Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
Odds by

IDP Mock Draft

We’ve hit the month of August, and the NFL preseason is underway (nothing pleases the soul quite like awful preseason football in Canton). And that can mean only one thing for fantasy football enthusiasts – draft season is in high swing. Soon preparation and practice will give way (hopefully) to the completion of a successful draft.

For many fantasy owners, the use of mock drafts is an invaluable tool when getting ready to draft their squads. However, that can be easier said than done for those who play in IDP leagues. Mock drafts that include individual defensive players aren’t especially easy to come by.

However, just because you can’t participate in many IDP mocks doesn’t mean you can’t do the next best thing, examine the ones that have occurred, in an effort to spot draft-day trends and potential value plays.

That’s a segue, just in case you didn’t pick up on it.

We’re going to look at recent IDP mock I conducted. It’s a relatively straightforward PPR league. Start one QB, two RB, three WR, one TE and one flex. Six points for all touchdowns. Standard 10/25 split between rushing/receiving yards and passing yards.

The starting lineup on defense consists of two DL, two LB, two DB and one “flex” (which will usually be a linebacker). Defensive scoring is 1.5 points per tackle, 4 points per big play (a fairly common roster setup and tackle-heavy(ish) scoring system). It’s also worth pointing out that it was a short bench (24 roster spots), so with the exceptions of a spare lineman and an extra linebacker the reserve slots (for the most part) were spent on offensive sleepers and depth.

In IDP leagues with a short bench, the smart play on defense is to let the waiver wire serve as your de facto reserves, especially where defensive backs are concerned.

The kicker position was omitted here, but the rule with those is simple – last round. No exceptions. Ever.

Now that we’ve got the scoring and lineup requirements squared away, let’s take a team-by-team look at how things unfolded, especially on the defensive side of the ball.

This is an IDP article after all. You don’t need me to tell you David Johnson can run or that Odell Beckham can catch.

TEAM 1: Johnson, Bryant and Kelce, Attorneys at Law

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.01David Johnson - RB, ARZ13.01Everson Griffen - DE, MIN
2.12Dez Bryant - WR, DAL14.12Ben Roethlisberger - QB, PIT
3.01Travis Kelce - TE, KCC15.01Jarrad Davis - ILB. DET
4.12Terrelle Pryor - WR, WAS16.12Carson Wentz - QB, PHI
5.01Ameer Abdullah - RB, DET17.01Jacquizz Rodgers - RB, TBB
6.12Kelvin Benjamin - WR, CAR18.12Taylor Gabriel - WR, ATL
7.01Doug Martin - RB, TBB19.01Thomas Davis - OLB, CAR
8.12C.J. Prosise - RB, SEA20.12Eric Berry - S, KCC
9.01Jamie Collins - OLB, CLE21.01T.J. Ward - S, DEN
10.12Jordan Matthews - WR, PHI22.12Jason Witten - TE, DAL
11.01Olivier Vernon - DE, NYG23.01Mario Addison - DE, CAR
12.12Jatavis Brown - OLB, LAC24.12Devontae Booker - RB, DEN

It rather pains me to say this about a team drafting with the advantage of going first, but I like this team. Really like it. It’s a squad that features arguably the best running back (David Johnson) the best tight end (Travis Kelce) and a solid defensive roster. That last part is made all the more impressive by the fact this team didn’t take a defensive player until the first pick of the ninth round. It just goes to show something I tell people all the time; you don’t have to set the pace at the defensive positions to walk away from your draft with a competitive roster.

IDP Pro Tip: In 2017, I’m a proponent of aggressively attacking the defensive line, which is easily the shallowest of the defensive positions. This team did that and then some by locking up a pair of top-10 bookends in Olivier Vernon of the New York Giants and Everson Griffen of the Minnesota Vikings.

TEAM 2: For Whom the Bell Toils

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.02Le’Veon Bell - RB, PIT13.02Cameron Jordan - DE, NOS
2.11DeAndre Hopkins - WR, HOU14.11Darren Sproles - RB, PHI
3.02Brandin Cooks - WR, NEP15.02Zay Jones - WR, BUF
4.11Carlos Hyde - RB, SFO16.11Muhammad Wilkerson - DE, NYJ
5.02Jordan Reed - TE, WAS17.02Julius Thomas - TE, MIA
6.11Willie Snead - WR, NOS18.11Tony Jefferson - S, BAL
7.02Russell Wilson - QB, SEA19.02Tim Hightower - RB, SFO
8.11C.J. Mosley - ILB, BAL20.11Sean Spence - ILB, IND
9.02LeGarrette Blount - RB, PHI21.02Cole Beasley - WR, DAL
10.11Joe Williams - RB, SFO22.11B.J. Goodson - ILB, NYG
11.02Quincy Enunwa - WR, NYJ23.02Sam Bradford - QB, MIN
12.11Zach Brown - ILB, WAS24.11Malcolm Jenkins - S, PHI

This is, at first glance, a similar squad to Team 1, and quite possibly a better one. Waiting until the back end of the eighth round to take their first IDP allowed them to load up at the offensive positions. I don’t like the Front 7 IDP options quite as much as the prior team, but C.J. Mosley and Zach Brown should both be consistent weekly starters, while the duo drafted after them both offer some upside as “sleepers.” If there’s a weakness here, it’s at tight end if Jordan Reed can’t stay healthy, but such is the risk involved in drafting the Washington star.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Both B.J. Goodson of the New York Giants and Sean Spence of the Tennessee Titans have appeal as late-round fliers who could demolish their relatively modest draft-day asking price, if they can lock down the three-down role they are expected to.

TEAM 3: AB and the Risk/Reward Brigade

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.03Antonio Brown - WR, PIT13.03Jamaal Williams - RB, GBP
2.10Rob Gronkowski - TE, NEP14.10Sterling Shepard - WR, NYG
3.03J.J. Watt - DE, HOU15.03Kiko Alonso - OLB, MIA
4.10Ty Montgomery - RB, GBP16.10Philip Rivers - QB, LAC
5.03Larry Fitzgerald - WR, ARZ17.03Fletcher Cox - DT, PHI
6.10Danny Woodhead - RB, BAL18.10Derrick Johnson - ILB, KCC
7.03Brandon Marshall - WR, NYG19.03Marqise Lee - WR, JAX
8.10Terrance West - RB, BAL20.10Haason Reddick - ILB, ARZ
9.03Marcus Mariota - QB, TEN21.03Kenny Vaccaro - S, NOS
10.10Samaje Perine - RB, WAS22.10Dwayne Allen - TE, NEP
11.03Navorro Bowman - ILB, SFO23.03Kam Chancellor - S, SEA
12.10Marvin Jones - WR, DET24.10Michael Bennett - DE, SEA

All I can say is wow; This is a fantasy owner who enjoys living on the edge. From the pick of New England Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski in Round 2 to Houston Texans’ defensive end J.J. Watt a few picks later to San Francisco 49ers’ inside linebacker Navorro Bowman in the 11th, the front half of the draft was absolutely loaded with risk/reward picks for this team. Bowman isn’t even the only veteran linebacker coming off a major injury being counted on as a weekly starter here; Derrick Johnson is 33 and coming off an Achilles tear.

IDP Pro Tip: I get asked a lot about a good time to target Watt, who has the potential to be the most dominant fantasy asset in the game. It’s hard question to answer without knowing an individual league’s parameters, but in this scoring format, early in Round 3 is likely about the soonest I’d consider it.

TEAM 4: The Rookie Back Brigade

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.04Odell Beckham - WR, NYG13.04Adam Thielen - WR, MIN
2.09Leonard Fournette - RB, JAX14.09DeForest Buckner - DT, SFO
3.04Doug Baldwin - WR, SEA15.04Matthew Stafford - QB, DET
4.09Dalvin Cook - RB, MIN16.09Jamal Adams - S, NYJ
5.04Tevin Coleman - RB, ATL17.04James Conner - RB, PIT
6.09Martavis Bryant - WR, PIT18.09Tyrod Taylor - QB, BUF
7.04Bobby Wagner - ILB, SEA19.04Frank Clark - DE, SEA
8.09Deion Jones - ILB, ATL20.09T.J. Yeldon - RB, JAX
9.04Delanie Walker - TE, TEN21.04C.J. Fiedorowicz - TE, HOU
10.09Tyrell Williams - WR, LAC22.09Geno Atkins - DT, CIN
11.04Ryan Shazier - ILB, PIT23.04Ramik Wilson - ILB, KCC
12.09Latavius Murray - RB, MIN24.09Micah Hyde - S, BUF

There’s a lot I like about this team, and not much I don’t. After six rounds of banging away at wide receiver and tailback (well, especially if the rookie tailbacks pay off), this drafter hit the linebacker spot with back-to-back picks, selecting a pair of potential top-five options in Bobby Wagner (Seattle Seahawks) and Deion Jones (Atlanta Falcons). Add in Ryan Shazier of the Pittsburgh Steelers, and you have arguably the finest top three at the position of any squad in the league. Love the wait at quarterback until Round 15 (Matthew Stafford) as well.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Ramik Wilson of the Kansas City Chiefs is flying under the radar in many IDP leagues, but he really shouldn’t be. The 24-year-old appeared to come into his own last season and should start next to the aforementioned Derrick Johnson in 2017.


TEAM 5: Hope Springs Eternal

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.05Julio Jones - WR, ATL13.05Jerrell Freeman - ILB, CHI
2.08Todd Gurley - RB, LAR14.08Ezekiel Ansah - DE, DET
3.05Lamar Miller - RB, HOU15.05Jack Doyle - TE, IND
4.08Sammy Watkins - WR, BUF16.08D’Onta Foreman - RB, HOU
5.05Michael Crabtree - WR, OAK17.05Rishard Matthews - WR, TEN
6.08Eddie Lacy - RB, SEA18.08Harrison Smith - S, MIN
7.05Alec Ogletree - ILB, LAR19.05Denzel Perryman - ILB, LAC
8.08Jeremy Maclin - WR, BAL18.08Carson Palmer - QB, ARZ
9.05Jameis Winston - QB, TBB19.05Charles Sims - RB, TBB
10.08Martellus Bennett - TE, GBP22.08A.J. Klein - ILB, NOS
11.05Jason Pierre-Paul - DE, NYG23.05Dante Fowler - DE, JAX
12.08Thomas Rawls - RB, SEA24.05Tyrann Mathieu - S. ARZ

Just like Team 4, this owner added three receivers and three running backs with the first six picks, although the picks here carry with them a lot more questions. Just as with Todd Gurley and Sammy Watkins, Team 5 will be hoping for a bounce-back year from Detroit Lions defensive end Ezekiel Ansah, who had only two sacks in an injury-marred mess of a 2016 season. This squad also found value with Chicago Bears linebacker Jerrell Freeman in Round 13; The veteran has top-10 upside at a reduced price as the top linebacker for the Bears in 2017.

IDP Sleeper Alert: After four years as Luke Kuechly’s understudy in Carolina A.J. Klein joined the New Orleans Saints in free agency. Not only does the 26-year-old appear to be in line to start, but Klein’s been making the defensive play-calls in Saints camp. That means an every-down role.

TEAM 6: The Elliott Conundrum

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.06Ezekiel Elliott - RB, DAL13.06Keanu Neal - S, ATL
2.07Aaron Rodgers - QB, GBP14.07Christian Kirksey - OLB, CLE
3.06Jarvis Landry - WR, MIA15.06Mike Wallace - WR, BAL
4.07Alshon Jeffery - WR, PHI16.07Brandon Graham - DE, PHI
5.06Mark Ingram - RB, NOS17.06Darren McFadden - RB, DAL
6.07Stefon Diggs - WR, MIN18.07Coby Fleener - TE, NOS
7.06Joey Bosa - DE, LAC19.06Reggie Ragland - ILB, BUF
8.07Paul Perkins - RB, NYG20.07Jeremy McNichols - RB, TBB
9.06Zach Ertz - TE, PHI21.06Nigel Bradham - OLB, PHI
10.07Khalil Mack - OLB, OAK22.07Tavon Austin - WR, LAR
11.06Cameron Meredith - WR, CHI23.06Eric Weddle - S, BAL
12.07Alvin Kamara - RB, NOS24.07Derek Wolfe - DE, DEN

I don’t blame Team 6 for pulling the trigger on Ezekiel Elliott; I’d be hard-pressed to pass on him at this spot too. In addition, by picking up Darren McFadden later on they covered themselves against a potential suspension. I also like the defensive line duo of Joey Bosa and Brandon Graham, who’s undervalued after managing just 5.5 sacks last year. Graham was among the league leaders in total QB pressures though; I’d expect that number to climb in Graham’s second season in Jim Schwartz’s attacking 4-3 scheme in Philly this year. The linebackers could be a weak spot, however.

IDP Pro Tip: The reason those linebackers could be weak (believe it or not) is the reigning Defensive Player of the Year. Khalil Mack is an absolute monster to be sure, but this scoring system doesn’t play to his strengths. Know your scoring, folks.

TEAM 7: Mocking from the Middle

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.07Melvin Gordon - RB, LAC13.07Dak Prescott - QB, DAL
2.06T.Y. Hilton - WR, IND14.06Josh Doctson - WR, WAS
3.07Isaiah Crowell - RB, CLE15.07K.J. Wright - OLB, SEA
4.06Davante Adams - WR, GBP16.06Melvin Ingram - DE, LAC
5.07Kwon Alexander - ILB, TBB17.07Marlon Mack - RB, IND
6.06Bilal Powell - RB, NYJ18.06Darron Lee - ILB, NYJ
7.07DeSean Jackson - WR, WAS19.07Evan Engram - TE, NYG
8.06Donte Moncrief - WR, IND20.06Vince Williams - ILB, PIT
9.07Hunter Henry - TE, LAC21.07Breshad Perriman - WR, BAL
10.06Derek Carr - QB, OAK22.06Ha Ha Clinton-Dix - S, GBP
11.07Matt Forte - RB, NYJ23.07Jahleel Addae - S, LAC
12.06Carlos Dunlap - DE, CIN24.07Emmanuel Ogbah - DE, CLE

I’m not generally a fan of picking in the middle of drafts, especially in a year where prior to the news of a potential Elliott suspension, there was a clear drop-off after the top-six. However, this team did a pretty good job all things considered. Defensively the team was pretty aggressive, taking the first linebacker (Kwon Alexander of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers) in the middle of the fifth. That’s not too early for last year’s highest-scoring player at the position, especially in a tackle-heavy format like this. They also did just fine at defensive back despite waiting until the end to grab their starters, hammering home the fact you can wait in the secondary and still be fine.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Where to begin? The late rounds were an IDP value bonanza for this team. Pittsburgh Steelers inside linebacker Vince Williams, Los Angeles Chargers safety Jahleel Addae and Cleveland Browns defensive end Emmanuel Ogbah all have a decent shot at out-performing their draft slot.

TEAM 8: Cool Brees-es

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.08Mike Evans - WR, TBB13.08Jamaal Charles - RB, DEN
2.05Jordy Nelson - WR, GBP14.05Leonard Williams - DE, NYJ
3.08Joe Mixon - RB, CIN15.08Kevin White - WR, CHI
4.05Drew Brees - QB, NOS16.05Jerry Hughes - DE, BUF
5.08Frank Gore - RB, IND17.08Deone Bucannon - ILB, AZ
6.05C.J. Anderson - RB, DEN18.05Barry Church - S, JAX
7.08Jamison Crowder - WR, WAS19.08Austin Hooper - TE, ATL
8.05Tyler Eifert - TE, CIN20.05Ted Ginn - WR, NOS
9.08Lavonte David - OLB, TBB21.08Ryan Tannehill - QB, MIA
10.05Eric Decker - WR, TEN22.05Kawann Short - DT, CAR
11.08Duke Johnson - RB, CLE23.08Shaq Thompson - OLB, CAR
12.05Benardrick McKinney - ILB, HOU24.05Antoine Bethea - S, ARZ

There’s talent on this team to be sure, whether it’s a rookie like Cincinnati Bengals tailback Joe Mixon or a grizzled veteran like the ageless Frank Gore. Moreover, from a defensive perspective the Leonard Williams/Jerry Hughes duo is solid for a team that didn’t hit that position until the 14th round. Still, the linebacker position for this squad could be a significant area of weakness. Deone Bucannon’s Week 1 availability is very much in doubt, and while Lavonte David remains a great player, the Tampa star is coming off easily the worst statistical season of his career.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Despite tallying 110 total tackles and finishing last year as a top-five fantasy defensive back, Antoine Bethea is going late in drafts after signing with the Arizona Cardinals in the offseason. As dart throws go, you could do a lot worse.

TEAM 9: Tommy Terrific and the Brady-ettes

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.09Devonta Freeman - RB, ATL13.09Aaron Donald - DE, LAR
2.04Amari Cooper - WR, OAK14.04Myles Jack - ILB, JAX
3.09Tom Brady - QB, NEP15.09Jeremy Hill - RB, CIN
4.04Christian McCaffrey - RB, CAR16.04Tyler Lockett - WR, SEA
5.09Tyreek Hill - WR, KCC17.09Avery Williamson - ILB, TEN
6.04Emmanuel Sanders - WR, DEN18.04Karl Joseph - S, OAK
7.09Jimmy Graham - TE, SEA19.09Shane Vereen - RB, NYG
8.04Adrian Peterson - RB, NOS20.04Marcell Dareus - DT, BUF
9.09Corey Davis - WR, TEN21.09Myles Garrett - DE, CLE
10.04Sean Lee - OLB, DAL22.04Blake Bortles - QB, JAX
11.09Jonathan Stewart - RB, CAR23.09Tahir Whitehead - OLB, DET
12.04Reshad Jones - S, MIA24.04David Njoku - TE, CLE

I know I said that I was mainly going to stick to the defenders here, and I will; Sean Lee, Reshad Jones and Aaron Donald are a decent foundation for an IDP team (even if I’m not usually inclined to take any defensive back that early). However, this team serves as a great object lesson in the perils of taking a quarterback too early. Sure, Tom Brady’s a great player who will probably score a lot of fantasy points in 2017. Nevertheless, there’s a price to be paid for hitting the position in Round 3; In this case, it’s a frightening lack of depth at running back.

IDP Pro Tip: There’s no shortage of hype surrounding No.1 overall pick Myles Garrett, and the young defensive end has a bright future. But while it didn’t happen here, Garrett’s also being overdrafted by some folks who don’t understand that rookie years like Joey Bosa had in 2016 are much more exception than rule.

TEAM 10: These Boys Is Shady’s

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.10LeSean McCoy - RB, BUF13.10Rex Burkhead - RB, NEP
2.03Jordan Howard - RB, CHI14.03Eric Kendricks - ILB, MIN
3.10Allen Robinson - WR, JAX15.10John Ross - WR, CIN
4.03Golden Tate - WR, DET16.03Reuben Foster - ILB, SFO
5.10Julian Edelman - WR, NEP17.10Morgan Burnett - S, GBP
6.03Greg Olsen - TE, CAR18.03Cameron Heyward - DE, PIT
7.10Mike Gillislee - RB, NEP19.10Jonathan Williams - RB, BUF
8.03Danielle Hunter - DE, MIN20.03Andy Dalton - QB, CIN
9.10Cam Newton - QB, CAR21.10Sean Davis - S, PIT
10.03Telvin Smith - OLB, JAX22.03Cliff Avril - DE, SEA
11.10James White - RB, NEP23.10Preston Brown - ILB, BUF
12.03John Brown - WR, ARZ24.03Cooper Kupp - WR, LAR

Who says that the days of the old “RB/RB” draft strategy are dead? Not only did Team 10 go that route, but by taking three straight receivers, a tight end and then getting lucky with New England’s Mike Gillislee this squad looks pretty formidable on offense. The defensive haul was good but not great; Minnesota Vikings defensive end Danielle Hunter and Green Bay Packers safety Morgan Burnett are both top-five options at their respective positions, but while Telvin Smith and Eric Kendricks are solid this team lacks a truly elite linebacker.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Unless, of course, rookie Reuben Foster of the San Francisco 49ers winds up breaking out as a rookie in 2017. The 31st overall pick in the 2017 NFL draft has been impressive so far in camp, and you won’t find many IDP LB3 with his upside.

TEAM 11: Luke, I Am Your Father

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.11A.J. Green - WR, CIN13.11Calais Campbell - DE, JAX
2.02DeMarco Murray - RB, TEN14.02Giovani Bernard - RB, CIN
3.11Demaryius Thomas - WR, DEN15.11Johnathan Cyprien - S, TEN
4.02Marshawn Lynch - RB, OAK16.02Von Miller - OLB, DEN
5.11Luke Kuechly - ILB, CAR17.11Robert Woods - WR, LAR
6.02Derrick Henry - RB, TEN18.02Eli Manning - QB, NYG
7.11DeVante Parker - WR, MIA19.11O.J. Howard - TE, TBB
8.02Matt Ryan - QB, ATL20.02Noah Spence - DE, TBB
9.11Kyle Rudolph - TE, MIN21.11Su’a Cravens - S, WAS
10.02Randall Cobb - WR, GBP22.02Kamalei Correa - ILB, BAL
11.11Mark Barron - ILB, LAR23.11Sheldon Richardson - DE, NYJ
12.02Rob Kelley - RB, WAS24.02Byron Jones - S, DAL

After alternating wide receivers and running backs over the first four rounds of the draft, Team 11 rolled the dice on the biggest risk/reward play on defense this side of J.J. Watt in Carolina Panthers middle linebacker Luke Kuechly. When Kuechly’s healthy, he can produce as well (or better) as any player at his position in fantasy football; He led all linebackers in fantasy points per game last season. Still, there’s no denying that a fifth-round pick is a steep price for a defensive player who has missed nine games the past two years with a pair of concussions.

IDP Pro Tip: Patience can sometimes be a virtue with IDPs. Team 11 used their last five picks on defensive players, and got value with just about every one of those selections, especially Washington safety Su’a Cravens and Baltimore linebacker Kamalei Correa.

TEAM 12: Nothing But Bad Luck

PickPlayerPickPlayer
1.12Jay Ajayi - RB, MIA13.12Kirk Cousins - QB, WAS
2.01Michael Thomas - WR, NOS14.01Kenny Britt - WR, CLE
3.12Keenan Allen - WR, LAC15.01Jordan Hicks - ILB, PHI
4.01Andrew Luck - QB, IND16.01Lawrence Timmons - ILB, MIA
5.12Spencer Ware - RB, KCC17.12Ndamukong Suh - DT, MIA
6.01Landon Collins - S, NYG18.01Chris Thompson - RB, WAS
7.12Pierre Garcon - WR, WAS19.12Mike Williams - WR, LAC
8.01Theo Riddick - RB, DET20.01Brandon Marshall - ILB, DEN
9.12Kareem Hunt - RB, KCC21.12Cameron Wake - DE, MIA
10.01Vontaze Burfict - OLB, CIN22.01Akiem Hicks - DE, CHI
11.12Corey Coleman - WR, CLE23.12Jared Cook - TE, OAK
12.01Eric Ebron - TE, DET24.01Eric Reid - FS, SFO

I’m not going to pile on Team 12 for the selection of Andrew Luck in the fourth round; This was a “slow” draft, and at the time the news about the Indianapolis quarterback wasn’t quite as foreboding as it is now. However, despite the fact that Landon Collins was the No. 1 IDP overall last year he plays a position (safety) where there are IDP options aplenty. That’s a pair of players in the first six rounds from deep positions, and it left Team 12 in a bit of a pickle on the defensive line. It’s a much shallower spot, and they don’t have an option I’d be comfortable starting every week.

IDP Sleeper Alert: Team 12’s last pick rather demonstrates what I meant about safeties just now. Eric Reid is moving into the “Kam Chancellor” strong safety role in San Francisco’s 4-3 defense in 2017, a role that brings with it more than a little IDP upside.