Albert Almora Jr.

Even with home plate rule working in their favor, Cubs still searching for clarity

Even with home plate rule working in their favor, Cubs still searching for clarity

This home plate rule will not fade silently into the background.

At least not with the Cubs.

The "Buster Posey Rule," as it's become known as over the last few years has been a big point of contention around Major League Baseball.

Recently, the Cubs have been right in the middle of that with two separate variations on the play, both of which benefitted the team.

Anthony Rizzo deviated from his path toward home plate on Memorial Day last week, taking out Pirates catcher Elias Diaz with a slide to break up a double play and help push a pair of Cubs runs across.

On the field, Rizzo's slide was ruled legal and later upheld by replay. But the following day, MLB actually announced they were wrong in ruling Rizzo's slide legal.

Thursday afternoon at Wrigley Field, the Cubs were once again gifted a run due to a controversial play at the plate. As Rizzo lifted a fly ball into left field, Albert Almora Jr. tagged from third base and tried to slide in for the Cubs' fourth run of the game.

A phenomenal throw from Phillies outfielder Dylan Cozens and a great tag and block by catcher Andrew Knapp prevented Almora from scoring initially.

The play went to review, where the umpiring crew ruled Knapp was blocking the plate before the ball arrived, thus not giving Almora a lane to slide.

As a result, Almora was ruled safe and the Cubs wound up winning the game - and the series - by a solo tally.

"It was a great play," Joe Maddon said. "Great throw, great play by the catcher. Technically, the catcher did a great job. Fortunately, the rule permitted the run and we'll take it."

So all's well that ends well, right?

Not so fast.

The Cubs are happy to have the run - and the win - of course, but they're still scratching their heads wondering what to do on those close plays at the plate.

"The rule's super unclear," Almora said. "I want to be safe, I don't want to be a dirty player and he wants to prevent a run."

Almora actually believes the runner is now in more danger than the catcher given there is supposed to be essentially zero contact between the two. Nobody's going to be plowing over catchers and getting away with it anytime soon.

On the play, Almora is seen extending his arm right into the shin guard of Knapp, which could spell doom for fingers or hands or wrists moving forward.

But players don't want to slide in feet first now and potentially hurt the catchers with their spikes.

Things have progressed to where these plays and hazy rules are in the heads of baserunners as they barrel down toward home plate from third base.

"I had the chance to hit him," Almora said. "But you don't want to. You don't want to be labeled as that guy. You want to be a fair player. You don't want to get hurt, you don't want to hurt anybody.

"It's an unfortunate rule; it's still very blurry. I just hope they really clear it up soon before someone gets hurt."

Cubs veteran catcher Chris Gimenez is nearing a decade in the big leagues and he has no idea what to do in either position, as catcher or baserunner.

Gimenez said the last thing a catcher's thinking with the ball coming in is if his leg or body is too far in front of the plate, preventing a lane for the runner.

At the same time, Gimenez has been caught too far off the plate in an effort to adhere to the rule and wound up letting runs score as guys dive in the back part of the plate.

But maybe Thursday afternoon will be part of the learning experience moving forward.

"It's just a sensitive subject," Rizzo said. "...I'm happy they overturned it. In my opinion, I think a lot more need to be overturned so guys have a better lane to slide. It's just one of those plays that's difficult."

Why Nico Hoerner is exactly what the Cubs were looking for

Why Nico Hoerner is exactly what the Cubs were looking for

It took roughly 20 seconds after he began speaking for the first mention of the word "winning." 

Nico Hoerner became the latest college hitter to go to the Cubs in the first round of the MLB Draft and in his introductory teleconference with the Chicago media, the Stanford shortstop didn't waste any team showing what he was about.

Theo Epstein's Cubs front office spends a lot of time and energy on the character of a player they draft and it's paid off well with Albert Almora Jr., Kris Bryant, Kyle Schwarber and Ian Happ in the past (as far as the Draft goes, at least). 

Hoerner checked all the boxes for Epstein and Co.

"First and foremost, it's his ability on the baseball field," said Jason McLeod, Cubs senior VP of player development and amateur scouting. "He's a talented player that can really swing the bat, that's a high-contact bat. We think there's actually more power for him there in terms of extra-base hits and lifting the ball.

"But we really love what he can do at the plate. He's a multi-tool athlete with incredible makeup. When you go and watch him, it's really apparent — he's a leader on the field, he's a leader in the dugout, he's incredibly passionate, he's all about winning.

"He's exactly what we're looking to bring into the organization."

Hoerner was the star of a Stanford team that went 46-12 overall this season and finished atop the Pac 12 conference.

He spent most of the spring focusing on his team at Stanford instead of the Draft.

"Honestly with the Cubs, I really had no idea," Hoerner said. "I asked my advisors throughout the whole process to give me really limited information and just let me focus on the season. 

"I was lucky to be on a really successful team this year and I was focused on winning. The draft process was pretty smooth."

Hoerner only hit 3 homers in 164 career college games, but collected 42 doubles and 9 triples while slugging .406 overall.

After a rough start to his collegiate career in 2016 (.254 average, .609 OPS), Hoerner turned it on and hit .307 his sophomore year and then .349 his junior season.

In between seasons at Stanford, Hoerner — an Oakland native — played for the Madison, Wisc., team in the Northwoods League in 2016, where he got a taste of the Midwest life and caught a glimpse into the world of Cubs fans.

He also played in the Cape Cod League in 2017, an experience he credited with helping him take huge strides before his junior season in college.

As the Cubs prepared for the Draft, they were holding out hope Hoerner would still be available at pick No. 24. They fell in love with his "exceptional makeup" and unique "natural hitting ability."

The Cubs think more power will come eventually, as he continues to fill out his 5-foot-11, 190-pound frame.

"He's just so skilled at barreling the ball up around the zone," McLeod said. "He has strong hands. I know this year when I went to see him, I was actually surprised just the strength of his body. Because you read the bio and you might see 5-11ish or 6-feet and you kinda expect him to be more of a medium frame guy, but this is a guy that's very strong, has very strong hands, high contact and he hits balls really hard.

"We do think that will translate really well because of what he already does well — which is really elite hand-eye coordination and ability to get the barrel to the ball and hit it hard."

Hoerner also fits the Cubs' mold in recent years as a player who can play all over the diamond. He has no qualms about moving if asked, but for now, he and the Cubs are content with sticking at shortstop.

"I'm gonna play shortstop as long as that's OK with them," Hoerner said. "That's what I love to do; I think I can do it at a really high level. 

"But at the same time, I think I can play every position on the field if need be. Just want to win ballgames."

There's that "winning" concept again...

What we learned about the Cubs in May

What we learned about the Cubs in May

There's not really much point in making any definitive statements about a team or individual players until Memorial Day comes around.

The first month of the MLB season is too dependent on variables like hot/cold streaks or weather (as was the case this year more than ever).

Typically it takes two months (about 1/3 of the season) to be able to draw any conclusions.

The Cubs went 14-13 in May, which was actually buoyed by winning 4 of the last 5 games of the month. (They were 16-10 in March/April.)

But they actually had a +46 run differential over the 27 games in May, better than the +36 run differential in March/April.

The point: One month is still a short enough time to be impacted by luck. A team with a +46 run differential should not be just one game above .500.

Some other numbers from May compared to March/April:

The offense woke up, hitting .273/.356/.457 (.814 OPS) in May compared to a .252/.334/.412 (.746 OPS) in March/April. They averaged 5.3 runs/game in May compared to 5.1 runs/game pre-May.

The pitching staff posted a 3.26 ERA and 1.25 WHIP in May, tiny increases over a 3.33 ERA/1.31 WHIP in March/April. They also still walked the same amount of batters per 9 innings (4.2) in each month.

Which leads us to the first thing we learned this month:

1. Maybe this is just who this Cubs team is.

The pitching staff still struggles with walking far too many hitters. The offense is still good — but not great — and prone to slumps. There's still an issue hitting with runners in scoring position and getting guys home from third base with less than 2 outs. They are still prone to mental mistakes on the basepaths and in the field. 

Maybe this is just an inconsistent team. They are still very young, after all.

That's one thing that we could've concluded about the Cubs in March/April that actually holds up now. 

But then again, entering the game on May 1, the Cubs were coming off a 5-game winning streak and looking like they were about to break out.

The Cubs started May with 5 straight losses, then won 5 games in a row (against the Marlins and White Sox) and proceeded to continue along the roller coaster for the remainder of the month.

Though, one thing is for certain...

2. Anthony Rizzo is just fine.

The back issue that caused him to miss more than a week of action in April isn't lingering. He didn't suddenly forget how to hit. 

Rizzo's splits per month:


.149/.259/.189 (.448 OPS), 1 HR, 9 RBI, 4 BB, 15 K


.303/.408/.576 (.984 OPS), 5 HR, 28 RBI, 18 BB, 10 K

The BB/K is particularly impressive.

And as Rizzo got hot, so, too, did the Cubs offense (see above).

Another factor in the offensive upturn was the second half of Bryzzo...

3. You were really worried about Kris Bryant's power?

After Bryant hit just 2 homers in 26 games in March/April, some seemed to be concerned about the power output of the Cubs' best player.

Bryant responded in kind with 6 homers in May and a .536 slugging percentage.

He's fine and he's now a full month removed from a scary brush with a 97 mph fastball to the head. 

As the weather continues to get warm on a consistent basis, watch as Bryant's power continues to flourish.

That being said, there is one thing to be concerned about with the Cubs offense...

4. Javy has gone full Javy.

Baez is still in the midst of a breakout season and woke up on the morning of June 1 still tied for the National League league in RBI (43). 

He's on pace for 40 homers, 131 RBI and 101 runs this year.

But he didn't draw a walk until the final day of May and struck out 25 times over the month.

He went all the way from April 11 to May 31 without drawing a free pass of any kind (intentional or otherwise). 

That lack of plate discipline led to a startling .274 OBP in May and thus a .769 OPS, which was better than only Addison Russell and Jason Heyward among Cubs regulars in May.

Baez needs to improve on his plate discipline or else teams will continue to throw balls out of the zone, thus decreasing the chances of Baez hitting the ball with authority (though not completely eliminating that percentage given his insane ability to hit balls a foot out of the plate into the bleachers).

Still, if Baez is going to have a true breakout season, he can't continue to have months with a 1:25 BB:K ratios.

Though the Cubs are boosted by the fact that...

5. Albert Almora Jr. is truly in the midst of a breakout campaign.

Almora continued to flash awe-inspiring, Gold Glove defense in May while taking another step forward at the plate. He hit .338 over the course of the month (tops among Cubs regulars) with an .850 OPS. 

He struck out just 10 times, helping to lend a different dimension to a Cubs offense that is trying to limit the whiffs and "move the baseball" more, to borrow one of Joe Maddon's favorite phrases.

Almora has emerged as the team's clear top choice in center field, though...

6. Ian Happ isn't destined for Triple-A, after all.

Fans and media alike were clamoring for Happ to be sent to the minors to figure out his swing, but he instead responded with a .981 OPS in May, posting a .400 OBP and .581 SLG despite a .226 AVG.

He still struck out 28 times, but that's just part of the roller coaster the Cubs are content to ride, in part because...

7. Ben Zobrist is still in 2016 form.

Maddon's favorite choice for the Cubs leadoff spot (against right-handed pitchers, at least) walked 13 times in May and struck out just 12. He hit a big homer Thursday night in New York and posted an .803 OPS and .367 OBP throughout the entire month.

However, that still pales in comparison to the numbers he put up in May 2016 (.406/.483/.653, .1.137 OPS, 6 HR, 25 RBI).

Zobrist is looking healthy and as important to the Cubs' offense as he was in 2016, though in a bit of a diminished capacity. He is 37, after all.

Then again, there's one part of this team that's certainly not in 2016 form:

8. The starting rotation is still a major issue, but there are reasons for optimism.

The Cubs are still doling out far, far too many walks as a pitching staff, though a lot of that can be attributed to Tyler Chatwood (23 BBs in just 19.2 IP in May). 

Chatwood, Yu Darvish and Jose Quintana have caused a lot of concern in Cubdom, and rightfully so. 

In 2016, the Cubs rotation was performing at a record-setting level as they got out to a ridiculous start and coasted into the postseason.

That won't happen in 2018 — that much is clear — but here is the reason for optimism:

ERAs in May

Jon Lester - 2.70
Jose Quintana - 3.09
Kyle Hendricks - 3.26

That's right, everybody: Quintana was second among Cubs starters in ERA in May.

The ERA doesn't tell the whole story (he still had a 1.40 WHIP in the month), but Quintana is showing much-needed signs of life in the rotation.

He tossed 6 shutout innings in New York Thursday night, which was actually his 5th start in the last 7 in which he's allowed 1 or fewer earned runs. 

Which brings us to the final thing we learned about the Cubs in May:

9. This team is still waiting for something to flip the switch, but we know what that "something" is now.

It's the rotation getting into a groove on a consistent basis. We saw that in the 5-game win streak to end April as the offense failed to score more than 3 runs in any of those games.

But that was just one turn through the rotation. 

In order to fully go on a run and avoid the roller coaster season the Cubs have been on to date, they'll need consistent performances from the Cubs rotation.

Which means Chatwood needs to figure his stuff out and Darvish needs to get healthy and get right — both mentally and physically. 

Until Darvish returns, Mike Montgomery looks to step in and take advantage of his opportunity in the rotation, which he responded to very well in Pittsburgh on Memorial Day.

This rotation is the key and a Quintana turnaround could mean good things moving forward into June.