Preps Talk

Why IHSA Success Factor rule could lead to playoff separation

montinifootball.png

Why IHSA Success Factor rule could lead to playoff separation

Will the newly implemented IHSA Success Factor rule, which takes effect this playoff season, lead to eventually separating private and public schools in Illinois come state playoff time? 

The Success Factor rule was put in place by the IHSA towards non-boundary or private schools "who have experienced success beyond the norm." These schools will now play 'up' a class in the playoffs. Both Montini Catholic (5A) and Springfield Sacred Heart-Griffin (5A) will be "successed" when the 2015 playoffs start. Both will compete in 6A if they make the state playoff field. Currently, both schools are 3-0 heading into Week 4 and both are the top two ranked teams in Class 6A polls.

While the Success Factor rule will only impact two schools for now, I can't help but wonder if this is just another step towards an eventual separation of both public and private schools during the playoffs.

[MORE PREPS: Week 4 - Top 25 Power Rankings]

Illinois remains the largest state in the country that still keeps all of its members together to compete against each other in the playoffs. Why? I've always felt that Illinois is unique when it comes to the large amount of private or Catholic high schools concentrated within the Chicagoland area. You'll be hard pressed to find any area in the country with as many private schools with as much history and tradition than here in Illinois.

Personally, I'd hate to ever see a separation happen for several reasons. Yet, it seems to me that IHSA membership keeps tweaking the system, whether the rules are intended to improve the entire state playoff system or to benefit a handful of schools or penalize a handful of schools.

If separation of public and private schools is the eventual goal, can we just stop the scavenger hunt, rip off the Band-Aid and just get to it already? 

40 Days to Kickoff: Chicago Ag Science

40 Days to Kickoff: Chicago Ag Science

NBCSportsChicago.com preps reporter "Edgy" Tim O’Halloran spotlights 100 high school football teams in 100 days. The first 75 team profiles will focus on teams making strides across Chicagoland and elsewhere in the state. Starting July 30, we’ll unveil the @NBCSPrepsTop 25 Power Rankings, leading up to kickoff on Friday, Aug. 24.

School: Chicago Ag Science

Head coach: Shawn Finnin

Assistant coaches: Craig Dovich Vince Patterson KJ Jones Richard Price

How they fared in 2017: 6-4 (5-1 CPL Chicago Great Lakes Conference). Chicago Ag made the Class 4A state playoff field and lost to Rochelle in opening round action.

2018 Regular Season Schedule:

Aug. 24 @ Lindblom

Aug. 31 vs Hubbard

Sept 7 vs King

Sept. 14 @ Harlan

Sept. 21 @ Julian

Sept. 28 vs Marshall

Oct. 4 vs Goode

Oct. 13 @ Urban Prep Englewood

Oct. 19 vs Orr

[MORE: 41 Days to Kickoff - Bogan]

Biggest storyline: Can the Cyclones keep winning in a new conference (CPL Illini Windy City) starting this year?

Names to watch this season: TE Tony Stafford and OL Kam Williams

Biggest holes to fill: The Cyclones will need to replace 8 starters on defense lost to graduation.

EDGY's Early Take: The Cyclones had a historic season in 2017 making the IHSA state playoff field for the first time in school history. With the recent success comes a "move up" to the Illini division this fall. Look for Ag Science to rely on an experienced offense (seven starters) including four returning starters on the Cyclones offensive line from a year ago.

41 Days to Kickoff: Bogan

41 Days to Kickoff: Bogan

NBCSportsChicago.com preps reporter "Edgy" Tim O’Halloran spotlights 100 high school football teams in 100 days. The first 75 team profiles will focus on teams making strides across Chicagoland and elsewhere in the state. Starting July 30, we’ll unveil the @NBCSPrepsTop 25 Power Rankings, leading up to kickoff on Friday, Aug. 24.

School: Bogan

Head coach: Stacy Douglas

Assistant coaches: Yahya Mohammad, Shaun Edward and Kevin Moore

How they fared in 2017: 5-4 (1-3 CPL Intra City 2 Conference). Bogan and the rest of the CPL Intra City conference schools were ineligible for the IHSA state football playoffs.

2018 Regular Season Schedule:

Aug. 24 @ Solorio

Aug. 31 vs. Whitney Young (at Gately)

Sept 8 vs. DuSable (at Stagg)

Sept. 13 vs. UCCS Woodlawn (at Stagg)

Sept. 20 vs. Juarez (at Stagg)

Sept. 29 vs. North Grand (at Stagg)

Oct. 5 vs. Little Village (at Stagg)

Oct. 11 vs. Carver (at Gately)

Oct. 19 TBA CPL Playoffs

Biggest storyline: After a forfeited season in 2016 and a winning record last season, can the Bengals find success moving up to the CPL Chicago Madison Street conference this season?

Names to watch this season: RB/DB Keondre White and TE/SS Mateo Foster

Biggest holes to fill: The Bengals will welcome back several returning starters but overall depth could be a potential issue this season.

EDGY's Early Take: Bogan, with third-year head coach Stacy Douglas, will be stepping up in a big way this fall. They will move from the Intra City conference to the Chicago Madison Street conference, which is IHSA state playoff eligible. While the schedule is a bit tougher this fall do not overlook the Bengals’ chances of competing for a conference title and a potential state playoff bid in 2018.