Philadelphia Eagles
Given the recent talk about the medical care provided to NFL players (I’ll now wonder whether any “calf” injury is actually a blood clot), more attention will be paid to whether the practices match the principles that were stridently articulated earlier this week by chief medical officer Allen Sills.
“The notion that there’s external factors that any of our physicians would put a player in harm’s way -- that’s nonsense,” Sills said, among other things, in defending the handling of Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts in London nearly two weeks ago.
The realities of professional football introduce plenty of external factors that make the situation necessarily and inherently different than the usual patient-care scenario.
Last night, for example, Bears running back D’Andre Swift took a helmet to the knee while being tackled during the first quarter against the Patriots. Swift immediately was in pain. He got up and limped off the field.
Not long after that, Prime Video cameras provided a closeup view of Swift’s knee. The impact had ripped a large hole in his pants, and blood was plainly visible on his skin. While he wasn’t bleeding profusely, Swift was definitely bleeding.
Prime Video sideline reporter Kaylee Hartung explained that Swift had received no medical attention on the sideline.
That’s unusual, to say the least. Cuts are addressed, in order to stop and/or conceal the bleeding. The player’s blood becomes a potential biohazard for others. The exposed wound puts the player at risk of external contamination.
In this specific case, the doctors on the sideline provided no treatment to Swift. While it’s possible he refused it, the disposition of the player-patient is one of the obvious “external factors” that can compromise care. The patient, in that setting, can at times be uncooperative.
Sills opened the door to this kind of scrutiny, through his insistence that no football factors (such as the player wanting to play, the team wanting him to be available, and the team and the league hoping to justify the decision not to revise the injury report, which included no suggestion that Hurts possibly wouldn’t play) never influence any medical decisions.
We all know that the context makes the medical care given to NFL players different. The still-unanswered questions regarding the treatment and advice given to Hurts flows from the basic recognition that a doctor who is disconnected from the shared urgency to play should have final say over whether the player will be permitted to take the field with a potentially serious health condition.
Those questions shouldn’t be shouted down or ignored. Swift’s case is a reminder of the dynamic that can lead to certain situations where the overriding goal that players will “be available” to play needs to be overridden by a doctor who cares only about the patient and nothing else.
Eagles Clips
On Wednesday, a report emerged regarding significant fines imposed on three head coaches for their interactions with officials. The news that the league dinged Patriots coach Mike Vrabel, Jets coach Aaron Glenn, and Eagles coach Nick Sirianni for $250,000 each lacked details about the behavior that caused it and the specific conditions that would keep the penalties, which reportedly are being held in abeyance, from being enforced.
Two of the coaches spoke to reporters on Thursday. Not much light was shed on the situation in either case.
“I won’t get into my conversations with the league,” Sirianni said when asked whether the fine was for a specific incident or something more general. “I try to keep everything player related, as far as my conversations with players, in-house. Not try, I do. Same with conversations with the league, same with conversations with the referees association. I’ll just keep that at that.”
He was then asked whether his approach to officials has changed in his tenure as a head coach.
“You are in constant growth,” Sirianni said. “I truly believe that I’ve been in constant growth there in maturity in every phase. You’re trying to get better as a coach on a daily basis. I’m always trying to get better as a human being, as a Christian, as a father, as a husband, as a son on a daily basis. I know that things don’t happen overnight, and there are times where you ‘relapse,’ to say, and you have a moment that you want back. But I can truly see growth, and that happens because, again, my faith. That happens, again, because of the people I have around me. I want to continue to grow as a person and as a coach, but that doesn’t mean we’re perfect. We all fall and it’s about how you get back up.”
That still leaves us with nothing regarding what they said or did to trigger the fines. Which creates the impression that it was more of a warning shot by the league aimed at getting all coaches to go easier on the officials. The fact that Sirianni expressly referenced the NFL Referees Association lends credence to the idea that it’s part of a broader effort to elevate the discourse.
Vrabel wasn’t specifically asked about the fine after Thursday night’s 30-24 loss to the Bears. In response to the last question of the press conference, he was asked about one of the calls made during the game.
“I’m not in very good favor with the officiating department,” Vrabel said, “so I probably shouldn’t say anything.”
He walked off after that, leaving no opportunity for a follow-up.
Regardless, the issue cries out for more details. Why were they fined? What did they do? What is the standard of behavior for getting the fines rescinded?
Vrabel is next scheduled to talk to reporters on Monday. Perhaps at that point, we’ll get some answers. Ditto for Glenn, who’ll speak after Sunday’s game against the Dolphins.
For now, the only lesson to other coaches is very broad: “Tread lightly.” And maybe that was the entire goal of the imposition of the fines.
Word on Thursday morning was that Eagles running back Saquon Barkley would return to practice and the team’s first injury report ahead of their Monday night game against the Cowboys confirms that he was back on the field.
Barkley was listed as a limited participant after missing the last couple of weeks with an ankle injury. Barkley is reportedly on track to play against Dallas, but he stopped short of making any guarantees.
“I would love to play Monday night. I would be doing myself a disservice to sit here and say Monday night I’m guaranteeing myself to play. I do know I have all trust in the trainers,” Barkley said, via Tim McManus of ESPN.com. “To be honest, I was trying to go last week. It sounded great in my head and then you sit and you’re like, maybe they were right. But I’m happy to have the opportunity to go out there and test it and God willing continue to trend in the right direction throughout the week and to be able to go and play Monday night.”
Defensive back Michael Carter (abdomen), tight end Dallas Goedert (knee), guard Willie Lampkin (illness), wide receiver DeVonta Smith (hamstring), linebacker Nolan Smith (concussion), and wide receiver Dontayvion Wicks (ankle) were out of practice for the Eagles.
Guard Landon Dickerson (knee, pectoral), linebacker AJ Epenesa (back), linebacker Jonathan Greenard (ankle), linebacker Jalyx Hunt (knee, ankle), center Drew Kendall (knee), defensive tackle Moro Ojomo (abdomen), and guard Tyler Steen (shoulder) joined Barkley as limited participants.
Linebacker Zack Baun (shoulder), cornerback Jakorian Bennett (knee), wide receiver Marquise Brown (ankle), tight end Grant Calcaterra (back), linebacker Jihaad Campbell (wrist), defensive tackle Jalen Carter (wrist), wide receiver Britain Covey (shoulder), defensive tackle Jordan Davis (shin, thumb), linebacker Arnold Ebiketie (shoulder), and tight end Eli Stowers (quad) were all listed as full participants.
The Eagles continue to make coach Nick Sirianni available for regular press conferences. He continues to say as little as possible about the Jalen Hurts situation.
On Thursday, Sirianni was asked whether he agrees with the NFL Players Association seeking a full investigation of the handling of the situation.
“Guys, I’m not going to go into any of that,” Sirianni said. “I respect your question. Obviously, I understand that everybody has questions about this, and I care deeply about Jalen and I want -- his wellbeing is first and foremost, but really, I’m here to talk about the Cowboys and our team in this week of practice.”
Hey, at least the reporters tried. That said, they had an opportunity o Wednesday to get some answers from offensive coordinator Sean Mannion on collateral questions relating to the Hurts situation, but didn’t.
Mannion was asked a couple of Hurts questions regarding his role in assisting Tanner McKee.
“He’s been around, and I know -- Just speaking on the Jalen thing, obviously, just want him to get healthy and just care for the guy and the work that he puts into our team each and every week,” Mannion said. “Certainly, want him to continue to be around and be a positive impact for us while he’s getting himself healthy. That’s the ultimate priority. He was around last week, and I know he’s tackling the health stuff he’s got going on, but he’ll still be a big positive impact anytime he’s around the team.”
Although the Eagles are committed to citing patient privacy when asked about Hurts’s condition (despite the fact that his entire diagnosis has been disclosed via multiple statements), there were areas on which Mannion may have helped shed useful light.
When did you find out Jalen had been taken to the hospital?
Did players ask you about Jalen’s trip to the hospital?
After Jalen went to the hospital, did you believe there was a chance Jalen wouldn’t play the game in London?
Did you at any point begin getting Tanner McKee ready to play?
When did you know Jalen would definitely play?
For how long did you not know whether Jalen would be available?
While unrelated to the diagnosis, treatment, or prognosis, specific questions about Mannion’s knowledge, impressions, and actions relating to the preparation of McKee would shed light on the failure of the team to downgrade Hurts to “questionable” for the game. Because, certainly, there was a point at which his availability to play was in question.
Mannion also could have been asked when Hurts first complained about issues with his calf, and whether he noticed any limitations to his mobility during practice. Mannion also could have been asked whether the decision to not use the tush push play on fourth and 1 from the Jacksonville 37 was influenced by Hurts’s condition.
The broader question for the organization, as noted by Chris Simms on Thursday’s PFT Live, is the failure of the team to make G.M. Howie Roseman available at any point over the past week to address the situation. He runs the show. He surely is the one person in the best position to answer any and all questions about how it was handled.
Apart from whether the situation was handled properly from a medical and football standpoint, the Eagles have done a poor job of providing meaningful answers to obvious questions. While those questions will be unavoidable in the coming investigation under the CBA, the Eagles apparently have successfully run out the clock as it relates to media inquiries.
Cowboys wide receiver George Pickens popped up on the injury report for the first time this season.
Pickens had a limited practice Thursday with a shoulder injury.
Cornerback Cobie Durant (hamstring), left tackle Tyler Guyton (calf) and outside linebacker Marist Liufau (forearm) were also limited.
The Cowboys practiced without outside linebacker Von Miller (rest), offensive tackle Drew Shelton (hamstring), wide receiver KaVontae Turpin (ribs) and linebacker Dee Winters (calf).
Safety Alijah Clark (hamstring), linebacker DeMarvion Overshown (hamstring) and cornerback Ameer Speed (knee) were full participants.
UPDATE 5:57 P.M. ET: The Cowboys announced that they inadvertently left cornerback Joey Porter Jr. (ankle, full) off their injury report.
The Eagles have signed offensive lineman Evan Neal, according to multiple reports. He presumably will join the practice squad.
Neal practiced with the team Thursday.
The Raiders cut Neal from their practice squad earlier in the week.
The Giants released Neal out of the preseason, and the Raiders signed him soon after.
Neal was not active for any games with the Raiders, and he has not played in a game since 2024.
The Giants selected him seventh overall in the 2022 draft, and he began his career at right tackle. The Giants moved him to right guard, and he did not play a snap there last season.
He ended his Giants career with 29 games played, including 27 starts.
Good news has been in short supply around the Eagles of late, but they got some on the injury front Thursday morning.
Mike Garafolo of NFL Media reports that running back Saquon Barkley is expected to take part in practice later on Thursday. Barkley is believed to be in line to play against the Cowboys on Monday night after missing the last two games with a hamstring injury.
The Eagles have also lost Tank Bigsby and Will Shipley to injuries in recent weeks, which has left them shorthanded in the backfield as they try to snap a losing streak that has stretched to four games.
Barkley has 36 carries for 182 yards and four catches for eight yards so far this season.
The Eagles’ handling of quarterback Jalen Hurts and his blood clot in Week 5 has sparked plenty of criticism of both the team and the league, which has been in lockstep with the team.
And some of that criticism has come from the NFL’s business partners.
The NFL owns 10 percent of ESPN. That hasn’t stopped some at ESPN from offering sharp criticism of the league and the Eagles for the situation. On Wednesday’s First Take, for instance, Chris “Mad Dog” Russo went off on the situation. (Stephen A. Smith and others had sharp criticism of the situation on Tuesday’s show, too.)
“One thing if I may about this whole thing with Hurts, the Eagles did a horrendous job, OK?” Russo said. “And I’m gonna believe the NFL now? That doesn’t have grass fields, that didn’t do anything with CTE until they were forced to. That wants to play an eighteenth game for the safety of the players, when they want to play another game.
“So the NFL now is saying, ‘Well, they didn’t do anything wrong. . . . The Eagles were great with this.’ I don’t trust them. Furthermore, the Eagles throwing Sirianni out there to meet the media. That is ridiculous. I mean, he doesn’t know. I mean, he’s not the — put a trainer out there. Put a team doctor. You made the poor guy answer questions with a hungry media in Philadelphia. That was a disgrace.
“And the NFL can’t sit there and [say] they care about safety. They care about safety, why are we going for an eighteenth game? They add it to a seventeenth game. Here’s the guy that had a blood clot, that got back to the hotel at 3:00 a.m., played the football game, they came back to — flew across the country, came back and said, ‘Well, he’s gonna miss this week against Carolina.’ Then they came back and said, ‘He’s gonna miss four games.’ And then they came back and said, ‘He’s gone for the year.’ That’s ridiculous. . . . Now, come on. Literally, come on.”
The NFL also has a content partnership with The Athletic, posting items from the New York Times subsidiary at NFL.com. That didn’t stop Mike Silver of The Athletic (a former employee of the league who has talked openly about certain subjects being off limits when he worked for NFL Network and NFL.com) from going all-in with his criticism of the Eagles and the league.
“Imagine medically evaluating an employee on an off-site work assignment, subjecting him to well-documented risk factors that could exacerbate the condition — and then having his symptoms worsen to the point where they are potentially life-threatening,” Silver wrote in a column posted on Wednesday.
“Then imagine proclaiming to the world that you are in no way culpable, and that any suggestion that you could possibly have handled the situation differently is an affront to logic and decency. Throw in a touch of indignant condescension, and voila: You are the National Football League.”
Silver specifically targeted Tuesday’s effort by NFL chief medical officer Allen Sills to downplay the situation.
“Now the NFL, whose medical officials were in the loop when Hurts’ initial blood clot was discovered the night before the game, is in full cover-your-ass mode,” Silver wrote. “That’s a curious strategy, given the dots that qualified physicians might connect, made worse by the assertion that none of us — even experts in the field — are qualified to question any of it.”
The secrecy, disguised as “patient privacy concerns” (despite multiple statements that spell out Hurts’s diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis in full detail), has only added to the interest in getting answers.
On Tuesday, Sills insisted that the handling of Hurts was “very conservative, very patient-focused and appropriately guarded in every step.”
Devin McCourty, a 13-year NFL veteran, appearing on Wednesday’s PFT Live (NBC is a broadcast partner but not a business or content partner with the league), raised an excellent question. Wouldn’t a “very conservative, very patient-focused and appropriately guarded” approach to a player who spent most of the prior night in a hospital for diagnosis and evaluation of a blood clot in his leg have resulted in a decision that he should not play a full-contact pro football game hours later?
Seventeen years ago next week, the NFL was forced by Congress to take brain injuries seriously, 15 years after the formation of the decidedly unserious “Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Committee,” which delayed the concussion reckoning for as long as it could. The avoidance of the worst-case scenario as to Hurts has prompted the league to attempt to delay a different sort of reckoning regarding the treatment of serious health conditions not involving the brain.
Fortunately, several of the media companies that are in direct business with the league are resisting the effort to avoid answering fair and tough questions about a lingering culture that could have gotten Jalen Hurts killed.
The NFL and the Eagles hope to run out the clock as to the Jalen Hurts situation, in the hopes that the media and fans will turn their attention to the next story that grabs our collective attention.
It may not be easy, because the issue has gotten the attention of Congress.
Via Tim McManus of ESPN, Senator Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.) has sent a letter to Commissioner Roger Goodell with specific questions about the manner in which the Eagles and the league handled Hurts’s blood clots:
“1. Does the NFL have a league-wide protocol for the detection, prevention, and treatment of [deep vein thrombosis] and [pulmonary embolism]? Which medical guidelines were consulted in developing this protocol?
“2. What standards and processes govern a player’s clearance to participate when a clot is suspected or diagnosed? Does the NFL have a league-wide Return-To-Participation Protocol?
“3. What education is provided to players, athletic trainers, and coaches on how to identify the signs and symptoms of DVT and PE?
“4. What specific measures has the League put in place to reduce blood clot risk, including, but not limited to, those associated with long flights?
“5. Will the League conduct a thorough review of the Eagles’ handling of this specific situation, including who cleared Mr. Hurts to play after staying awake overnight, and cleared subsequent air travel on a transatlantic flight back to the U.S. from London? If so, what is the timeline?”
Someone also should ask whether the league will implement a protocol for blood clots and other potentially serious health conditions, similar to the procedures utilized for diagnosing concussions and clearing players to return to play. The league has used an unaffiliated neurotrauma consultant in such situations for 17 years, in order to counter the inherent biases of doctors hired by the various teams.
The NFL Players Association has requested a full investigation. Under the Collective Bargaining Agreement, it has the absolute right to initiate one. Congress, through its oversight powers as to an industry that enjoys a federal broadcast antitrust exemption, also has the ability to investigate.
Given the league’s effort to sweep this one under the rug and move on, anyone with the power to force the NFL to answer for the Hurts situation absolutely should.
The NFL isn’t messing around when it comes to behavior toward game officials. With an asterisk.
Albert Breer of SI.com reports that the NFL has fined Patriots coach Mike Vrabel, Jets coach Aaron Glenn, and Eagles coach Nick Sirianni $250,000 each for conduct toward game officials.
The discipline may be more performative than substantive. Breer explains that “the fines are in abeyance, meaning they’d be on hold, and could be repealed with good behavior.”
It’s not entirely clear where things stand, and what it would take to avoid the fines. Also, the amounts are borderline cartoonish. In 2012, former Patriots coach Bill Belichick was fined only $50,000 for confronting and grabbing the arm of a replacement official. Recently, 49ers owner Jed York was fined a mere $500,000 to go along with a six-game suspension after a prostitution-related arrest.
These fines seem over the top, especially since the specific behavior that prompted the fines has not been identified.
In Week 4, Vrabel was flagged for his comments to an official after a disputed call. “I told him it was a terrible — I’m not going to say effing — call,” Vrabel said after the game. “I’ve said that 87 times since I’ve been a head coach. It was nothing derogatory. You’d have to ask him. I think he was a little sensitive.”
The league was more than a little sensitive. But it’s not as if the $250,000 will be collected. All in all, it feels like an olive branch to the NFL Referees Association, after a pair of suspensions were imposed on officials for interactions with players in Week 5.