Skip navigation
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up

Player ratings: Manchester United v Manchester City

The PST crew looks ahead to Matchweek 12 in the Premier League which includes a clash between Man United and Manchester City.

Manchester United - Manchester City player ratings were extremely tough to dish out, but we did it anyway.

[ VIDEO: Premier League highlights ]

Basically, the vast majority of players got a six and a couple were handed marks just above that. Just. The 0-0 draw wasn’t inspiring, as both team settled for a draw (See: Three things we learned).

[ MORE: Guardiola reaction | Solskjaer reaction ]

Here’s a look at the Manchester United - Manchester City player ratings from a tense Manchester derby at Old Trafford.

Manchester United player ratings

David de Gea: 6 - Did well to deny Mahrez in the first half. Aside from that, collected a few crosses with ease.

Aaron Wan-Bissaka: 6 - Struggled early on defensively. City targeted him and he was caught out one-on-one by Sterling, but recovered well.

Victor Lindelof: 6 - Headed just over from a corner. Not tested defensively

Harry Maguire: 6 - Headed over a corner, while at the other end he looked assured and made some big blocks.

Luke Shaw: 7 - Did a job on Mahrez defensively, and did the same when Ferran Torres came on. Shrugged off an injury.

Fred: 6 - Battled through injury in the first half and dug deep to shut out City’s attack.

Scott McTominay: 6 - See above. Didn’t see a lot of the ball and his positioning was very deep.

Paul Pogba: 7 - Got himself into some dangerous positions and sprayed the ball around nicely. Had quality on the ball as he started on the left and played centrally.

Bruno Fernandes: 6 - Tried to impact the game but couldn’t. Rodri and Fernandinho shut his space down expertly.

Mason Greenwood: 6 - One shot which was blocked and did his best to roam across the front line.

Marcus Rashford: 6 - See above. Not a lot going on in attack. Won a penalty kick early in the second half but was ruled out by VAR as he was offside.

Anthony Martial (74' on for Greenwood): N/A

Manchester City player ratings

Ederson: 6 - One sloppy pass in the first half but did well apart from that.

Kyle Walker: 6 - Lucky to not give away a penalty kick in the second half. Did okay.

John Stones: 7 - Solid defensively and really calm on the ball. It’s nice to see his confidence growing once again.

Ruben Dias: 6 - A couple of good blocks and tackles. An easy outing for the Portuguese defender.

Joao Cancelo: 6 - See above. Solid defensively at left back but didn’t get forward.

Rodri: 6 - Sat in and tried his best to dictate the tempo of the game.

Fernandinho: 6 - Plugged the gaps well. Couldn’t help City grab control of the game.

Riyad Mahrez: 6 - Should have scored when clean through. Whipped in one dangerous cross. That was about it.

Kevin de Bruyne: 7 - Textbook class on the ball. Set up Mahrez superbly, then fired the rebound over. United doubled up on him.

Raheem Sterling: 6 - Turned Wan-Bissaka inside out and went close early on. Didn’t see a lot of the ball.

Gabriel Jesus: 6 - Skied a good chance over the bar in the first half.

Ferran Torres (66' on for Mahrez): 6 - One good run against Shaw but game up short.

Follow @JPW_NBCSports