On Friday, two flight attendants employed by Atlas Air filed a lawsuit against the Jaguars and former Jaguars (now Commanders) kicker Brandon McManus. PFT has obtained and reviewed a copy of the complaint.
You can review it, too, if you like. Here’s the link.
The plaintiffs have opted to proceed under the Jane Doe pseudonym. That was a point of contention in the lawsuits filed three years ago against Deshaun Watson, because Watson argued he didn’t know who was accusing him of wrongdoing. In this case, that shouldn’t be an issue; the Jaguars and McManus should be able to discern without much effort or guesswork the names of the individuals who are suing.
The plaintiffs are both residents of Harris County, Texas. That would help explain the decision to hire Houston-based attorney Tony Buzbee.
At paragraph 9, the complaint makes this broad allegation: “The NFL is no stranger to scandal, especially when it comes to offenses against women. Despite a pervasive advertising campaign to the contrary, many of its players have been accused of committing heinous sexual crimes and transgressions. The NFL’s failure to properly address this undeniable culture of sexual harassment and violence against women led to the preventable and disgraceful sexual misconduct towards Plaintiffs at the hands of Defendant Brandon McManus.”
“The flight quickly turned into a party as Defendant McManus and a number of his teammates disregarded the flight attendants’ personal space, air travel safety, and federal law,” the complaint alleges at paragraph 12.
“Defendant McManus himself spent the 8-hour flight roaming the plane, and even entered the crewmember-only galley multiple times,” the complaint alleges at paragraph 12. “Defendant McManus recruited three flight attendants (not the Plaintiffs) to the party, passing out $100 bills to encourage them to drink and dance inappropriately for him. Based on information and belief, the three flight attendants drinking and dancing with Defendant McManus no longer work for Atlas Air Worldwide Holdings.”
Paragraphs 16 through 23 focus on allegations made by Jane Doe I. At paragraph 17, the complaint alleges as follows: “Defendant McManus first cornered Jane Doe I when the pilot indicated that turbulence required seatbelts for all individuals on the plane. When Jane Doe I belted herself into her designated jump-seat, Defendant McManus got up, sat next to her and began talking to her.”
Paragraph 18: “At this time, Jane Doe I had already observed Defendant McManus drinking with and sexualizing the other flight crew, and was very uncomfortable with McManus’s presence near her. Despite her obvious discomfort, Defendant McManus leaned in to kiss Jane Doe I. She quickly put her hand up to block herself from Defendant McManus’s attempted unwanted advances. She firmly told Defendant McManus to go away, and he did in fact leave her alone for a short period of time.”
Paragraph 20: “On two separate occasions, Defendant McManus grabbed Jane Doe I and ‘grinded’ on her. Each time, she could feel his erect penis through his clothes as he rubbed himself on her. Both incidents were unprovoked, unwanted, and reprehensible.”
Paragraph 22: “As McManus was grinding against her, Jane Doe I froze and made eye contact with another Jaguars player, who looked ashamed of his teammate’s behavior. McManus eventually stopped and walked away.”
Paragraph 23: “Defendant McManus’s second assault on Jane Doe I occurred during the flight’s second meal service. Defendant McManus came up behind her, grabbed her tightly by the waist, and rubbed his clothed but erect penis on her multiple times. Yet again, Jane Doe I could not move away because she was standing in a small aisle and was carrying a large tray.”
Paragraphs 24 through 30 focus on the allegations made by Jane Doe II. From paragraph 24: “Defendant McManus also targeted Jane Doe II when she was occupied with job duties and unable to move away from his violative conduct. When Jane Doe II was serving the flight’s second meal service, Defendant McManus approached her from behind, grabbed her waist, and ‘grinded’ on her.”
Paragraph 26: “Like Jane Doe II, she could feel Defendant McManus’s erect penis through his clothes as he rubbed himself on her. When Jane Doe II turned around and confronted Defendant McManus, he simply smirked and walked away. She was humiliated and embarrassed.”
The complaint includes three causes of action: (1) assault and sexual assault by McManus; (2) intentional infliction of emotional distress by McManus; (3) negligence and gross negligence by the Jaguars.
The Jaguars have been sued under the theory that the team had a duty of “ordinary care” to protect the plaintiffs against player misconduct. The team is accused of negligent hiring, training, and supervision of McManus, along with the broader claim that the team failed to create and maintain proper policies and procedures for hiring, training, and supervising employees — and for failing to adopt policies and procedures to protect flight staff from sexual harassment.
The case seeks compensatory and punitive damages. The reference at the outset of the complaint to a request for damages in excess of $1 million dollars is ultimately meaningless, other than to satisfy the court’s jurisdictional minimum. The jury will give the plaintiffs whatever the jury decides to give the plaintiffs, if anything.
McManus’s lawyer, Brett Gallaway, previously issued a denial of the allegations: “To be clear, these are absolutely fictitious and demonstrably false allegations made as part of a campaign to defame and disparage a talented and well-respected NFL player. We intend to aggressively defend Brandon’s rights and integrity and clear his name by showing what these claims truly are — an extortion attempt.”
McManus will eventually respond to the complaint, with a formal answer or a motion to dismiss. Eventually, a schedule will be put in place for the discovery process (i.e., depositions, requests for documents, requests for written responses, and similar devices) and eventual trial. Like any case, it could settle at any time.
The coming weeks and months will reveal plenty of information about the claims made last week against former Jaguars, now Commanders, kicker Brandon McManus. The primary witnesses will be the two plaintiffs and McManus. There will be other important sources of evidence.
Atlas Air Worldwide Holdings, the charter company the Jaguars used for the flight from Jacksonville to London, will surely receive a subpoena for documents and/or testimony relevant to the claims made by two Atlas Air flight attendants. Whether, for example, the plaintiffs promptly reported the alleged incident internally will be a question posed in the litigation. Whether the plaintiffs made a claim against Atlas for failing to provide a safe work environment also will be explored.
Also, whether Atlas Air had security cameras in the plane will be important to showing what did or didn’t happen during the flight.
The contract, if any, between Atlas and the Jaguars also will become relevant. Does Atlas have an obligation to indemnify the Jaguars? Do the Jaguars have an obligation to indemnify Atlas? Has Atlas required its employees to sign an agreement referring all claims against Atlas and/or its customers to arbitration?
Those factors could have a major influence on the resolution of the case. And that information will emerge as the case unfolds.
It will surely take time for the case to unfold. If it unfolds at all. Any civil case can settle, at any time.
If the Jaguars knew about the lawsuit against the team and former kicker (now Commanders kicker) Brandon McManus before Monday, that information didn’t make its way to coach Doug Pederson.
“I saw the article that came out,” Pederson told reporters on Tuesday. “Obviously, disappointing to hear the news that took place. You know, other than that, honestly, being that it’s a legal matter at this time, I can’t really comment until more information is gathered.”
Pederson then said as to the Monday article, “That’s the first I’ve heard of it, yes.”
He was also asked about the allegation that it was a “party” atmosphere on the flight from Jacksonville to London that sparked claims from two flight attendants that McManus sexually assaulted them. Pederson did not deny the accuracy of the characterization.
“A typical flight is not that way, it’s a business trip,” Pederson said. “It’s a business trip. And that’s how we approach it from an organizational standpoint, you know, from the league standpoint. So, for that — when I read that, that part was disappointing.”
Pederson said the team didn’t know about the claims before moving on from McManus. Pederson also declined to get into specifics as to how the players and others were seated on the plane.
Atlas Air has large planes, including 747s, in their fleet. It’s possible Pederson and other management personnel weren’t even on the same level of the plane where the alleged misconduct occurred.
Pederson’s comments come at a time when attorney Tony Buzbee has said an effort was made to settle the claims before the lawsuit was filed on Friday. It’s possible that the pre-suit settlement effort was focused only on McManus.
Tony Buzbee is back.
The lawyer who represented more than 20 women who had claims against Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson for sexual misconduct during massage sessions represents the two flight attendants who claim that former Jaguars (now Commanders) kicker Brandon McManus sexually assaulted them on a flight from Jacksonville to London.
Buzbee posted this message on Instagram regarding the litigation: “For those who have inquired, The Buzbee Law Firm is lead counsel for the two women who brought this case. We filed the case on Friday, but before that filing we attempted, without success, to resolve this matter without the need for litigation. Our efforts at resolution were met with arrogance, ignorance and stupidity, strikingly similar to how Deshaun Watson’s team responded when we tried to resolve those cases pre-filing. The allegations made in this lawsuit are very serious. We made sure to fully vet them and speak to witnesses before even taking the cases. We will pursue this case with the same tenacity we are known for. It’s a shame that this type of conduct still occurs. It happens far too often. These women were simply trying to do their jobs!”
It’s unclear when McManus and/or the Jaguars were first notified of the claims, or whether the NFL was notified of the potential violation(s) of the Personal Conduct Policy. It’s also unknown whether the information was disclosed to the Commanders before McManus signed with them earlier this year.
Although the case has been described as an “extortion attempt,” it is normal and usual for lawyers to send a demand letter before filing a lawsuit. As mentioned in the attached clip, my first writing assignment in law school was to write a demand letter.
They are sent every day, coast to coast. But the hundreds if not thousands.
The question in response to each demand letter is whether the pre-suit settlement effort is taken seriously, or whether it is dismissed. Watson, by refusing to respond to a fairly low opening demand from his first alleged victim of $100,000, learned the hard way. Whether a similar lesson will be learned by McManus and the Jaguars remains to be seen.
The lawsuit filed against the Jaguars and former Jacksonville (now Commanders) kicker Brandon McManus creates plenty of concerns for the team and the league. Embedded within the allegations of sexual misconduct involving two flight attendants is another potentially major issue for the organization.
If alcohol was being served or consumed on the flight, the Jaguars could be in hot water with the league.
In November 2022, a pair of incidents involving apparent and/or actual alcohol consumption on team flights prompted the NFL to issue a strongly-worded reminder to all teams about the relevant rule. After former Titans offensive coordinator Todd Downing was arrested for DUI under a timeline that suggested he was drinking on the plane back from Green Bay following a Thursday night win and Commanders players were disciplined for having beer on the team plane back from Philly after a Monday night win, the league made it clear that future penalties would be even worse.
Portions of the memo from the league office were leaked at the time. It threatened “significant discipline” for future violations.
Whether the league was huffing and puffing or whether the league will be blowing houses down will be determined if, only 11 months later, the alleged partying on the Jaguars’ plane to London involved the kind of adult beverages that adults consume at adult parties.
And to those who will bristle at the notion that alcohol use on team planes or in team facilities is frowned upon by the NFL, the goal is to make sure that, once the plane lands and the employees disperse in their personal cars, there’s no chance they’ll potentially maim or kill one or more local citizens who happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.