Skip navigation
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
View All Scores

Great Moments in Jon Heyman’s Hall of Fame inconsistency

Image (1) bonds1.jpg for post 3277

This is the time of year when we remember that, no matter how good a reporter Jon Heyman is -- and I fully and sincerely believe him to be an excellent reporter -- he’s clown shoes when it comes to the Hall of Fame.

First, his tweet from a few moments ago, addressing the ballot logjam issues we discussed this morning:

understand predicament Hall voters feel with jammed ballot. heres a possible solution: dont vote for guys who cheated!

— Jon Heyman (@JonHeymanCBS) December 5, 2014

Now his column from 2011:
Screen Shot 2014-12-05 at 11.46.21 AM

Read the whole thing here. It includes this passage:

For the Hall, it’s a judgment call. Scoundrels and cheats are already in. So are foul-tempered jerks. Bonds may be all three. He is also one of the three greatest players I ever saw in his prime, along with Alex Rodriguez and Rickey Henderson. A baseball Hall of Fame would be empty without Bonds.

While I do believe Bonds took steroids (whether it was knowingly or not doesn’t much matter to me, though if I had to guess, I think he knows everything that goes in his body), I don’t believe all steroid users should be excluded from the Hall of Fame. I’m not here to sit in moral judgment of another human being.

I agree with 2011 Jon Heyman. I think he and 2014 Jon Heyman should have a sit-down about it all, though, and come up with a unified message.

(thanks to Simon for the heads up on the 2011 article)