Watch Now

Should Giants turn to McCarthy as starter?

October 18, 2026 08:05 PM

Mike Tomlin, Jason Garrett, Devin McCourty and Maria Taylor discuss the Giants' quarterback situation and explain why New York might make J.J. McCarthy the team's starter going forward.

Related Videos

Kirk could be fantasy option while Evans is out

Diggs, Burks may see uptick in fantasy production

Purdy thriving in ‘quarterback-friendly’ offense

Burden on playing for Johnson, alongside Williams

Bernard, Cooper Jr. headline top rookies of Week 6

Take a shot on the Bengals over the Ravens

49ers vs. Falcons will be a ‘staring match’

Why is Quinn now wearing his hat forward?

Mustapha, Warner must be wary of suspensions

Rams should’ve been prepared for Adams’ injury

Simms: Gardner-Johnson’s NFL career is on thin ice

Inside Purdy’s success with Shanahan and the 49ers

What will Harbaugh do with McCarthy and Winston?

Will Harris move on from Quinn after mistakes?

What Jacobs’ return could mean for the Packers

Inside reports of Hurts being awake for 36 hours

What to make of Sirianni’s comments on Hurts

Unpacking details surrounding Hurts’ blood clots

Quinn, Commanders have ‘a lot of issues’

What’s next for Colts after firing Ballard?

Did Quinn know it was 4th down vs. 49ers?

Will 49ers make a big move with York back?

Shanahan’s masterful coaching has 49ers rolling

Headlines: ‘Browns Beat the Browns (of old)’

Ballard’s Colts lacked ‘difference-making’ vision

Simms: Eagles’ handling of Hurts ‘concerning’

Questions surround Hurts’ blood clot situation

Is point total too low for Steelers vs. Saints?

Expect high-scoring Patriots vs. Bears TNF matchup

Ripple effects of Dalton signing with Falcons

Latest Clips

New-look 76ers show that ‘sharing is caring’

LeBron ‘still getting rhythm’ as 76ers beat Knicks

Highlights: 76ers spoil Knicks ring night at MSG

Brunson to MSG: ‘Thank you for not leaving Game 4'

Knicks raise 2025-26 championship banner at MSG

Team USA recaps men’s team final at Worlds

Richard feeling ‘comfortable’ ahead of all-around

Tracy Morgan on banner raising: ‘I’m gonna cry’

2026-05-31T025844Z_476990769_MT1USATODAY29100890_RTRMADP_3_NBA-PLAYOFFS-SAN-ANTONIO-SPURS-AT-OKLAHOMA-CITY-THUNDER_copy.jpg

SGA: OKC, Spurs are in first round of boxing match

First impressions of Pistons, Celtics with George

Highlights: George smashes Celtics’ debut record

HLs: Pistons close out Celtics in fourth quarter

How can Philly complete ‘The Process’ with LeBron?

Pistons’ second-half spark buries Celtics at home

Cunningham: Pistons ‘lit a fire’ in second half

Melo: ‘Hard to describe’ emotions flowing in NYC

U.S. men’s team off podium at gymnastics worlds

Japan reigns supreme for men’s team title

What Rams WR will make up for the loss of Adams?

Doubs injury opens door for other players

No Vacancy: A banner raising 53 years in the works

Perloff: Miami hasn’t earned the No. 1 ranking

Perloff: Knicks aren’t poised to repeat as champs

Not So Fast makes NBA MVP and Finals predictions

Texans should give C.J. Stroud ‘whatever he wants’

Sirianni ‘out of his lane’ with Hurts’ injury

Was Hurts’ injury announcement handled properly?

Quinn’s questionable play-calling continues

Brentford ‘as good as Liverpool’ before red card

Pabst: Underdog champions are good for sports