Daniel Lynch allows one run in no-decision Tuesday

Lynch tossed a scoreless first inning, then gave up a two-run homer to Angel Martínez in the second. Lynch would go on to pitch into the fourth, departing with one out at 70 pitches while collecting three strikeouts. The 29-year-old left-hander will take a 3.06 ERA, 1.05 WHIP, and a 46/19 K/BB ratio across 61 2/3 innings into a start against the Blue Jays in Kansas City on Friday.

Lynch struck out two and walked one as he built up to 59 pitches. This was his fourth start since joining the rotation. He pitched into the fifth after totaling four innings last time out. The 29-year-old began his career as a starter but performed better after shifting to the bullpen in recent years. For most of 2026, he was the team’s best reliever but only got one save. Perhaps that’s because a return to the rotation was the plan all along. He’s set to pitch on the road against the Guardians next time out.

All three runs came off long balls allowed by Lynch; a solo shot by Mookie Betts and a two-run blast by SHohei Ohtani. The southpaw gave up just one other hit and struck out three, but it’s another unimpressive start for the 29-year-old. It’d be a mistake to trust him as a streamer for a scheduled start against the A’s next week.

Lynch pitched a scoreless first inning, but after retiring the first two batters he faced in the second inning, he would allow the next four batters he faced to reach base and was credited with allowing four earned runs when all was said and done. Lynch would see two of those runs come across to score on an RBI double by Pete Crow-Armstrong, with the other two coming across to score after Seiya Suzuki singled off Jose Cuas. This was Lynch’s first start of the season and just his sixth start since 2024. If he gets another turn, he would be scheduled to start on Wednesday on the road against the Dodgers, which may not go much better than what we saw today.

MLB.com’s Anne Rogers reports that this is part of a larger chance the Royals are giving Lynch to earn a spot in the rotation. The left-hander was a starter in the minors, but his own injuries and other free agent signings have pushed him to the bullpen, where he has a 1.96 ERA in 46 innings. He has a career 18.5 percent strikeout rate and has thrown more than one inning just tiwce since May 15th, so we wouldn’t get your hopes up for much fantasy value in his first few starts.

We assumed Erceg would be down today after throwing 32 pitches and giving up three runs with a five-run lead in Sunday’s game. The Royals had other ideas. To be fair, Erceg didn’t give up one hard-hit ball today, Two of the singles actually left the bat at less than 40 mph, and the lone extra-base hit, a double from Jazz Chisholm Jr., might have been handled by a better first baseman than Salvador Perez (he’d just replaced Vinnie Pasquantino after Pasquantino was removed for a pinch-runner). With any luck, this probably would have been a clean inning for Erceg. Still, Erceg just isn’t a very good reliever at the moment, what with his 18/13 K/BB in 21 1/3 innings. Daniel Lynch IV, who worked a scoreless eighth today, might be asked to take over in the ninth for now.

Lynch struck out three of the four. Lynch was only the choice to close today because both Lucas Erceg and Matt Strahm had pitched the last two days, but he’s been the Royals’ best reliever this season. He still might wind up being interesting in fantasy leagues if Carlos Estévez fails to return to form.

Erceg walked Gunnar Henderson on seven pitches, only to pick him off afterwards. Another walk and a groundout followed. Facing Pete Alonso, Erceg got ahead 1-2 but walked him after a couple of borderline check-swings weren’t called. Samuel Basallo then singled to tie the game. Erceg’s stuff is down a notch this year, but he actually had great velocity tonight, throwing 1-1.5 mph than his season averages. Still, he certainly can’t afford to walk batters like this when he’s just not getting many strikeouts. This might open the door for Matt Strahm and/or Daniel Lynch IV to receive save chances.

The former starter had a solid year out of the bullpen in Kansas City, pitching to a 3.06 ERA, 1.36 WHIP, and 45/25 K/BB ratio in 67 2/3 innings. The command will need to get better if Lynch is going to repeat that in 2026, but there is some upside with the 29-year-old in the bullpen.

Lynch returns to Kansas City’s bullpen mix following a one-month absence due to nerve irritation in his left elbow. The 28-year-old former starter has posted a respectable 2.59 ERA, 1.42 WHIP and 29/22 K/BB ratio across 41 2/3 innings (39 appearances) this season.