Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
NBCSports Header Logo

Which 11 players make the cut for PST’s MLS Team of the Year?

Jose Goncalves, Cole Grossmany

New England Revolution defender Jose Goncalves (23) tries to shield the ball from Real Salt Lake midfielder Cole Grossmany during the second half of an MLS soccer match, Friday, July 4, 2014, in Sandy, Utah. Real Salt Lake won 2-1. (AP Photo/Kim Raff)

AP

Perhaps there hasn’t been an easier time putting together a buzz-worthy XI in MLS history. While defenders rarely get their due, this season brought some names to the forefront in ways that garnered MVP talk, like Chad Marshall in Seattle. And the World Cup and qualifying provided some other defenders a cannon from which to launch their stars into the sky.

Yet it’s still pretty tricky to cull 11 players from the hundreds who dot rosters around Major League Soccer. So we’ve brought in two XIs for you (and I may sneak in a third). Myself and Joe Prince-Wright will now put our Teams of the Year out for your perusal, hatred and laurels.

[ MLS: Playoff predictions/preview | Season-ending awards ]

Joe Prince-Wright is up first, being the lead writer/editor and all, and starts with USMNT backstop Nick Rimando of Real Salt Lake as his netminder. Marshall makes his cut as one of four Seattle Sounders stars. Matt Besler slides in at back after his tremendous World Cup.

Bradley Wright-Phillips, Thierry Henry, Bobby Convey

New York Red Bulls players Bradley Wright-Phillips, left, Thierry Henry, bottom, and Bobby Convey celebrate a goal by Wright-Phillips against the Columbus Crew during the first half of an MLS soccer match, Saturday, July 12, 2014, in Harrison, N.J. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)

AP

JPW’s MLS best XI (3-4-3)

Nick Rimando (RSL)

Jose Goncalves (NE) – Chad Marshall (SEA) – Matt Besler (SKC)

Lee Nguyen (NE) – Clint Dempsey (SEA) – Osvaldo Alonso (SEA) – Diego Valeri (POR)

Robbie Keane (LA) – Bradley Wright-Phillips (NYRB) – Obafemi Martins (SEA)

As for me, you’ll see a lot of the same faces, but seeing as I’m the guy compiling the post, I’ll submit a second XI as well. Take that, JPW.

For me, to watch the ‘Caps is to watch the best goalkeeper in the league, as David Ousted has been simply phenomenal. Just his play in the final 20 minutes against Colorado was a reason for cheers, high-fives, fist-bumps and other modes of congratulatory sentiment. Landon Donovan gets a nod from me for his record-setting season in L.A., while Matt Hedges may’ve quietly been the best defender in the league.

Landon Donovan

Los Angeles Galaxy midfielder Landon Donovan, left, battles for the ball with Seattle Sounders defender Chad Marshall, right, during the first half of an MLS soccer match, Saturday, Oct. 25, 2014, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

AP

Nick Mendola’s MLS best XI (3-4-3)

David Ousted (VAN)

Matt Hedges (DAL) -- Chad Marshall (SEA) -- Jose Goncalves (NE)

Diego Valeri (POR) -- Lee Nguyen (NE) -- Landon Donovan (LA) -- Clint Dempsey (SEA)

Robbie Keane (LA) -- Obafemi Martins (SEA) -- Bradley Wright-Phillips (NYRB)

As for a second XI, it pains me as a Buffalonian to slot a player in over New England’s shot-stopper Bobby Shuttleworth, but what Steve Clark did in Columbus this year was fantastic. His two PK stops put him just past Bill Hamid in my book. I had a very difficult time not slotting in Kendall Waston, who only played 10 games for Vancouver but was simply wonderful. Twenty-two games, however, was enough to get Omar Gonzalez a look in my second side.

MLS: Sporting KC v D.C. United

Sporting KC forward Dom Dwyer (14) battles to control the ball against D.C. United defender Bobby Boswell (32) in the first half at RFK Stadium in Washington, Saturday, May 31, 2014. United defeated Sporting KC, 1-0. (Chuck Myers/MCT via Getty Images)

MCT via Getty Images

Nick Mendola’s MLS second XI (3-4-3)

Steve Clark (CBS)

Bobby Boswell (DC) -- Chris Schuler (RSL) -- Omar Gonzalez (LA)

Tony Tchani (CBS) -- Javier Morales (RSL) -- Osvaldo Alonso (SEA) -- Pedro Morales (VAN)

Thierry Henry (NYRB) -- Dom Dwyer (SKC) -- Erick Torres (CHV)

What do you think? Harsh to leave out Gyasi Zardes, Chris Wondolowski, Seb Le Toux, Federico Higuain and Ethan Finlay? My goodness, I could’ve put together more XIs and still felt like I was uppercutting the league!

Follow @nicholasmendola