2017 NCAA Tournament: Major Bias, underseeding Mid-Majors

2017 NCAA Tournament: Major Bias, underseeding Mid-Majors

BY TYLER BYRUM, @theTylerByrum

Every season it happens, a handful of teams in the major conferences (ACC, Big East, Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, Pac-12) get bias toward their NCAA Tournament seed.

As a result it punishes the mid-major teams that everyone loves to root for.

Now, mid-majors should not receive preferential treatment because it would be ‘more fun.' After all, the committee would just ensure all the teams from North Carolina, Florida, and California were all in the same side of the bracket.

(That would actually be pretty fun.)

But the 2016-2017 season proves once again that in order for a mid-major to earn a favor NCAA Tournament seed, they better be able to walk on water.

A near-record number of top seeds from conference tournaments won automatic qualifiers, meaning many of the mid-and low-major teams with the best records earned a spot in the Big Dance. Place that next to the fact that this was a historically weak bubble, and the 2017 NCAA Tournament bracket should have shaped up nicely for "The Other 26."

But instead, the mid-majors got regulated to some poor seeding, and to make matters worse some of the best mid-majors will be taking each other out in the first round. It is not until one takes a look at the overall seeding when disparity becomes glaringly obvious.

It almost feels that because Gonzaga was selected to a No. 1 seed, that the committee had done a service to mid-majors.

This is where the committee should shift teams so mid-majors actually compete against the bigger teams. A majority of the mid-major champions and their at-larges could take out the first-four at-larges (all of which were from a major conference).

If the smaller teams lose, then oh well.


Looking at the overall seeding here is where each mid-major team fell:

No. 1 Gonzaga (No. 4 overall)

-One of the biggest questions of the weekend was if the Zags were going to actually earn one of the four No. 1 seeds. By what should be no surprise, Mark Few’s team earned that bid due to the plethora of upsets in the conference tournaments. Thankfully Kentucky, Duke, and Arizona, who all won a major conference tournament, did not jump the Zags. In which, Gonzaga has the argument to be ahead of each.

No. 6 SMU (No. 21 overall)

-A somewhat appropriate seed. Simply the Mustangs record from last season, (25-5) and not being eligible for the NCAA postseason, had to be a prevailing factor in how high they climbed. Outside of conference play, their biggest win was over TCU. Above the Mustangs they had the Big 12 champion, Iowa State and the ACC runner-up Notre Dame which is a problem in itself, but near impossible to pass. Ahead of two teams though, the Mustangs have an argument to be higher.

No. 6 Cincinnati (No. 22 overall)

-As a preseason favorite to compete nationally, the Bearcats slipped to a No. 6 seed. Once again this is an appropriate seed; their AAC Championship loss to SMU is what dropped them below the Mustangs and even from a No. 5 seed. This is the one mid-major at-large slot that should not be changed.

No.7 St. Mary’s (No. 25 overall)

-Three of the Gaels four losses were to the fourth best team in the tournament. If the Zags fell to a No. 2 seed then this is appropriate, but the committee rewarded the Zags and not the Gaels. Easily Saint Mary’s, led by one of the best in the NCAA Jock Landale, should be above Creighton and at the very least Maryland. Oh they play another dangerous mid-major, VCU.

No. 7 Dayton (No. 28 overall)

-Dayton is another squad that should be above the Blue Jays and the Terps, but also South Carolina. Here is another case where the committee placed a champion ahead of Dayton, which was Michigan, so that they could not climb up. No. 7 seed is not that bad but it is facing Wichita State that is an outrage.

No. 10 Wichita State (No. 38 overall)

-How the heck did the Shockers fall to a No. 10 seed? This is dumb and where some seeding starts to fall apart. Wichita State is ranked 20th nationally and 22nd in the coaches poll, not only that they won their conference in championship week. Talk about names carrying teams, Wichita State’s name did not carry them anywhere this season. On top of that, they face No. 2 Kentucky in the next round if they were to win. The Shockers could easily be a Sweet 16 team if they were not playing the No.5 overall seed.

No. 10 VCU (No. 39 overall)

-Appropriate seed, but why not have them face other No. 7 seeds, South Carolina or Michigan? Would not be an issue if they did not do this multiple times.

No. 11 Rhode Island (No. 44 overall)

-Appropriate seed, although it makes no sense to have Xavier higher than them. Providence and Wake Forest are ahead of the Atlantic 10 Champions but are in a play-in game, something Rhode Island avoided with their auto-bid.

No. 12 Nevada (No. 47 overall)

-Fair seed.


No. 12 Middle Tennessee State (No. 48 overall)

-Did the committee even watch Middle Tennessee this season? No one in their right mind would have them this low, a No. 10 seed at the lowest. The Blue Raiders are way better than many teams ahead of them but got a favorable First Round matchup with Minnesota. Their early season loss to Tennessee State greatly hurt them, but no other early bad losses by major teams hurt their respective teams.

No. 12 UNC-Wilmington (No. 49 overall)

-Fair seed and a fun team to watch.

No. 12 Princeton (No. 50 overall)

-Second longest active winning streak in college basketball (19 games) and they are only a No. 12 seed? It’s fair. Tigers did not do any work outside of conference play this year and 16 of their 19 wins in a row are against Ivy League schools.

No. 13 Bucknell (No. 51 overall)

-Fair seed.

No. 13 East Tennessee St. (No. 52 overall)

-Fair seed.

No. 13 Vermont (No. 53 overall)

-Fair seed, but maybe bump them up a spot or two becuase of their impressive record.

No. 13 Winthrop (No. 54 overall)

-Fair seed.

No. 14 New Mexico State (No. 55 overall)

-Fair seed.

No. 14 Florida Gulf Coast (No. 56 overall)

-Fair seed, but playing in-state opponent Florida State come on now. Do not expect ‘Dunk City’ to pull out another fairy tale run, but the darlings of the NCAA a couple seasons ago should have at least played a non-Florida team in the first round.

The remaining seeds are all from non-major conferences, due to their records and how they won a minor conference they are appropriately place near the bottom of the bracket. While one could argue that their place could be moved around themselves, it is near impossible to say they deserve to pass one of the at-large teams.

Here are the remaining single bid conference teams: No. 14 Kent State, No. 14 Iona, No. 15 Northern Kentucky, No. 15 Troy, No. 15 Jacksonville State, No. 15 North Dakota, No. 16 Texas Southern, No. 16 South Dakota St., No. 16 UC Davis, No. 16 N.C. Central, No. 16 New Orleans, No. 16 Mt. St. Mary's 

Click here to join CSN's 2017 NCAA Tournament Bracket Challenge to have a chance to win Washington Wizards floor seats and other prizes. Presented by Chasen Boscolo.

Wilmer Difo homers but Phillies top Nats


Wilmer Difo homers but Phillies top Nats

WASHINGTON -- Rhys Hoskins hit a two-run homer, Vince Velasquez pitched five effective innings and the Philadelphia Phillies snapped Washington's six-game win streak with a 3-1 victory over the Nationals on Saturday.

Velasquez (2-4) allowed one run and one hit in his first win since April 7. He also struck out four, walked four and hit a batter.

Edubray Ramos, Tommy Hunter, Luis Garcia and Hector Neris then combined for four innings of one-hit relief. Neris earned his sixth save.

Trea Turner led off the Washington ninth with a walk and was running when Matt Wieters popped out to short right field. Turner, who slid into second, lost track of the ball and was easily doubled off first.

Wilmer Difo homered for Washington. Third baseman Anthony Rendon went 0 for 2 with two walks after missing 19 games with what the team called a contusion to his toe.

Nationals right-hander Tanner Roark (2-3) tied his season high with nine strikeouts in 6 1/3 innings. He was charged with three runs and six hits.

Andrew Stevenson accounted for Washington's other hit, a one-out single in the sixth. Pedro Severino followed with a walk, but Ramos induced a double-play grounder from Rafael Bautista.

Cesar Hernandez opened the game with a single off Roark and Hoskins homered to center on a 3-2 pitch. It was his fifth of the season.

Maikel Franco provided an insurance run when he followed Carlos Santana's one-out triple with a single in the sixth.


Phillies: RHP Ben Lively (lower back strain) threw 20 pitches in a bullpen session. Lively was placed on the disabled list April 27. ... Manager Gabe Kapler said RHP Pat Neshek (shoulder strain) will throw a bullpen session as the next step in his rehabilitation. Neshek has not appeared in a game this season.

Nationals: 1B Ryan Zimmerman was scratched from the lineup due to stiffness in his side, according to manager Dave Martinez. ... RHP Trevor Gott, who sprained an ankle in the sixth inning Friday night, is day to day.


The winners of the last three NL Cy Young Awards square off when Philadelphia's Jake Arrieta (3-1, 3.49 ERA) opposes Max Scherzer (6-1, 1.79 ERA). Arrieta won the award in 2015 with the Cubs and Scherzer, the National League Pitcher of the Month for April, has claimed the honor each of the last two seasons.

Future NBA prospect Omer Yurtseven transfers to Georgetown from NC State


Future NBA prospect Omer Yurtseven transfers to Georgetown from NC State

The pieces are starting to come together for Patrick Ewing.

On Monday the Georgetown Hoyas picked up perhaps the biggest (literally and figuratively) target of the transfer market, Omer Yurtseven.

From North Carolina State, the transfer from Istanbul Turkey will have two years remaining of eligibility. Due to NCAA transfer rules, he is not allowed to play for the 2018-19 season.


Standing at 7-0, the center helped power the Wolfpack to an NCAA tournament bid this past season. Averaging 13.5 points, 6.7 rebounds, and 1.8 blocks a contest, Yurstseven earned All-ACC Third Team honors in the 2017-18 season. He also touted a 58.3 shooting percentage and was not afraid to pull it up from deep either (22 made three-pointers).

NC State lost in the first round of the NCAA Tournament to No. 8 Seton Hall, but he was limited due to foul trouble with only two points and two rebounds in 14 minutes of play.

Initially, he is the option to fill the void that Jessie Govan will leave, whether that is during this offseason or next. Already the team has lost power forward Marcus Derrickson

Yurtseven will just be another frontcourt talent for Ewing with the Hoyas.

It was widely reported that he was considering playing options, both in the United States and abroad before this announcement. Easily he has the talent to go in first round of the NBA Draft whichever year he declares.

On the same day, the Hoyas also announced the signing of four-star guard James Akinjo.