Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
Odds by

Nick Saban’s two-year stint as an NFL head coach began in 2005. It could have started eight years earlier.

In a Thursday interview with Chris “Mad Dog” Russo of SiriusXM Mad Dog Radio, Saban admitted — eventually — that the Giants had offered him the head-coaching job after the Giants fired Dan Reeves, when Saban was the head coach at Michigan State.

“It’s very difficult in college, you know, and the NFL, you have an opportunity to go to the NFL, you’re still coaching, you’re still recruiting,” Saban said. “If you stay in college, you don’t want it to upset your coaching and recruiting and all that. So you don’t wanna say that I’m gonna go interview for the Giants job. So [G.M.] George [Young] and I worked out a deal. He said, ‘Well, where do you think we can meet and nobody would know it?’ And I said, ‘The least obvious place you would ever think. Just come to my house in East Lansing and nobody will ever know it.’ That’s what he did.”

In other words, Saban (like plenty of other college coaches over the years) had made various promises that he didn’t want anyone to know he was thinking about breaking, until the moment he decided to do so.

So did the Giants offer him the job in 1997?

“You know, I can’t really remember what we talked about and how we ended up there, but I think Ernie [Accorsi] was assistant general manager then,” Saban said. “And I love Ernie. He was at the Browns when I was there with Belichick. Yeah, they did offer me the job actually.”

Saban obviously didn’t take it. The Giants hired Jim Fassel, who took them to the Super Bowl in 2000.

It’s unclear whether the Giants made another run at Saban after Fassel was fired, after the 2003 season. A year later, Saban took the Dolphins job.

If he’d jumped to the NFL in 1997, Saban would have faced the same issues he did in Miami. The salary cap is the great equalizer, and there’s no way to recruit an annual flock of players who are the equivalent of NFL first-round picks. Saban learned that, at the college level, it’s a lot easier to stack the deck in his favor.


One of the best arguments against the Protect College Sports Act comes from the obvious hypocrisy between placing artificial limits on player compensation and no limits on coach compensation.

There is no argument to justify the disconnect. That hasn’t stopped those trying to limit player freedoms from trying to come up with one.

Former radio host Doug Gottlieb, who has coached the University of Wisconsin Green Bay basketball program to a buyout-worthy record of 22-43 over two seasons, argued last week that “coaches are worth more than players, they just do more.” Right or wrong, that’s not the issue. The issue is whether one group of workers should have their pay limited in the name of “saving” college sports and whether another group should be able to follow the rules of a free marketplace.

Former college football coach Nick Saban, who now works for ESPN and as a political operative aimed at getting the PCSA passed (I’d love to know how much, if anything, he’s getting paid to be a primary face of that effort), tried a similar approach while appearing Tuesday on First Take.

“Well, but these things are totally different markets,” Saban said in response to the clear double standard, via Awful Announcing. “Like, that’s like asking me, does a student’s scholarship equal the professor’s pay? I mean, how much value does a coach create for a university?”

First, let’s get past the “scholarship” bullshit. Student-athletes are no longer students. They’re employees, the same as the coach, the professor, and everyone else who provides services to a university. The actual cost to the school of having another student attend (or not attend) class is no longer relevant to the analysis. For many of the capable players, they’re majoring if anything in football — just don’t ask for the real stats on the placement rate. And with the schools turning their Advanced Football Studies coursework into many millions of dollars, they’re entitled to be paid now, especially since there’s a small chance of being paid later.

Second, Saban still avoids the issue. For players, capping their pay is supposedly necessary to “saving” the entire collegiate sports system. For coaches, it continues to be “grab what you can while you can.”

Saban then pivoted to the question of coaching buyouts, which also have gotten out of control. With, for some reason, no effort to get Congress to intervene.

“You know, rather than worry about amount of money people make,” Saban said, “I think the thing that has been difficult is when coaches get fired, and they have these huge buyouts. And everybody says, ‘Well, how can the university afford to pay him that?’ I think you can figure out, OK, you can’t have any more than a five-year contract or whatever it is. And maybe the buyout can only be so much. But I think that’s maybe a better way to approach it than try to make these two things — they’re different markets, you know? Players’ market’s different than coaches’ market.”

Whether Saban realizes it or not, he’s admitting to the existence of a disconnect by conceding that a certain type of limit should be placed on coaching compensation. He’s just suggesting something that doesn’t limit the pay a coach receives. He wants to limit the amount the coach would be owed if/when the school decides to fire one coach and hire another.

From player pay to professor pay to coaching pay to coaching buyouts, there are business decisions that every university must make in a way that balances the budget. In the past, the administrators were able to do that with a line item for “player compensation” that was $0.00. Now, it’s harder to balance the budget. They still should be expected to do it.

The issue isn’t chaos created by players being allowed to participate in capitalism. It’s chaos created by mismanagement. Schools make purchases they can’t afford, when it comes to the revenue-generating sports programs — especially since those programs are required for some reason to subsidize the non-revenue-generating sports.

This shouldn’t be a political issue. It should be a “hire better businesspeople” issue. Businesspeople who know how best to generate maximum revenue and to carve it up responsibly. How to restrain themselves from pulling out all the stops to attract the next shiny object, player or coach, in the hopes of earning even more revenue.

The entire effort to cap player pay cuts against the supposed American ideal that stands for two simple words: Get paid. Given that one side is very well organized and funded and that the other is disorganized and voiceless, the effort to turn freedom on its head has had success in the Senate. Here’s hoping that the House of Representatives takes the basic concepts of U.S. financial liberty a little more seriously than 77 Senators have.


The age of bet! bet! bet! has forced college conferences to implement injury reports. But, of course, college coaches are going to do college-coach things.

This week, LSU’s Lane Kiffin played an apparent game with the requirement that multiple reports be issued. Quarterback Sam Leavitt went from “doubtful” on Wednesday to “questionable” on Thursday to off the injury report on Friday night.

And while the College GameDay desk yukked it up about Lane being Lane, there’s a difference between one coach playing games with the other coach and deliberate falsehoods being perpetrated on the betting public. How many people put money on Ole Miss by taking “doubtful” to mean for LSU what “doubtful” usually means when used in the NFL context?

The next question is whether the SEC will shrug at the apparent shenanigans. By rule, fines for inaccurate reports range from $25,000 to $100,000.

Violations of the injury-reporting rules typically come from programs failing to properly disclose actual injuries. In this case, Lane may have lied about Leavitt in order to force Ole Miss to spend time preparing for Leavitt’s understudy.


Football’s equivalent of the Joker returns to Gotham City on Saturday, when coach Lane Kiffin’s LSU team plays at Ole Miss, the program he ditched during a playoff season.

College GameDay is on the scene. And the “fuck Lane Kiffin!” chant came early. (A preview of it happened during SportsCenter, when Stanford Steve did a quick segment from the scene in Oxford.)

There’s not much ESPN can do about that. And, in this day and age, it’s no longer as jarring as it used to be to hear “F” bombs on live TV.

But it’s a snapshot of the vitriol Kiffin will be facing all day and all night when he faces a school that had its best chances ever to chase a championship — and that he abandoned before the job was finished.

And so the man at the center of the effort to remove the so-called “chaos” in college football will be dealing with a different kind of chaos until the game ends and Kiffin exits the playing field.

Meanwhile, here’s hoping someone explains to Kirk Herbstreit why Kiffin is being booed. Because even Kirk’s dog understands that one.


I said it this week on PFT Live. And I’ll say it again now.

Anyone who supports the Protect College Sports Act opposes player rights.

Those who are speaking out in support of the bill won’t admit it. We’ll do it for them. Under the guise of ending chaos tracing to decades of antitrust violations that denied the players the ability to earn anything for their skills, sacrifices, and fame, the proponents of the bill want to limit the amount of money that goes to players, diverting it to the programs.

That’s the fundamental problem none of them will ever acknowledge. There are only so many dollars that can be siphoned from the piggybanks of the boosters. Every dollar that goes to an NIL fund is one less dollar that can go to the program. They want to reduce what can go to the players, maximizing what can go to the programs.

Unwilling to embrace a nationwide union that would allow the creation of a salary cap, transfer limits, and other rules aimed at creating order, the powers-that-be crave an exemption from the laws that prevent the universities from coming together and crafting anticompetitive — and anticapitalist — restrictions on the players’ earning power and freedom to transfer. And ESPN has been leading the conga line, with influential voices like Nick Saban and Pat McAfee openly pushing the Protect College Sports Act.

On Saturday, ESPN gave Senator Ted Cruz (R-Texas), one of the sponsors of the bill, an extended interview during College GameDay to press the case for passage of the proposed law. Cruz, not surprisingly, opened by pointing to the LSU and Brendan Sorsby situations as evidence of the current chaos. The loud reaction to those specific situations was always about mustering political momentum to get the bill passed.

Cruz also claimed that there currently is a "[s]piral of costs that is bankrupting almost every college program in the country. . . . They’re losing tens of millions of dollars.” That contention, to use a technical term, is horseshit.

There was no opposing viewpoint offered in response, other than the organic and incessant booing of Cruz (which included a one point a “Ted you suck!” chant). No time was provided for those who have concerns about the bill.

At one point, host Rece Davis posed a perfunctory question to Cruz regarding the absence of limits on compensation and mobility for coaches and administrators. Cruz offered an evasive word salad in response, and he received no pushback.

Contrary to what ESPN is leading its viewers to believe, the bill has real opposition. On Monday, Senator Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) will conduct a press conference at noon ET with “college athletes, professional athlete unions, families and advocates” to address the problems with the bill.

From the email announcing the event, “participants will detail how the bill denies college athletes the rights and protections they are owed as workers and cuts off any path these athletes have to advocate for themselves — all so the NCAA, college athletic conferences and schools can consolidate money and power over athletes’ lives.”

Why wasn’t Murphy given equal time on College GameDay? Cruz and Murphy could have debated the merits and problems with the bill. While there are no safe bets in this age of bet! bet! bet!, it would be safe to wager the farm on ESPN not preempting McAfee’s show and taking Murphy’s press conference live as it happens on Monday.