Monday’s game between the Caps and Dallas Stars was not without controversy. Less than two minutes into the game, Devin Shore appeared to block Braden Holtby’s path in the crease allowing for a wraparound attempt that Shore was eventually able to knock into the net to give Dallas the early lead.

Barry Trotz immediately challenged for goalie interference, but the goal stood because Brooks Orpik pushed Shore into the crease. You can read more on the challenge here.

“I knew it was going to be close,” Trotz said. “Originally we see Brooks pushes or crosschecks their guy a little bit into the crease. [Shore] doesn't really try to get out of there. He was just sort of standing there and he wasn't trying to get out.”

RELATED: Seeing Holtby pulled was 'biggest disappointment' of Monday's loss

While Orpik certainly did push Shore into the crease, Shore also makes no effort to leave which prompted Trotz to challenge the goal. After losing the challenge, Trotz said the referee explained to him that the deciding factor was not the initial push, but what happened afterward.

“[Orpik] gives him another little shot because he's on top of our goalie. If he doesn't do that I think it probably comes back our way,” Trotz said. “Even the referee says that's close, the only reason I say no is Brooks gave him a sort of a little second one.”


Washington ultimately lost on Monday because of their poor start to the game. The Caps dug themselves a 3-0 deficit before the team began to turn things around in the second period. If the first goal had been taken off the board, perhaps it could have given the Caps the wakeup call they needed in the early going.

Despite knowing the call would be close, Trotz knew it was a gamble worth taking.

“[Shore’s] effort level to get out of the crease wasn't great,” Trotz said. “I knew it was going to be close, we knew that was going to be a little bit, but I would do it again.”