The Padres actually have a point when it comes to Anthony Rizzo's controversial slide at home plate

The Padres actually have a point when it comes to Anthony Rizzo's controversial slide at home plate

As Anthony Rizzo streaked toward home plate in the sixth inning, nobody knew it was about to be the most-talked about play in baseball for a news cycle (or longer).

Rizzo smacked into San Diego Padres catcher Austin Hedges, attemping to jar the ball loose and score an all-important run in a close game at Wrigley Field.

The play is a rarity in this game now, as MLB rules have changed to try avoid home plate collisions and keep players on the field.

The Cubs backed Rizzo and didn't think he did anything wrong. 

The Padres were upset, with manager Andy Green calling it a "cheap shot." 

Who's in the right?

Let's treat this like an internet court case:


Anthony Rizzo said it's "game on."

The face of the Cubs doesn't think he was in the wrong with his slide, saying, "By no means do I think that's a dirty play at all. I've talked to a lot of umpires about this rule. And my understanding is: If they have the ball, it's game on.

"I went pretty much straight in. He caught the ball. He went towards the plate. It's a play where I'm out by two steps. I slide, he runs into me. It's just one of those plays where it's unfortunate he had to exit."

Rizzo hopped on David Kaplan's ESPN 1000 radio show Tuesday and reiterated it was not a dirty play and instead was a "hard baseball play."

Rizzo has a very solid point, especially if that's how MLB umpires are explaining it to him. If a catcher is blocking the plate, why should a player just lay down and slide into a catcher's shinguards and risk injury to himself?

Cubs manager Joe Maddon backed the face of the franchise:

“I’d much prefer what Rizz did tonight. And what he did was right, absolutely right, so there’s nothing wrong with that. Nobody could tell me differently.

“It’s a good play. The catcher’s in the way. You don’t try to avoid him in an effort to score and hurt yourself. You hit him, just like Rizz did.”

Even Jon Lester had Rizzo's back:

"He caught the ball. He protected the plate. And Rizz had nowhere to go."

To a man, the Cubs don't think Rizzo's slide was wrong. Of course not. Why would they think he was wrong? The umpires did not throw Rizzo out of the game. A couple years ago, the collision at the plate was just a part of the game.


First off: Hedges was not blocking the plate. He did have the ball, so we can all agree there. But he was in front of the plate. No part of him blocked Rizzo's path to the plate, as these images and GIFs show from the Padres broadcast:

The Padres have a very solid case here. Rizzo went out of his way to go after Hedges.

Why? Not because Rizzo is a dirty player. The Padres can think that, but come on. He's the face of the Cubs, he does not have a reputation as a dirty player and as Patrick Mooney said early Tuesday morning, why would Rizzo need to send a message to the hapless Padres of all teams?

Rizzo is ultra-competitive and wants to win. He was out by several steps on that throw from former Cub Matt Szczur, so Rizzo went at Hedges in an effort to knock the ball loose. He wanted to win and he made a split-second decision to try to give his team an advantage while playing within the rules as he understands them.

That's not dirty. But that also doesn't mean the Padres shouldn't be upset. They have every right to be.


Rizzo has a point, especially if umpires or the league have explained to him that he can hit the catcher if he's in the way.

But the Padres have a point in that Major League Baseball has tried to reduce — or completely eliminate — any contact at home plate whenever possible. And in the case of Monday night, it was very possible contact could have been avoided. It actually would've been easy to avoid contact here.

So the Padres and their fans and broadcasters have every right to be upset. The Cubs have every right to defend Rizzo (and they absolutely should until proven otherwise). The Cubs should just avoid making statements talking about Hedges blocking the plate, because he was not.

Rizzo could've easily slid around Hedges and gone toward the back side of home plate. Of course, we're watching it in slow motion and the game doesn't happen in slow motion. The players don't operate or make decisions in slow motion.

It all happens very quickly and in this case, it very well may be possible that Rizzo's split-second decision was wrong.

But if so — if Rizzo is in the wrong here — then MLB needs to step in here and explain it and use it as an example to teach and inform. 

Will Rizzo get suspended for this play? I honestly don't know. Probably not, but it's possible. Players have gotten suspended for less and the league is trying hard to avoid "The Buster Posey Play" where the San Francisco Giants superstar broke his leg on a similar home plate collision

It's unfortunate Hedges was injured on the play. Everybody is in agreement there, from Rizzo to Lester to Maddon to everybody in the Padres camp.

Regardless of if Hedges was injured or not, the Padres do have a strong case in being upset by the play.

Cubs open Summer Camp at South Bend alternate site

Cubs open Summer Camp at South Bend alternate site

Baseball has returned to South Bend. The Cubs’ alternate site this season, which is usually the home of the Cubs’ Single-A affiliate, welcomed a group of players to Four Winds Field on Tuesday.

South Bend Summer Camp is scheduled to start in earnest Wednesday, according to Cubs general manager Jed Hoyer.

Hoyer praised Cubs senior director of player development Matt Dorey and assistant director of baseball development Jeremy Farrell for their work setting up the South Bend site, as well as South Bend Cubs owner Andrew Berlin and president Joe Hart for “a really good job of catering to our every need.”

Click to download the MyTeams App for the latest Cubs news and analysis.

Player housing is so close to the ballpark that, “players can literally walk from their room right down into the field,” Hoyer said. “I think that should be a really good setup for those guys.”

Throughout Summer Camp, the number of players at South Bend will increase. The Cubs originally assigned 11 players to the alternate site, but the club has 10 open spots in its 60-player pool. The Cubs will evaluate its depth before filling those spots.

The club also has to cut its Wrigley Field Summer Camp roster from 39 players down to 30 by Opening Day. Those who do not make the Opening Day roster will move to the alternate site.



Cubs' Anthony Rizzo misses workout, intrasquad game due to lower back tightness

Cubs' Anthony Rizzo misses workout, intrasquad game due to lower back tightness

Cubs first baseman Anthony Rizzo, perhaps the only 30-year-old in spring training or Summer Camp history to be able to claim he showed up in the best shape of his life, took Tuesday’s workout and scrimmage off because of lower back tightness.

Rizzo has typically dealt with back tightness annually for a few games each season.

The difference this time is that the three-time All-Star worked out with a personal trainer during baseball’s shutdown and lost 25 pounds in the past three months, dropping a uniform size and drawing raves from teammates and team officials.

Click to download the MyTeams App for the latest Cubs news and analysis.

His status is to be evaluated again Wednesday morning.

During Tuesday's three-inning sim game, Willson Contreras homered off Craig Kimbrel in the first inning as the Cubs defeated the Cubs by what is believed to be a 2-0 score.