The United States men’s national team slipped up for the first time this World Cup and looked like they’d never conceived failure as a possibility, playing a baffled 90 minutes where their stars didn’t shine and their wizard lost his magic touch.
In short, Mauricio Pochettino’s Yanks picked a bad time to play their worst game in a long time... or at least since the last time they played Belgium.
MORE — USMNT 1-4 Belgium recap | Player ratings
Individual errors and legacy-challenging performances abounded throughout a 4-1 loss to Belgium in the Round of 16 that leaves the USMNT in a sad and strange position coming out of the 2026 World Cup on home soil.
Their weaknesses and depth were exposed on numerous occasions by a Belgium side who roasted the American defense while keeping Jeremy Doku and Kevin De Bruyne on the bench to start the game.
This generation may still turn out to be golden but the jeweler’s loupe is getting a real workout at the moment. The future remains bright and there will be time to discuss that, but pulling out the polish tonight is so unnecessary and, honestly, a massive eye roll.
So what went wrong for Pochettino and the Yanks in Seattle?
Stars don’t shine as isolated Pulisic hurts himself
It’s going to sound cruel to Christian Pulisic given the calf injury he suffered during this tournament, but Clint Dempsey’s seat on the throne as the best USMNT ever player in history got a lot more comfortable this summer.
Pulisic at 27 has 33 goals and 23 assists in 91 caps. He’s a fantastic player and an all-time great for the program. Now that we’ve got that out of the way, he was oh-so-poor well before he left this game through injury, forcing dribbles into traffic and cutting an isolated figure on one side of the field.
He managed an assist against Paraguay but exits this tournament with one goal and three assists in his last 14 caps, all but two of which were against non-CONCACAF competition. In club play, he hasn’t scored in 19-straight appearances. He even skipped last summer’s Gold Cup with a new manager to be ready for this tournament. That seemed to work as he started last club season in red-hot form only to turn ice cold for the better part of 2026.
He’ll be back and do great things in the shirt, and Pulisic was hardly the only star to have his worst game at the worst time. Weston McKennie frustrated with several loose passes to thwart possession and won just 1-of-7 duels. Sergino Dest was a mess in the first half aside from a few incisive dribbles.
Outside of Malik Tillman and Tyler Adams, the big names were either quiet or the wrong kind of loud.
Pochettino’s positional blind spot
While Pochettino nailed a lot of things for this tournament including the rotated lineup against Turkiye, there are a few things we assume he’d take back if given the chance to do it all over again.
The midfield was good for most of the tournament but so much of that was led by Tyler Adams doing so many jobs in order to free up Malik Tillman and Co. to do more attacking duties.
This was the first time they faced a strong midfield and Adams had to deal with an electric, in-form Youri Tielemans. McKennie was sloppy and a bit scattered in the first half, and they needed a bit more steel and solidity in the middle of the park. The problem is Pochettino didn’t have that in the team and part of that was his fault. Yes, Johnny Cardoso was injured and a big miss but Tanner Tessmann was the sort of force that could give Adams a proper hand in a game like this.
He also seemed insistent on Ricardo Pepi as the only possible game-changer up top behind Balogun despite Haji Wright and Timothy Weah’s histories in the shirt. He may’ve fallen out with Weah — unless there’s a hidden injury — whose usage was a real question mark. Pochettino did a lot more right than wrong, but his decisions on Monday were strange and did not come out in the wash.
Goalkeeper, back depth fears exposed at the worst time
Matt Freese isn’t the reason the United States lost this game, and he’s not a bad goalkeeper, but the Yanks have now gone a dozen years without an elite goalkeeper between the posts. It’s coincidental that this 4-1 loss to Belgium came 12 years after Tim Howard stood on his head just to take the Belgians to extra time in a historic performance.
When the keeper isn’t elite, he needs help from his backs. Tim Ream is the team captain and it’s difficult to say there was another back who should’ve been starting over him — Auston Trusty has the best shout — after the Turkiye game showed big worries for the other men behind Chris Richards, but Ream had a rough game Monday. And even Richards eventually slipped into big mistake mode on Romelu Lukaku’s final goal.
Presuming Noahkai Banks doesn’t have a change of heart regarding the U.S. versus Germany debate, the answers aren’t clear beyond further development for Richards and fullback Alex Freeman. A keeper can always come out of left field but at the moment there’s no obvious answer at the position, either.
This group of midfield and forwards will get the team to another World Cup. What happens behind them in the next few years will dictate whether they can compete for another group.
