Mock drafting is an invaluable part of the fantasy off-season as it helps gamers hone their art, and think twice about their player valuations when they are put under pressure as the pick timer runs down. Do you stick with the best player available, or resort to picking for roster need? I conducted an IDP mock over the last couple of weeks with some of the fantasy industry’s best and brightest defensive minds (listed below) to tackle some of those difficult questions, especially when you start adding in individual defensive players (IDP).
The league setup was PPR offensive scoring and balanced IDP scoring. Here’s the starting roster: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX, DL, DL, LB, LB, LB, DB, DB and DFLEX. As always, participants deployed several different draft strategies in this mock, so let’s look at how it all broke down.
| Team | Manager | Site(s) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eric Olinger | (Dynasty League Football) | @OlingerIDP |
| 2 | Evan Silva | (RotoWorld) | @EvanSilva |
| 3 | Matt Schauf | (Draft Sharks) | @DraftSharks |
| 4 | Sigmund Bloom | (FootballGuys) | @SigmundBloom |
| 5 | Jene Bramel | (FootballGuys) | @JeneBramel |
| 6 | Jeff Ratcliffe | (PFF) | @JeffRatcliffe |
| 7 | Ross Miles | (RotoWorld/PFF Fantasy) | @RossMilesNFL |
| 8 | Steve Gallo | (The Huddle) | @SteveGalloNFL |
| 9 | Jim McCormick | (ESPN) | @JMcCormickESPN |
| 10 | Gary Davenport | (Fantasy Sharks) | @FantasySharks |
| 11 | Jamey Eisenberg | (CBS) | @JameyEisenberg |
| 12 | Walton Spurlin | (Fantasy Sharks) | @WaltonSpurlin |
Rounds 1-2
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.01 | 1 | Eric Olinger | J.J. Watt | 2.01 | 13 | Walton Spurlin | DeMarco Murray | |
| 1.02 | 2 | Evan Silva | Jamaal Charles | 2.02 | 14 | Jamey Eisenberg | Demaryius Thomas | |
| 1.03 | 3 | Matt Schauf | Rob Gronkowski | 2.03 | 15 | Gary Davenport | Arian Foster | |
| 1.04 | 4 | Sigmund Bloom | Adrian Peterson | 2.04 | 16 | Jim McCormick | Dez Bryant | |
| 1.05 | 5 | Jene Bramel | Le’Veon Bell | 2.05 | 17 | Steve Gallo | Jeremy Hill | |
| 1.06 | 6 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Marshawn Lynch | 2.06 | 18 | Ross Miles | Odell Beckham | |
| 1.07 | 7 | Ross Miles | Julio Jones | 2.07 | 19 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Calvin Johnson | |
| 1.08 | 8 | Steve Gallo | Eddie Lacy | 2.08 | 20 | Jene Bramel | Jordy Nelson | |
| 1.09 | 9 | Jim McCormick | Antonio Brown | 2.09 | 21 | Sigmund Bloom | A.J. Green | |
| 1.10 | 10 | Gary Davenport | LeSean McCoy | 2.10 | 22 | Matt Schauf | Justin Forsett | |
| 1.11 | 11 | Jamey Eisenberg | Matt Forte | 2.11 | 23 | Evan Silva | Alshon Jeffery | |
| 1.12 | 12 | Walton Spurlin | C.J. Anderson | 2.12 | 24 | Eric Olinger | Mike Evans |
Notes: Lots of intrigue early in the draft with J.J. Watt going as the No.1 overall selection. The last few seasons have seen Watt creeping up draft boards, and last year he went in the third round in this very mock, but yet another utterly dominant season over his fellow defensive linemen sets Watt a class apart against his peers and has driven his value skywards. Value-based draft strategies would support the pick, but personally I am on the fence. You need to be a confident drafter with a good handle on offensive depth and sleepers to make up for passing on a running back or wide receiver in round one, so it’s not a strategy for everyone. Watt being the first player off the board wasn’t the only surprise early, as Jamaal Charles was taken second overall by Evan Silva, over Le’Veon Bell and Adrian Peterson who have typically been the first two backs selected, and Rob Gronkowski went third, despite Brady’s suspension still lingering at the time, significantly earlier than his late round one ADP. I made Julio Jones the first receiver taken on the basis that I have nothing between the top-five receivers, and Jones has several plus points such as a nice warm weather, indoor schedule to edge him ahead. I’d have loved to pair him with Arian Foster in the second round, but he went a few picks earlier so I doubled down on receivers in this PPR format by selecting Odell Beckham Jr. The hype train for Justin Forsett in PPR formats continues, as he goes as the 12th running back at 2.10 to Matt Schauf (who took Gronk). I was hoping he’s make it back to me in round three after going WR-WR.
Rounds 3-4
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.01 | 25 | Eric Olinger | Randall Cobb | 4.01 | 37 | Walton Spurlin | Emmanuel Sanders | |
| 3.02 | 26 | Evan Silva | Mark Ingram | 4.02 | 38 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jimmy Graham | |
| 3.03 | 27 | Matt Schauf | Frank Gore | 4.03 | 39 | Gary Davenport | Alfred Morris | |
| 3.04 | 28 | Sigmund Bloom | Andrew Luck | 4.04 | 40 | Jim McCormick | Aaron Rodgers | |
| 3.05 | 29 | Jene Bramel | T.Y. Hilton | 4.05 | 41 | Steve Gallo | Travis Kelce | |
| 3.06 | 30 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Brandin Cooks | 4.06 | 42 | Ross Miles | Jonathan Stewart | |
| 3.07 | 31 | Ross Miles | Lamar Miller | 4.07 | 43 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Kelvin Benjamin | |
| 3.08 | 32 | Steve Gallo | DeAndre Hopkins | 4.08 | 44 | Jene Bramel | Andre Ellington | |
| 3.09 | 33 | Jim McCormick | C.J. Spiller | 4.09 | 45 | Sigmund Bloom | Robert Quinn | |
| 3.10 | 34 | Gary Davenport | Jordan Matthews | 4.10 | 46 | Matt Schauf | Keenan Allen | |
| 3.11 | 35 | Jamey Eisenberg | Melvin Gordon | 4.11 | 47 | Evan Silva | Andre Johnson | |
| 3.12 | 36 | Walton Spurlin | Jeremy Maclin | 4.12 | 48 | Eric Olinger | Carlos Hyde |
Notes: The first two quarterbacks go in rounds three and four, and it is Andrew Luck going before Aaron Rodgers. The industry as a whole is divided between the two and typically once one goes, the other is taken soon afterward. We had the second defensive player taken in round four and it’s another defensive lineman, Robert Quinn. Like elite, every-down running backs, there are only a handful of dominant edge-rushers, so their value is increased by their rarity. Melvin Gordon became the first rookie taken, but went after veteran Frank Gore (RB14) taken by Schauf, who now has popular veteran RB ‘sleepers’ Forsett and Gore on his roster. Gore’s ADP has been steadily rising over the last few months, but Schauf still took him a good round before most. I took my first running back in Lamar Miller in round three but would have been very tempted to pick Brandin Cooks if Jeff Ratcliffe had not selected him directly before me. There are concerns Miller can’t handle, or won’t be given a full workload, especially as he didn’t get over 20 carries in a single game last year, but he still finished as the No.9 RB last year, so has upside if leaned on. I also took my second running back in round four in Jonathan Stewart (RB19). Stewart has only had two seasons of over 200 touches, so relatively few miles on the clock considering he’s a 28-year old veteran. He was the No.14 running back over the final six weeks of the season (99 rushing yards per game) when the Panthers started giving him the majority of snaps and is an intriguing RB2 this year. C.J. Spiller is a very popular pick in PPR leagues with some fantasy analysts suggesting he could record as many as 80 receptions this year. He was the 16th running back taken which is close to his ceiling unless he can supplant Mark Ingram in rushing packages.
Rounds 5-6
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.01 | 49 | Eric Olinger | Luke Kuechly | 6.01 | 61 | Walton Spurlin | Lavonte David | |
| 5.02 | 50 | Evan Silva | Chandler Jones | 6.02 | 62 | Jamey Eisenberg | Amari Cooper | |
| 5.03 | 51 | Matt Schauf | Golden Tate | 6.03 | 63 | Gary Davenport | DeAndre Levy | |
| 5.04 | 52 | Sigmund Bloom | T.J. Yeldon | 6.04 | 64 | Jim McCormick | Ameer Abdullah | |
| 5.05 | 53 | Jene Bramel | Todd Gurley | 6.05 | 65 | Steve Gallo | Martavis Bryant | |
| 5.06 | 54 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Joseph Randle | 6.06 | 66 | Ross Miles | Charles Johnson | |
| 5.07 | 55 | Ross Miles | LeGarrette Blount | 6.07 | 67 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Russell Wilson | |
| 5.08 | 56 | Steve Gallo | Brandon Marshall | 6.08 | 68 | Jene Bramel | Rashad Jennings | |
| 5.09 | 57 | Jim McCormick | Giovani Bernard | 6.09 | 69 | Sigmund Bloom | C.J. Mosley | |
| 5.10 | 58 | Gary Davenport | Julian Edelman | 6.10 | 70 | Matt Schauf | Navorro Bowman | |
| 5.11 | 59 | Jamey Eisenberg | Latavius Murray | 6.11 | 71 | Evan Silva | Allen Robinson | |
| 5.12 | 60 | Walton Spurlin | Joique Bell | 6.12 | 72 | Eric Olinger | Sammy Watkins |
Notes: Typical of most leagues that use defensive players, they started to come off the board with more regularity from round five onwards. Five linebackers and a third defensive end (Chandler Jones) all went during rounds five and six, with Luke Kuechly (LB1) going a full round before Lavonte David (LB2). In leagues that score tackles for loss, David would edge Kuechly, in leagues that don’t, it’s a wash between the pair. Four more rookies come off the board, with T.J. Yeldon one spot before Todd Gurley. Since we drafted there have been reports Gurley is participating in training camp and could play Week 1, making him great value in this spot. His ADP is sure to rise in the coming weeks and he’ll challenge Gordon to be the No.1 rookie selected in redraft leagues. My fifth round pick was LeGarrette Blount, after three running backs (the two rookies and Joseph Randle) went in the picks before me. Blount has been a surprisingly effective runner for the Patriots, as in his last 15 games (since Dec 2013) he has averaged 73 yards a game and one touchdown, which are low-end RB1 numbers in PPR formats, so missing on the upside of the rookies isn’t as big a deal as it first looks. Miller, Stewart and Blount aren’t the most attractive sounding RB corps, but I’m confident they can outperform public perception.
Rounds 7-8
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.01 | 73 | Eric Olinger | Shane Vereen | 8.01 | 85 | Walton Spurlin | Ben Roethlisberger | |
| 7.02 | 74 | Evan Silva | DeSean Jackson | 8.02 | 86 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jarvis Landry | |
| 7.03 | 75 | Matt Schauf | Bobby Wagner | 8.03 | 87 | Gary Davenport | Peyton Manning | |
| 7.04 | 76 | Sigmund Bloom | Justin Houston | 8.04 | 88 | Jim McCormick | Mike Wallace | |
| 7.05 | 77 | Jene Bramel | Roddy White | 8.05 | 89 | Steve Gallo | Jamie Collins | |
| 7.06 | 78 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Duke Johnson | 8.06 | 90 | Ross Miles | Jason Pierre-Paul | |
| 7.07 | 79 | Ross Miles | Vincent Jackson | 8.07 | 91 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Nelson Agholor | |
| 7.08 | 80 | Steve Gallo | Tevin Coleman | 8.08 | 92 | Jene Bramel | Anquan Boldin | |
| 7.09 | 81 | Jim McCormick | Chris Ivory | 8.09 | 93 | Sigmund Bloom | Eric Decker | |
| 7.10 | 82 | Gary Davenport | Greg Olsen | 8.10 | 94 | Matt Schauf | Doug Martin | |
| 7.11 | 83 | Jamey Eisenberg | Cam Newton | 8.11 | 95 | Evan Silva | Sean Lee | |
| 7.12 | 84 | Walton Spurlin | Martellus Bennett | 8.12 | 96 | Eric Olinger | Isaiah Crowell |
Notes: Through eight rounds none of the fantasy analysts in the draft have utilized the Zero-RB approach, with everyone rostering at least two by this stage. Running a strict Zero RB draft strategy requires you to have utmost confidence and is not recommended for casual drafters. Even here none of the ‘best and brightest’ have tried it, although it was in the back of my mind as I picked Miller, Stewart and Blount. If I was pursuing a Zero RB strategy I’d have been looking at selecting Luck/Rodgers in round three, Graham/Kelce/best WR in round four and more upside receivers in rounds five and six. By the end of round eight only Ratcliffe, Jene Bramel and Jim McCormick have yet to select a defensive player. My first came in round eight, picking Jason Pierre-Paul. Despite his fireworks injury I have JPP in the same tier (albeit now at the bottom) with Robert Quinn and Chandler Jones who went in rounds four and five. Three rounds later Pierre-Paul screamed value when compared to the WR4 and RB4 left on my board.
Rounds 9-10
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9.01 | 97 | Eric Olinger | John Brown | 10.01 | 109 | Walton Spurlin | Telvin Smith | |
| 9.02 | 98 | Evan Silva | Paul Posluszny | 10.02 | 110 | Jamey Eisenberg | Michael Floyd | |
| 9.03 | 99 | Matt Schauf | Steve Smith | 10.03 | 111 | Gary Davenport | Larry Fitzgerald | |
| 9.04 | 100 | Sigmund Bloom | Everson Griffen | 10.04 | 112 | Jim McCormick | Sheldon Richardson | |
| 9.05 | 101 | Jene Bramel | Ezekiel Ansah | 10.05 | 113 | Steve Gallo | Breshad Perriman | |
| 9.06 | 102 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Carlos Dunlap | 10.06 | 114 | Ross Miles | Mychal Kendricks | |
| 9.07 | 103 | Ross Miles | Paul Worrilow | 10.07 | 115 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Karlos Dansby | |
| 9.08 | 104 | Steve Gallo | Calais Campbell | 10.08 | 116 | Jene Bramel | Khalil Mack | |
| 9.09 | 105 | Jim McCormick | Alec Ogletree | 10.09 | 117 | Sigmund Bloom | Greg Hardy | |
| 9.10 | 106 | Gary Davenport | Muhammad Wilkerson | 10.10 | 118 | Matt Schauf | Von Miller | |
| 9.11 | 107 | Jamey Eisenberg | Rob Ninkovich | 10.11 | 119 | Evan Silva | Cameron Jordan | |
| 9.12 | 108 | Walton Spurlin | Cameron Wake | 10.12 | 120 | Eric Olinger | Zach Ertz |
Notes: I timed picking Pierre-Paul just right as 17 players of the players taken in rounds nine and ten were IDPs, including a run of three defensive ends before my selection of Paul Worrilow in round nine. There was an interesting quirk of coincidence when all three Cardinals receivers were taken over these two rounds as well, with John Brown the first off the board, and Michael Floyd went one pick before Larry Fitzgerald. Four game suspensions to Sheldon Richardson (DL12) and Greg Hardy (DL13) couldn’t dissuade Jim McCormick or Sigmund Bloom from taking them higher than their projections suggest. Although they will offer owners a scoring advantage on a points-per-game basis, and be crucial during the fantasy playoffs, their teams will need to draft depth on the defensive line earlier than ideal to cover their absence.
Rounds 11-12
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11.01 | 121 | Eric Olinger | Olivier Vernon | 12.01 | 133 | Walton Spurlin | D’Qwell Jackson | |
| 11.02 | 122 | Evan Silva | Fletcher Cox | 12.02 | 134 | Jamey Eisenberg | Lawrence Timmons | |
| 11.03 | 123 | Matt Schauf | Clay Matthews | 12.03 | 135 | Gary Davenport | Tre Mason | |
| 11.04 | 124 | Sigmund Bloom | Brandon LaFell | 12.04 | 136 | Jim McCormick | Brian Quick | |
| 11.05 | 125 | Jene Bramel | Derrick Johnson | 12.05 | 137 | Steve Gallo | Demario Davis | |
| 11.06 | 126 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Jelani Jenkins | 12.06 | 138 | Ross Miles | Kyle Williams | |
| 11.07 | 127 | Ross Miles | Drew Brees | 12.07 | 139 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Nigel Bradham | |
| 11.08 | 128 | Steve Gallo | Keenan Robinson | 12.08 | 140 | Jene Bramel | Matt Ryan | |
| 11.09 | 129 | Jim McCormick | Kiko Alonso | 12.09 | 141 | Sigmund Bloom | Jordan Cameron | |
| 11.10 | 130 | Gary Davenport | Jurrell Casey | 12.10 | 142 | Matt Schauf | Devonta Freeman | |
| 11.11 | 131 | Jamey Eisenberg | Harrison Smith | 12.11 | 143 | Evan Silva | James Laurinaitis | |
| 11.12 | 132 | Walton Spurlin | Torrey Smith | 12.12 | 144 | Eric Olinger | Matthew Stafford |
Notes: This stage of the draft, as with the previous few rounds, can make or break your season. The balance of offensive and defensive players has shifted towards IDPs as owners look to grab starters rather than offensive bench warmers. Between rounds 9-12, 33 players (69 percent) have been defensive, including 18 linebackers and 14 defensive ends. It’s a careful balance of picking the best player available versus your roster’s need, while also not getting caught short by a run at any particular position. Owners executing a ruthless Zero RB strategy can start striking for their running backs here while other owners are looking elsewhere, and Tre Mason (12.03) and Devonta Freeman (12.10) – the only two backs taken in these four rounds - are typical candidates. Despite talk of the Saints becoming more of a rushing-based offense, I selected Drew Brees in round 11, as the 7th quarterback off the board. I still like Brees as a top-five quarterback this year and it had been three rounds since Peyton Manning had been taken, so he stood out as a value pick. Kyle Williams is one of my favorite IDP sleepers this year and I needed a DL2. 17 defensive ends had already been taken and I wasn’t prepared to wait on him any longer. Harrison Smith was the first defensive back taken, by Jamey Eisenberg at the tail end of round 11.
Rounds 13-14
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13.01 | 145 | Eric Olinger | Eric Kendricks | 14.01 | 157 | Walton Spurlin | Fred Jackson | |
| 13.02 | 146 | Evan Silva | Ryan Shazier | 14.02 | 158 | Jamey Eisenberg | Demarcus Lawrence | |
| 13.03 | 147 | Matt Schauf | Marcell Dareus | 14.03 | 159 | Gary Davenport | Cameron Heyward | |
| 13.04 | 148 | Sigmund Bloom | Kenny Stills | 14.04 | 160 | Jim McCormick | Brandon Marshall | |
| 13.05 | 149 | Jene Bramel | Preston Brown | 14.05 | 161 | Steve Gallo | Jerry Hughes | |
| 13.06 | 150 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Bishop Sankey | 14.06 | 162 | Ross Miles | Morgan Burnett | |
| 13.07 | 151 | Ross Miles | David Cobb | 14.07 | 163 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Kevin White | |
| 13.08 | 152 | Steve Gallo | Ryan Mathews | 14.08 | 164 | Jene Bramel | DeAngelo Williams | |
| 13.09 | 153 | Jim McCormick | Charles Johnson | 14.09 | 165 | Sigmund Bloom | Jerod Mayo | |
| 13.10 | 154 | Gary Davenport | Danny Trevathan | 14.10 | 166 | Matt Schauf | Aaron Donald | |
| 13.11 | 155 | Jamey Eisenberg | Knile Davis | 14.11 | 167 | Evan Silva | Tom Brady | |
| 13.12 | 156 | Walton Spurlin | Corey Liuget | 14.12 | 168 | Eric Olinger | Rueben Randle |
Notes: After taking the first defensive player (J.J. Watt at 1.01), Eric Olinger was also the first to select a defensive rookie, linebacker Eric Kendricks (LB28). Kendricks looks set to take over an every-down middle linebacker role for the Vikings and this is a great spot to grab him. We’ve seen rookie linebackers excel in recent seasons, but taking Kendricks’ upside as a LB3 (he’s an LB2 on Olinger’s roster) could pay dividends. The Tennessee running back duo of Bishop Sankey and David Cobb went back to back in round 13 to Ratcliffe and me, respectively. Both players have their vocal supporters and detractors, and both have been touted as potential breakout candidates. Sankey’s popularity has been rising in recent weeks, but whether either of them can emerge as having fantasy value remains to be seen. Handcuff RBs were in hot order in the previous two rounds, seeing Ryan Mathews, Knile Davis and Fred Jackson all selected as owners look to round out their roster depth in the second half of the draft with upside. The first two DTs came off the board in Marcel Dareus (DL19) and Aaron Donald (DL25). Both are viable, high floor DL2/3s in leagues that combine DTs and DEs.
Rounds 15-16
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15.01 | 169 | Eric Olinger | Darren McFadden | 16.01 | 181 | Walton Spurlin | Antonio Gates | |
| 15.02 | 170 | Evan Silva | Eli Manning | 16.02 | 182 | Jamey Eisenberg | Davante Adams | |
| 15.03 | 171 | Matt Schauf | Tony Romo | 16.03 | 183 | Gary Davenport | Kendall Wright | |
| 15.04 | 172 | Sigmund Bloom | Stephen Tulloch | 16.04 | 184 | Jim McCormick | Michael Bennett | |
| 15.05 | 173 | Jene Bramel | Ndamukong Suh | 16.05 | 185 | Steve Gallo | Ryan Tannehill | |
| 15.06 | 174 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Mario Williams | 16.06 | 186 | Ross Miles | Stephone Anthony | |
| 15.07 | 175 | Ross Miles | Michael Johnson | 16.07 | 187 | Jeff Ratcliffe | DeVante Parker | |
| 15.08 | 176 | Steve Gallo | Geno Atkins | 16.08 | 188 | Jene Bramel | Pierre Garcon | |
| 15.09 | 177 | Jim McCormick | Julius Thomas | 16.09 | 189 | Sigmund Bloom | Vic Beasley | |
| 15.10 | 178 | Gary Davenport | Curtis Lofton | 16.10 | 190 | Matt Schauf | Terrance Williams | |
| 15.11 | 179 | Jamey Eisenberg | Vontaze Burfict | 16.11 | 191 | Evan Silva | David Johnson | |
| 15.12 | 180 | Walton Spurlin | Marques Colston | 16.12 | 192 | Eric Olinger | Jerrell Freeman |
Notes: Those waiting on quarterbacks have started to grab their guy as we see seven taken between picks 14.11 – 17.12, including Silva selecting Tom Brady (QB10) at 14.11, before following up immediately with Eli Manning (QB11) at 15.02. That triggered Schauf to select Tony Romo (QB12) with the next pick. I really like Jene Bramel’s pick of Pierre Garcon in round 16. He’s a player I’d been considering for several rounds, but had gone with roster need in Michael Johnson as an upside DL3 (round 15), and Morgan Burnett screamed value to me in round 14, three rounds after Harrison Smith was taken. Retrospectively defensive backs slipped across the board and it was another four rounds before Reshad Jones and Eric Weddle were selected, who are closely matched with Smith and Burnett, so Garcon, or another offensive player would have been a better selection. Darren McFadden went ten rounds after Joseph Randle, highlighting the huge shift in opinion on who wins out in the battle to be the Cowboys’ No.1 running back.
Rounds 17-18
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17.01 | 193 | Eric Olinger | Roy Helu | 18.01 | 205 | Walton Spurlin | Ryan Kerrigan | |
| 17.02 | 194 | Evan Silva | Danny Woodhead | 18.02 | 206 | Jamey Eisenberg | Charles Sims | |
| 17.03 | 195 | Matt Schauf | Colin Kaepernick | 18.03 | 207 | Gary Davenport | Jay Ajayi | |
| 17.04 | 196 | Sigmund Bloom | Dwayne Allen | 18.04 | 208 | Jim McCormick | Eric Weddle | |
| 17.05 | 197 | Jene Bramel | Kyle Rudolph | 18.05 | 209 | Steve Gallo | Johnathan Cyprien | |
| 17.06 | 198 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Jason Witten | 18.06 | 210 | Ross Miles | Delanie Walker | |
| 17.07 | 199 | Ross Miles | Gerald McCoy | 18.07 | 211 | Jeff Ratcliffe | T.J. McDonald | |
| 17.08 | 200 | Steve Gallo | Philip Rivers | 18.08 | 212 | Jene Bramel | Tyler Eifert | |
| 17.09 | 201 | Jim McCormick | Reshad Jones | 18.09 | 213 | Sigmund Bloom | Dont’a Hightower | |
| 17.10 | 202 | Gary Davenport | Daryl Smith | 18.10 | 214 | Matt Schauf | Terrance West | |
| 17.11 | 203 | Jamey Eisenberg | David Harris | 18.11 | 215 | Evan Silva | Austin Seferian-Jenkins | |
| 17.12 | 204 | Walton Spurlin | Teddy Bridgewater | 18.12 | 216 | Eric Olinger | Thomas Davis |
Notes: At this point you’re generally trying to draft based on roster need, with consideration for value, while people also start grabbing their sleepers they don’t want to miss on. Roy Helu, Charles Sims, Jay Ajayi and Terrance West are all prime examples as players that would have significant value boosts if they inherited a starter’s role through injury or poor play. Those waiting on tight end are also making moves in this last third of the draft, with 12 being selected between rounds 15-19. I grabbed Delanie Walker in round 18 over Austin Seferian-Jenkins after seeing Kyle Rudolph and Jason Witten go in round 17. I selected DT Gerald McCoy as my fourth defensive lineman in round 17 despite not requiring a defensive tackle. He’s got double-digit sack potential, and is a lock to break 40 total tackles, which are DL2 numbers. He gives me a high-floor, safe option versus more risky DL3 Michael Johnson. I love Walton Spurlin’s pick of Teddy Bridgewater (QB16) who I’m hoping takes a step forwards and posts a low-end QB1 season this year.
Rounds 19-20
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19.01 | 217 | Eric Olinger | K.J. Wright | 20.01 | 229 | Walton Spurlin | Charles Woodson | |
| 19.02 | 218 | Evan Silva | Owen Daniels | 20.02 | 230 | Jamey Eisenberg | Matt Jones | |
| 19.03 | 219 | Matt Schauf | Brandon Graham | 20.03 | 231 | Gary Davenport | Damontre Moore | |
| 19.04 | 220 | Sigmund Bloom | Josh Hill | 20.04 | 232 | Jim McCormick | Jacquies Smith | |
| 19.05 | 221 | Jene Bramel | Tyrann Mathieu | 20.05 | 233 | Steve Gallo | Antrel Rolle | |
| 19.06 | 222 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Larry Donnell | 20.06 | 234 | Ross Miles | Zach Brown | |
| 19.07 | 223 | Ross Miles | Sio Moore | 20.07 | 235 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Anthony Barr | |
| 19.08 | 224 | Steve Gallo | Donte Moncrief | 20.08 | 236 | Jene Bramel | Avery Williamson | |
| 19.09 | 225 | Jim McCormick | Sean Weatherspoon | 20.09 | 237 | Sigmund Bloom | James Ihedigbo | |
| 19.10 | 226 | Gary Davenport | Victor Cruz | 20.10 | 238 | Matt Schauf | Eric Berry | |
| 19.11 | 227 | Jamey Eisenberg | Coby Fleener | 20.11 | 239 | Evan Silva | Heath Miller | |
| 19.12 | 228 | Walton Spurlin | Barry Church | 20.12 | 240 | Eric Olinger | Andy Dalton |
Notes: I needed some linebacker depth heading into the final six rounds and was delighted to be able to grab two of my favorites in Sio Moore and Zach Brown. Moore was on pace for a borderline LB1 season before his hip injury, while Brown has put up impressive numbers in limited playing time, and now he is being projected as a three-down inside linebacker. Larry Donnell looks like great value in the 19th round considering he was the TE12 last year and finished the year slow. Rankings become less relevant at this stage of a draft and it’s important to look for upside. Great examples are Victor Cruz, Matt Jones and Eric Berry. Cruz and Berry are returning from long layoffs and are somewhat unknown quantities, but have been top players at the positions before, while Jones has been subject to a large amount of off-season hype.
Rounds 21-22
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21.01 | 241 | Eric Olinger | Landon Collins | 22.01 | 253 | Walton Spurlin | Connor Barwin | |
| 21.02 | 242 | Evan Silva | Bruce Carter | 22.02 | 254 | Jamey Eisenberg | Earl Thomas | |
| 21.03 | 243 | Matt Schauf | Malik Jackson | 22.03 | 255 | Gary Davenport | Da’Norris Searcy | |
| 21.04 | 244 | Sigmund Bloom | Antoine Bethea | 22.04 | 256 | Jim McCormick | Benardrick McKinney | |
| 21.05 | 245 | Jene Bramel | Joe Flacco | 22.05 | 257 | Steve Gallo | Aldon Smith | |
| 21.06 | 246 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Sam Bradford | 22.06 | 258 | Ross Miles | Ha Ha Clinton-Dix | |
| 21.07 | 247 | Ross Miles | Kam Chancellor | 22.07 | 259 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Kenny Vaccaro | |
| 21.08 | 248 | Steve Gallo | Michael Griffin | 22.08 | 260 | Jene Bramel | Calvin Pryor | |
| 21.09 | 249 | Jim McCormick | Cameron Artis-Payne | 22.09 | 261 | Sigmund Bloom | Darren Sproles | |
| 21.10 | 250 | Gary Davenport | Jordan Reed | 22.10 | 262 | Matt Schauf | Dwayne Bowe | |
| 21.11 | 251 | Jamey Eisenberg | Carson Palmer | 22.11 | 263 | Evan Silva | Donte Whitner | |
| 21.12 | 252 | Walton Spurlin | Marvin Jones | 22.12 | 264 | Eric Olinger | Tyvon Branch |
Notes: 11 of the players taken in rounds 21 and 22 were defensive backs, and I took two of them in Kam Chancellor and Ha Ha Clinton-Dix. I’m not worried about having both Packers safeties as both showed they can be productive alongside each other last year, but I do wish I’d have known multiple projected DB1s would still be available in round 21. Hindsight is 20/20 and no draft looks perfect when you look back over your decisions. Truth be told I’d have taken Sam Bradford as a backup QB if Ratcliffe hadn’t sniped me, despite not being a fan of drafting a backup QB or TE in short bench situations. Most leagues only start one QB and one TE, so there are usually plenty of options on the waiver wire, so stack your roster on draft day with upside WRs and RBs, and be ruthless in cutting one of them when you need a bye-week QB or TE during the season.
Rounds 23-24
| Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | Rd | Ovr | Owner | Name | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23.01 | 265 | Eric Olinger | Chris Long | 24.01 | 277 | Walton Spurlin | Theo Riddick | |
| 23.02 | 266 | Evan Silva | T.J. Ward | 24.02 | 278 | Jamey Eisenberg | Rolando McClain | |
| 23.03 | 267 | Matt Schauf | Charles Tillman | 24.03 | 279 | Gary Davenport | Christian Jones | |
| 23.04 | 268 | Sigmund Bloom | Glover Quin | 24.04 | 280 | Jim McCormick | Montee Ball | |
| 23.05 | 269 | Jene Bramel | Jeron Johnson | 24.05 | 281 | Steve Gallo | Sam Barrington | |
| 23.06 | 270 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Prince Amukamara | 24.06 | 282 | Ross Miles | Andre Williams | |
| 23.07 | 271 | Ross Miles | Cody Latimer | 24.07 | 283 | Jeff Ratcliffe | Johnathan Hankins | |
| 23.08 | 272 | Steve Gallo | Charles Clay | 24.08 | 284 | Jene Bramel | Randy Gregory | |
| 23.09 | 273 | Jim McCormick | Leonard Williams | 24.09 | 285 | Sigmund Bloom | Ladarius Green | |
| 23.10 | 274 | Gary Davenport | Jay Cutler | 24.10 | 286 | Matt Schauf | Virgil Green | |
| 23.11 | 275 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jeremy Langford | 24.11 | 287 | Evan Silva | Reggie Nelson | |
| 23.12 | 276 | Walton Spurlin | Rashad Johnson | 24.12 | 288 | Eric Olinger | Corey Graham |
Notes: Entering the final two rounds I’m looking purely for offensive upside at receiver and running back as although I like my top end talent at both positions, my bench is shallow at both positions. Thankfully two second year players in Cody Latimer and Andre Williams were available for me, although I was close to picking Patriots RB James White as a handcuff of sorts for Blount. Williams’ short-yardage potential won me over. Ratcliffe’s selections of Prince Amukamara and Johnathan Hankins also jump out as particularly astute, as both are overlooked for flashier names. Amukamara could be the No.1 fantasy cornerback at the end of the season, while Hankins quietly had 50 total tackles and seven sacks last season in his first as a starter.