Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
Odds by

Fantasy Baseball Catcher Breakdown: Hunter Goodman, Drake Baldwin become top dogs entering 2027

Add on Google

With the 2026 MLB season behind us, it’s time for our positional breakdowns. Just like last year, we’re going to review each position to uncover what we learned from a fantasy perspective and how we can apply it to next year.

In the coming days throughout November, we’ll be breaking down the standout seasons, the breakout candidates, the prospects to know, and our early 2027 rankings. We’ll kick things off with the catcher position.

Stay up to date with the MLB free agent market this offseason, including player signings, contract details, and more as the 2026-27 Hot Stove gets underway.

2026 POSITION BREAKDOWN: Catcher

🎙️ STATE OF THE POSITION

Despite preseason expectations that we were in for a truly deep year of catcher value, only 10 catchers earned at least $10 in value in 2026, according to Fangraphs’ Player Rater. That was down from 12 in 2025 and tied with the 10 who did it in 2024. However, 15 catchers earned at least $7 in value, the same as in 2025, which means the overall production was similar to what we saw in 2025, just not better.

In all, catchers had a .690 OPS, a .232 average, and 91 wRC+. The league average for all hitters was a .719 OPS, .244 average, and a 100 wRC+, so we are continuing to see below-average offensive production from the catcher position. That’s unfortunate after catchers posted a .700 OPS and 95 wRC+ in 2025. These aren’t massive changes, but they are small steps backwards when we had hoped to be moving forward. Perhaps an influx of young talent continuing to adjust to MLB pitching will change that in 2027.

🏆 2026’s Top Ten Catchers

1. Hunter Goodman (Rockies)

.245/.310/.529, 41 HR, 84 R, 88 RBI, 5 SB, 112 wRC+

Goodman was the top-ranked catcher in fantasy baseball in 2026, mostly due to his 41 home runs. Hitting .245 with 88 RBI and five steals doesn’t hurt, but the home runs carried the day. That wasn’t just a product of Coors Field either. Goodman hit .255 with 25 home runs in 72 games on the road in 2026. He had a 14.4% barrel rate and a 75 mph swing that portends the kind of power he produced. He also played 138 games, and even though that was slightly down from 2025, it’s still a near-every-day player, which is a huge asset for a catcher. He was 6th among all catchers in plate appearances, and that’s something we should see continue in 2027. Now, he did have a 30.5% strikeout rate, a 17.2% swinging strike rate (SwStr%), and was 14th among catchers with at least 200 plate appearances in wRC+, so there could be a tiny bit of regression coming here, but he figures to remain one of the top catchers in fantasy next season. Goodman did have shoulder surgery in the offseason, but he’s expected to be fully healthy by the start of spring training, and I don’t expect it to meaningfully impact his production.

2. Drake Baldwin (Braves)

.284/.358/.459, 25 HR, 85 R, 79 RBI, 3 SB, 126 wRC+

Drake Baldwin was making a case to be the top catcher in fantasy baseball before an oblique injury sidelined him for a month. He then hit just .063 in his first 12 games back before recapturing his previous level. The batting average is elite from the catcher position, and 25-30 home runs plus 80+ runs and RBI with some chip-in steals is going to help you in every single category. He makes league-average contact and had just a 11.7% SwStr%, so the batting average doesn’t feel like a fluke at all. The Braves hit him near the top of the order in a good hitter’s park, and there’s a strong case for Baldwin to be the top catcher off the board in 2027.

3. Gabriel Moreno (Diamondbacks)

.311/.388/.486, 16 HR, 72 R, 83 RBI, 6 SB, 141 wRC+

What a season for Gabriel Moreno. We had been waiting for the power he flashed in the 2023 postseason to carry over, and we finally got it with 16 home runs and a 7.7% barrel rate that was aided by a career-high pull rate. Now, 16 home runs is not on the level of many catchers in this article, but few, if any, of them hold a candle to Moreno’s contact ability. He had a sub-6% swinging strike rate and an elite 92% zone contact rate. He makes tremendous swing decisions and now supports those decisions with an approach that’s looking to drive the ball a little more often. He had the best wRC+ of the entire position group, and if we can get 15 home runs from him as a regular occurence, he’d be top 3-5 at the position every single season. Considering his HR/FB rate went from 10.6% in 2025 to 11% in 2026 and we had those modest approach changes, I think that kind of home run production could be real.

4. William Contreras (Brewers)

.270/.341/.417, 18 HR, 82 R, 94 RBI, 1 SB, 109 wRC+

Contreras was one of the top two catchers off the board in the spring, so this is a bit of a “down” performance; although, it’s nothing to be mad about. Contreras saw his batting average climb back to .270, and his barrel rate go back up to 8.5%, but the home run total didn’t change much. Part of that is that he almost doubled his launch angle, and his fly ball rate got a bit out of whack, leading to plenty more infield fly balls. His batting average was also just .252 in 58 games in the second half when his fly ball rate was most extreme, so perhaps it’s something he can rectify in the offseason. That being said, you’re talking about steady production and elite volume in a good lineup, which is hard to ask for when targeting a catcher in fantasy baseball. Perhaps he’s just an 18-20 home run hitter, but if he’s going to hit .270 and play nearly every day in Milwaukee, then that’s going to be something valuable.

5. Liam Hicks (Rays)

.284/.367/.434, 18 HR, 66 R, 82 RBI, 3 SB, 123 wRC+

Hicks had a breakout season with the Marlins and was traded to the Rays at the deadline. Before the season started, I wrote about Hick’s elite approach at the plate. I mentioned that his overall Contact Value on Pitcher List’s Process+ stat was elite, and his Process+ score in 2025 was among the best of any late-round fantasy hitter. That just means that his swing decisions were among the best in baseball. He just didn’t have much power. Well, Hicks came into 2026 with a slightly different batting stance and a more aggressive approach, raising his pull rate by almost 5% and being more aggressive, both inside and outside of the strike zone. Because he makes such elite contact, being more aggressive gave him more chances to do damage, trusting that his barrel would find the ball. He didn’t hit the ball any harder, but because he was attacking pitches earlier and pulling them more, he hit more home runs and drove more balls into the gap. The power didn’t really carry over into the second half, and he hit just five home runs in his last 57 games, but he may wind up as more of a 10-15 home run hitter, but the batting average is absolutely real.

6. Dillon Dingler (Tigers): .243, 27 HR, 72 R, 91 RBI, 107 wRC+

7. Carter Jensen (Royals): .239, 27 HR, 80 R, 81 RBI, 2 SB, 116 wRC+

8. Ivan Herrera (Cardinals): .241, 19 HR, 98 R, 69 RBI, 8 SB, 109 wRC+

9. Shea Langeliers (Athletics): .262, 23 HR, 58 R, 58 RBI, 3 SB, 115 wRC+

10. Salvador Perez (Royals): .229, 21 HR, 50 R, 78 RBI, 1 SB, 77 wRC+

📈 2027 Breakouts

Samuel Basallo (Orioles)

Last year was supposed to be Basallo’s breakout year, but injuries put a damper on that. He did post a 12.1% barrel rate with a 74.3 mph swing that showcased his overall power, but he hit just .222 in nearly 400 plate appearances. I believe the contact quality will win out in the end, and even though a 15% swinging strike rate and elevated chase rate will likely keep the batting average closer to .240, he’s a legitimate 25+ home run bat. Also, the mid-season trade of Adley Rutschman means that Basallo will be the starting catcher in Baltimore next year with an easy path to 500+ plate appearances. Very few catchers have his raw tools and power upside, and he’ll be just 23 years old next season. He could finish as a top-ten catcher just like Carter Jensen did this year.

Leo Bernal (Cardinals)

Bernal had a good season at Triple-A, hitting .278/.363/.468 with 16 home runs, 77 RBI, and nine steals. Then, after a late-season MLB audition, he turned heads with the Cardinals, hitting .284/.333/.474 with five home runs and 21 RBI in 24 games. He had a nearly 10% barrel rate in Triple-A, which carried over to the big leagues, and his 74 mph bat speed suggests that the hard contact is very much real. He will pull and elevate the ball, and he also has solid plate discipline, not expanding the zone too much and producing league-average zone contact rates. With Ivan Herrera likely ticketed for a role as the regular DH, it looks like Bernal and Jimmy Crooks will be the starting catchers in St. Louis to begin the season. If we can get that to be a 75/25 share in favor of Bernal, he can be a top-12 overall catcher. Just don’t expect the same HR pace (5 HRs in 24 games) to carry over into a full season. I’d expect him to be more of a 15-20 home run hitter over a full season.

Ethan Salas (Padres)

Salas has been on the radar for a while as one of the top catching prospects in baseball since he was 16 years old. Last season, he made his MLB debut at 20 years old, hitting .256/.275/.462 with two home runs and five RBI in 16 games. Salas has shown a tremendous approach at the plate. He’s never posted a double-digit swinging strike rate at any level despite frequently being young for the level. He had a 94% zone contact rate in Triple-A and a 92% zone contact rate in the big leagues. I know 16 games is a small sample size, but he’s just 20 years old and didn’t look overmatched at all. It may take a few years for the power to truly develop, and his bat speed is below average, but he could post solid on-base numbers with a decent batting average, and his defensive value will keep him in the lineup often.

📝 2027 Prospects To Know

Rainiel Rodriguez (Cardinals)

Rodriguez shouldn’t have fantasy value in 2027. He’s 19 years old. The Cardinals have two MLB-ready catchers in front of him. However, Rodriguez is just so good. He has vaulted up to being the 10th-ranked prospect in all of baseball, according to MLB Pipeline, after tearing up High-A for 28 games and then getting promoted to Double-A, where he hit .328/.408/.591 with 23 home runs, 74 runs, 66 RBI, and seven steals in 87 games. His bat speed is elite, and his quality of contact is absurd for his age. His production last season means there’s a good chance that he starts 2027 in Triple-A. If his defense continues to improve, he could push for MLB at-bats in the second half of the season.

Caden Bodine (Rays)

The Rays traded Nick Fortes to the Red Sox, which seemed to open up a path for Bodine to win the backup catcher job. The 22-year-old is Tampa Bay’s third-ranked prospect, according to MLB Pipeline, and was the 30th overall pick in the 2025 MLB Draft. Bodine is a switch-hitter with gap-to-gap power and a good feel for the barrel. He posted a .342/.410/.517 slash line in 117 games across four levels of the minor leagues in 2026. He never had a swinging strike rate higher than 8% at any level and posted an 89% contact rate on the season. He’s a great pitch framer, which the Rays will love, and there’s a chance that he could push Liam Hicks for playing time if Hicks’ bat slips because Hicks is poor at controlling the running game.

Jason Schiavone (Astros)

The 2024 MLB Draft pick had a breakout season, becoming the first minor league catcher in 45 years to post a 30/30 season when he hit 32 homers and swiped 32 bases. He also slashed .252/.391/.531 in 123 games while climbing from High-A Asheville to Triple-A Sugar Land. All of that prompted Astros director of player development Sam Niedorf to say that Schiavone “should be knocking on the door at Daikin [Park] before we know it.” I would say there’s a chance that Schiavone starts the year as the Astros’ backup, but he could also eventually supplant Yainer Diaz, or Diaz could be traded before he enters free agency. Schiavone only had nine games in Triple-A last year, so we don’t have a ton of Statcast data, but it was a 92 mph average exit velocity, which is nice to see. There are some contact concerns, so the .250 average might be more like .230 in the big leagues, but he’s also just 24 years old, so there is room for growth.

Owen Ayers (Cubs)

The Athletic’s Sahadev Sharma reported this offseason that the Cubs seem to be “ready to go young and lean on switch-hitting prospect Owen Ayers to team up with Miguel Amaya.” It makes sense after Ayers had a breakout season in 2026, hitting .289/.403/.526 with 25 home runs and 13 steals across 125 games split between Double-A and Triple-A. He did hit just .247/.365/.356 in 49 games at Triple-A, but he posted an over 15% walk rate and continued to make consistent contact despite the low batting average, so the plate approach and bat-to-ball skills remain. Amaya has battled injuries in his career and has never topped 363 plate appearances in a season, so Ayers would be a name to watch if he does indeed land the backup catcher job.

Ronald Acuña Jr. and Fernando Tatis Jr. round out the top 10 in our first edition of the 2027 rankings.

🔮 2027 Top 12 Catchers

1. Drake Baldwin: I think he was headed for the top spot before the injury. Next year, it’ll be his.
2. Shea Langeliers: I think the power and home park are about even with Goodman, but I trust Langeliers’ plate approach just a bit more.
3. Hunter Goodman: I think there will be slight regression based on his contact profile and strikeout rates. The power might also dip closer to 35 home runs.
4. William Contreras: As steady as they come. May lack the upside of these top three, but the consistency is there.
5. Gabriel Moreno: Can he pop 15 home runs again? I think it’s entirely possible, but I don’t think there is more in the tank there.
6. Ivan Herrera: He’s catcher eligible, but this may be the last season for that. His DH role will give him tons of at-bats, and the power is a real asset.
7. Cal Raleigh: Yes, 2026 was a terrible year, but he also had a 14% barrel rate and still has 75 mph bat speed. The power is going to come back, but the 2025 average won’t.
8. Dillon Dingler: Dingler was tremendous in 2026 and is another 25+ home run catcher who will hit .240. The lineup around him is fine, which will limit the counting stats.
9. Carter Jensen: Oh, hey, did you say 25+ home runs with a .240-ish batting average? How about also in a bad park for hitters? The 28% strikeout rate isn’t ideal.
10. Ryan Jeffers: He was having a tremendous year before the injury. Had 368 plate appearances, but will they let him play as much as he was on pace to?
11. Samuel Basallo: Mentioned him above as a breakout. Could be another one of those 25+ home run catchers with a .240-ish average.
12. Will Smith: Limited to 276 plate appearances in 2026, but I don’t think he’s washed. He’ll be good for 450 plate appearances in one of the league’s best lineups.