What it could take for Phillies to re-sign Wilson Ramos

What it could take for Phillies to re-sign Wilson Ramos

A week into his Phillies career, this fan base has warmed to Wilson Ramos to the point that many are wondering whether they'll try to keep him around past this season.

This question started pouring in the morning after Ramos' historic, 3-extra-base-hit, 3-RBI debut.

Will they? Should they?

Ramos' last contract

Ramos, who turned 31 on Aug. 10, is a free agent after the season. He'll be coming off a two-year, $12.5 million contract that paid him approximately $8.5 million in 2018.

He signed that deal with the Rays after his All-Star 2016 season with the Nationals, when he hit .307 with an .850 OPS, 22 homers and 80 RBI.

If you're wondering why an All-Star catcher signed such a relatively inexpensive deal, it's because he tore his ACL on Sept. 26 of that 2016 season. Tampa Bay knew it wouldn't have him until late in 2017. The Rays went in essentially paying that $12.5 million for 1½ seasons of Ramos.

That figure is necessary to look back to as an idea of what Ramos will and should be looking for this time around.

Ramos has only built upon his résumé since signing that deal. Over the last three seasons, he has the second-highest batting average (.296) and OPS (.828) among catchers, and that's despite 224 below-average plate appearances when he came back from injury last summer.

The free-agent landscape

Barring a serious injury, Ramos will not just be the top catcher on the free-agent market, he'll be one of the top hitters, period. There's the Bryce Harper-Manny Machado tier, and then the group that includes Ramos, Nelson Cruz and Daniel Murphy.

Powerful, switch-hitting catcher Yasmani Grandal is also a free agent but it seems unlikely the Dodgers let him get away, which means every team looking to upgrade behind the plate will be placing a call to Ramos' agent.

Comparable deals

In December 2013, the Yankees signed a then-29-year-old Brian McCann to a five-year, $85 million contract.

In November 2014, the Blue Jays signed a then-31-year-old Russell Martin to a five-year, $82 million contract.

Neither deal has gone as planned. And, as we saw last offseason, the free-agent landscape has changed. When it comes to these lengthy, high-priced contracts, teams are more reluctant now than they were over the last decade. Carlos Santana's $60 million deal was the fourth-largest for a position player this past offseason.

A better template for a deal is the one signed by Francisco Cervelli in May of 2016, a three-year, $31 million extension with the Pirates. Cervelli was the same age. Ramos is a superior player so he will make a higher annual salary.

Something in the three-year, $48 million vicinity seems realistic for Ramos. If the Phillies frontload the contract, perhaps they can get Ramos to agree to make the third year of the deal a mutual option with a buyout.

The Phillies have plenty of money to spend. The issue is, if the free-agent negotiations for Machado and Harper take weeks or longer, another team could swoop in and sign Ramos. So if the Phillies do prioritize bringing him back, they'd have to have these negotiations separately and irrespective of each other and be willing to spend on Ramos even without knowing whether they'll also land a bigger fish.

What about Alfaro?

While the Phillies were supposed to be better in 2018 than they were in 2017, they went into this year looking to learn about many of their young players. It was why Jorge Alfaro was the starting catcher and why the Phillies felt comfortable carrying two young catchers together.

Alfaro has shown flashes of power at the plate and athleticism defensively and on the bases. He's also swung-and-missed at a higher rate than anyone in the majors and struck out at a higher rate than anyone in the majors. Alfaro's punched out 120 times in 322 plate appearances. He's struck out 9 percent more often this season than Ryan Howard did in his career.

Alfaro is out of options, so his fate here is either as the starting catcher or backup. If wins and losses didn't matter for the 2018 Phillies, he would have continued to be their No. 1. But the Phillies arrived earlier than expected and are contending in late-August, so you have to go with the players that give you the best chance to win on a daily basis. It's why Asdrubal Cabrera became the regular shortstop over Scott Kingery and why Ramos will play two-thirds of the remaining games, if not a bit more.

So ... should they re-sign Ramos?

Signing Ramos to a two- or three-year deal would not permanently stunt Alfaro's growth. It would give Alfaro time to develop in the majors as a backup, to learn the little nuances from Ramos and focus on making more contact. On Friday night, Alfaro had a two-strike, broken bat bloop single off Noah Syndergaard to score a runner from third with less than two outs. Those are the kinds of ABs he needs to keep having, because if you're a National League team with a whiff-prone eight-hole hitter, you're essentially giving the opposing team two outs at the bottom of the order.

Gabe Kapler said this week that Ramos' stoicism has stood out and that Alfaro can learn from the veteran's mannerisms both behind the plate and during mound visits. He compared Ramos' impact on a young catcher to Jake Arrieta's on a young pitcher.

"He's almost stoic," Kapler said. "That's an important quality for a catcher to have. Pitchers want to be inspired, but they also want to calmed down."

Let's be real, though, if the Phillies do open the checkbook to re-sign Ramos, it will be because of his bat. That calming veteran presence is an added bonus.

Re-upping (a healthy) Ramos would be a logical move for a team in the Phillies' position — an ascending National League contender with offensive needs and young pitchers. There's no reason they should let him get away, unless an aggressive spender comes over the top and offers five years.

More on the Phillies

How we would have been breaking down Phillies' home opening series vs. Brewers

How we would have been breaking down Phillies' home opening series vs. Brewers

After playing nearly the first week of the season on the road (just as they have four of the last five seasons), today the Phillies open up Citizens Bank Park for the 2020 season. What a beeee-U-T-FULL day it is! Perfect for what would have been opening day. 

It's a crusher, isn't it? First off, the weather's usually terrible for the home opener and we get a day like this. Second, the Phillies would have mopped up with the Marlins and then the Mets to start the season, it says right here. The Phillies would be looking for a third straight home-opening win.

So who's the opponent for the Fightins on the occasion of their 139th home opener? One of last season's wild-card entrants, the Milwaukee Brewers. The Brew Crew lost the wild-card game to the eventual World Series champion Washington Nationals 4-3. Blew a 3-0 lead as the Nats scored three eighth-inning runs and that was it. Josh Hader, Milwaukee's elite closer, took the loss.

In the lineup, Yasmani Grandal left after one strong season and Mike Moustakas joined the Reds after hitting 35 homers in 2020. The Brewers have just two players remaining from last year's 1-8. Chief among them, 2018 MVP (and last season's runner-up) Christian Yelich.

Can you count on a lineup with that kind of turnover? One positive is second-year cleanup hitter Keston Hiura. He played in 84 games last season but if the second baseman meets expectations (30+ home runs, batting average near .300) maybe this lineup can withstand the key losses.

As for former MVP Ryan Braun, at this point in his career the 13-year veteran will split time at first base and in the outfield.

Brewers pitching? Brandon Woodruff's coming off an All-Star season in '19 but the rest of Milwaukee's rotation could be a weakness. They've got three new pieces in the rotation via free agency and trade, and Adrian Houser, had a 3.72 ERA in 18 starts for the Brewers last season.

Woulda been a great day ...

Subscribe and rate the Phillies Talk podcast:
Apple Podcasts / Google Play / Spotify / Stitcher / Art19 / YouTube

More on the Phillies

The day John Kruk rolled out of a radiation treatment and electrified Philadelphia

The day John Kruk rolled out of a radiation treatment and electrified Philadelphia

All these years later, the hair on the back of my neck still stands up when I think about it.

April 11, 1994.

Phillies home opener at Veterans Stadium. The Colorado Rockies were in town.

And John Kruk was back in the lineup.

The Phillies should be playing their home opener today. They should be coming back home after seven games on the road. Dan Baker should be calling new skipper Joe Girardi's name for the first time. Jake Arrieta should be toeing the slab. The 'Everybody Hits' guy should be doing his thing. Bryce Harper's long mane should be flopping in the wind as his helmet flies off and he dives into second base with a hustle double. 

Of course, there is none of this today. Ballparks and arenas all across the land are closed as the sporting world, the entire world, deals with this beast called coronavirus.

There's an old saying in baseball that no one is bigger than the game. Coronavirus has proven to be the exception.

But while baseball has paused, our baseball memories, thankfully, have not. And that's why today I'm reliving my favorite Phillies home opener, the day cancer-stricken John Kruk, just a few days after his 33rd birthday, literally rolled out of a radiation treatment and smashed an RBI double in his first at-bat of the season as 58,627 of his best friends looked on in amazement and showered him with loud adulation from the seats.

Remember it?

"It was the loudest I'd ever heard Veterans Stadium — and we had just clinched a pennant and played in a World Series there six months earlier," Frank Coppenbarger said.

Coppenbarger, the Phillies' equipment and clubhouse man in those days, was on the first base line as the team received their 1993 National League championship rings during introductions.

Kruk was the last player to be introduced and the crowd erupted as Baker, still the Phillies' PA man, announced his name.

"The introduction was plenty loud," Coppenbarger recalled. "But when he hit that double, I thought the place might crack and fall apart. It was a deafening roar like I'd never heard in any ballpark.

"You couldn't help but have a lump in your throat."

We checked in with Ed Wade, then the Phillies' assistant GM, Larry Bowa, then the third base coach, Dave Hollins, then the starting third baseman, Larry Andersen, then a teammate, Baker, and Mike DiMuzio, who still oversees stadium ops for the Phils.

They all mentioned the ovation, the roar that rose from the crowd, as Kruk's bat met Colorado pitcher Mike Harkey's 3-1 fastball in the bottom of the first inning.

"It was unbelievable," DiMuzio said. "Right up there with 1980 when Tug (McGraw) struck out Willie Wilson (to clinch the World Series title). 

"But for an individual player, it was the loudest ovation I ever heard at the Vet."

The Rockies' catcher that day was none other than Joe Girardi.

He did not recall the moment, but at least he had an excuse.

"Too many foul tips," he said.

• • •

The thunderous ovation that Kruk received that day was rooted in the 1993 season. Phillies fans loved that team for its character and its characters and Kruk was one of the most popular, and productive, characters. But the ovation, and what made the moment so memorable, was intensified by the public battle that Kruk had gone through in the previous weeks.

Kruk had been diagnosed with testicular cancer during spring training. While the team trained in Clearwater and went to Denver and Cincinnati for the first six games of the season, Kruk was in Philadelphia undergoing treatment at Jefferson Hospital. When he felt good enough, he'd head down to Veterans Stadium and take some swings against Dickie Noles. Sometimes there was ice on the field.

At home in Florida, 26 years later, Kruk picked up the phone the other day and recalled his ordeal. Bill Giles had arranged for him to stay in a hotel a few blocks away from the hospital as he went through his treatment. After every treatment, Kruk would walk back to the hotel and throw up. When he felt better, he'd eat the soft pretzel that a nice vendor would give him every day as he walked back to the hotel.

"I think I had a soft pretzel 25 straight days," he said. "I offered to pay the guy and he said, 'No. Just get better.' I would love to find out who that guy was."

Throughout his treatment, Kruk had eyed the home opener for his return. As the club headed to Cincinnati for a weekend series with the Reds, he headed to Reading for three rehab games. He received a radiation treatment before Friday's game. He did not have treatment on the weekend and felt good during the Saturday and Sunday games.

The home opener was on a Monday afternoon. Kruk had a radiation treatment that morning then reported to Veterans Stadium, where he was reunited with his teammates. Regardless of whether he'd be activated from the disabled list or not, he was going to take the field for introductions and the ring ceremony.

But Kruk wanted to play. His cancer doctor had cleared him — as long as he had the energy to do it after the radiation treatment. After arriving at the park, Kruk lobbied the Phillies medical team and general manager Lee Thomas and manager Jim Fregosi to put him on the active roster. An hour before game time, outfielder Tom Marsh was sent to Triple A and Kruk was activated.

Before the game, club officials gave the players instructions regarding introductions and the ring ceremony. Kruk would be introduced last. Orders from above. 

He protested.

"I didn't like that," Kruk said. "We were celebrating the National League championship that day. I didn't want it to be about me. I get it, I had cancer. But it was supposed to be about the team goal we accomplished, not me."

Kruk lost his protest. 

He was introduced last.

And as he made his way down the row of teammates and coaches stretched along the first-base line, with a chorus of cheers behind him, he began to realize the magnitude of the moment.

"Vuke was in tears," Kruk said of the John Vukovich, the late, great Phillies coach. "Bowa had tears in his eyes. These are tough men and to see that — that's when it hit me. I thought to myself, 'Don't screw this up.' "

He didn't.

• • •

The moving moment became even more emotional just a few moments into the game when Kruk, batting third in Fregosi's lineup, came to the plate in the first inning. There was one out and Mariano Duncan was on first base. Kruk worked the count to 3-1 and guessed fastball. He got one up in the zone, where he liked it.

"I knew my timing wasn't good, so I knew I had to start my swing early," Kruk said. "I knew Harkey liked to challenge guys with his fastball and I was just hoping I'd get one because I don't think I would have hit anything else. Luckily, I got one."

The ball rocketed off Kruk's bat into the gap in right-center. The crowd erupted. Duncan scored from first. And as Kruk gathered himself at second base, the roar of the crowd continued to swell.

On the outside, Kruk played it off and turned his attention to being a base runner.

On the inside, he was overwhelmed.

"I was like, 'Holy crap, what just happened here?' " he said. "That hit was a big weight off my shoulders. I mean, six weeks earlier, I didn't know if I'd ever play again.

"I remember how loud the crowd was. Walt Weiss (Colorado's shortstop) walked past me and said, 'Hey, dummy, tip your cap.' I'm still not sure if I did. I didn't know what to do so I just went back to playing."

Kruk quickly found himself rounding third when his buddy, Hollins, drove a double down the right-field line. As Kruk crossed home plate, he shook hands with Darren Daulton, another close buddy, and continued on to the dugout, where he was greeted by teammates who couldn't believe what they just saw.

"Some guys were jokingly pissed off," Kruk said with a laugh. "They went through an entire spring training and I had a handful of at-bats against Dickie Noles on the ice at the Vet. Guys were like, 'It shouldn't be that easy.' It's not. I got lucky."

The first-inning double was one of three hits Kruk had on the day. That ain't luck. The Phillies lost the game, 8-7, and Kruk recalled, "by the time I had my last at-bat, I was worn out. From the emotion of it all, the radiation in the morning, begging them to play, finally playing, I was whipped."

• • •

Through the magic of the internet, you can watch the Phillies' 1994 home opener on your computer screen.

You can watch it.

I can watch it.

But Kruk won't. 

"Nah," he said. "It's in my head."

He paused. 

"I remember a lot about that day," he added. "It was really special. As players, we had the feeling of being embraced because of what we did the year before, and for me ...

"I'll always be a guy from West Virginia. But I felt like a Philadelphian that day. That ovation. My God. It left me thinking, 'I love this place.' "

Subscribe and rate the Phillies Talk podcast:
Apple Podcasts / Google Play / Spotify / Stitcher / Art19 / YouTube

More on the Phillies