Trading for Edwin Diaz would cost Phillies too much

USA Today Images

Trading for Edwin Diaz would cost Phillies too much

The Phillies are interested in the top available relievers — specifically lefties Zach Britton and Andrew Miller — but could also explore the trade market.

Over Thanksgiving weekend,'s Jon Morosi reported the Phillies and Braves have expressed interest in trading for Mariners closer Edwin Diaz.

Let's get the caveats out of the way. This time of year, almost all teams are discussing all available players. Terms like "interest" can mean a variety of things. It could mean genuine interest, or it could mean a team has simply placed a phone call about a player it probably won't be able to acquire.

Phillies or not, Diaz is a safe bet to be traded this offseason. The Mariners are in sell-mode, and he's coming off a career year he may never be able to duplicate. Diaz led the majors with 57 saves in 65 attempts, striking out 124 in 73⅓ innings with a 1.96 ERA and 0.79 WHIP. Selling high is clearly the move for a team that has already dealt James Paxton this offseason.

All Diaz needs to succeed is his fastball-slider combination. His fastball has averaged exactly 97.3 mph in each of his three big-league seasons, with his slider picking up velocity and now just a tick under 90. He hadn't previously been as dominant as he was in 2018, but the pure stuff should give an acquiring team confidence that Diaz — 25 in March — will be a top reliever the next four seasons.

Diaz cannot become a free agent until after the 2022 season, which is huge for the Mariners because it means they can ask for a ton in a trade. They have a young, elite player at his position under team control for 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022. 

The Mariners would be fully within their right to try for Sixto Sanchez, the Phillies' most exciting and highest-ceiling pitching prospect. If that sounds like an unreasonable asking price, it's really not when you consider the value Diaz could bring a team relative to his cost the next four years. You're not just getting a top-level closer — you're getting him for about one-third of the price the top free-agent relievers will command.

Should the Phillies do that? No, in my opinion. You don't trade a top starting pitching prospect for a closer unless you have a strong rotation and are a piece or two away from winning a title. For the Phils, there would be the added benefit of keeping him away from the Braves, but that's still not a reason to trade away one of your best young assets in a win-now move.

If the Phils feel more comfortable adding a top reliever via trade than free agency, they should set their sights a bit lower. Think back to their own trade of Ken Giles to the Astros in December 2015. Giles was coming off two very good seasons and, like Diaz, was cost-controlled. Giles wasn't quite at Diaz's level though, and as a result, the centerpiece of the Phillies' return was Vince Velasquez, not someone in the tier above like Lance McCullers Jr.

That is a more logical trade for a team in the Phillies' position. Potential trade fits could include Cleveland's Brad Hand, Arizona's Archie Bradley and Brad Boxberger and San Diego's Kirby Yates. All are above-average relievers ranging from good to great and all would cost less to acquire than Diaz.

And, again, the free-agent market is stocked with late-inning bullpen help. A lefty like Britton or Miller makes the most sense to improve the Phillies' relief corps, though any of Craig Kimbrel, Adam Ottavino, David Robertson and Jeurys Familia would represent an upgrade as well.

The Phillies will find the bullpen help they need this offseason and they can find it without selling the farm.

Click here to download the new MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Phillies

O-H, yeah, Bryce Harper gives Indians fans a little something to remember him by

O-H, yeah, Bryce Harper gives Indians fans a little something to remember him by

CLEVELAND — Bryce Harper knows how to play a crowd. He’s done it all season at Citizens Bank Park with his pre-game bow to the fans in the right-field seats followed by his heaving of a warm-up ball into the upper deck.

The fans love it.

They love it even more when he hits home runs.

Harper belted his 33rd homer of the season to lead a 9-4 Phillies’ win over the Cleveland Indians on Saturday night. The home run was an impressive one, a three-run shot that put the Phils ahead, 5-4, with one out in the fifth inning.

The Phillies have played 153 games and they are in the midst of an 11-game road trip. At this time of year, the days seem to become a blur. Sometimes players don’t even know what day it is, or what city they’re waking up in. All they know is that there is another game to play.

But Harper was keenly aware of his surroundings Saturday night, keenly aware of what state he was in. As he crossed home plate after his go-ahead homer, he raised his arms and made the "O-H” sign above his head. And as he spoke with reporters after the game, he wore an Ohio State cap — backwards, of course.

“Big win for the Bucks today,” he said of the 76-5 whooping that Ohio State’s football team put on Miami of Ohio.

Harper’s wife, Kayla, played soccer at Ohio State. That was the birth of his fandom.

The fans in Cleveland appreciated the love that Harper showed for the Buckeyes.

They just would have preferred that he’d done it after, say, a harmless single.

Phillies starter Jason Vargas really appreciated the homer. He gave up four runs in the first two innings — two were unearned after Jean Segura’s error in the first inning — but kept his club in the game until the bats got going in the middle innings. Vargas pitched 6 2/3 bullpen-saving innings and ended up with his first win since July 28, when he was a member of the Mets.

Brad Miller hit the first of his two homers in the fourth inning and Harper put the Phils ahead with his three-run shot in the fifth. Harper’s homer was preceded by hits from Adam Haseley and J.T. Realmuto. 

With his team up, 4-2, Cleveland manager Terry Francona brought in lefty Oliver Perez to face Harper. Perez had retired Harper the night before. This time, Harper fouled off five pitches before hitting the ninth pitch, a full-count slider, over the wall in right field.

“It’s nice to be able to stay competitive and keep us in position to get back into the game and then, golly, I mean I can’t say that I’ve seen a more professional at-bat than the one Harper had against Perez right there,” Vargas said. “I think that any time you see an at-bat like that from your main guy, it’s just — he really didn’t give in and he really made the effort to stay in the at-bat and do everything he could do to get his pitch and he really capitalized and made a difference for us.”

Harper has 15 homers and 36 RBIs in his last 40 games.

“He has been tremendous in the second half of the season for us,” manager Gabe Kapler said. “We win when Harper hits.

“That nine-pitch at-bat felt determined to me. Like he was determined not to fail. He was determined to put the ball in play and put it in play hard. He just did a good job of getting up underneath that baseball and putting it in the air.”

The Phils hit four homers on the night and they got excellent work from the bullpen, which has a 2.69 ERA — second-best in baseball — over the last 20 games.

A smiling Vargas stood in the dugout and greeted reliever Jared Hughes when he retired dangerous Francisco Lindor to end the seventh.

The victory was the 99th of Vargas’ career and it kept the Phils mathematically alive in the NL wild-card race at five games back with nine to play.

Vargas, 36, intends to pitch next season — the Phillies hold a $6 million option on his contract, though it’s unclear if they will pick that up — but he would prefer to get his 100th win before then.

He lines up to make one more start this season.

“I’d definitely like to get it sooner than later, obviously, but I’ve gone this long without having 100,” Vargas said. “It will be nice when it comes and hopefully it comes. It would definitely be a nice thing to have.”

Click here to download the MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Phillies

Bryce Harper hits go-ahead home run as Phillies power past Indians

Bryce Harper hits go-ahead home run as Phillies power past Indians


CLEVELAND — The math says the Phillies still have a chance at making the postseason.

But sitting five games back in the National League wild-card race with just nine games remaining has turned them into spoilers.

With that, the Phils threw a little hurdle in the way of the Cleveland Indians with a 9-4 win on Saturday night.

The 91-win Indians entered the night tied with Tampa Bay for the second American League wild-card spot. They had won five in a row.

The Phils trailed 4-1 after two innings, but they came back to take the lead on the strength of home runs by Brad Miller and Bryce Harper. Harper’s three-run shot in the fifth gave the Phillies the lead.

Jay Bruce and Miller — he blasted his second homer of the game in the ninth — padded the lead with solo homers.

Jason Vargas gave a tired bullpen a break with 6 2/3 strong innings.

The Phillies are 79-74. They need to win three of their final nine games to have their first winning season since 2011.

Vargas’ night

The veteran lefty came into the game with a 7.17 ERA in his previous five starts and he lasted just three innings in his previous two.

Vargas survived a costly error in the first inning and held the Indians to four runs, two of which were unearned. His fastball topped out in the mid-80s, but he was able to change speeds off of that on his way to eight strikeouts. His changeup was a good pitch.

The win was Vargas’ first since July 28, when he was with the Mets. He has 99 career wins.

Good job by the ‘pen

Jared Hughes, Jose Alvarez and Edgar Garcia teamed on 2 1/3 scoreless innings to protect the lead.

Over the last 20 games, the Phillies’ bullpen has posted a 2.69 ERA. That’s second-best in the majors over that span.

Win the battle

On Friday night, lefty reliever Oliver Perez came out of the bullpen and retired Bryce Harper on a ground ball. Cleveland manager Terry Francona went back to Perez when Harper came up with two men on base and one out in the fifth inning. This time, Harper won a long, nine-pitch battle against Perez. He fouled off five pitches before clubbing a full-count slider over the wall in right-center. The three-run homer gave the Phillies a 5-4 lead. Jay Bruce lengthened the lead to 6-4 with a solo homer later in the inning. Bruce, who has missed time with an elbow injury, has just two hits since the All-Star break. Both are homers.

Harper has 33 homers on the season.

No excuse

Shortstop Jean Segura committed a first-inning error that eventually cost Vargas two runs. Cleveland leadoff man Francisco Lindor hit a ground ball right at Segura and he made a low throw across the diamond that Rhys Hoskins could not pull out of the dirt. It was a play that a top defensive first baseman makes, but that’s not the point. The error was completely avoidable and never would have happened if Segura had not been so nonchalant in flipping his throw across the diamond. His lack of intensity on the play cost the team two runs.

Later in the game, Segura made an excellent play when he ranged behind the second-base bag, spun and fired to first base to get Franmil Reyes. Segura can do it when he wants to.

Up next

Vince Velasquez (7-7, 4.89) gets the ball in Sunday night’s series finale. He will go up against Cleveland right-hander Adam Plutko (7-4, 4.34).

Click here to download the MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Phillies