Final Scores
Bowl | Score | MVP |
| 2000 | West 18 -15 | Dominic Robinson |
| 2002 | West 26-6 | Vince Young |
| 2003 | East 47-3 | Chris Leak |
| 2004 | East 45-28 | Ted Ginn Jr. |
| 2005 | West 35-3 | DeSean Jackson |
| 2006 | East 27-16 | Chris Wells |
| 2007 | West 24-7 | Chris Galippo |
| 2008 | East 33-23 | Terrell Pryor |
| 2009 | East 30-17 | Tajh Boyd & Bryce Brown |
| 2010 | West 30-14 | Ronald Powell |
| 2011 | East 13-10 | Demetrius Hart |
| 2012 | West 24-12 | Doral Green Beckham & Cyler Miles |
| 2013 | East 15-8 | James Quick |
| 2014 | West 28-6 | Joe Mixon |
| 2015 | West 39-36 | Derrius Guice |
| 2016 | West 37-9 | Shea Patterson |
| 2017 | East 27-17 | Hunter Johnson |
| 2018 | West 17-16 | Caden Sterns |
| 2019 | East 48-14 | Graham Mertz |
| 2020 | West 33-20 | Bryce Young |
| 2022 | West 34-14 | Rayshon Luke |
| 2023 | East 55-17 | Dante Moore |
| 2024 | West 31-28 | Koi Perich |
| 2025 | West 13-7 | Keisean Henderson |
| 2026 | East 17-14 | Luke Wafle |
