and make an early deal like they did last year for Jose Quintana or five years ago for Jake Arrieta? Will they definitely wait another five weeks until July to make a move?

"It's just the natural order of things," Epstein said. "We wouldn't be opposed to doing something, but that's not the case right now. It's not happening."