Roy Halladay prefaced all of this by saying that he loves Charlie Manuel and that he was great, but he told Jim Salisbury of CSNPhilly.com that it was time for a change:
Salisbury asked him about the things that “were being overlooked” and Halladay referred to punctuality, extra BP and practice and little things like that.
I guess everyone has their own way of looking at this stuff, but ultimately it comes down to wins and losses. When there is a stickler in place and the team starts losing people are quoted as saying that a more player-friendly, softer touch may be in order to relax people. When that guy is in place and the team loses there is inevitably a call for a firmer hand.