Redskins

Quick Links

Is McCoy the answer at backup QB for the Redskins?

colt-mccoy-warmup.png

Is McCoy the answer at backup QB for the Redskins?

In less than a year, the Redskins completed a stunning turnaround, ascending from a laughingstock in 2014 to a division champion in 2015. But now comes the difficult part: taking that all-important next step and improving from a franchise that was fortunate to get into the playoffs to one that can do some damage once it gets there. And that work begins right now for Jay Gruden, Scot McCloughan and the players.

In the coming weeks, Redskins reporters Tarik El-Bashir and Rich Tandler will examine the 25 biggest questions facing the Redskins as another offseason gets rolling.

No. 1

Who should be the backup quarterback in 2016?

El-Bashir: Before I get to my answer, I'd like to point out how refreshing it is to be discussing the backup quarterback and not the starter in January. It's impossible to understate the importance of entering an offseason with the two most important pieces—head coach and starting quarterback—in place and secure in their roles. Because of that, the Redskins are already miles ahead of where they were at this point last year.

Anyway, back to the question at hand. I believe Colt McCoy is the perfect backup for the Redskins and, if the player and the team are smart about it, they’ll come to an agreement on an extension. From all appearances, he’s got a good relationship with Jay Gruden and Kirk Cousins. He's also got a strong grasp of the system after spending the past two seasons in Washington and, just as important, he didn’t create any waves after the disappointment of getting beat out by Cousins for a starting job he didn’t know was even up for grabs last preseason.     

In 2014, McCoy proved he be effective in a pinch. He came off the bench to lead Washington to a win over Tennessee and, a week later, directed a 2-5 Redskins’ team to an enormous upset in Big D on Monday Night Football. In 2015, though, he played a much smaller role. In fact, McCoy appeared in only two games and played only 46 snaps.

Which brings me to my next point: McCoy is the Redskins’ best option, but it takes both sides to strike a deal. With Cousins having locked up the starting job and likely to sign a mega-deal in the coming months, the Redskins’ other quarterback (s) in 2016 probably won’t play much, except for in mop-up situations or in the unlikely event that a sturdy and reliable Cousins gets hurt.

Is McCoy ready to embrace that role? I don’t know. That’s up to McCoy. If he still believes that, at 29, he can be more than a backup for someone, I’d imagine he’ll want one last kick at the can. And there’s no shortage of teams with question marks at quarterback. To me, though, the smart move for both McCoy and the Redskins is to get a deal done…even if it means paying a bit above average money for a backup.

Tandler: The best solution for a backup quarterback for the 2016 Redskins may well be to re-sign Colt McCoy. He will be 30 before the season starts, he knows the offense and he is already a well-respected presence in the locker room. But they many not be able to do that.

McCoy is slated to be a free agent on March 9. He might figure that he has one last chance to be a starting quarterback in NFL and he knows it won’t be in Washington, where Kirk Cousins will be the man and he has proven to be very durable. So if he goes off seeking greener pastures in Cleveland or Houston or perhaps even Dallas to back up the fragile Tony Romo, the Redskins will be looking for a new backup quarterback and with the inevitable departure of Robert Griffin III they may be looking for two.

The free agent market for potential backups is the usual collection of has beens and never-weres. Just to throw out a name of someone in the former category, Matt Schaub of the Ravens could be a good fit. He’s certainly not an ideal option if you need someone for more than a couple of games, but neither is McCoy.

If the organization wants a younger quarterback instead of or in addition to a veteran, they could grab one later on in the draft. One player I’ll have my eye on is Kevin Hogan, who is a 6-4 redshirt senior out of Stanford. He’s a local product, from McLean and a graduate of Gonzaga. Stanford, of course, runs a pro style offense and he shouldn’t have much trouble picking up the Redskins’ system. Hogan should be available in the latter rounds of the draft.

To answer the question, I think the Redskins will stick with three quarterbacks with either McCoy or someone like Schaub as the backup and a Saturday draft pick as a developmental QB.

25 Questions series

  • Today: Is McCoy the answer at backup QB for the Redskins?
  • Tomorrow: Should the Redskins try to keep Alfred Morris?

Quick Links

Redskins 2018 position outlook: Defensive line

redkins_d-line_vs_sd_usat.png
USA Today Sports Images

Redskins 2018 position outlook: Defensive line

Redskins 2018 position outlook: Defensive line

Training camp opens next week, and we have a break here, giving us time to put the depth chart under the microscope. Over the coming week, we will look at every position, compare the group to the rest of the NFL, see if the position has been upgraded or downgraded from last year, and take out the crystal ball to see what might unfold.

Defensive line

Additions: Daron Payne (drafted in first round), Tim Settle (drafted in fifth round)
Departures: Terrell McClain (released)

Starters: Payne (NT), Jonathan Allen, Matt Ioannidis
Other roster locks: Stacy McGee, Anthony Lanier, Settle
On the bubble: Ziggy Hood, Phil Taylor

How the defensive line compares

To the rest of the NFL: We are going to have to see about this. Over the last couple of years the D-line has been transformed from an aging group into one where youth is in good supply. Ioannidis is the oldest of the starters at age 24. Allen is 23 and Payne just turned 21 in May. It looks like there is great potential there but we haven’t seen enough of it on the field to make solid comparisons to other lines around the league. Allen missed 10 games of his rookie year with an injury and Ioannidis missed two and was hampered in a few more with a broken hand. Payne, of course, is a rookie. Let’s check back in late October and see how things are going then. 

To the 2017 Redskins:  The primary reason that the line should be significantly better this year is the presence of Payne and Settle on the roster. That means that it is very unlikely that Hood will have to play nose tackle. He has been the starter there for the past two years, forced there by injuries. Jim Tomsula that Hood is not well suited to play the nose. So they have an improvement there. If they get a mostly healthy season out of Allen and if Ioannidis continue to improve this will be the best defensive line they have had since moving to the 3-4 defensive in 2010. 

2018 outlook

Biggest upside: As noted, Payne just turned 21. He seems to have a rare understanding of the game for a rookie. You often see rookies just trying to survive on physical ability early one. Payne has plenty of that, but he also seems to realize that strength and ability alone won’t let him thrive at this level. He pays close attention to his technique during drills, making sure he does things the right way the first time. If he builds on this for the next year or so the Redskins could have a legitimate star. 

Most to prove: Since so many Redskins fans are accustomed to seeing veteran defensive linemen the team signs as free agents play poorly, they automatically put McGee in the “bust” category. But many of his teammates said he was the most consistent player on the line last year. It’s safe to say that he played better than the popular perception. Next year, he will carry a $4.8 million salary cap number and like most players who are not starters but making good salaries, he will need to play well enough to justify that cap number.  

Rookie watch: The Redskins did not expect Settle to be available in the fifth round and he was too good to pass up when he was still on the board. He should get some opportunity as a rookie. He is likely to be the only other nose tackle on the roster besides Payne (sorry, but the numbers make it unlikely that Phil Taylor will make the roster). That could have him active on many game days and that usually means getting some snaps in the rotation. We will see what he can do with his chances. 

Bottom line: The Redskins were last in the league in rushing defense in 2017. It wasn’t all on the line—in particular, injuries to the inside linebackers hurt a lot—but the simple fact is that the organization long neglected the line. The philosophy was to create a patchwork unit from aging free agents. That has changed now with three homegrown players set to start and Settle and 2016 undrafted free agent find Anthony Lanier providing reserve help. It’s going to be a better unit, no question. But improvement over the last several years is a low bar and we’ll find out if this develops into a quality line over the next few months. 

Quote-unquote

Greg Manusky on Payne:

Payne is doing a great job. He’s trying to get acclimated to some of the calls, hasn’t had a lot of mental errors. He’s done a great job. Physical player.

2018 position outlook series

Stay up to date on the Redskins. Rich Tandler covers the team 365 days a year. Like his Facebook page, Facebook.com/TandlerNBCSand follow him on Twitter  @TandlerNBCSand on Instagram @RichTandler

 

Quick Links

10 Questions in 10 days: Major questions at linebacker on Redskins depth chart

foster_hamilton_spaight.jpg
USA TODAY Sports

10 Questions in 10 days: Major questions at linebacker on Redskins depth chart

With Redskins Training Camp set to begin July 26th, JP Finlay takes a look at 10 of the most pressing questions for the Burgundy and Gold. 

No. 10: Major questions at linebacker on Redskins depth chart

The Redskins top two linebackers rank among the most productive units in the NFL. When healthy, Mason Foster and Zach Brown are highly efficient tacklers. In fact, Brown led the league in tackles for most of 2017 before his season ended with a foot injury. 

The healthy part is the trick. 

Last year, Foster separated his shoulder against the Rams in Week 2 and was shut down for the season by October. Brown played through nagging injuries all year before shutting things down in December. 

When both players were on the field, the Redskins defense excelled. In just four starts, Foster made 30 tackles to go with an interception, a fumble recovery and half a sack. Brown logged double-digit tackles in nine games last season, and probably would have more without the foot trouble. 

Foster and Brown are very good in the Redskins scheme, and both players are expected to be fully healthy for the start of training camp. Their injuries from last season are not the type that suggest durability concerns, and both players posted full 16-game seasons in 2016.

Foster and Brown aren't the question. The depth chart after Foster and Brown are the question. 

Zach Vigil, Martrell Spaight, Josh Harvey-Clemons and rookie Shaun Dion Hamilton are competing for two or possibly three roster spots. 

Spaight is the most recognizable name in the group. He's been a good special teams player for Washington, and is well liked in the locker room. By last December, however, Vigil was playing better football. 

More telling for both Vigil and Spaight was that Harvey-Clemons took the starter reps alongside Foster when Brown was absent during OTAs. The second-year man out of Louisville has more physical gifts than either Vigil or Spaight, and now given a full year to learn to play linebacker, Harvey-Clemons could make inroads.

A safety in college, Harvey-Clemons can run. He was a bit of a surprise last season making the 53-man roster out of camp, so expect him to definitely have a shot this year. 

Hamilton will be the wild card. An ultra-talented player out of Alabama, he dealt with a number of injuries in college. Redskins VP Doug Williams talked gushingly about Hamilton after the draft, and if the former 5-Star recruit can stay healthy, he could certainly push for a spot as well. 

Prior to 2017, the Redskins kept four inside linebackers on their final 53 roster. In 2017, the team kept five: Brown, Foster, Spaight, Will Compton and Harvey-Clemons. Compton left via free agency and is now playing in Nashville. 

Foster and Brown are roster locks, and it seems like Harvey-Clemons gets the third nod. 

Spaight, Vigil and Hamilton better be ready for serious competition in Richmond. 

MORE REDSKINS NEWS:

#REDSKINSTALK PODCAST

Don't forget to subscribe to the #RedskinsTalk podcast, hosted by JP Finlay.

Click here for the #RedskinsTalk on Apple Podcastshere for Google Play or press play below.