Why Brad Marchand is NHL’s most frustrating player
There are 30 general managers in the NHL outside of Boston that, if given the opportunity, would be willing to pay a king’s ransom to acquire Brad Marchand.
There is nothing that he does not do well, and over the past three or four seasons has rapidly developed into one of the most impactful players in the NHL.
The list of players in the league that are better than him at this moment is a short one, and it seems to get shorter every year.
Since the start of the 2015-16 season his 97 goals are tied for the third most in the league, while his 0.50 goals per game average is tied for second in the league (with Auston Matthews and behind only Alex Ovechkin). His 196 total points are the seventh most, while he is one of just six players in the league that have averaged more than a point-per-game over that stretch. His 57.5 percent Corsi rating is second best in the league. He is a crucial part of what has become the best, most dominant line in hockey -- alongside Patrice Bergeron and David Pastrnak -- for what is now one of the best teams in the league and at a salary cap hit of $6.125 million per season is probably still one of the best bargains in the league given what he produces.
That’s what makes his other antics, the ones that keep getting him called into the principal’s office for supplemental discipline so often you would think they were serving peanut butter cups and Yoo-Hoo in there, so damn frustrating.
[Marchand suspended five games for elbowing]
On Wednesday Marchand was suspended five games for elbowing New Jersey Devils forward Marcus Johansson in the head. Johansson suffered a concussion on the play (his second of the season) and is sidelined indefinitely.
Instead of being consistently regarded as one of the league’s best players -- which he is! -- Marchand’s reputation is still that of a pest, or an agitator, or, if you prefer, just simply a dirty player.
What is worse than the fact that the latter part of the criticism is absolutely true, is that he doesn’t seem to be willing to change. Or Learn.
If he is willing to change or learn, he hasn’t actually done it.
Marchand is no stranger to the folks at the NHL’s Department of Player Safety and it’s not uncommon for him to be called in at least once or twice per season. That is not an exaggeration, either.
Since the DoPS was formed before the 2011-12 season Marchand has been fined or suspended by the department eight different times. That is more than any other player in the NHL during that stretch, while the only players in the league to be punished more than four times are Zac Rinaldo (seven times) and Raffi Torres (five times).
That is not a group of players you want to be included with in any context.
(Just a quick note on all of that: I am only looking at punishments handled by the Department of Player Safety. So it does not include the suspension Marchand received during the 2010-11 season -- meaning he has actually been fined or suspended nine times in his career -- and I did not include punishments handled by NHL operations -- so players suspended or fined for PEDs, comments or criticisms, or diving or embellishment are not included in the tallies.)
It has cost him 17 games in suspensions and close to $714,000 in forfeited salary.
It also does not include the incidents that did not result in supplemental discipline from the league but certainly drew attention -- like the late hit on John Tavares earlier this season that resulted in a five-minute major for interference, or the dangerous trip on Anton Stralman last season, which came one week after he was fined for a different dangerous trip on Niklas Kronwall, which came after he was warned earlier that season for slew-footing.
The point here is that no matter what he does, or no matter what the league does to him, he still comes back and does the same stuff that keeps getting him in trouble. Again and again and again and again and again.
On Thursday Marchand apologized for letting his teammates and organization down, while also briefly mentioning that he hopes that Johansson has a quick recovery for the concussion that he inflicted on him.
Marchand: “I’ve been trying to play a certain way for awhile now and it was never my intent to get into a situation like this, to injury Marcus, so hopefully he has a full healthy recovery very quickly. I’m sorry I let my teammates down and I let the organization down."— Joe McDonald (@JoeyMacHockey) January 25, 2018
If those words sounds familiar it might be because we’ve heard similar sentiments from Marchand in the past.
Back in November Marchand talked about how his game has changed, mostly due to the changing style of play in the league, but also because being a legitimately good hockey player tends to lead to a longer career than just being a pest.
Here he is, via the Toronto Star:
“I’m trying to get away from the s--- a little bit, and I have, just because they crack down on it so easily now and I can’t afford to get suspended. ... There are very few guys on any team that even get into anything. These kids that come up now, they’re all skill players, they don’t get into it. There’s no fighters anymore.”
Here he is apologizing for getting suspended just before the 2016 Winter Classic for clipping Mark Borowiecki. It is a combination of words that looks very similar to the ones he said on Thursday.
“I just want to acknowledge the situation that I put my teammates in and affecting the game for them, and taking away for the excitement for the fans being a part of this rivalry and taking it away from them, and also affecting this game for myself and putting myself in the situation to not be a part of this. So I want to apologize, and I truly am sorry to everyone about, again, the situation. And it was not my intent to make a hit or try to injure anyone on that play.”
That, by the way, was the second time Marchand had been suspended for clipping. In the DoPS era only one other player in the entire league has been suspended or fined for that infraction. He has been suspended for it twice.
He has also been suspended or fined three other times since that incident not even two years ago, including his most recent five-game ban.
It is frustrating. It is infuriating. It is exhausting.
It is all of that because it does not need to be this way. Not that there is ever a valid excuse for a player to do the things that Marchand so often does, but it is not like he is player that has to play on the edge to survive in the NHL or keep his job.
He is not just an energy guy or someone that is paid to rattle the cage of an opponent.
He is a top-line player. There is legitimate argument to be made that he has been one of the 10 best players in the league for a couple of years now. He is an All-Star for crying out loud.
The thing that has to be a concern for the Bruins is that he is probably only one infraction away from really getting hammered by the league.
It is kind of amazing that it has not already happened given what has happened to some other players with similar histories. And even that isn’t entirely fair because few players in the league actually have a history that compares Marchand’s.
His five-game ban is the third-longest suspension handed out this season.
Rinaldo was hit with a six-game ban for punching an unsuspecting player (a punishment that received vast criticism for being far too light), while Radko Gudas, another player with a pretty extensive history, was given 10 games for slashing Mathieu Perreault.
Habitual repeat offender Raffi Torres finally did so many awful things that the NHL suspended him for half of a season. It predates the DoPS era, but the league became so fed up with Matt Cooke playing in the gutter that they hit him with a 10-game regular season ban plus the first-round of the playoffs (which ended up being seven more games) for elbowing Ryan McDonagh.
You have to wonder if that day of reckoning is just around the corner for Marchand.
When the DoPS handles suspensions or fines the first thing they do, even before looking at a player’s history, is determine whether or not the incident is worthy of supplemental discipline.
When the answer to that question is yes, that is when the history comes into play.
At this point Marchand’s apologies and proclamations that he has changed are empty.
They mean nothing because he keeps doing it and it’s not doing him, his teammates, and most importantly, the players on the other side of the ice that he constantly puts at risk any favors.
He is one of the best players in the league.
He is also by far the most frustrating.
It is act that is getting old and somebody, whether it is the Bruins or the NHL, needs to put a stop to it.