The Next XI? Best from MLS’s non-Stars would still be pretty good
Between active and non-active All-Stars (announced today), 32 of the top players in Major League Soccer get excluded from this exercise. Take out the injured players we’re not allowing ourselves to pick (since that was likely the same restriction facing Peter Vermes and Don Garber), and almost all of the league’s big name get excluded from this exercise.
That exercise? Pick the best Next XI. Choose any formation you want, but you have to be able to justify your pick with more than “I think he can pay that spot.” Other than that, everything’s fair game.
Our XI still doesn’t have room for a number of notable performers, though the likes of Sebastien Le Toux, Nigel Reo-Coker, Brandon Barklage, Diego Chara, and Ned Grabavoy probably deserve some words of praise. Still, at times we went for more than pure first half performance in this one. When things were close, we did weigh things like past performance. It’s all all-star selection, after all.
But with a handful of spots, that kind of tie breaker wasn’t enough to keep some new guys our of our “next XI":
[GK - 1] - Dan Kennedy - With Michael Gspurning out, the Chivas USA man steps in. While Kennedy may not have replicated his stellar form from last season’s first half, he has enough gravitas to justify this pick, though nobody will fault you for wanting Jimmy Nielsen in this spot.
[D - 4] - Chris Klute, Jose Goncalves (pictured), Djimi Traore, Sheanon Williams - Goncalves belongs on the real all-star team, so this was a no brainer. If the Portuguese wasn’t garnering so much attention, more people would be talking about Traoré. Williams’s slow improvement has left him overlooked in PPL Park, while Chris Klute, at this very second, is the league’s best left back. He’s the DeAndre Yedlin of this team, albeit at Seth Sinovic’s expense. We’ll see if the former Atlanta Silverback can keep it up.
[M - 3] - Oriol Rosell, Michel, Marcelo Sarvas - While some thought Kansas City would take a step back after losing Roger Espinoza (and letting Julio Cesar go), Rosell has brought a different if still highly effective presence to central midfield. Michel has similarly stabilized Dallas, while Marcelo Sarvas has quietly been the Galaxy’s best midfielder.
[AM - 1] - Federico Higuaín - Five goals, six assists, and a big reason why Dominic Oduro’s about to hit double-digits in goals, Higuaín’s the best playmaker that failed to make the all-star team. How he failed to get in there is a good question, but we’re happy to welcome him in our Next XI.
[F - 2] - Alvaro Saborio, Claudio Bieler - Saborio’s time with Costa Rica makes him an easy omission from the festivities at Sporting Park, but coming off a hat-trick in New York, he’s also an easy selection for our XI. The RSL star’s averaging a goal every 108 minutes this year. Bieler was also a straight forward selection, though it does create some interesting questions with our team ...
How would Saborio and Bieler work together? Higuaín playing behind two forwards? Would that midfield work?
We’re betting good players find a way to get together, but if not, don’t worry. This team isn’t actually going to play a game together.