White Sox

Garfien: Do South Siders need to go back in time?

183507.jpg

Garfien: Do South Siders need to go back in time?

Thursday, June 3, 201012:43 PM

By Chuck GarfienCSNChicago.com
Frank Thomas hasnt picked up a bat in 20 months. I learned this the other day when I half-jokingly asked him if he would join the Comcast SportsNet softball team.

Hows that for a ringer?

But the greatest hitter in White Sox history laughed at my idea, admitting Id probably break my back.

And yet, wherever the Big Hurt goes in Chicago, he hears the same plea from anxious, desperate White Sox fans.

Frank, we need you!

Unfortunately, this team doesnt need Frank. It needs something that has yet to be invented.

A time machine.

(If anyone sees Doc Brown roaming around a vacant shopping mall parkinglot with his 1985 DeLorean and furry dog Einstein, please have himreport to U.S. Cellular Field immediately)

The White Sox slow, baffling start has left many to long for those bright and sunny days of yesteryear when all seemed right in the world. Like April 5, 2010. Opening Day.

A lot has changed since then.

Two months into the season, this hasnt exactly been a Hollywood masterpiece. Kevin Costners 1995 flop "Waterworld" is probably more like it.

Doing whatever he can to prevent the Sox ship from sinking further, pitching coach Don Cooper offered these deep thoughts before Wednesdays second straight loss to the Rangers:

You swim in confidence, you drown in negativity.

But if the Sox struggles continue, there wont be enough life preservers to save everyone. Its a boat the Big Hurt has been on before.

At this point in the season, you need to be as positive as ever, because if not, the negativity is close, Thomas said Wednesday on White Sox Pregame Live, when I shared with him Coopers message.

Cooper feels it, Thomas said. He knows the media is going to be on everyone, he knows whats going to happen if they dont start winning ballgames.

And Frank, who has been one of the teams biggest supporters -- if not personal cheerleaders -- in 2010 could not ignore the reality if the Sox dont turn it around soon.

Something is going to happen with this ballclub.

Something as in big changes?

At this point in the season, you need to be as positive as ever, because if not, the negativity is close.-- Frank Thomas on the importance of positive thinking during team strugglesThats the only way I see it.

It is possible for the White Sox to save their season, with or without a Kenny Williams overhaul. History proves they can.

Remember 2005? On July 25, the Cleveland Indians trailed the first-place White Sox by 15 games in the Central Division, only to go on a blistering two-month hot streak to cut the lead to 1 12 games by late September. The Indians didnt end up catching the Sox, but it certainly makes the Twins' current 8 12-game advantage sound a lot more appealing.

But then again, that Indians team had C.C. Sabathia and Cliff Lee, not to mention a healthy Grady Sizemore and Travis Hafner.

The 2003 Florida Marlins (with Ozzie Guillen as their third-base coach) were 10 games under .500 on May 22. They went on to make the playoffs, and beat the Giants, Cubs and Yankees for the World Series title.

Helping the Marlins' cause that year was a 20-year-old phenom named Miguel Cabrera, who was called up midseason. Any chance the Tigers let us borrow Miguel for the next four months?

Both of those teams found magic midsummer. So far, the White Sox have been doing a disappearing act in the Central Division, watching their hopes gradually vanish.

Its left us pondering the same old questions.

Do these 2010 White Sox actually have a run in them? Can they play the kind of Ozzie Ball we thought they could on Opening Day? Will the starting rotation, projected to be one of the best in the game, finally start pitching like it?

I want to believe yes. But the Sox keep proving no.

When I asked Cooper to sum up the teams situation in one word, he said, Important. Not critical, but important.

Maybe. But if the Sox dont start winning soon, it will likely be anchors away for some big-time stars (you know the names).

Sink or swim.

Chuck Garfien hosts White Sox Pregame and Postgame Live on Comcast SportsNet with former Sox slugger Bill Melton. Follow Chuck @ChuckGarfien on Twitter for up-to-the-minute Sox news and views.

Luis Robert highlights White Sox prospects as Arizona Fall League concludes

Luis Robert highlights White Sox prospects as Arizona Fall League concludes

The Arizona Fall League wrapped up on Thursday for White Sox prospects and the overall results were mixed.

Perhaps the most important thing from the seven-week season is that Luis Robert began to show his potential. After injuries limited him to just 50 games in 2018, his first season playing in the U.S., Robert added 18 games and 79 plate appearances against much more experienced players in Arizona.

Robert, still just 21 and the second-youngest hitter on the team, hit in his first 14 games in the AFL and tallied a hit in 16 of his 18 games. He did this while missing over a week in the middle of the season due to a hamstring injury. The Cuban outfielder’s final numbers are .324/.367/.432. He had five walks, which isn’t an inspiring total, but he kept the strikeouts down at 13.

One of the things that still hasn’t shown in games very often is Robert’s power. He didn’t hit a home run in the 2018 minor league season, but it’s possible his thumb injury was affecting his ability to hit for power. Robert’s power didn’t come through much in the AFL, but there was definitely improvement. He hit two home runs and had two doubles, but this home run last week was definitely seductive.

The AFL isn’t make or break for prospects. Adam Engel hit .403/.523/.642 in the AFL in 2015 and hasn’t shown the ability to hit in the majors yet. Still, Robert showed flashes of his potential with the bat while also causing chaos on the base paths with five stolen bases in five attempts.

Robert was one of seven White Sox minor leaguers who played for the Glendale Desert Dogs. Glendale finished the season 12-18.

The next biggest hitting prospect on Glendale was Luis Alexander Basabe. Basabe struggled in his time in Arizona, but did show some of what has makes him an intriguing prospect.

Basabe hit just .180, but did draw 12 walks in 63 plate appearances. The 22-year-old isn’t known for hitting for average. He is a career .258 hitter in six minor league seasons, including a .251 mark in Double-A in the second half of 2018. However, if he can draw walks at a high rate while bringing good speed in the outfield, he can have some value.

Overall, hitting .180/.333/.180 is a disappointing stint, but there was at least one positive with the walk rate.

Laz Rivera rounded out White Sox hitters with a line of .215/.271/.246. Rivera had solid stints at both levels of Single-A in 2018, his first full season of pro ball, but the AFL showed he may find the adjustment to Double-A a tough one.

On the pitching side the only marquee name was Zack Burdi, but he got shut down early in the season. He made only five appearances (4 2/3 innings, 3 unearned runs, 5 strikeouts, 1 walk, 2 hits), but Rick Hahn said there’s nothing to be concerned about.

Tanner Banks (4.43 ERA, 10 strikeouts, 5 walks, 30 hits in 22 1/3 innings), Zach Thompson (2.70 ERA, 15 strikeouts, 6 walks, 10 hits in 13 1/3 innings) and Danny Dopico (6.57 ERA, 15 strikeouts, 12 walks, 10 hits in 12 1/3 innings) also pitched for Glendale. All three will be 25 or older when 2019 rolls around.

White Sox free-agent focus: Josh Donaldson

1115_josh_donaldson.jpg
USA TODAY

White Sox free-agent focus: Josh Donaldson

This week, we’re profiling some of the biggest names on the free-agent market and taking a look at what kind of fits they are for the White Sox.

The White Sox third baseman of the future is?

That's a question without an answer at the moment, with the long-term prognosis for the hot corner a mystery in the wake of a pair of Achilles tears suffered by 2017 first-round pick Jake Burger earlier this year. There were already questions floating around, though not necessarily inside the White Sox organization, about whether the heavy-hitting Burger could play third base on a regular basis. Now, thanks to those injuries, those questions have been amplified.

Yolmer Sanchez is coming off a disappointing season offensively and doesn't appear to be a long-term solution. Yoan Moncada might move over there this spring considering that middle infielder Nick Madrigal (this year's first-round choice) could be quickly making his way toward the majors. Past that, though, there's not a surefire third-base prospect like there are at many other positions throughout the White Sox farm system.

And so attention has naturally turned to external solutions. Colorado Rockies MVP candidate Nolan Arenado is a free agent next winter, and plenty of fans have their sights on adding him as the finishing piece this rebuilding effort needs to vault the White Sox into the realm of perennial contenders. But this winter has its own multi-time All-Star third baseman in Josh Donaldson. Any takers?

The focus has been on the South Siders' reported interest in Bryce Harper and Manny Machado, the two biggest fish in this free-agency pond, but don't forget Donaldson is just three years removed from an MVP campaign with the Toronto Blue Jays, when he slashed .297/.371/.568 with 41 home runs and 123 RBIs. Donaldson's got four top-eight MVP finishes to his name, including the win in 2015. Harper and Machado have three top-eight MVP finishes combined, including Harper's win in 2015.

In an insanely productive four-year stretch from 2013 to 2016, Donaldson slashed .284/.375/.518 with 131 homers and 413 RBIs.

But it's the last two seasons, heretofore unmentioned, that have made Donaldson less attractive than the Harpers, Machados and Arenados of the world. He played in only 113 games in 2017, still smacking 33 home runs and driving in 78 runs in that injury-shortened season. Then last season, he played in only 52 games, getting dealt from Toronto to the Cleveland Indians late in the summer. Though 52 games is hardly enough to judge a season on — let alone a player's future performance — his numbers plummeted, his slash line dipping to .246/.352/.449 and his home-run total to just eight.

Whether or not teams believe Donaldson's best days are behind him thanks to a pair of injury-riddled seasons remains to be seen. But one inarguable fact is his age. He'll be 33 on Opening Day 2019. Does that line up with the White Sox long-term plans? Not as well as the 27-year-old Arenado, of course. But Arenado's going to be a popular guy next winter, so would it be wise to put all the eggs in the Arenado basket?

Donaldson might not fit in the White Sox contention window, but he's got one heck of a track record and could bring some big-time production to whichever lineup he joins for 2019.