Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
View All Scores

An PK controversy that wasn’t. Controversial, that is

San Jose Earthquakes v Chivas USA

CARSON, CA - SEPTEMBER 15: Juan Agudelo #11 of Chivas USA and his teammates look on prior to a penalty kick being awarded to the San Jose Earthquakes during the MLS match at The Home Depot Center on September 15, 2012 in Carson, California. The Earthquakes defeated Chivas USA 2-0. (Photo by Victor Decolongon/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Chivas USA is a big, fat, slow-moving target right now. Still, at the risk of appearing to pile on, this needs to be said:

Players and officials around Chivas USA are wrong to criticize officials’ decision on a controversial penalty kick in Saturday’s loss to Supporters Shield front-runners San Jose.

In the first half of a scoreless game, Chivas USA center back John Valencia decided it was a good idea to waylay San Jose striker Alan Gordon off the ball.

As Goats goalkeeper Dan Kennedy said later, Gordon and fellow Earthquakes forward Steven Lenhart are quite physical, always looking to mix it up and even dish out a little of “the business” off the ball. Kennedy is 100 percent correct about that.

But it doesn’t matter. Valencia simply must keep his cool here. Gordon and (even more) Lenhart are wily provocateurs and everyone knows it. This can come as no surprise, so “keep your cool” must be a point of emphasis coming into any contest with San Jose.

(MORE: Comprehensive highlights from the match)

What particularly peeved Chivas USA players and management was in the call apparently being made by the fourth official.

Again, that doesn’t matter. That does not absolve Valencia of reacting emotionally and putting his team and a result in jeopardy. What Chivas USA assistant Greg Vanney said about it:

The frustration there is, having seen the replay, is one of our players puts us in a tough situation. The frustration there is also that none of the officials actually involved in the game actually saw it. It was the fourth official who called it all the way from midfield. I’m not really sure how that plays out and whose responsibility is what, but I know the two linesman or the center actually didn’t see the play.”

Below is the sequence in question; you can see for yourself.

Just in case you don’t know, Chris Wondolowski converted the spot shot, Gordon later added to the lead and the Earthquakes further solidified their death grip on top spot in the Western Conference.

Again, I know the frustration factor is high at Chivas, dealing as best as possible with an organization in turmoil and a club that is essentially being run by the league at the moment. Still, denying individual culpability when things go wrong is no way to get things points in the right direction.

.