Eagles film review: How Eagles shut down Packers on key goal-line stand

Eagles film review: How Eagles shut down Packers on key goal-line stand

By now, we’ve all seen the Eagles’ final defensive play from Thursday’s 34-27 win plenty of times. With 28 seconds left, backup cornerback Craig James broke up a pass that was then intercepted by Nigel Bradham. Game over. 

But on the previous possession, the Packers had a 1st-and-goal from the Eagles’ 1-yard line and failed to punch it in. The Eagles were clinging to that seven-point lead in the fourth quarter.  

That means the Packers had a total of five plays inside the Eagles’ 5-yard line in the fourth quarter and failed to score. That’s bend-but-don’t-break defense. 

If you’re wondering why the Packers didn’t run the ball on any of those five plays, it’s a fair question. But as the Eagles’ pass defense was getting shredded on Thursday, their run defense was as stout as ever. Aside from scrambles from Aaron Rodgers, the Packers averaged just 2.07 yards per carry on Thursday and the Eagles were stacking the box. 

Because that last play has gotten enough time, let’s take a closer look at that goal-line stand from earlier in the fourth quarter: 

On 1st-and-goal from the 1-yard line with 9:19 left, here’s the initial look from the Packers. They have eight on the line. They’re clearly showing run, but there will be some pre-snap motion. Marcedes Lewis will spread out left and Jimmy Graham will spread wide right. The Packers want to find a matchup they like … and they do. 

At the top of the screen, Malcolm Jenkins is in man coverage against Lewis, but at the bottom is what the Packers want. They have Graham in a 1-on-1 situation against Rodney McLeod with no help in sight. They’re going to trust their 6-7 tight end to go up and get a ball against a 5-10 safety. Just a simple fade. 

Rodgers never thought about going anywhere else. 

“We got to the goal line, we liked the matchup on the outside, Jimmy Graham on the safety,” Packers coach Matt LaFleur said. 

The only problem is that McLeod played it perfectly. Incomplete. 

This is the look on second down. The Packers set up in a run formation again, but this is going to be a play fake. The entire offensive line blocks left and LaFleur is hoping the defensive line follows. After the game, LaFleur called this a keeper, but it seems like Rodgers might have had an option to throw to the fullback. But nothing was open. 

At the faux mesh point, Brandon Graham never buys the play fake. He keeps after Rodgers. Likewise, Zach Brown didn’t buy it either. He’s going to stick the fullback coming out of the backfield. 

As soon at Rodgers turns, there’s nothing there. Graham is in his face. Brown is in coverage. Rodgers is forced to throw it away. 

Incomplete. Brings up third down. 

On third down, the Packers finally spread out the field a little bit and are in shotgun. They have four wide, but the Eagles can’t completely abandon their worry about a run. That’s still on the table and, again, a play fake from the Packers. 

At the faux mesh point, Rodgers is going to roll left where he has two players in single coverage, including Graham on cornerback Rasul Douglas. This isn’t the same matchup advantage they had on first down against the smaller safety. 

Anyway, the fake works and Derek Barnett sells out on the run. But at the same time, McLeod is coming like a heat-seeking missile. McLeod is coming up huge on this goal-line stand. Douglas has tight coverage on Graham and Andrew Sendejo has good coverage on his man too. 

With McLeod charging, Rodgers is forced to throw and you’ll notice no one is open. He’ll simply throw the ball away, choosing to live to see another down. 


On fourth down, there’s no illusion, no play fake. Rodgers is dropping back to throw and eventually he’s going to buy even more time to throw. The Eagles’ coverage lacked all day, but it was great on this play. 

The Eagles went with a four-man rush, so they have seven players drop in coverage to cover six potential receivers. At the depth of Rodgers’ dropback, no one is open. 

Graham gets easy pressure working against backup right tackle Alex Light. Starter Bryan Bulaga left the game with injury and Graham was feasting on the backup. It didn’t show up on the stat sheet, but this was a huge mismatch for the Eagles late in this game. The pressure from Graham forces Rodgers out of the pocket and there’s still no one open. 

As Rodgers sets his feet again, there’s still no one open. But Rodgers is a future Hall of Famer for a reason. With Fletcher Cox barreling down on him, he throws a desperation pass to Graham (circled) in the back of the end zone with Brown in coverage. He puts it on the money, but perhaps could have thrown it sooner. 

That came close to being completed, but give credit to the Eagles. Their coverage held up on a crucial play for over six seconds!

That final PBU from James and INT from Bradham later in the game was a huge play, but that moment doesn’t happen without this four-play goal-line stand. 

This was the 31st 1st-and-goal from the 1-yard line in the NFL this season. The only other time the offense didn’t come away with points was when the Lions fumbled the ball away. In fact, 28 of the 30 previous teams to have a 1st-and-goal from the 1-yard line this season scored touchdowns. 

It really was a great stop by the Eagles. 

Click here to download the MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Eagles

Hall of Famer Harold Carmichael: 'I didn't know if I was good enough'

Hall of Famer Harold Carmichael: 'I didn't know if I was good enough'

Harold Carmichael learned back on Monday that he had finally made it into the Hall of Fame, but for logistical reasons he wasn’t allowed to tell anybody until after the official announcement on Wednesday.
As it happened, on Tuesday night, Harold found himself sitting next to his close friend and long-time coach Dick Vermeil at a dinner at NaBrasa Brazlian Steakhouse in Horsham.
For three hours.

Vermeil had just learned he didn't make it into the Hall of Fame. Carmichael had just learned he had.

And he couldn't say a word.
“It was killing me,” Carmichael said. “We talked about being disappointed that he didn’t get in, but I couldn’t say anything to him. He was promoting Dick Vermeil wines and we had about 160 people and they were asking me if I’d heard anything yet and I would just get off the subject. I really didn’t want to lie to anybody. I just couldn’t say anything about it. It was very, very tough for me. It’s still tough for me right now because I’m still trying to answer a lot of the texts. Got over 400 just in the past 24 hours and phone messages. My mailbox is full. They just gotta have patience. Like I did for 36 years.”
Carmichael’s wait is over.
This fall, he’ll be enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame alongside more than 300 other all-time greats.
Carmichael retired after the 1984 season, so he’s been eligible since 1989. Despite ranking 5th in NFL history in receptions when he retired, he was never even a finalist until this year.
“I didn’t know if I deserved to be in there,” Carmichael said Thursday. “I’ve been hearing I should be in there for the past 30-some years. It was not a lock for me. I didn’t know if I was good enough. I tried to do my best, but it was not for me to say I should be in the Hall of Fame. It was for me to try to put the numbers up and try to be the type of person they would want to represent the Hall of Fame.”
From 1973 through 1983, Carmichael led the NFL in yards (8,414), touchdowns (77) and catches (549). 
When he retired after playing two games with the Cowboys in 1984, Carmichael ranked 5th in NFL history in catches, 7th in yards and 7th in TD catches.
Today, 36 years after his last touchdown, Carmichael still ranks 24th in NFL history in TD catches.
This is all from a kid who didn’t get recruited to play major-college football, was a walk-on at Southern University in Baton Rouge and was drafted in the 7th round.
“When I got here, Harold Jackson and Ben Hawkins were the starting receivers,” Carmichael said. “They were veterans and I was trying to learn how to be a football player and questioning whether I could play in the National Football League.”
Now, nearly half a century later, Carmichael has been recognized as one of the greatest of all time. 
He’s only the 8th receiver drafted in the 7th round or later to make it into the Hall of Fame and the first whose career began in the 1970s or later.
Carmichael, 70, said the last 24 hours have been a whirlwind as congratulations have come in from 50 years worth of friends, teammates, coaches and associates.
“My son said to my wife, ‘Mom, I didn’t know so many people loved dad like this,’” Carmichael said.

More on the Eagles

Eagle Eye podcast: What’s taking so long, Doug?

USA Today Images

Eagle Eye podcast: What’s taking so long, Doug?

On the latest Eagle Eye podcast presented by Nissan, Reuben Frank and Dave Zangaro try to figure out what’s taking Doug Pederson so long to hire an offensive coordinator. 

Some top names have already found jobs. The guys update the remaining vacancies and speculate about the Eagles’ plan and toss out one new theory. 

They also look back at the biggest lessons from the 2019 season. 

• Coaches are getting hired all over the NFL 
• Updating offensive coordinator opening
• What are the Eagles’ waiting for? 
• Lessons from the 2019 season 
• Will Jordan Howard be back in 2020? 
• Figuring out which DEs are on the bubble 
• Our championship weekend predictions 
• Harold Carmichael is finally Hall-bound
• Which Eagles player is next? 

Click here to download the MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Eagles