Hunter

Goodman

On the surface, it appears to be nothing more than a routine day off for Goodman, but with trade rumors swirling around, perhaps they’re just taking an extra precaution in case someone is willing to match the “extremely high” price tag that has been placed on the prized slugger. Brett Sullivan will do the catching for the Rockies and bat eighth against Royals’ right-hander Seth Lugo.

It was starting to look like maybe the trade rumors were bothering Goodman, as he’d gone 0-for-12 with nine strikeouts in his previous three games. He’s now tied for second in the majors with 33 homers. He has two more than last year, when he set a record for Rockies catchers. Barring a trade or an injury, he’ll almost certainly become the first Rockies hitter to reach 40 homers since Nolan Arenado in 2019 and maybe the first to reach 45 since Todd Helton hit 49 in 2001 to tie the franchise record established by Larry Walker in 1997.

Feinsand’s update coincides with a report from The Athletic’s Ken Rosental earlier this week that the Rockies have been asking for a top prospect as part of any multi-player package. The 26-year-old slugging backstop is the rare hitter that is statistically better away from Coors Field’s high-octane offensive environment and should command a massive prospect haul, especially since he won’t reach free agency for three more years. Goodman would be one of the biggest names moved at the trade deadline and it seems like Colorado’s new-look front office, which features Paul DePodesta at the helm, will have to be blown away to consider jettisoning their lineup anchor.

It makes sense since Goodman is under team control for three more seasons and is hitting .254/.326/.545 this season in 100 games with 31 home runs, 60 RBI, and five steals. We know the Rockies have asked the Rays for Theo Gillen and have asked the Red Sox for Franklin Arias, both of whom are top ten prospects in baseball, according to MLB Pipeline. As Rosenthal mentions, “it’s the usual dance,” as the Rockies expect teams to meet their offer, and the other teams expect the Rockies to lower their asking price. It remains more likely that Goodman stays in Colorado.

Goodman doubled and scored a run in the fifth inning. He then came through in a clutch spot for the Rockies in the eighth. With the game tied and two outs in the bottom of the inning, he took Clayton Beeter deep for a solo homer to put Colorado ahead and in line for the win. The 26-year-old backstop is having an outstanding season, hitting .257/.326/.565 with 31 homers, 64 runs scored, 57 RBI, and five steals across 393 plate appearances.

Goodman is third in the majors with 30 home runs and is under contract for three more seasons and is making just $810,000 this season in the final year before arbitration. As Rosenthal notes, the Rockies are under new leadership and “will have several additional opportunities to trade” Goodman this offseason and beyond. While it’s possible that Goodman is traded in a couple of weeks, the Rockies would need to receive a haul of players under team control for multiple years who they believe will be part of their core.

Goodman has been the subject of trade rumors as of late, and this certainly didn’t hurt his stock if he truly is available. The three roundtrippers bring him up to 30 on the season, and he was able to plate five, improving his RBI total to 56. Goodman was a breakout star last year, but he’s been even better in 2026 with those aforementioned totals and an .886 OPS to go with them. He’s probably staying in Colorado — why on Earth they would trade him is anyone’s guess — but Goodman has the type of power that will play in whatever park he lands in.

The Yankees, looking for more offensive consistency at catcher, have also been linked to Twins C Ryan Jeffers. Goodman, who still has three years of team control remaining, would likely cost a pretty penny. It’s possible that Austin Wells could have a hot July and get the Yankees off this idea, but if not they could do much worse than Goodman, who already has 27 homers this year and has been an All-Star in both 2025 and 2026.

Goodman missed each of the team’s previous two games after jamming his hand on a play at the plate on Monday against the Dodgers. He’ll function as the Rockies’ designated hitter and bat cleanup against Carson Whisenhunt on Thursday night in San Francisco.

Goodman sits out his second straight contest after jamming his hand on a play at home plate during Monday’s series opener in Los Angeles. The 26-year-old slugging backstop underwent precautionary X-rays that came back negative for any fractures, which is an extremely encouraging development. He’s officially day-to-day with a left hand contusion.