In last week’s article on fantasy success based on game location, I found that offenses don’t appear to run the ball any better when playing indoors, but they do post greater passing efficiency.
The question, then, is whether or not that increased effectiveness through the air is due to actually playing inside, or if it’s simply the result of favorable simulated weather. That is, how much does weather affect fantasy production?
Temperature and Passing Stats
The first aspect of weather I examined is temperature. Do quarterbacks really pass the ball worse in cold weather?
The short answer is yes. There is a relationship between temperature and net-YPA. The data shows a steep drop in temperatures of 20 degrees or below, although that’s probably just due to a small sample size of such games. In reality, the relationship is probably more linear.
Nonetheless, it seems like there isn’t a really big drop in passing efficiency until temperatures get quite cold. It’s not like 20 degrees is some magic number, but things probably get a bit dicey when the temperature affects a quarterback’s ability to grip the football.
If you recall from my first Rotoworld article, there’s a very strong relationship between hand size and passing success, likely due to big-handed quarterbacks being able to firmly grip the ball and throw it with accuracy. Well, if cold temperatures hinder their ability to do that, it makes sense that we’d see reduced passing efficiency.
Note that nearly all NFL games are played in at least moderate temperatures. It’s in the coldest of the cold games that it seems like we should expect dramatically reduced passing efficiency. The drop from 80-plus degrees to 21-30 degrees, for example, has historically cost quarterbacks just 8.7 percent of their overall efficiency.
Wind and Passing Stats
The idea that cold temperatures affect passing stats is pretty common, but the effect of wind on an offense gets less hype. Nonetheless, I think strong winds—which are much more common than really cold temperatures—can wreak havoc on a passing game.