Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
Odds by

IDP Mock Draft

We’ve hit the month of August, and the NFL preseason is underway (albeit late thanks to the scourge that is improperly congealing field paint). And that can mean only one thing for fantasy football fanatics -- draft season is in high swing. Soon preparation and practice will give way (hopefully) to the completion of a successful draft.

For many fantasy owners, the use of mock drafts is an invaluable tool when getting ready to select their teams. However, that can be easier said than done for those who play in IDP leagues. Mock drafts that include individual defensive players aren’t easy to come by.
However, just because you can’t participate in one doesn’t mean you can’t do the next best thing, examine ones that have occurred in an effort to spot draft-day trends and potential value plays.

That’s what we’re going to do here, with a look at a recent IDP mock I conducted. It’s a fairly straightforward PPR league, starting one QB, two RB, three WR, one TE and one flex. Six points for all touchdowns. Standard 10/25 split between rushing/receiving yards and passing yards.

The starting defensive lineup consists of two DL, two LB, two DB and one “flex”. Defensive scoring is 1.5 points per tackle and 4 points per big play (a fairly common roster setup and tackle-heavy scoring system). It’s also worth pointing out that it was a short bench (24 roster spots), so with the exception of a spare DL and an extra LB the reserve slots were spent on offensive sleepers and depth.

In IDP leagues with a short bench, the smart play on defense is to let the waiver wire serve as your de facto reserves, especially where defensive backs are concerned.

The kicker position was omitted here, but with those the rule is simple -- last round. No exceptions. Ever.

Now that we’ve got the scoring and lineup requirements ironed out, let’s take a team-by-team look at how things developed, especially on the defensive side of the ball.

This is an IDP article after all. You don’t need me to tell you Antonio Brown is good.

Team 1: What Can Brown Do for You?

Pick Pick
1.01Antonio Brown - WR, PIT13.01Jordan Howard - RB, CHI
2.12Alshon Jeffery - WR, CHI14.12Mohamed Sanu - WR, ATL
3.01Doug Martin - RB, TB15.01Antonio Gates - TE, SD
4.12Matt Forte - RB, NYJ16.12Mark Barron - LB, LAR
5.01Russell Wilson - QB, SEA17.01Thomas Davis - LB, CAR
6.12Allen Hurns - WR, JAX18.12Ryan Tannehill - QB, MIA
7.01Navorro Bowman - LB, SG19.01Mario Williams - DE, MIA
8.12Melvin Gordon - RB, SD20.12Bashaud Breeland - CB, WAS
9.01Willie Snead - WR, NO21.01Anquan Boldin - WR, DET
10.12Everson Griffen - DE, MIN22.12Kony Ealy - DE, CAR
11.01Gary Barnidge - TE, CLE23.01K.J. Wright - LB, SEA
12.12Kenneth Dixon - RB, BAL24.12Calvin Pryor - DB, NYJ

Speaking of Antonio Brown, the consensus No. 1 pick in fantasy football was the first pick here. This team got excellent value with their selection of San Francisco 49ers’ linebacker Navorro Bowman. Bowman is my top-ranked player at his position in 2016, yet he came off the board almost three full rounds after Luke Kuechly was selected. Everson Griffen was a fine pick to anchor the defensive line, and K.J. Wright was a sneaky value late. I also like the idea of back-to-back LB picks in Round 16 and 17, although it may have worked out even better a bit earlier in the draft.

IDP Pro Tip: This team played it smart it the secondary, eschewing the position altogether until the end of Round 20. The elite options are tempting, but there are always a fistful of surprise stars at that position every season. Wait.

Team 2: Mr. Jones and Me

Pick Pick
1.02Julio Jones - WR, ATL13.02Deone Bucannon - LB, AZ
2.11Jamaal Charles - RB, KC14.11Tyler Boyd - WR, CIN
3.02T.Y. Hilton - WR, IND15.02Jason Pierre-Paul - DE, NYG
4.11Julian Edelman - WR, NE16.12Victor Cruz - WR, NYG
5.02Duke Johnson - RB, CLE17.02Charcandrick West - RB, KC
6.11Ben Roethlisberger - QB, PIT18.11Morgan Burnett - S, GB
7.02Khalil Mack - LB, OAK19.02Stephone Anthony - LB, NO
8.11Frank Gore - RB, IND20.11Jared Cook - TE, GB
9.02DeSean Jackson - WR, WAS21.02Alex Smith - QB, KC
10.11Ladarius Green - TE, PIT22.11Will Compton - LB, WAS
11.02Theo Riddick - RB, DET23.02Antoine Bethea - S, SF
12.11Fletcher Cox - DT, PHI24.11Corey Liuget - DE, SD

Team 2 looked a bit better before Julian Edelman pulled up lame in training camp, but there’s still a lot to like about his offensive picks over the first 10 rounds. In fact, the only questionable pick in the front half is probably Khalil Mack. Don’t get me wrong, Mack might be the best defensive player in the National Football League who isn’t J.J. Watt. But this scoring hurts his fantasy value unless he has DL eligibility. Add in Stephone Anthony losing play-calling duties to James Laurinaitis in New Orleans, and LB could be a weakness for this club.

IDP SLEEPER ALERT: After missing most of the 2015 season Antoine Bethea isn’t just flying under the radar. He’s off it entirely. However, Bethea is running ahead of youngster Jaquiski Tartt in Niners camp, and the veteran has a long history of IDP production. He’s a great late flier in the secondary.

Team 3: You Down With ODB?

Pick Pick
1.03Odell Beckham - WR, NYG13.03Olivier Vernon - DE, NYG
2.10Brandin Cooks - WR, NO14.10Wendell Smallwood - RB, PHI
3.03Mark Ingram - RB, NO15.03DeAndre Washington - RB, OAK
4.10C.J. Anderson - RB, DEN16.10Jabaal Sheard - DE, NE
5.03Larry Fitzgerald - WR, AZ17.03Harrison Smith - S, MIN
6.10Drew Brees - QB, NO18.10Matt Ryan - QB, ATL
7.03Delanie Walker - TE, TEN19.03Jimmy Graham - TE, SEA
8.10Jonathan Stewart - RB, CAR20.10Demario Davis - LB, CLE
9.03Laquon Treadwell - WR, MIN21.03Leonte Caroo - WR, MIA
10.10Derrick Johnson - LB, KC22.10Reggie Nelson - S, OAK
11.03Paul Posluszny - LB, JAX23.03Cliff Avril - DE, SEA
12.10Stefon Diggs - WR, MIN24.10Manti Te’o - LB, SD

Team 3 has the potential to be pretty filthy on the front end if C.J. Anderson winds up a bellcow for the Broncos, as this squad is LOADED at wide receiver. They didn’t address the defensive side of the ball until late in Round 10, where they popped a pair of veteran linebackers in Derrick Johnson and Paul Posluszny. Both have long been IDP stalwarts, but it’s a risk that could backfire if age catches up to Johnson or Posluszny loses subpackage snaps to rookie Myles Jack. Harrison Smith is an elite fantasy DB, and a good value in the 17th round.

SLEEPER ALERT: Demario Davis may never be the player the Jets hoped he’d be, and after a disappointing 2015 season Davis has been dropping in IDP drafts. Nevertheless, Davis is all but assured a three-down role for a Browns’ defense that will be on the field a lot. Someone has to make those tackles.

Team 4: Living On the Edge

Pick Pick
1.04DeAndre Hopkins - WR, HOU13.04Geno Atkins - DT, CIN
2.09Devonta Freeman - RB, ATL14.09Jameis Winston - QB, TB
3.04Demaryius Thomas - WR, DEN15.04Ryan Shazier - LB, PIT
4.09Thomas Rawls - RB, SEA16.09Dwayne Allen - TE, IND
5.04Jordan Matthews - WR, PHI17.04Karlos Williams - RB, BUF
6.09Travis Kelce - TE, KC18.09Jerrell Freeman - LB, CHI
7.04Ryan Mathews - RB, PHI19.04Johnathan Cyprien - S, JAX
8.09Carson Palmer - QB, AZ20.09Rueben Randle - WR, PHI
9.04Tavon Austin - WR, LAR21.04Cameron Heyward - DE, PIT
10.09Sean Lee - LB, DAL22.09Dont’a Hightower - LB, NE
11.04Kamar Aiken - WR, BAL23.04Clayton Geathers - S, IND
12.09C.J. Prosise - RB, SEA24.09Malik Jackson - DT, JAX

If you’re the type of fantasy owner who doesn’t shy away from risk, then this is a team that should appeal to you. If Thomas Rawls comes back healthy and Devonta Freeman can come close to last year’s numbers, this will be a hard team to beat, especially with upside plays like Tavon Austin and Ryan Mathews behind them racking up “flex” points. The dice-rolling carried over on defense. Three of the four linebackers taken (Lee, Shazier and to a lesser extent Hightower) have shown the ability to post gaudy IDP numbers and an inability to stay on the field.

IDP Pro Tip: The selection of defensive end Cameron Heyward in Round 21 was a savvy move. Heyward isn’t going to pile up double-digit sacks, but he’s the sort of high-floor tackle producer who makes a strong complement to a big-play pass-rushing type (in this case Geno Atkins).

Team 5: For Whom the Bell Tolls

Pick Pick
1.05Todd Gurley - RB, LAR13.05Brandon Marshall - LB, DEN
2.08Le’Veon Bell - RB, PIT14.08Kiko Alonso - LB, MIA
3.05Randall Cobb - WR, GB15.05Marcus Mariota - QB, TEN
4.08Doug Baldwin - WR, SEA16.08Chris Hogan - WR, NE
5.05Greg Olsen - TE, CAR17.05Zach Miller - TE, CHI
6.08Jeremy Langford - RB, CHI18.08Kenny Vaccaro - S, NO
7.05Michael Crabtree - WR, OAK19.05Cameron Artis-Payne - RB, CAR
8.08DeAngelo Williams - RB, PIT20.08Avery Williamson - LB, TEN
9.05Carlos Dunlap - DE, CIN21.05Vontaze Burfict - LB, CIN
10.08Dorial Green-Beckham - WR, TEN22.08Stephon Tuitt - DE, PIT
11.05Blake Bortles - QB, JAX23.05Gerald McCoy - DT, TB
12.08Josh Doctson - WR, WAS24.08Mike Adams - S, IND

Who says no one goes RB/RB anymore? Not only does this team have arguably 2016’s top two tailbacks, but getting DeAngelo Williams later greatly eases the pain of Bell’s suspension. They doubled up on suspended AFC North stars, grabbing Cincinnati Bengals outside linebacker Vontaze Burfict in Round 21. If Burfict can keep his head on straight once he returns and talented but injury-prone linebacker Kiko Alonso of the Dolphins can stay healthy, this squad has the potential to have one of the league’s more formidable LB corps.

IDP Pro Tip: Team 5 took all of one IDP in the draft’s first half, an elite lineman in Carlos Dunlap. Six of the team’s last seven picks were on defense. There’s depth galore at linebacker and in the secondary in 2016. If you do your homework you can take advantage of that depth.

Team 6: The Newton Gang

Pick Pick
1.06David Johnson - RB, AZ13.06Jordan Hicks - LB, PHI
2.07Brandon Marshall - WR, NYJ14.07Devontae Booker - RB, DEN
3.06Cam Newton - QB, CAR15.06Philip Dorsett - WR, IND
4.07Luke Kuechly - LB, CAR16.07Darren Sproles - RB, PHI
5.06DeVante Parker - WR, MIA17.06Jason Witten - TE, DAL
6.07John Brown - WR, AZ18.07Barry Church - S, DAL
7.06Jeremy Hill - RB, CIN19.06Ryan Fitzpatrick - QB, NYJ
8.07Alec Ogletree - LB, LAR20.07Ndamukong Suh - DT, MIA
9.06T.J. Yeldon - RB, JAX21.06Ben Heeney - LB, OAK
10.07Zach Ertz - TE, PHI22.07Karl Joseph - S. OAK
11.06Corey Coleman - WR, CLE23.06Robert Woods - WR, BUF
12.07Cameron Jordan - DE, NO24.07Danielle Hunter - DE, MIN

This team was all over the place early, hitting four separate positions in the draft’s first four rounds. Not only were they the first team to take a quarterback (Cam Newton in Round 3), but they followed that up by being the first team to take a linebacker the next round. The trio of Kuechly, Alec Ogletree and Jordan Hicks is the best top three at the position in this draft, and Cameron Jordan of the Saints was a sneaky value in Round 12. It’s a risky philosophy if his WR or RB falter, but it’s also one that could pay big dividends on defense.

IDP SLEEPER ALERT: There isn’t a linebacker in the NFL I like more this year from a value standpoint than Hicks. He was phenomenal as a rookie before getting hurt and will play every down at MIKE for the Eagles. LB1 upside available outside the top 15? Yes please.

Team 7: Who Needs Running Backs?

Pick Pick
1.07A.J. Green - WR, CIN13.07Bilal Powell - RB, NYJ
2.06Jordy Nelson - WR, GB14.06Philip Rivers - QB, SD
3.07Sammy Watkins - WR, BUF15.07Shane Vereen - RB, NYG
4.06Donte Moncrief - WR, IND16.06Lawrence Timmons - LB, PIT
5.07Dion Lewis - RB, NE17.07James Laurinaitis - LB. NO
6.06Danny Woodhead - RB, SD18.06Malcolm Jenkins - S, PHI
7.07Aaron Donald - DT, LAR19.07Clive Walford - TE, OAK
8.06Marvin Jones - WR, DET20.06Kurt Coleman - S, CAR
9.07Charles Sims - RB, TB21.07Mike Wallace - WR, BAL
10.06Bobby Wagner - LB, SEA22.06Cameron Wake - DE, MIA
11.07Julius Thomas - TE, JAX23.07Jelani Jenkins - LB, MIA
12.06Derek Carr - QB, OAK24.06Brandon Graham - DE, PHI

The “Zero RB” strategy has been gaining in popularity in recent years, and this is the closest to adherence to that plan any team came here, with four straight receivers to open the draft. Aaron Donald is a fantastic anchor for the defensive line, and Jenkins and Coleman are both coming off great years in the secondary. But Bobby Wagner, Lawrence Timmons and James Laurinaitis are three veteran linebackers who have a tendency to be overvalued in drafts. They aren’t bad options, but they aren’t especially great ones either.

IDP Pro Tip: Wagner’s IDP value takes a hit partly because the scorekeepers in Seattle tend to award assists rather than solos. Learning which stat crews are generous (or stingy) can give you an edge when choosing between similarly-ranked fantasy options.

Team 8: Defense Wins Championships

Pick Pick
1.08Dez Bryant - WR, DAL13.08Eli Manning - QB, NYG
2.05Amari Cooper - WR, OAK14.05Corey Graham - S, BUF
3.08LeSean McCoy - RB, BUF15.08Kwon Alexander - LB, TB
4.05Latavius Murray - RB, OAK16.05Kirk Cousins - QB, WAS
5.08Kevin White - WR, CHI17.08Will Fuller - WR, HOU
6.05Ezekiel Ansah - DE, DET18.05LeGarrette Blount - RB, NE
7.08Coby Fleener - TE, NO19.08Robert Ayers - DE, TB
8.05C.J. Mosley - LB, BAL20.05Austin Seferian-Jenkins - TE, TB
9.08Reshad Jones - S, MIA21.08Karlos Dansby - LB, CIN
10.05Markus Wheaton - WR, PIT22.05Jurrell Casey - DE, TEN
11.08Derrick Henry - RB, TEN23.08Anthony Barr - LB, MIN
12.05Tevin Coleman - RB, ATL24.05Davante Adams - WR, GB

Team 8 was the final squad to select a starting quarterback. In fact, by the time they got around to grabbing Eli Manning in Round 13, the team already had one defensive starter at all three positions. It’s a bold move, but one that appears to have paid off. Whether its Detroit Lions defensive end “Ziggy” Ansah, inside linebacker C.J. Mosley of the Baltimore Ravens or Miami Dolphins safety Reshad Jones (the top overall IDP in 2015 in this scoring format) all three of those players have a shot at finishing the year No. 1 at their position.

IDP Pro Tip: I’ll freely admit that I’m not generally the sort to advise hitting defensive backs twice in the first 14 rounds of a draft. But Jones and Graham are ranked first and second on more than a few experts’ boards. Sometimes you have to be able to think outside the (tackle) box.

Team 9: High Wattage

Pick Pick
1.09Adrian Peterson - RB, MIN13.09Mike Thomas - WR, NO
2.04J.J. Watt - DE, HOU14.04Kawann Short - DT, CAR
3.09Jarvis Landry - WR, MIA15.09Jerick McKinnon - RB, MIN
4.04Aaron Rodgers - QB, GB16.04Hasean Clinton-Dix - S, GB
5.09Matt Jones - RB, WAS17.09Steve Smith - WR, BAL
6.04Emmanuel Sanders - WR, DEN18.04Andy Dalton - QB, CIN
7.09Josh Gordon - WR, CLE19.09Von Miller - LB, DEN
8.04Telvin Smith - LB, JAX20.04Jordan Cameron - TE, MIA
9.09Torrey Smith - WR, SF21.09Ben Watson - TE, BAL
10.04Rashad Jennings - RB, NYG22.04Bernardrick McKinney - LB, HOU
11.09Chris Ivory - RB. JAX23.09Sheldon Richardson - DE, NYJ
12.04Malcolm Smith - LB, OAK24.04Ron Parker - S, KC

This team’s fortunes may well live or die with the back of their second-round selection. Before the news of his back surgery, Houston Texans defensive end J.J. Watt was a no-brainer first-round pick in the vast majority of IDP formats (including this one). Now the three-time Defensive Player of the Year is the definition of risk/reward. If he makes it onto the field for Week 1 (Watt has never missed a game in his NFL career) at anywhere close to 100 percent he’s an absolute steal here. But if the injury lingers throughout the season… well, that would be bad.

IDP Pro Tip: KNOW YOUR SCORING! Von Miller may be the reigning Super Bowl MVP and the highest-paid defensive player in NFL history, but in this scoring system he’s only a so-so fantasy option. Even in Round 19 you can likely do better.

Team 10: Youth is Served

Pick Pick
1.10Ezekiel Elliott - RB, DAL13.10Vincent Jackson - WR, TB
2.03Mike Evans - WR, TB14.03Eric Kendricks - LB, MIN
3.10Eddie Lacy - RB, GB15.10James Starks - RB, GB
4.03Golden Tate - WR, DET16.03Landon Collins - S, NYG
5.10Eric Decker - WR, DEN17.10Rob Ninkovich - DE, NE
6.03Andrew Luck - QB, IND18.03Mychal Kendricks - LB, PHI
7.10Ameer Abdullah - RB, DET19.10Pierre Garcon - WR, WAS
8.03Tyler Eifert - TE, CIN20.03Brock Osweiler - QB, HOU
9.10Jamie Collins - LB, NE21.10Charles Clay - TE, BUF
10.03Muhammad Wilkerson - DE, NYJ22.03David Harris - LB, NYJ
11.10Sammie Coates - WR, PIT23.10Charles Johnson - DE, CAR
12.03Isaiah Crowell - RB, CLE24.03Michael Griffin - S, MIN

The idea of spending a first-round pick on a rookie (with a bad hammy, no less) will no doubt give some fantasy owners the vapors. But I’ll confess I like this team quite a bit. There aren’t any glaring weaknesses, including on defense. Jamie Collins of the Patriots and the Kendricks brothers (Minnesota’s Eric and Philly’s Mychal) are a solid front three at linebacker, and Team 10 might have the best DL duo in the league. If they can get a healthy Tyler Eifert back early in the season, this team has some real postseason potential.

SLEEPER ALERT: After several productive seasons, Rob Ninkovich’s playing time (and fantasy numbers) dipped in 2015. With Chandler Jones now in Arizona, Nink should see a bump in both this year. He’s a sneaky value late in drafts as a DL2. Update: Rob Ninkovich is expected to miss 4-6 weeks with a triceps injury.

Team 11: Three Kings (and a Bunch of Jesters)

Pick Pick
1.11Allen Robinson - WR, JAX13.11Javorius Allen - RB, BAL
2.02Lamar Miller - RB, HOU14.02Devin Funchess - WR, CAR
3.11Jordan Reed - TE, WAS15.11Paul Perkins - RB, NYG
4.02Kelvin Benjamin - WR, CAR16.02Tyrod Taylor - QB, BUF
5.11Lavonte David - LB, TB17.11Denzel Perryman - LB, SD
6.02DeMarco Murray - RB, TEN18.02Michael Bennett - DE, SEA
7.11Robert Quinn - DE, LAR19.11Breshad Perriman - WR, BAL
8.02Sterling Shepard - WR, NYG20.02Preston Brown - LB, BUF
9.11Travis Benjamin - WR, SD21.11Paul Worrilow - LB, ATL
10.02Justin Forsett - RB, BAL22.02Kyle Rudolph - TE, MIN
11.11Tom Brady - QB, NE23.11Kam Chancellor - S, SEA
12.02Tyrann Mathieu - S, AZ24.02Dante Fowler - DE, JAX

Team 11 deployed a rather interesting tactic when it came to the defensive side of the ball by spending early picks on “core” players at each position, then waiting until very late to build around them. Robert Quinn and Tyrann Mathieu are coming back from injuries, but if they return to form both could easily finish in the top-five at their positions. If the value plays they targeted late are able to complement those stars, this has all the makings of a balanced, competitive club, especially once Tom Brady gets back from suspension and declares war on the NFL.

SLEEPER ALERT: Actually, it’s a double-dip of young linebackers. Preston Brown plays in front of the league’s most generous stat crew and gets a value bump with Reggie Ragland hurt. Ditto for Denzel Perryman, who is slated for an every-down role in Year 2 of his NFL career.

Team 12: Me Gronk Smash Puny Human

Pick Pick
1.12Keenan Allen - WR, SD13.12Martellus Bennett - TE, NE
2.01Rob Gronkowski - TE, NE14.01Danny Trevathan - LB, CHI
3.12Carlos Hyde - RB, SF15.12Matthew Stafford - QB, DET
4.01Jeremy Maclin - WR, KC16.01Tony Romo - QB, DAL
5.12Giovani Bernard - RB, CIN17.12Kendall Wright - WR, TEN
6.01Michael Floyd - WR, AZ18.01Chris Johnson - RB, AZ
7.12Arian Foster - RB, MIA19.12Connor Barwin - DE, PHI
8.01Tyler Lockett - WR, SEA20.01Eric Weddle - S, BAL
9.12DeAndre Levy - LB, DET21.12Eric Berry - S, KC
10.01D’Qwell Jackson - LB, IND22.01Rishard Matthews - WR, MIA
11.12Calais Campbell - DE, AZ23.12Gerald Hodges - LB, SF
12.01Jay Ajayi - RB, MIA24.01Devin Taylor - DE, DET

There are certain caveats that go with picking on the turn. The first is to take advantage of those back-to-back picks. Be aggressive. Force the action. Try to be the fly in the ointment that starts positional runs. The second is to not get cute. Don’t be afraid to “reach” for a player you want. With a 23-pick gap between picks, Odds are that player who isn’t quite at his ADP isn’t making it back to you. Whether it’s pulling the trigger on Gronk to start Round 2 or going IDP three picks in a row in the draft’s first half, that’s how picking on the turn should be done.

IDP Pro Tip: If you’re new to IDP and leery of when to start picking them, wait a bit. Let the first few come off the board. Then, with one of your doubles on the turn, hit defense twice. Whether it’s LB/LB or a linebacker and a lineman, you’ll give yourself a firm base for your defensive unit.

Gary Davenport is a Senior Staff Writer at Fantasy Sharks, an NFL and Fantasy Football Analyst at Bleacher Report and a Contributing Author and Associate Editor at Football Diehards. A member of the Pro Football Writers of America and Fantasy Sports Writers Association, Gary was the winner of the 2015 FSWA award for Print Article of the Year. You can follow Gary on Twitter @IDPSharks.