Preps Talk

Fenwick to take appeal to court after controversial finish in semifinal game

Fenwick to take appeal to court after controversial finish in semifinal game

The controversial finish from last Saturday's Class 7A semifinal game between Plainfield North and Fenwick will be decided in court.

On Monday, Fenwick officials released the following statement:

‘‘Pursuant to the outcome of the game, IHSA invited Fenwick to submit an appeal to the IHSA Board. Early Monday morning, the IHSA Board determined that it would not hear the appeal. As a result, in an effort to protect the rights and rightfully earned opportunities of its students, Fenwick High School has filed a lawsuit in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois seeking declaratory, injunctive and other relief against IHSA.’’

Fenwick is seeking a reversal of its 18-17 Class 7A semifinal overtime loss to Plainfield North after a referee made a mistake and allowed an untimed down, which eventually led to the 18-17 Fenwick overtime loss to Plainfield North.

The Friars were leading 10-7 with four seconds left in the fourth quarter. Fenwick quarterback Jacob Keller heaved a ball downfield to run out the clock. After the referee’s intentional grounding call and subsequent untimed down, Plainfield North kicked a 22-yard field goal to tie the game at 10, sending the game into the extra session. After Fenwick took a 17-10 lead in overtime, Plainfield North’s Dillon McCarthy answered with a rushing touchdown. His two point conversion was the difference in the game moments later.

The Illinois High School Association on Saturday night admitted that the referee's call was incorrect, however, “IHSA by-law 6.033 clearly states that, ‘the decisions of game officials shall be final; protests against the decision of a game official shall not be reviewed by the Board of Directors.’ Given that rule, the contest result shall remain final with Plainfield North advancing to the Class 7A State Championship.”

[RELATED: CSN to carry live coverage of the 2016 IHSA Football State Championships Nov. 25 & 26]

In the statement, IHSA Executive Director Craig Anderson expressed “sincerest apologies” to the Fenwick Friars football program, administration and community.

Plainfield North head coach Tim Kaine declined comment in a conference call Monday morning.

The case will be heard on Wednesday at 9 a.m. in Cook County Chancery Court.

The 7A championship will be Saturday at 4 p.m. on CSN Chicago. East St. Louis advanced to the game by defeating Benet.

98 Days to Kickoff: Plainfield South

98 Days to Kickoff: Plainfield South

NBCSportsChicago.com preps reporter "Edgy" Tim O’Halloran spotlights 100 high school football teams in 100 days. The first 75 team profiles will focus on teams making strides across Chicagoland and elsewhere in the state. Starting Aug. 5, we’ll unveil the @NBCSPrepsTop 25 Power Rankings, leading up to kickoff on Friday, Aug. 30.

School: Plainfield South

Head coach: Bill Bicker

Assistant coaches: Adam Chavez (OC), Rob Szudarski (DC), Ben Delange (OL), Corey Carver (DL), Clint Reams (LB)

How they fared in 2018: 7-3 (7-2 Southwest Prairie). Plainfield South made the Class 8A state playoff field and lost to Naperville Central in opening round action. 

2019 Regular Season Schedule:

Aug. 30 @ West Aurora

Sept. 6 vs Minooka

Sept. 13 @ Oswego

Sept. 20 vs Oswego East

Sept. 27 @ Joliet Central

Oct. 4 vs Plainfield Central

Oct. 11 vs Plainfield East

Oct. 18 @ Joliet West

Oct. 25 vs Romeoville

Biggest storyline: Where will the Cougars place in the newly expanded Southwest Prairie Conference?

Names to watch this season: Senior RB Jaylin Eisen, junior QB Niko Schultz, junior OL Deuce Yates

Biggest holes to fill: The Cougars will need to replace eight graduated starters from last season’s defense, a unit that was one of the best in the Southwest Prairie.

EDGY's Early Take: Head coach Bill Bicker was able to put together a punishing ground game and a speedy defense to get into the state playoff field last season. 2019? Look for the Cougars to rely on an experienced offense led by junior QB Niko Schultz. If the defense can reload a bit, expect Plainfield South to challenge for another state playoff spot this fall.

99 Days to Kickoff: Prospect

99 Days to Kickoff: Prospect

NBCSportsChicago.com preps reporter "Edgy" Tim O’Halloran spotlights 100 high school football teams in 100 days. The first 75 team profiles will focus on teams making strides across Chicagoland and elsewhere in the state. Starting Aug. 5, we’ll unveil the @NBCSPrepsTop 25 Power Rankings, leading up to kickoff on Friday, Aug. 30.

School: Prospect Knights

Head coach: Dan DeBoeuf

Assistant coaches: Brock Collins (DC), Tim Beisher (STC), Matt Weber (WR), Jeff Collier (DB), Dan Keller (LB), Jim Argentine (DL), Dan Yeoman (DB), Michael Watson (RB), Tom Whalen, Dominic Canon and Mike Naboltny

How they fared in 2018: 5-5 (2-3 Mid Suburban East). Prospect made the Class 7A state playoff field and lost to Glenbard East in opening round action. 

2019 Regular Season Schedule:

Aug. 30  @ St Viator
Sept. 6 vs Hoffman Estates
Sept. 13 vs Niles West
Sept. 20 @ Highland Park
Sept. 27 @ Elk Grove
Oct. 4 @ Hersey
Oct. 11 vs Rolling Meadows
Oct. 18 vs Hersey
Oct. 25  @ Wheeling

Biggest storyline: Can the Knights challenge for the Mid-Suburban East conference title in 2019?

Names to watch this season: OL/DL Sebastian Swistak (Sr.), WR Matt Meyer (Sr.) and RB/DB Luke Zardzin (Jr.)

Biggest holes to fill: The Knights bring back a ton of experience back this fall; however, a few key seniors will graduate this spring. That list includes QB Jimmy Martin and RB Michael Shafis.

EDGY's Early Take: In his first year as Prospect head coach, Dan DeBoeuf was able to make the IHSA state playoffs-- the first postseason berth for the school since 2012. What will the Knights do for an encore? More postseason success is expected in 2019. With 15 returning starters back in the fold, I'm looking for the Knights to challenge for a state playoff spot and a conference title.