Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
NBCSports Header Logo

Breaking down the USMNT break downs

WCup Costa Rica US Soccer

U.S. forward Clint Dempsey, left, is restrained by teammate Michael Bradley, center left, during an argument with Costa Rica defender Kendall Waston (19) during the second half of a World Cup qualifying soccer match, Friday, Sept. 1, 2017, at Red Bull Arena in Harrison, N.J. Keylor Navas (1) looks on during the argument. Costa Rica won 2-0. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)

AP

There’s a frightening trend for the United States men’s national team, one that hasn’t been a conversation point for the team for some time.

This team is showing a distressing need for frequent wake-up calls.

The U.S. men earned their status as darlings of their fans by succeeding in the face of underdog status. Sometimes, it was the result of favorable draws and results -- see the fun 2002 World Cup run.

Other times, a rough group stage was superseded by fortunate math and brave performances in a knockout round, like the 2009 Confederations Cup.

[ MORE: Qualifying scenarios for the USMNT ]

And finally, once it was simply emerging from a perceived Group of Death and getting a Matrix-like performance from your world class goalkeeper.

Maybe some or all of those were cases of dousing garbage in gallons of air freshener -- I’d like to think not -- and two of those examples included prime players from the current crop of Yanks, but they certainly didn’t feel like the roller coaster ride we’re experiencing now.

Keeping in mind that the Yanks needed results on the last day of qualifying to make it to the World Cup as recently as the 2010 edition, did it ever feel like this, so often?

After battering Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 6-0, Jurgen Klinsmann’s Yanks slept through a 0-0 draw in Trinidad and Tobago before losing to Guatemala for the first time in better than two decades. They responded by blowing out Guatemala, SVG, and T&T by a combined score of 14-0 the rest of the way. So it wasn’t about class.

Klinsmann then lost his job after a horrible start to the Hex, one that may still prove to a major part of a historic downfall. It wasn’t even that the Yanks fell to their two main CONCACAF rivals; Klinsmann’s men were outclassed by Mexico at home and embarrassed by Costa Rica on the road. See ya, JK.

[ MORE: Three things from the USMNT’s home loss to Costa Rica ]

WCup Costa Rica US Soccer

Costa Rica forward Marco Urena, left, celebrates after scoring a goal on U.S. goalkeeper Tim Howard, right, during the first half of a World Cup qualifying soccer match, Friday, Sept. 1, 2017, in Harrison, N.J. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)

AP

All of this demanded change, but also circled the players’ names moving forward. Were they subconscious quitters who just wanted a coach fired? Was their underperformance mostly about the coach, or were they simply not that good? Moreover, how would they respond?

Hello, Bruce. And hello another bellying up to the bar to throw down top shelf stuff in front of a rabid group of partiers. In San Jose, the Yanks waxed Honduras to the tune of 6-0. Yay! Much better!

Again, it wasn’t about class.

So what was next? The U.S. was out shot 9-3 in Panama en route to a 1-1 draw, one that felt fine at the time on account of the four points gained, but looks poor in the residue of Friday’s home loss to Costa Rica.

About that second Costa Rica loss: No, the U.S. wasn’t totally outplayed, but it sure did look outworked (though to ignore some of the worst own- and middle-third passing decisions would be criminal). The word ‘entitled’ even comes to mind, like a team that is ready to buy into its own hype after generating even a marginal amount.

So what’s wrong, overall? The answers from the Internet come from every direction, some grasping at straws, some looking at the minutia, and others going meta. I’ve even read the rationale that the American “pay to play” structure is to blame, with kids being told they are the best players ever by youth clubs desperate to stop each kid’s parents thousands of annual dollars from moving across town. That’s a talk for another day, an embarrassing one that probably doesn’t equate to the national team’s struggles.

But there’s definitely something about mentality here, especially as CONCACAF watches Mexico just go out and win qualifiers. El Tri isn’t free from flaws and its coach has been under fire, but it won its first five matches of the fourth round and conceded just once. It’s conceded just twice in the Hex, and once was on a Michael Bradley bomb. Part of this certainly has to do with the fact that Mexico’s most impactful defensive forces in this generation are really strong (By the way, Mexico was without mighty Hector Moreno and a number of other recognizable names like Miguel Layun and Marco Fabian. They beat Panama).

There’s also a problem the U.S. has had for a long, long time aside from DaMarcus Beasley’s best days: the left side. Thanks to the good people at CONCACAF.com, let’s take a look at how CONCACAF is coming at the U.S. in World Cup qualifiers:

USMNT 1-2 Mexico

USA - Mexico

Costa Rica 4-0 USMNT

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.45.15 AM

USMNT 6-0 Honduras

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.44.49 AM

Panama 1-1 USMNT

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.57.45 AM

USMNT 2-0 Trinidad and Tobago

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.45.42 AM

Mexico 1-1 USMNT

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.46.05 AM

USMNT 0-2 Costa Rica

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 10.46.26 AM

So aside from the Mexico opener and the Honduras blowout, the tactical idea is to get the ball on the left of the midfield and see what opens up (more or less, the graphics aren’t perfect).

Here’s a bonus heat map from the Gold Cup Final, one of only three matches in the tournament in which the Americans conceded a goal (Jamaica is going right to left).

Screen Shot 2017-09-03 at 11.05.17 AM

It’s probably all of the above in some aspects, but Bruce Arena is not the sort of boss who we should expect to be consistently outfoxed tactically as he was with Darlington Nagbe in the central midfield and Costa Rica just fouling the heck out of the Yanks.

Come Tuesday in Honduras, it’s going to be dirtier, grittier, and filled with desperation. The Yanks, in all likelihood, will respond well. Yet even if they post a 3-0 win and look dominant, this batch of players has proven that we should draw no comfort or expectation that it will continue come October 6 against Panama. That’s just one month away, and that’s scary.

Follow @NicholasMendola