2025 Fantasy Baseball Top 300 update: Ailing Bobby Witt Jr. tumbles, Julio Rodríguez joins top 10

If you were following along with the preseason edition, here’s our regular-season top 300 overall rankings, which will be updated weekly on Mondays.

These are rest-of-season rankings for mixed 5x5 fantasy baseball leagues.

You can check out our rankings for dynasty leagues here.

2025 Fantasy Baseball Top 300 overall ranks

**Updated as of Monday, Sept. 8**

Top 300	Player	Team	Pos	Rk	Sept 1
1	Aaron Judge	Yankees	OF	1	1
2	Shohei Ohtani	Dodgers	DH	1	2
3	Tarik Skubal	Tigers	SP	1	4
4	Juan Soto	Mets	OF	2	5
5	Corbin Carroll	Diamondbacks	OF	3	7
6	Jose Ramirez	Guardians	3B	1	8
7	Fernando Tatis Jr.	Padres	OF	4	9
8	Elly De La Cruz	Reds	SS	1	6
9	Vladimir Guerrero Jr.	Blue Jays	1B	1	15
10	Julio Rodriguez	Mariners	OF	5	14
11	Yordan Alvarez	Astros	OF	6	22
12	Kyle Schwarber	Phillies	DH	2	13
13	Gunnar Henderson	Orioles	SS	2	12
14	Bobby Witt Jr.	Royals	SS	3	3
15	Francisco Lindor	Mets	SS	4	18
16	Paul Skenes	Pirates	SP	2	20
17	Freddie Freeman	Dodgers	1B	2	19
18	Manny Machado	Padres	3B	2	16
19	Ronald Acuna Jr.	Braves	OF	7	10
20	Kyle Tucker	Cubs	OF	8	11
21	Garrett Crochet	Red Sox	SP	3	21
22	Logan Gilbert	Mariners	SP	4	23
23	Jazz Chisholm Jr.	Yankees	2B	1	24
24	Matt Olson	Braves	1B	3	26
25	Bo Bichette	Blue Jays	SS	5	35
26	Jarren Duran	Red Sox	OF	9	25
27	Bryce Harper	Phillies	1B	4	27
28	Pete Crow-Armstrong	Cubs	OF	10	28
29	Pete Alonso	Mets	1B	5	31
30	Ketel Marte	Diamondbacks	2B	2	32
31	Jackson Chourio	Brewers	OF	11	30
32	James Wood	Nationals	OF	12	29
33	Seiya Suzuki	Cubs	OF	13	33
34	CJ Abrams	Nationals	SS	6	34
35	Wyatt Langford	Rangers	OF	14	38
36	Jackson Merrill	Padres	OF	15	36
37	Mookie Betts	Dodgers	SS	7	50
38	Hunter Brown	Astros	SP	5	42
39	Junior Caminero	Rays	3B	3	46
40	Michael Harris II	Braves	OF	16	37
41	Chris Sale	Braves	SP	6	59
42	Cal Raleigh	Mariners	C	1	44
43	Brent Rooker	Athletics	OF	17	40
44	Jose Altuve	Astros	2B	3	39
45	Cristopher Sanchez	Phillies	SP	7	49
46	Zach Neto	Angels	SS	8	47
47	Nick Kurtz	Athletics	1B	6	90
48	Edwin Diaz	Mets	RP	1	48
49	Rafael Devers	Giants	3B	4	54
50	Jeremy Pena	Astros	SS	9	53
51	Brice Turang	Brewers	2B	4	62
52	Hunter Greene	Reds	SP	8	67
53	Cody Bellinger	Yankees	1B	7	52
54	George Kirby	Mariners	SP	9	41
55	Mike Trout	Angels	OF	18	57
56	Framber Valdez	Astros	SP	10	51
57	Andres Munoz	Mariners	RP	2	60
58	Jacob deGrom	Rangers	SP	11	45
59	Yoshinobu Yamamoto	Dodgers	SP	12	63
60	Riley Greene	Tigers	OF	19	68
61	Ian Happ	Cubs	OF	20	86
62	Bryan Woo	Mariners	SP	13	61
63	Blake Snell	Dodgers	SP	14	58
64	Max Fried	Yankees	SP	15	64
65	Jhoan Duran	Phillies	RP	3	65
66	Joe Ryan	Twins	SP	16	43
67	Oneil Cruz	Pirates	SS	10	55
68	Logan Webb	Giants	SP	17	69
69	George Springer	Blue Jays	OF	21	99
70	Shota Imanaga	Cubs	SP	18	74
71	Freddy Peralta	Brewers	SP	19	79
72	Teoscar Hernandez	Dodgers	OF	22	70
73	Josh Naylor	Mariners	1B	8	75
74	Alex Bregman	Red Sox	3B	5	71
75	Maikel Garcia	Royals	2B	5	77
76	Vinnie Pasquantino	Royals	1B	9	84
77	Brandon Nimmo	Mets	OF	23	83
78	Trevor Story	Red Sox	SS	11	87
79	Dylan Cease	Padres	SP	20	82
80	Raisel Iglesias	Braves	RP	4	97
81	Byron Buxton	Twins	OF	24	76
82	Christian Walker	Astros	1B	10	81
83	Willson Contreras	Cardinals	C	2	72
84	Randy Arozarena	Mariners	OF	25	85
85	Bryan Abreu	Astros	RP	5	80
86	Anthony Volpe	Yankees	SS	12	78
87	Shane Bieber	Blue Jays	SP	21	92
88	Brandon Lowe	Rays	2B	6	91
89	William Contreras	Brewers	C	3	89
90	Kevin Gausman	Blue Jays	SP	22	94
91	Christian Yelich	Brewers	OF	26	56
92	Cade Smith	Guardians	RP	6	93
93	Nolan McLean	Mets	SP	23	100
94	Aroldis Chapman	Red Sox	RP	7	95
95	Robbie Ray	Giants	SP	24	106
96	Josh Lowe	Rays	OF	27	102
97	Carlos Rodon	Yankees	SP	25	98
98	Tyler Glasnow	Dodgers	SP	26	73
99	Salvador Perez	Royals	C	4	101
100	Jacob Wilson	Athletics	SS	13	116
101	Jesus Luzardo	Phillies	SP	27	104
102	Pablo Lopez	Twins	SP	28	142
103	Andy Pages	Dodgers	OF	28	105
104	Alec Bohm	Phillies	3B	6	103
105	Bryan Reynolds	Pirates	OF	29	107
106	Trevor Rogers	Orioles	SP	29	108
107	Nick Pivetta	Padres	SP	30	112
108	Carlos Estevez	Royals	RP	8	127
109	Steven Kwan	Guardians	OF	30	117
110	Willy Adames	Giants	SS	14	115
111	Bryce Miller	Mariners	SP	31	114
112	Robert Suarez	Padres	RP	9	122
113	Yandy Diaz	Rays	1B	11	119
114	Eugenio Suarez	Mariners	3B	7	118
115	Sonny Gray	Cardinals	SP	32	124
116	Dylan Crews	Nationals	OF	31	96
117	Michael King	Padres	SP	33	136
118	Tyler Soderstrom	Athletics	1B	12	120
119	Kenley Jansen	Angels	RP	10	125
120	Nico Hoerner	Cubs	2B	7	123
121	Matt Chapman	Giants	3B	8	130
122	Jeff Hoffman	Blue Jays	RP	11	138
123	Lawrence Butler	Athletics	OF	32	126
124	Brandon Woodruff	Brewers	SP	34	132
125	David Bednar	Yankees	RP	12	133
126	Gleyber Torres	Tigers	2B	8	128
127	Tommy Edman	Dodgers	2B	9	154
128	Ramon Laureano	Padres	OF	33	166
129	Ranger Suarez	Phillies	SP	35	139
130	Luke Keaschall	Twins	2B	10	137
131	Pete Fairbanks	Rays	RP	13	131
132	Jo Adell	Angels	OF	34	155
133	Clayton Kershaw	Dodgers	SP	36	140
134	Daulton Varsho	Blue Jays	OF	35	159
135	Jurickson Profar	Braves	OF	36	144
136	Mark Vientos	Mets	3B	9	145
137	Ceddanne Rafaela	Red Sox	SS	15	134
138	Matthew Boyd	Cubs	SP	37	149
139	Royce Lewis	Twins	3B	10	158
140	Michael Busch	Cubs	1B	13	129
141	Geraldo Perdomo	Diamondbacks	SS	16	157
142	Kyle Bradish	Orioles	SP	38	146
143	Ozzie Albies	Braves	2B	11	163
144	Jacob Misiorowski	Brewers	SP	39	150
145	Matt McLain	Reds	2B	12	289
146	Sandy Alcantara	Marlins	SP	40	143
147	Noelvi Marte	Reds	3B	11	151
148	Ezequiel Tovar	Rockies	SS	17	111
149	Spencer Strider	Braves	SP	41	121
150	Taylor Ward	Angels	OF	37	168
151	Dansby Swanson	Cubs	SS	18	156
152	Jonah Tong	Mets	SP	42	135
153	Ben Rice	Yankees	C	5	152
154	Sean Manaea	Mets	SP	43	148
155	Cade Horton	Cubs	SP	44	183
156	Jung Hoo Lee	Giants	OF	38	160
157	Gavin Williams	Guardians	SP	45	178
158	Chandler Simpson	Rays	OF	39	141
159	Tanner Bibee	Guardians	SP	46	162
160	Chris Bassitt	Blue Jays	SP	47	172
161	Jackson Holliday	Orioles	2B	13	171
162	Shea Langeliers	Athletics	C	6	169
163	Kerry Carpenter	Tigers	OF	40	167
164	Trent Grisham	Yankees	OF	41	170
165	Will Smith	Dodgers	C	7	147
166	Giancarlo Stanton	Yankees	OF	42	202
167	Brad Keller	Cubs	RP	14	NR
168	Spencer Torkelson	Tigers	1B	14	173
169	Shohei Ohtani	Dodgers	SP	48	177
170	Nathaniel Lowe	Red Sox	1B	15	200
171	Quinn Priester	Brewers	SP	49	198
172	Brenton Doyle	Rockies	OF	43	110
173	Luis Gil	Yankees	SP	50	179
174	Dennis Santana	Pirates	RP	15	182
175	TJ Friedl	Reds	OF	44	181
176	Ivan Herrera	Cardinals	C	8	189
177	Spencer Steer	Reds	1B	16	187
178	Trevor Megill	Brewers	RP	16	201
179	Trea Turner	Phillies	SS	19	17
180	Harrison Bader	Phillies	OF	45	280
181	Jordan Westburg	Orioles	2B	14	109
182	Xavier Edwards	Marlins	SS	20	164
183	Heliot Ramos	Giants	OF	46	190
184	Parker Messick	Guardians	SP	51	188
185	Ryan Walker	Giants	RP	17	184
186	Ryan Mountcastle	Orioles	1B	17	192
187	Bryson Stott	Phillies	2B	15	229
188	Max Scherzer	Blue Jays	SP	52	161
189	Masyn Winn	Cardinals	SS	21	193
190	Abner Uribe	Brewers	RP	18	153
191	Payton Tolle	Red Sox	SP	53	191
192	Ha-Seong Kim	Braves	SS	22	251
193	Kyle Manzardo	Guardians	1B	18	247
194	David Peterson	Mets	SP	54	186
195	Jordan Lawler	Diamondbacks	SS	23	180
196	Cam Schlitter	Yankees	SP	55	197
197	Nick Lodolo	Reds	SP	56	204
198	Andrew Vaughn	Brewers	1B	19	196
199	Sal Frelick	Brewers	OF	47	203
200	Luis Garcia Jr.	Nationals	2B	16	209
201	Tanner Scott	Dodgers	RP	19	176
202	Brendan Donovan	Cardinals	2B	17	220
203	Cole Ragans	Royals	SP	57	208
204	Will Vest	Tigers	RP	20	243
205	Lars Nootbaar	Cardinals	OF	48	205
206	Jesus Sanchez	Astros	OF	49	194
207	Drake Baldwin	Braves	C	9	210
208	Ian Seymour	Rays	SP	58	206
209	Austin Hays	Reds	OF	50	207
210	Wilyer Abreu	Red Sox	OF	51	175
211	Luis Arraez	Padres	2B	18	215
212	Addison Barger	Blue Jays	3B	12	174
213	Max Muncy	Dodgers	3B	13	267
214	Carson Montgomery	White Sox	SS	24	258
215	Ryan Pepiot	Rays	SP	59	231
216	Yainer Diaz	Astros	C	10	212
217	Josh Jung	Rangers	3B	14	216
218	Shane Baz	Rays	SP	60	236
219	Romy Gonzalez	Red Sox	SS	25	NR
220	Marcell Ozuna	Braves	DH	3	228
221	Colton Cowser	Orioles	OF	52	222
222	Adrian Morejon	Padres	RP	21	260
223	Adrian Houser	Rays	SP	61	218
224	Samuel Bassallo	Orioles	C	11	199
225	Jake Burger	Rangers	3B	15	NR
226	Hurston Waldrep	Braves	SP	62	235
227	Hunter Goodman	Rockies	C	12	217
228	Ryan O’Hearn	Padres	1B	20	230
229	Jac Caglianone	Royals	1B	21	219
230	Eury Perez	Marlins	SP	63	214
231	Brayan Bello	Red Sox	SP	64	232
232	Dylan Beavers	Orioles	OF	53	211
233	Zebby Matthews	Twins	SP	65	261
234	Jack Flaherty	Tigers	SP	66	233
235	Luis Castillo	Mariners	SP	67	237
236	Jeremiah Jackson	Orioles	SS	26	NR
237	Merrill Kelly	Rangers	SP	68	241
238	Colt Keith	Tigers	2B	19	221
239	J.T. Realmuto	Phillies	C	13	239
240	Tyler O’Neill	Orioles	OF	54	270
241	Jake Cronenworth	Padres	2B	20	224
242	Jakob Marsee	Marlins	OF	55	223
243	Clay Holmes	Mets	SP	69	238
244	Carlos Correa	Astros	SS	27	250
245	Cristian Javier	Astros	SP	70	225
246	Alec Burleson	Cardinals	OF	56	NR
247	Kyle Stowers	Marlins	OF	57	NR
248	Will Warren	Yankees	SP	71	246
249	Drew Rasmussen	Rays	SP	72	242
250	Jose Quintana	Brewers	SP	73	NR
251	Agustin Ramirez	Marlins	C	14	248
252	Lucas Giolito	Red Sox	SP	74	252
253	JoJo Romero	Cardinals	RP	22	277
254	Jack Leiter	Rangers	SP	75	257
255	Matt Shaw	Cubs	3B	16	256
256	Jose A. Ferrer	Nationals	RP	23	259
257	Zac Gallen	Diamondbacks	SP	76	269
258	Jeff McNeil	Mets	2B	21	291
259	Ryan Weathers	Marlins	SP	77	NR
260	Ke’Bryan Hayes	Reds	3B	17	264
261	Aaron Nola	Phillies	SP	78	244
262	Gabriel Moreno	Diamondbacks	C	15	273
263	Justin Verlander	Giants	SP	79	272
264	Brett Baty	Mets	2B	22	254
265	Ryan McMahon	Yankees	3B	18	276
266	Andres Gimenez	Blue Jays	2B	23	245
267	Bubba Chandler	Pirates	SP	80	253
268	Isaac Collins	Brewers	OF	58	274
269	Yu Darvish	Padres	SP	81	255
270	Lenyn Sosa	White Sox	2B	24	266
271	Brandon Pfaadt	Diamondbacks	SP	82	282
272	Sal Stewart	Reds	3B	19	195
273	Matt Wallner	Twins	OF	59	262
274	Daylen Lile	Nationals	OF	60	NR
275	Brady Singer	Reds	SP	83	285
276	Nick Castellanos	Phillies	OF	61	165
277	Andrew Abbott	Reds	SP	84	263
278	Parker Meadows	Tigers	OF	62	NR
279	Brandon Marsh	Phillies	OF	63	292
280	Daniel Palencia	Cubs	RP	24	88
281	Masataka Yoshida	Red Sox	DH	4	NR
282	Joey Cantillo	Guardians	SP	85	NR
283	Mason Miller	Padres	RP	25	271
284	Victor Robles	Mariners	OF	64	NR
285	Luis Morales	Athletics	SP	86	294
286	Jordan Leasure	White Sox	RP	26	NR
287	Jordan Beck	Rockies	OF	65	227
288	Brooks Lee	Twins	SS	28	278
289	Victor Vodnik	Rockies	RP	27	295
290	Cam Smith	Astros	3B	20	284
291	Tyler Wells	Orioles	SP	87	NR
292	Caleb Durbin	Brewers	2B	25	298
293	Jorge Polanco	Mariners	2B	26	NR
294	Mike Yastrzemski	Royals	OF	66	281
295	Emmet Sheehan	Dodgers	SP	88	NR
296	Jared Triolo	Pirates	SS	29	NR
297	Kyle Teel	White Sox	C	16	296
298	Janson Junk	Marlins	SP	89	NR
299	Cade Povich	Orioles	SP	90	NR
300	Shawn Armstrong	Rangers	RP	28	NR

Sept. 8 Notes

***This will be the last update of the regular season.... it’s all really just matchups for the final two weeks. If you’d like my opinion on any start/sits or add/drops, feel free to contact me on Bluesky or X. I plan on posting an early top 300 for 2026 at some point in October and maintaining that through the spring.***

- Dropping off the list: Roman Anthony (66th), Adolis García (113th), Kodai Senga (185th), Seth Lugo (213th), Lourdes Gurriel (226th), Tyler Freeman (234th), Devin Williams (240th), Nestor Cortes (249th), Kyle Finnegan (265th), Emilio Pagán (268th), Seranthony Domínguez (275th), Jasson Domínguez (279th), Joc Pederson (283rd), Tommy Pham (286th), C.J. Kayfus (287th), Cedric Mullins (288th), José Soriano (290th, Connor Norby (293rd), Gavin Lux (297th), Braxton Ashcraft (299th), Calvin Faucher (300th)

- Little is known about Trea Turner‘s hamstring injury at the moment, so he gets a rather generic ranking of No. 179 for now. Bryson Stott has climbed from No. 229 to No. 187, as he could ascend to the leadoff spot in Philadelphia with Turner absent. At the very least, he’ll probably stop receiving so much time off against lefties.

- Daniel Palencia tumbles nearly 200 spots to No. 280 after leaving Sunday’s game with a shoulder issue. Maybe that will prove to be an overreaction, but there’s only three weeks to go and it seems likely that he’ll miss some time. Brad Keller joins the rankings at No. 167 as the probable favorite for saves in the Cubs pen. Porter Hodge could also be in the mix.

- A pair of Orioles starters, Tyler Wells and Cade Povich, made the rankings this week, mostly because they’re due to face the Pirates and White Sox in their next two starts. It was encouraging that Wells averaged 93.0 mph with his fastball last week in his first outing back from Tommy John surgery. That’s slightly better than where he was in 2023 and the beginning of 2024 (92.6 mph).

- It was between Shawn Armstrong and the Reds’ Tony Santillan for the last spot, with Armstrong winning out. Santillan seems like the best bet in the Cincinnati pen at the moment after Emilio Pagán took his sixth blown save last week. Pagán, though, has been better than anyone should have expected with his 3.38 ERA and 30.5% strikeout rate in 58 2/3 innings.

- You’ll see Rockies hitters plunging down the rankings this week. Four of the team’s final six series are on the road and they’re pretty tough for the most part; they’ll get the Dodgers and Padres this week and go to Seattle and San Francisco during the final week of the season.