Skip navigation
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up

Comparing PHT editor and reader predictions to second round results

Sean Bergenheim

FILE - This May 4, 2011, file photo shows Tampa Bay Lightning left wing Sean Bergenheim, of Finland, celebrating one of his goals against the Washington Capitals during the second period in Game 4 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup playoffs Eastern Conference semifinal series, in Tampa, Fla. Tampa Bay’s big three of Martin St. Louis, Vincent Lecavalier and Steven Stamkos have been a big part of the Lightning’s success in the NHL playoffs. But so has Sean Bergenheim, who has emerged as an offensive force during the team’s run to the Eastern Conference finals. (AP Photo/Chris O’Meara, File)


It’s not easy to make forecasts for many things in life. If it was, Las Vegas probably wouldn’t allow people to gamble on sporting events and lotteries probably wouldn’t exist anymore.

Some people are frightened by the randomness of the world while others are delighted by the unpredictable nature of many events.

Either way, part of the fun of predicting the outcomes of games comes when we find out if our wild guesses picks are accurate. Last time, we took a look at how our results (along with reader results) compared to the first round realities. Let’s see how PHT editors and readers did in the second round.

Eastern Conference semifinals

1. Washington Capitals vs. 5. Tampa Bay Lightning

Actual result:Lightning beat Capitals 4-0
PHT readers pick: Capitals win series 4-2. (44.54 percent)
Joe’s pick: Capitals win series 4-2.
James’ pick: Capitals win series 4-1.

2. Philadelphia Flyers vs. 3. Boston Bruins

Actual result: Bruins win series 4-0.
PHT readers pick: Flyers win series 4-2. (41.1 percent)
Joe’s pick: Flyers win series 4-3.
James’ pick: Flyers win series 4-2.

Western Conference semifinals

1. Vancouver Canucks vs. 5. Nashville Predators

Actual result: Canucks win series 4-2.
PHT readers pick: Canucks win series 4-2. (32.13 percent)
Joe’s pick: Canucks win series 4-2.
James’ pick: Canucks win series 4-1.

2. San Jose Sharks vs. 3. Detroit Red Wings

Actual result: Sharks win series 4-3.
PHT readers pick: Red Wings win series 4-2. (46.3 percent)
Joe’s pick: Red Wings win series 4-3.
James’ pick: Sharks win series 4-2.

First round records:

PHT readers: 5-3 (with two exactly correct)
Joe: 6-2 (with three exactly correct)
James: 8-0 (with two exactly correct)

Second round records

PHT readers: 1-3 (with one exactly correct)
Joe: 1-3 (with one exactly correct)
James: 2-2 (with none exactly correct)

Overall record

PHT readers: 6-6 (with three exactly correct)
Joe: 7-5 (with four exactly correct)
James: 10-2 (with two exactly correct)