Roll the dice, flip a coin, pick a card. Your guess is as good as mine when it comes to what the Giants might do with the No. 13 pick in the 2020 MLB Draft.
This isn't like when the Giants zeroed in on Joey Bart with the No. 2 pick in 2018. It's not even like when they took Hunter Bishop last year at No. 10 overall. Simply put, this year's draft is unlike any other.
In a money-saving move as the MLB season is yet to start this year, the draft was reduced from 40 rounds to only five. College seasons were cut short due to the coronavirus, and some high school players in certain areas didn't play a single game. Many scenarios can play out in a normal year by the time the Giants are on the clock for their first of seven picks, but the long list of odd circumstances this time around makes the draft even more of a crapshoot.
The Giants could buck recent history and take the top pitcher on the board. They have been connected to Oklahoma right-hander Cade Cavalli, a former two-way player, more frequently the closer we get to Wednesday's draft. Tennessee left-hander Garrett Crochet and high school flamethrowers Mick Abel and Nick Bitsko also have been seen as options for San Francisco.
While the MLB draft isn't one for need, the Giants do have a hitter-heavy farm system. Aside from Seth Corry and Sean Hjelle, the Giants don't have too much upside among their top pitching prospects. President of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi also took four right-handed pitchers in the first round when he was the Los Angeles Dodgers' general manager from 2015 to 2018.
If the Giants do select a hitter in Round 1 for the fifth straight time -- they didn't have a first-round pick in 2016 -- they could accomplish two things: Draft a catcher for the second time in three years, and draft a member of the Soderstrom family for the second time in 27 years.
On June 3, 1993, the Giants selected pitcher Steve Soderstrom with the No. 6 pick in the MLB draft. On Wednesday, Steve's son, Tyler, a catcher out of Turlock High School, could be taken by the Giants seven picks later.
[GIANTS INSIDER PODCAST: Listen to the latest episode]
But why would the Giants take a catcher in the first round just two years after grabbing Bart with the second pick in the draft? Let's start with the bat.
The younger Soderstrom stands 6-foot-2 and weighs 190 pounds, though he recently has been listed as even bigger by some outlets. He was named California's Gatorade Player of the Year, and hit .357 with one home run through five games before his senior season was shut down. As a junior, Soderstrom hit .450 with four homers and a 1.340 OPS.
Throughout last summer, Soderstrom was one of the highest rising prospects in the country. At every showcase he went to against top talent, he created buzz for scouts and hit .364 with 10 RBI over nine games for Team USA on the 2019 18U National Team. While he hit seven home runs over 82 high school games, Soderstrom's power potential calls for plenty more long balls down the road.
Check out this video (volume up) of a recent hitting session for @tylersode. Has a added a great deal of strength to his frame now measuring 6’3” 204 pounds. Consistent exit velo’s of 98-103 MPH. #MLBDraft #ShapeTheState #BeSeen @PBR_California pic.twitter.com/xa9DCNy5kT— 𝐋𝐞𝐬 𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐚𝐜𝐡 (@LesLukach) June 3, 2020
Soderstrom already has a polished swing at 18 years old and a clear plan at the plate. This at-bat with Team USA shows his advanced approach at such a young age.
Writing about Tyler Soderstrom and this at-bat is really impressive. Look how he’s able to extend and still hit a laser to the wall on a low and away pitch pic.twitter.com/8DgXwOPTmq— Dalton Johnson (@DaltonJ_Johnson) June 9, 2020
His bat is what will get him drafted so high, and his defense certainly comes with question marks. The latter brings us to the Bart conundrum, something fans already feel with Buster Posey entrenched behind the dish and Bart on his way. But Soderstrom brings exactly what Zaidi is looking for more often on his roster: Defensive versatility.
Many evaluators believe Soderstrom will move to third base, a position he split time at in high school. He also has the athleticism to play a corner outfield position, and certainly should be able to man first base. Timing is everything, and it's no mistake that Soderstrom posted a montage on May 31 of himself fielding ground balls.
Zaidi said last August that he wants Bart, who hasn't played anywhere else outside of catcher in the minor leagues and at Georgia Tech, to learn another position. That sure sounds a lot like Soderstrom.
“It’s always a good idea for a player to have somewhere else they can play to give the manager more options to put them when they’re not catching," Zaidi said to The Athletic's Andrew Baggarly last August.
When Zaidi was the Dodgers' GM, Los Angeles took catcher Will Smith No. 32 overall out of the University of Louisville in 2016. And like Soderstrom, Smith is a lot more than a catcher on the field. He made his MLB debut last season and caught every game he played in. But he also played 58 games at third base in the minors, and 11 more at second base.
Baseball is becoming more and more positionless every year, and it seem inevitable the DH is coming to the NL. The goal is to get as many great bats in the lineup at once. It also is an added bonus to have multiple players who can get in the squat and be a threat at the plate at the same time. Zaidi is at the forefront of new-age thinking in baseball, and Soderstrom seems to fit what he's looking for.
The Giants also want to protect their backyard as Zaidi and the front office proved by taking Bishop, a former Serra High School (San Mateo) star, one year ago. Going with Soderstrom, who played his high school ball fewer than two hours from Oracle Park, would again keep Northern California's best talent in the Bay Area. From his bat to his defensive versatility, proximity and family history, making Tyler Soderstrom a Giant makes a lot of sense.
Soon, Soderstrom bloodlines once again can turn orange and black through the draft.